Understanding Organizational Communication
Understanding Organizational Communication
CHAPTER 8
Organizational Communication
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
Upon completion of this chapter, you will be able to:
1. Define organizational communication and identify its components.
2. ldentity the characteristics of communication channel to determine the
effectiveness of the communication process.
3. Highlight different communication networks and their utilities.
4. Diagnose the barriers to effective communication and to determine strategies to
overcome these.
5. Discuss the concept of transactional analysis to improve interpersonal communication.
Introduction
friends,
Communication in its varied forms permeates all aspects of our life including family,
occurs at different levels in the organization
workplace, business, and the government. It
Communication results in exchange ofideas and
self, interpersonal, group, and organization.
deal oftime commu-
the sharing of likes and dislikes among individuals. People spend a great
both inside and outside the organization. It is the most
nicating with individuals and groups,
but it is seldom learly under-
widely dealt area in the entire field of organizational studies, the attainment of
stood. In practice, effective communication is not only the prerequisite for
modern management
organizational goals, but also one of the biggest challenges facing
conflicts
is
Poor communication probably the most frequently cited source ofinterpersonal
(Thomas and Schmidt 1976). Since we spend nearly 70% of our waking hours communicat
reasonable to conclude that a lack
ing-writing, reading, speaking, and listening-it seems
It
of effective communication is one of the main barriers to successful group performance.
of lovers' confliçts, ethnic prejudice, and war between
is attributed to be the primary cause
conflicts. These are only
nations, the generation gap, industrial disputes, and organizationalcommunication.
representative of the numerous problems attributed to ineffective
Groups cannot exist without communication which involves transfer of ideas, content,
and their meaning to all members of the group. Any idea or information can be passed on
to be complete,
only through transmission of meaning. For the process of communication
the meaning has to be understood too. A member ofa group who speaks only French will not
be fully understood by the others in the group if they do not know French. Communication,
therefore, must include both the transfer and the understanding of meaning.
The next question is why people need communication, especially in an organizational set
cordáade o
ting. According to Scott and Mitchell (1976), the functions of communication within groups
ca
or organizations are as follows: thecoocos5e
employees, and these rules flow through the entire organizational hierarchy. managers dve
v
commnrarchy When managers e a v i o u a io oil
subordinates,they
want to control the behaviour of theirDordinates, they communicate these rulesandguide
lines through formal or informal means.
G g .& l o d v i
kooond duc
-14as
202 PART I1: INTERPERSONAL AND TEAM PROCESSES
including mail system, phones lines, and computers. The effectiveness of the
communication channel will depend upon choosing the appropriate channel and
its integrity. For preserving
example, writing a letter but forgetting to mail it halts the communication
process.
Decoding: The fourth step is the process by which receiver interprets
a
to derive
meaning from it, for effective communication depends. upon the receivermessage
a
as much as on
sender. Whether or not the
meaning ofa message remains the same, once it has been decoded,
it has been received.
The perceptual process influences
the decoding process. For a message to be noticed
a receiver, for
example, it must be loud enough, bright enough or different enough to get theby
receiver's attention.
Feedback: Feedback is the process of
reassuring that the message has reached the intended
person in the right manner. The message received should be the same as that was
to be sent. intended
Feedback
One's total success in the communication process depends on various skills such as
speaking, listening, reading, and reasoning. We know that our attitudes influence our
[Link] hold predisposed ideas, on numerous topics, and our communication
is
affected by these attitudes. Further, we are restricted in our communication by the
extent of our knowledge on that particular topic. We cannot communicate what we do
not know, and should our knowledge be too extensive, it is possible that our readers wl
not understand the message. [Link] amount of knowledge the source holds about
the subject will affect the
message that is transferred. Finally, just as attitudes intluence
communication so does our position in the socio-cultural system in which we exist. Our
beliefs and values, all parts of our culture, act and influence us
in the communication
process.
Methods of Communication
Individuals in organizations can communicate in a number of
nication has its definite ways. Every process of commu-
advantages in organizations and
plays a significant role. The different
way's in which people can communicate in
Oral and written organizations are given here.
communication: Oral communication
immediate feedback, seeking clarifications, if any, to provide provides opportunities and for
to' answer questions.
