Measurement Uncertainty in Science Class
Measurement Uncertainty in Science Class
I. GENERAL DATA:
START
. The teacher takes the opportunity to ask them: if I wanted to measure the width of
a table, what instrument would you use? Students are expected to respond: "A
ruler or a measuring tape.
. Then, the teacher asks: How would you measure the thickness of a sheet of paper?
. The teacher explains that it is very easy to measure the thickness of a sheet of paper. This can be done
to make by stacking a considerable amount of sheets (28 sheets) and measuring the total thickness
Then the thickness of the stack of papers is divided by the number of papers.
In this case, the thickness of a sheet of paper would be the quotient of 4 mm and 28.
. Next, the teacher clarifies that the purpose of this session is for the students to
starting from the study of methods for measuring physical quantities and the theory of errors,
They manage to carry out an inquiry process that will take them three sessions. Also, that this
the session will begin with the design of strategies to conduct an inquiry that involves the
measurement methods and the theory of errors. This strategy design will consist of
develop a protocol that explains the procedure for taking measurements of
volumes; justify the selection of tools, materials, equipment, and instruments of
accuracy; and verify the reliability of the information source to be used in the
inquiry.
DEVELOPMENT
. The teacher invites the students to organize themselves into work teams and to take notes in
on your "experience notebook" of everything that will be worked on today.
. The teacher poses questions that generate a process of inquiry on the part of the
students; for example: what do they understand by 'measure'? what things can be measured? what
Are there things that cannot be measured? Is it possible to measure love for others? How to measure volume?
of a liquid? How to measure the volume of an irregular stone? How to measure the volume
of a solid ball? How to measure the volume of a wax cylinder? Based on the
information that will be provided to you later, what type of measurement will be carried out
to measure the volumes of the four things mentioned above?
. The teacher mentions that today a process of inquiry will begin on methods of
measurement of physical magnitudes and theory of errors, which will last three sessions. Meanwhile
that today the purpose described at the beginning of the session will begin.
. The teacher invites the students to come up with strategies that lead them to measure volumes.
of each of the four things mentioned, in order to answer the questions raised;
Furthermore, to justify the things they use to carry it out, as well as to consider the
relevant scientific knowledge to address the questions raised.
. The students discuss (brainstorming) in work teams about the way in which
They will proceed to determine the required volumes.
. Then, the students develop a sequence of actions that allows them to determine
the required volumes, and in which they take into account the materials of their environment and
measuring instruments according to the actions to be performed, while reviewing the
scientific knowledge related to (fundamental and derived physical quantities) that
It is found on pages 17 to 19 and 22 of the 5th grade high school CTA book, and others.
that the teacher considers appropriate.
measurement_type_1
Type of measurement:..................................................
. For better understanding, the teacher presents brief information about the
measurement methods (Annex 1).
Vhe[Link]
experimental/contents/ClassBook/[Link]
. Then, the teacher mentions to his students that accurate measurements are a part
fundamental of physics. However, no measurement is absolutely precise. Since
there is always an uncertainty associated with every measurement. The teacher will reach the
students the information related to the measurement error or uncertainty of a
measurement (Annex 2) and the propagation of error or propagation of uncertainty (Annex 3).
Note: the student can generate one or several procedures to determine the
volumes for each considered object. It is necessary to respect any idea no matter how
extravagant that it may be. The role of the teacher is to accompany and guide in the process of
investigation that the students will carry out, considering challenging questions from the
teacher and those generated by the students themselves.
CLOSURE
. Finally, the teacher asks the students: what have you learned today? The activity
Has it seemed significant to you for understanding the measurement methods, so
How are the fundamental and derived quantities? What difficulties have you encountered while
Did you carry out the learning activities?
. In addition, the students will obtain the necessary materials to carry out the
required measurements.
Ministry of Education. Science, Technology and Environment Book for 5th grade
Secondary Education. 2012. Lima. Santillana S.A.
Notebook of experiences
Dictionary
Paper plotters
Markers
Internet
_______________________ __
V°B° ADVISOR TEACHER
Teamwork:
MAGNITUDE
MEASURE
MEASURE
2°
3°
4°
Type of measurement:
2°
3°
4°
Type of measurement:
8. How to measure the volume of a solid sphere?
2°
3°
4°
Type of measurement:
2°
3°
4°
Type of measurement:
ANNEX 1
Measurement methods
Source:
[Link]
experimental/contents/BookClass/[Link]
ANNEX 2
Theory of errors
It is very important to note that when measuring the magnitude of a
Physical quantity, it is impossible for the result of this measurement to be exact. It is necessary to include
an uncertainty or error due to imperfections of the instrument (systematic error, can
to be controlled), or to limitations of the meter (random error, cannot be controlled, is the result
of chance).
a. Absolute error. If a single measurement is taken, the measured quantity is expressed with an error.
or absolute uncertainty which is equal to the precision of the measuring instrument used.
b. Relative error. If a single measurement is made, the relative error is the quotient between the
absolute error and the value of the measurement. The relative uncertainty is expressed
generally in a percentage.
Next, we will look at some examples where absolute errors will be considered.
relative.
Example 1. If we measure the length of a rod with a ruler graduated in centimeters, just as it is
is shown in the figure:
0,5
Relative error =
21,5
0,5
Percentage relative error= × 100 %0.02325581 ... × 100 %≈ 2.33 %
21,5
Note: a person with good reflexes and 'trained' has a reaction time of 0.10
about a second, but the reaction time of most people
"untrained" is 0.20 seconds.
Regarding the relative error, this would be:
0.20
× 100 %0.444 ... × 100 %≈ 44.44 %
0.45
ANNEX 3
01
02
03
04
05
06
07
08
09
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25