Exploring Identity in Alexie's Novel
Exploring Identity in Alexie's Novel
CI 519
December 6, 2011
Multi-Genre Text Set: The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian
by Sherman Alexie
Essential Questions:
1. How do internal and external expectations manifest themselves in our
lives?
2. How can such societal expectations impact our identities?
3. Should a person’s responsibility to their family, tribe, or community take
precedence over their individual goals?
4. How does literature help us to understand ourselves and the world around
us?
Poem:
Endless Search by Native American poet Alonzo Lopez
Primary Text Summary: The
Absolutely True Diary of a
Part-Time Indian by Sherman
Alexie
To say that life is hard on the Spokane rez doesn’t begin to touch it. “My
parents came from poor people who came from poor people who came from
poor people,” Arnold explains, “all the way back to the very first poor
people.” The kid was born with 10 too many teeth, so he gets them pulled —
all in a single day, because the Indian Health Service pays for major dental
work only once a year. When Arnold cracks open his geometry textbook, he
finds his mother’s name written on the flyleaf. “My school and my tribe are
so poor and sad that we have to study from the same dang books our
parents studied from,” Arnold says. “That is absolutely the saddest thing in
the world.”
Enraged, Arnold beans his geometry teacher with the book and gets
suspended from school. The targeted teacher, Mr. P., visits Arnold at home
and gives him a piece of advice: get out. Mr. P. has seen too many promising
students — like Arnold’s sister, Mary Runs Away — fade year by year, beaten
down by poverty and hopelessness. “The only thing you kids are being
taught is how to give up,” Mr. P. says.
“The Absolutely True Diary” tracks Arnold’s year of getting out. He transfers
to Reardan High, 22 miles away, a gleaming campus full of wealthy white
kids, with a computer room and chemistry labs. He’s the only Indian — if you
don’t count the school mascot. Early on, Arnold fears being beaten up by the
jocks. “I was afraid those monsters were going to kill me,” he says. “And I
Page 2 of 17
don’t mean ‘kill’ as in ‘metaphor.’ I mean ‘kill’ as in ‘beat me to death.’” (The
comedian in Alexie pops up as often as the poet.) Arnold’s toughness soon
earns him their respect, though, as well as a spot on the varsity basketball
team.
What he can’t win back is the love of his neighbors at home. On the rez he’s
considered a traitor. His best friend punches him in the face. When Reardan
plays Wellpinit High in basketball, the Indians rain so much abuse on Arnold
that a race riot nearly breaks out. Triumph and grief come in equal measure.
Arnold figures out that he’s smarter than most of the white kids, and wins
the heart of a white girl named Penelope. (“What was my secret?” he says.
“If you want to get all biological, then you’d have to say that I was an
exciting addition to the Reardan gene pool.”) Meanwhile, his father’s best
friend is shot and killed, and his sister dies in a trailer fire. “I’m 14 years old,
and I’ve been to 42 funerals,” Arnold says. “That’s really the biggest
difference between Indians and white people.”
For 15 years now, Sherman Alexie has explored the struggle to survive
between the grinding plates of the Indian and white worlds. He’s done it
through various characters and genres, but “The Absolutely True Diary of a
Part-Time Indian” may be his best work yet. Working in the voice of a 14-
year-old forces Alexie to strip everything down to action and emotion, so that
reading becomes more like listening to your smart, funny best friend recount
his day while waiting after school for a ride home. Which, by the way, Arnold
doesn’t have. Unless his folks get lucky and come up with some gas money.
Rationale:
The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian has a Lexile Level of 600.
The book is very readable for struggling 10th grade readers as the language
is highly accessible. The novel is a compelling read, light-hearted yet at the
same time deeply serious. Teens of all learning abilities will relate to the
universal themes of the novel. The central text was chosen with the
intention of reaching multiple intelligences. Because of the art throughout
the novel, the format of the book lends itself well to differentiation. Often,
the art in the novel highlights the main idea of that chapter, serving as a
useful aid in reading comprehension for struggling learners and ELL’s.
We are all limited to some extent by the countless expectations that are
linked to our gender, age, culture and socioeconomic status. This is also true
of Junior who is characterized by his poverty and culture. Ultimately, he must
choose between accepting what others expect him to be, or to fight against
these forces that are holding him back.