It has the advantage of
additional information
of oral communication is the absence of a being personal
and faster. One disadvantage
record of what was discussed. A formal
comprises of both written and oral words. The written meeting
and the deliberations of the component is the written agenda
meeting are in spoken words. Written
more
impersonal, but it provides the receiver with more [Link] is
It is more time
consuming when compared to oral communication and also does not
feedback. facilitate immediate
Non-verbal communication: The
components of communication, which are not expressed
through written or spoken words, are included under the domain of non-verbal commu-
nication. It includes body movement, facial
receiver and the sender. Apart from expression, and physical distance between the
this, environmental
quality furniture, convey a lot about the status of the factors,
such as a spacious office with
person. Body language is an important
back-up for verbal communication, but sometimes incompatibility between the verbal and
the non-verbal
components of communication creates confusion.
Use of technology: The
application of new technology for the communication of information
indudes computerized information processing systems, new forms of telecommunication sys-
tems and a combination of
the two. The advancements in technology have introduced differ
ent methods of communication such as
voice e-mailing, faxing, home banking,
mails, and text messaging, etc. The main videoconferencing,
challenge for the future is to integrate the vari
ous
technologis and to ensure that the social structures
and power
tions are congruent relationships in organiza
with the new electronic office systems. The drawbacks
are
perceived the form of information overload, loss of records in the of new technology
in
the dehumanizing
impact of paperless office, and
the dissemination of new ideaselectronic
and
equipments. Howéve, new technology will help in
practices, and in the process organizations will
become
knowledge-based organizations.
Communication Channels
Selecting a communication channel to transmit a timely, accurate, and
able message is very important. completely understand-
People are channels who use speech, sight,
to communicate with each other. and body motions
Mechanical channels go beyond
the capabilities
body include newsletters, magazines, telephones, radio, television, and of the human
and
Most people háve personal
preferences among the various communication computers.
available. Some believe that face-to-face communication channels
is best whenever
rely almost entirely on memos. More and more people use possible. Others
computer channels às a first choice.
203204 PART I1: INTERPERSONAL AND TEAM PROCESSES
Cherocterstics of In
reality, there is no single best communication channel. The
Communicahoneannes depend upon the following characteristics: effectiveness of channel will
a
Communication Networks
The communication between
groups or people is termed as a linkage. A communiation network
is a series of interconnected
linkages. Together, these linkages connect individuals or groups in
the communication process. If the
message needs to be conveyed from the top to the lowest level
it goes through many persons in between. Direct communication between the top and loweat
level would probably have been more accurate and more
efficient, because it would eliminate the
opportunity for the message to be lost or distorted as it passes through each linkage. Communl
cation networks can be classified into
and informal communication networks.
two broad categories-formal communication networka
JL
Diagonal communication
Figure 8.2
Formal Communication
Networks
206 PART I1: INTERPERSONAL AND TEAM PROCESSES
Otherypes of Formal Diferent networks have diferent characteristics. In some, infornmation flows quickly, In
some, information flow is channelled to the right place at the right time. In other networks,
CommunIcation
the accuracy of information is distorted in transmision. Some common formal communica-
Newprks tion networks are (Figure 8.3) explained here.
Choinhisis more
ofer ue yerically 1. The chain network is-the simplest of networks. Although it can be used as a horizon-
Tenewos Two tal communication network-for example, interdepartmental communication-it is
tegda sousmember more often
ara postionedleithera used vertically, In the vertical configuration, the person with the greatest
power is usually located at the top of the chain. Although the chain allows the possibil-
hetoporqtha
botiom of
oS an Yered ity feedback, many linkages can exist between a sender and the receiver, which make
Even when they are accurate, chain networks tend to be slow and
distortions likely.
Grqle This hework
scacmembarto subject information
to overload. Such a network usually produces relatively slow deci-
icce drecl sions, and the quality of these decisions depends highly on the leader of the network
iWO ohermenmbars 2. The "Y" network is a modification of the chain network. Two equal status members
neworkhos are positioned either at the top or at the bottom as in an inverted Y. Like the chain, the
ogonizgtign
negemar Informal Communication Networks
gderiogep The informal communication networks that exist in organizations are created by employeos
secd ot ning They emerge through natural and spontaneous human interaction-they follow around water
4self 3o ong own coolers, tea session, lunchrooms, and whenever people get together in groups. They are not
moinia easy to control, transmit information rapidly, and often carry rumours. Some examples o
alaistang informal communication networks in organizations are described here.
ensubopipaies ond Grapevine: It is an informal channel of communication not controlled by the management
Oledgeagages
and serves as a foundation for all the gossip and rumours in the organization. Many employ
c a move royndn
otie Premisesohd ces in the organization view it as more effective and credible when compared to the formal
ngrmalY chgt with management dhannels (Modic 1989). It has also been found that about 80% ofthe grapevineat
peiple. the workplace is related to work and 80% of it is generally true (Simmons 1985). Grapevines
CHAPTER 8: ORGANIZATIONAL COMMUNICATIONI
ON 2
SO
Chain Circle
Star
Wheel
Figure 8.3
Common Formal
Communication
Networks
generally, arepresent in organizations when there is ambiguity in situations and
confused. A good manager will always have access to the rumours employees feel
floating in the organization
through loyal subordinates. After knowing these rumours, the manager can pass on the news
that will improve
relationships or act to eliminate gossip that might be harmful to organiza-
tional performance (Kiechel 1985).
Social gatherings: Organizations need to create
level away from the formal culture of the
opportunities for employees to meet at a social
to people to pass on their
organization. Social gatherings provide a platform
observations, grievances, and achievements to their colleagues and
superiors at an informal level. It can be in the form of company picnics, luncheons, weekend
parties, and so on.
Management by wandering around: Instead of limiting themselves to their own offices and
maintaining an official distance from their subordinates and colleagues, managers can move
around in the office premises and informally chat with
people. This will help serve two pur-
poses: one, the employees will shed their inhibitions with the superiors and feel free with
them; and secondly, the manager will have more information available to him which other-
wise would never have reached him. The informally communication with
management by wandering around (Peters and Waterman 1982).
employees is called
208 PART I1: INTERPERSONAL AND TEAM PROCESSES
wwwwM
Barriers to Communication
Communication, though intended to be smooth and effective, is not
times tends to become ineffective. always flawless and some-
erca Ineffective communication may be attributed to different
types of human or technical barriers. The
tht major barriers can be classified into four categories:
1. Intrapersonal factors
2. Interpersonal factors
3. Organizational factors
4. Technological factors
poco
2rogpeS
Intrapersonal Factors
(Intrapersonal
as barrier in
factors refer to the elements within the individual's personality which act
a
receiving, analysing, and interpreting the information that is available.
Prpuotaoi There different intrapersonal bárriers in an
are
individual's personality. Some of these are
as follows:
Selective perception: The way in which we
which our thoughts aboufit are converted in the form ofsubject
perceive a or an event affects the
way in
have a tendency to see and hear what meaningful communication. People
they are emotionally prepared to see and hear. They
seek out favourable messages and
ignore unpleasant
ones.
CHAPTER 8: ORGANIZATIONAL COMMUNICATION 0
Individual diferences in communication skills: People also differ in their ability to develop
and apply basic communication skill. Some people are capable of expressing themselves, but
they cannot write clear and concise messages. Some are effective listeners but
Such dificulties are poor speakers.
potential barriers to éfective communication.
Emotions: The emotional state of the
person at the time of sending or receiving the message
has aprofound impact on its effectiveness.
Frameof reference: As has been discussed in the chapter on perception, people often
the same perceve
thing differently but assume thát other people perceive it the same way they
When
communicators use different frames of reference, they cannot achieve common under-ao.
standing in their communication.)
Preconceived ideas: The interpretation or reception of the message is influenced the
receivers preconceived opinions about the content of the by
receiver tends to make a message. When this happens, the
snap judgement about what is being said.
preted from the receiver's point of view, with little Since the message is inter-
or no consideration of
point, the intended meaning of the the senders view-
message may be completely lost.
pterparsond commb
Interpersonal Factors lcoton Baui0
Interpersonal factors play an important role when two
other in the individuals communicate with each eosytede
organizational setting. Some of the interpersonal
effective communication factors which act as a
are given here: barrier to
Climate: Within an organizational context, the
ordinate largely derives from the relationship between the superior and sub-
treatment each receives from
dckotsu
in which this the other and from the way
reciprocal behaviour is interpreted. The engSup Pote
the cimate of an combination of attitudes determines
flow of interpersonal relationship. The lack of climate can easily lead toa ppucaiion
communication, games to manipulate information, restricted
antagonism. and widespread distrust and
Trust: The communication process is a transaction eperce
information is meant to have a between sender and receiver. Transfer of ersic
such relationships. Distrust andreciprocal effect on both. Trust is a major characteristic
suspicion of
and subordinate can serve all
ion sou
defensiveness and decrease thebetween superior
a
to increase
frequency of open expression, thereby making only
communication ineffective.
Credibility: It refers to the CommUTGeilon
Johnson(1972) Credibility isperceived characteristics of an
composed of the following sixinformation
source.
distinct elements:
According to
1. eteig icilae
Honesty or general trustworthiness eepioaijch
2.