The essential question of this unit asks: how do internal and external
expectations manifest themselves in our lives? Students will consider issues
of gender, age, culture and socioeconomic status, how they are tied to
Page 3 of 17
identity, and how these factors impact life choices. Students will create a
multimedia portfolio to describe expectations imposed by ones community
and family and how these can be the hardest ties to break. My hope is that
students will learn that they are not without power; choices can be made.
They will also learn that there will be consequences for choosing to go
against the grain.
The multi-genre unit outlined below enhances the literary experience with
supplemental guest speakers, video, poetry, informational texts and videos.
This unit challenges students to think critically about relevant themes in their
lives. Selected texts enhance student understanding of the essential
questions of the unit. The holistic unit outline and study question include
lesson by lesson themes, highlighting the rationale for how each text fits in
the unit and how the selected texts promote student learning of the unit
essential questions.
Learning Goals/Objectives:
In this unit students will:
Read and respond to The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian
as well as supplementary texts.
Draw parallels between themselves and the characters in the novel,
developing an understanding and knowledge of the internal and
external expectations in their lives.
Explore the roles others play in their lives and their own identity;
develop an understanding of how internal and external pressure
shapes daily choices and their future roles in society.
Discuss the idea of identity and expectations in terms of gender, age,
race, culture and socioeconomic status.
Enhance the comprehension of literary devices such as
characterization, setting, and theme.
Work collaboratively in groups as well as individually, developing
communication skills and listening strategies.
Make predictions, inferences and draw conclusions.
Create a final multimedia portfolio that centers on the overarching
class question for this unit: How do internal and external expectations
shape and affect our lives?
Work on their public speaking abilities by sharing part their multi-genre
project with the class.
Page 4 of 17
when writing or speaking to support conclusions drawn from the
text.
2. Determine central ideas or themes of a text and analyze their
development; summarize the key supporting details and ideas.
Page 5 of 17
Unit Outline
Page 6 of 17
Geometry Is Not a Country Somewhere 43) in class Blues” (p.48-53).
Near France” (p. 25 -31)
Day 5 Day 6 Day 7 Day 8
Topic/ Lesson: What does Lesson: Are we in control Lesson: How Does Lesson: Socio-
Activity hope mean? of our own decisions? Culture Affect Our economic status
Expectations?
In “How to Fight Junior and his family
Junior’s parents tell Monsters” Junior’s father Junior expects the are extremely poor
him that white people tells him that white White boys at and oftentimes cannot
have the most hope people aren’t better than Reardon to think even afford to eat. In
and Junior decides to him but Junior doesn’t the same as the “Halloween”, Junior
leave the rez. believe him: “But he was Indian boys on the joins Penelope in trick-
so wrong. And he knew rez, and is or-treating for spare
Students will discuss he was wrong. He was surprised when change instead of
the idea of hope and the loser Indian father of that doesn’t candy, to donate to
what that might look a loser Indian son living happen. Students the homeless. Junior
like in other parts of in a world built for will consider says “I was a poor kid
the world. winners” (55). stereotypes and raising money for
how culture other poor people. It
Watch and discuss What expectations does impacts what we made me feel almost
video Junior have for himself? expect of ourselves honorable.” (79)
7 Billion: Are You and of others.
Typical? -- National Watch and discuss a Students will consider
Geographic Magazine how Junior’s socio-
[Link] segment of TED Talk: *HW: Read “Tears
v=4B Are we in control of our of a Clown” (p. 74 - economic status
2xOvKFFz4&feature=player_emb
own decisions? 76) and impacts his life, and
edded
[Link] Halloween (p. 77 – how he views himself
dan_ariely_asks_are_we_
in_control_of_our_own_decisions.html 81) and others.