Expertise or competence
3.
Dynamism or enthusiasm terperenu sejsi
4.
Objectiity or open-mindedness
5. Intention
0DRatienodk
6. General reputation ecouseiney
These are not
necessarily possessed
by given
a source but are attributed to that source by
individual receivers. Credibility of a source isactually determined by the receiver.
Sender-receiver similarity: The accuracy of communication between two gopie eve eens
tors is
directly related to the extent to which communica
degree of similarity between communicators intheyterms
perceive themselves to be similar. The
of
oece ondUn
characteristics such as age, sex, Witc they dgaotren
intelligence, and socioeconomic status, as well as common
race,
attitudes, interests, values
and abilities, influences the ease and
openness of their communication. Similar Demgnieioroblen
nicators are more willing to commu-
accept the viewpoints of one another and to Words hoye duilen
agreement. express common
07eaningS tor direreu
Interpersonal sensitivity: Some people have the
theircommunication goals because they lack necessary
skills but are unable to achieve
though communicated in an appropriate manner,interpersonal sensitivity. Their messages,
may not be able to motivate the receivers undersidnding
comuuniCaTon
210 PART II: INTERPERSONAL AND TEAM PROCESSES
to respond postively to them. Insensitive individuals may use language that is ofensive to
others or that may be indifferent to the needs and feelings of other people.
Selective listening: People have a tendency to hear what they want to hear and tune out what
they do not want to hear. We are more receptive to messages that satisfy our needs or coincide
with our beliefs, And we tend to deny, reject or distort
messages that are threatening or in
conflict with our éxisting beliefs (Larwood and Whittaker 1977). People become defensive
when they are criticized by others as it is a threat to their
ego.
Semantic problem: Words have different meanings for different people. Some problems
in understanding
communication occur because the words used by the sender are under-
stood by the receiver in a different manner due to semantic
the sender uses highly abstract or technical terms or when he
problems. This happens when
speaks a language which is not
understood by the receiver.
Organizational Factors
Organizational factors are the elements within the organizational setting that either facilitate
barriers that may prevent the communication
or act as
process from running smoothly. Some
of these organizational factors which act as communication barriers
are discussed here.
ereoraiona Status: The persons status in an organization depends largely upon the prestige associated
with the position occupied. The
impact of status on effective communication is highly felt.
It has been found that:
People generally prefer to direct their communication to individuals with higher sta-
tusin the organization.
People with high status generally communicate more with one another than they do
with people of lower status in the organization.
The wider the status diference, the greater the likelihood that information will flow
from higher to lower status rather than vice versa.
gopgz0iona
A person with a high status in the
organization generally dominates in a conversation
with a person of lower status.
A person with low status often
attempts to gain the favour af those with high status,
guperorongonicg by displaying respect, offering praise, and agreeing with their views.
Grouresei Hierarchical transmission: As organizations grow, hierarchies evolve to facilitate the
accomplishment of broadened activities and to ease communication. Information must be
systematically channellized to all parts of an organization. Although the transfer of informa-
tion through an organizational chain of command (hierarchical fans) is necessary, it does
give rise to numerous communication difficulties. For example, the more levels a message
must pass through, the
longer it takes to reach its destination and less likely it is to be accurate
Group size: Interpersonal communication becomes increasingly difficult as the size of the
work group increases.
ploars
This occurs in part because the number of possible communication
channels between individual members increases rapidly when group size increases. Fora
group of five people there are 5(5-1)/2, or 10, channels of communication possible. As the
number of individuals increase, the number of channels also increases.
Spatial constraints: The kind of task or job a person is engaged in will influence his
munication with others. The shorter the distance between two employees, the greatercom
wll
be their frequency of interaction and less likely that
they will encounter problems of mutual
coordination due to miscommunication.