Page 7 of 17
– 66) “Grandmother Gives Me “Thanksgiving” (p.101
Some Advice” (p. 67 – – 103)
73)
Day 9 Day 10 Day 11 Day 12
Topic/ Lesson: Celilo Lesson: Author Lesson: Taking a Look at Lesson: Navigating
Activity Falls Case Background Eating Disorders Between Two Worlds
Study (Computer Lab)
# Provide struggling
Does Penelope have an Junior saying “I was half
Students learn students with article and a eating disorder? How do her Indian in one place and half
about Native preview of the website in expectations of herself and white in the other.” (118)
advance
American life Read NY times of beauty play a role in her Discuss Jr./Arnold’s dual
and culture in review of the behavior? identities and how he feels
the North west novel (cited he is navigating between
by viewing a earlier) View and discuss a clip of two different tribes. Junior
video and the movie Miss says of his cartoons “I use
discussing Using Sherman Representation. A trailer for them to understand the
Celilo Falls. Alexie’s website this video is located at: world.” (95) Why does
to gain http:// Junior draw? How does art
background on [Link]/the- help Junior? How is art like
Cone, J., & the author. film/ literature?
Oregon State Students will
University. discover that Students will draw a
(2007). Celilo A.T.D.P.T.I. is a picture of themselves and
Falls and the fictionalized their dual identity.
remaking of the autobiography.
Columbia River.
Corvallis, OR: Students work in
*HW: Read “Dance, Dance, *HW: Read “And a
Sea Grant small groups to
Oregon, Oregon investigate, Dance” (p.118 – 129), “Don’t Partridge in a Pear Tree”
analyze, and Trust Your Computer” (p. (p.150 – 151), and
State University
synthesize what 130 – 132) and “My Sister “Reindeer Games” (p.135 –
they found and Sends Me a Letter” (p. 133 – 149).
how this relates 134)
Page 8 of 17
*HW: Describe to the novel.
how the loss of
Celilo falls *HW: Read “Rowdy
affects NW Gives Me Advice
native About Love” (p. 114
Americans – 117) and “Hunger
Pains” (p.104 –
113)
member of the Quick write: Explain when several Students will read and discuss a news
community.” (132) expectations affected your life, article from the Guardian
Students will consider include the forces working on the
this quote and read inside as well as social and familial Literacy Strategy (Vocab)
the poem “Endless expectations. SSR
Search” by Native Group Work
American poet Alonzo Class Share and Synthesis
Lopez to continue [Link]
thinking about the more-harmful-than-heroin-crack
individual versus
collective identity.
Students will be introduced to the in
themed multimedia portfolio group
project.
Page 9 of 17
*HW: “Red Versus
White” p. 152 – 158, *HW: Read “Rowdy and I Have a
“Wake” (p.159 – Long and Serious Discussion About
167), “Valentine Basketball” (p. 197 – 198)
Heart” (p.168 – 178), “Because Russian Guys Are Not *HW:
and “In Like a Lion” Always Geniuses” (p.199 – 213) Talking About Turtles (p.219 - 230)
(p. 179 – 196) and “Remembering” (p.214 – 218)
Page 10 of 17
is the most Film signals. New York:
important and then Video Hyperion.
“stretch” it with a Audio HW: Finalize
visual Text presentation
representation. Article
HW: Finalize
portfolio
Page 11 of 17
Study Questions
ReelNative Videos
1. How do societal expectations impact the identity of Guy Narcomy?
2. How do internal and external expectations influence Melissa D Rae?
Chapter 6 - Go Means Go
1. According to Junior's parents who has the most hope?
2. Where does Junior want to go?
3. Describe Reardon.
4. Why would the Indians on the rez be angry with Junior?
Page 13 of 17
2. How can societal expectations impact our identities?
Chapter 11 - Halloween
1. What made Junior feel almost honorable?
Chapter 14 - Thanksgiving
1. How did Rowdy show respect?
Page 14 of 17
5. Explain how the story of Celilo Falls relates to the Native American
experience.
Page 15 of 17
1. What does Junior's dad always do when the family doesn't have money?
2. What was a "beautiful and ugly thing"?
Chapter 23 - Wake
1 .What did the Indians on the rez stop doing to Junior after his grandmother
dies?
2. Junior says “When it comes to death, we know that laughter and tears are
pretty much the same." How is this brought out in this chapter?
Chapter 28 - Remembering
1. What does Junior quote mean? "She went searching for her dreams, and
she didn't find them, but she made the attempt"
2. How is Junior making the "attempt"?
3. What does the picture on page 218 represent?
Page 16 of 17
2. How does alcoholism affect our community and our society?
3. How does alcoholism affect a person’s responsibility to their family, tribe, or
community?
References:
[Link]
[Link]
[Link]
Time%20Indian
[Link]
[Link]
[Link]
[Link]
Page 17 of 17