Technological Factors
Technological factors are the elements in the medium, content or the quantity of informatlon
that has to be passed on for
[Link] to take place. The following includes
some of the
technological factors that act as barriers to effective communication:
CHAPTER 8: N
ORGANIZATIONAL COMMUNICATION 2
extent to
communication accuracy is the Tachnological Barie
Language meaning: A major determinant of
and
is a system
to the same word. Since language longuoge andme
which communicators assign similar meanings
of symbols, words themselves have no meaning. They are simply labels. The meaning a per-
determinant
social background,
Son attaches to a
message is uniquely determined by individual needs, myhicatioh ac
and so on. Curacyishextep to
For some words, dictionaries give so many different meanings, the word that the
as Which copmuncitors
sender refers to may be different from the word the receiver perceives. There are some words dssign similaremcaning
which are spelt in the same way but have diferent meanings: for example,live (verb) and live ne some wore
(adjective); wind (verb) and wind (noun). Some words are pronounced the same way but are Non verbocues: hese
spelt diferently: for example to, two, and too; here and hear. non-verbod SinuilarB
Non-verbal cues: When people speak, their words are usually accompanied by a variety of Slep uessgestiho
meaningfu mon=verbal cues, such as physical postures, gestures, facial expression, body,
touch, and visual behaviour. These non-verbal stimuli are silent messages that may com- dccUrgte tgnste
municate the inaccurate transfer of meaning: for example, the degree of eye contact between eng
communicators may indicate interest,
movements (shifts in position, hand
liking, involvement or aggression. Similarly, body
of relaxation.
gesture, nods) may convey eagerness, anger or a feeling
In order to understand
of their
people better, we need to pay attention to all three components
communication, that is, their body language, words, and tone of 0ggressO
its enormous voice. Because of Gharinelenedivenes
impact, body language is very important. A manager will be to commu-
nicate much more
effectively if he is conscious of his own body language,able and he will be
Wiren endels
able increase his understanding of others if he learns to interpret
to merorepda dno
Research studies (Mehrabian 1972) indicate that the three their body language. dhogiamsor compe
are
expressed the manner shown in Table 8.1.
in components of communication ewspapershoy
The importance of
non-verbal communication in undopemos;
edged by theorists and practitioners who assert that themanagement been
has acknowl-
non-verbal messages is an complex interplay of verbal and
skilful at observing
integral part of the management process. Managers must be
must be aware of the
and responding to the non-verbal messages of subordinates, and they
impact of their non-verbal behaviour on the subordinates ynep
process of communication. Box 8.1 provides some of the during the
interpretations of non-verbal torrmeio
behaviours. dtierp
In the majority of cases, verbal and non-verbal cues communicate the same proce
that is, they message,
complement each other. However, non-verbal stimuli may contradict and even
negate the intended meaning of a verbal message. For example, a statement "That's
that's just great" said in reaction to an great,
unfavourable outcome is almost always
negative. general, when non-verbal cues are
In perceived as
nginekeca eg or embarrassne
Made no
ncagning
Neyot ness
degs,e
es
Pair Qiecio
estlessnessOr gier
pinghe
Set the goals of communication in advance: Before going ahead with the process of
communication, the communicator should know what he wants to achieve through this.
Is it to control the behaviour of others, to motivate them or to give them some intorma-
tion? Depending on the goal, the mode of communication would vary.
Use proper language: The sender of the message should ensure that the language used for
dissminating the information is easy to understand and does not involve the use of jargons
or words that are beyond the comprehension of the receivér.
Improve senders credibility: The person sending the message across should be see as a
credible person. He should be an expert in the area, and his words should match with his
actions. Most people fail in this credibility test because they are not able to live up to the
expectations of the receivers.
Encourage feedback: Any process of communication is incomplete without feedback. The
sender can be sure of the authenticity of his message only if it has been received by the
receiver as it was
intended.
Two-way communication and sensitivity to non-verbal messages
can improve the feedback process.
Develop a trusting climate: he culture of the organization should promote trust. The process
ofcommunication inefective
is if the person sending a message is not sure that it
confidential
will remain confidential.
Select an appropriate channel: An appropriate channel will help to make the process of
communication effective. Care has to be taken to select the right channel. Level (1972) has
proposed the following guidelines for selecting the right channel:
Oral communication would be appropriate only for discusing interpersonal problems
and problems related to workperformance
Written communication is desirable in situations where information is of a general
nature and requires future action.
Oral communication followed by written communication is suitable in all kinds
of situations, especially the ones requiring immediate action and job-related
instructions.
Written communication followed by oral communication is not a frequently used
method of communication.
Avoid evaluative judgement: Any judgement prior to receiving the message is not desirable.
The receiver should be open to communication without any precónceived ideas and bias. He
should try to create a climate that fosters acceptance and understanding.
Listen to the entire message: A message has two components-content and feeling.
A receiver should try to fully receive the message rather than in parts. Many a times, the
feling associated with the message is more important than the content and a good manager
takes note osit. The feling is usually communicated by non-verbal means. All of these must
be observed in listening for the total meaning of the message.
Provide appropriate feedback: The receiver should provide appropriate feedback to the
sender about the message that he has received. Appropriate feedback will bring about con-
structiye dialogue without creating a defensive environment and will help attain a common
communication ground.