0% found this document useful (0 votes)
12 views3 pages

Understanding Crash Causation Factors

Uploaded by

kael
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
12 views3 pages

Understanding Crash Causation Factors

Uploaded by

kael
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

Welcome to Module 4.

In this module, we will look at the crash process, the importance of good
data, and how road safety engineers can break the chain of events that lead to a crash.

So, what is a road crash? The United Nations Economic Commission for Europe (UNECE) defines a
traffic collision as

• Occurring on a public road or travelway

• Resulting on someone being killed or injured, and

• Involving at least one moving vehicle.

It is important to remember that crashes are multi-factor events – we will look at it closer later in
this video.

There are three main types of crashes:

Single-vehicle crashes.

Vehicle to vehicle crashes which are divided into:

- Head-on.

- Side on.

- Rear-end.

And Vehicle to vulnerable road user crashes.

Remember – these account for more than half of all fatalities on the world’s roads.

Single-vehicle crashes usually involve:

loss of control,

running off the road, with injuries caused by

- sudden impact with rigid objects at the roadside,

- or roll-over of the vehicle.

Head-on vehicle crashes, usually result from overtaking or loss of control of the vehicle.

Single vehicle and head-on crashes occur more often in rural locations because there are more
opportunities for high speeds and overtaking.

Side-on crashes usually occur with vehicles turning at intersections, out of or into a side road or
access.

Rear-end (shunt) crashes usually occur with a vehicle waiting to turn at an intersection or stopped at
a pedestrian crossing.

Side-on and rear-end crashes tend to occur more often in urban locations, with more intersections
and stationary vehicles.

Vulnerable road user injuries (including injuries to people on powered two-wheelers) usually happen
when hit by a motor vehicle.

These occur more often in urban areas – towns and villages.


There are three main types of contributing factors, which overlap:

Human factors. People make mistakes.

Vehicle factors

Road infrastructure and environment factors, the road infrastructure, but also (for example)
weather.

Crashes are never caused by just one factor.

Let’s look at the story of a crash.

A car has run off a road, at a sharp bend, down a steep embankment, and hit a tree, in a rural
location at night.

The crashed car was not seen for 3 hours.

The ambulance arrived 1 hour later, treated the injured “at the scene”, then delivered the casualties
to the hospital, but the passenger had already died.

Pause the video for a few minutes and try to answer these questions: What caused the crash (which
could be prevented)? How could the forces of impact have been reduced? And most importantly in a
Safe System: How could the fatality and injuries have been prevented?

So, when the police arrived, they found that:

• the driver had been driving too fast.

• The driver had a high alcohol content in his blood test.

• The driver and passenger were not wearing seatbelts.

The Police recorded the “cause” as “speeding compounded by alcohol.”

Then Vehicle engineers inspected the vehicle and found problems with:

- brakes,

- steering,

- headlights,

- seatbelts.

After that, highway engineers inspected the site and observed that:

The sharp bend was at the end of a long straight section.

There was no "Curve" warning sign (it was damaged previously and not replaced).

There were no edge line markings on that road, nor tactile edge lines road studs which might have
alerted the driver.

Centreline markings had faded, due to poor quality of paint.

Embankment height was 3.5m high, side slope 1:2. There were no crash barriers at that location.

The tree was 5m from near the edge of the traffic lane, with no crash protection.
The emergency services were not aware of the crash for 3 hours.

They took 1 hour to arrive with medical help.

Earlier may have avoided the fatality.

These factors can be described as a chain of events, which all contributed to the crash and its
severity.

If just one of these factors in the chain had been changed, would the chain have been broken?
Would the crash have happened, or the injuries reduced been avoided if we had:

Better driver behaviour.

Better vehicle design and maintenance.

Better police enforcement for both driving and vehicle condition.

Better emergency services, facilities and responses.

Most crucially, better road design and maintenance can prevent death and injury despite other
factors. Forgiving road design is an essential part of a safe system.

In this module, we will also look at another case study – "Jane's Story" – a fictitious scenario to
explain the chain of events that leads to a crash.

It was developed by Dr Barbara Sabey from Transport Research Laboratory in the UK and first used
in the 1980s.

Please watch it once you have finished this video.

In summary, in this module, we learned that

According to the UNECE, a crash involves at least one motor vehicle and results in death and/or
injury.

There are three main types of crashes: single-vehicle crash, vehicle to a vehicle crash and vehicle to
vulnerable road user crash.

Crashes are multi-factor events. There are three main types of contributing factors to a crash:
human factors, vehicle factors, road infrastructure and environmental factors.

Crashes are never caused by just one factor.

Avoiding road death and injury is at the heart of the Safe System.

Road Engineers can provide a self-explaining road that helps avoid drivers’ mistakes. By providing
good quality signing, road markings and surfacing, we can often break the chain of events that lead
to a crash.

Forgiving road design aims to prevent death and injury when a crash occurs. We will hear more
about this in later modules.

That concludes this Module on Crash Causation.

In the next module, we will look at Road Safety Engineering Measures of Speed Management.

Common questions

Powered by AI

Human factors such as errors in judgment, speeding, and impaired driving play a significant role in initiating road crashes. Strategies to address these factors include public awareness campaigns, strict enforcement of traffic laws, driver education programs, and using technology like breathalyzers and speed cameras. These measures help promote safer driving behaviors, reducing the likelihood of crashes caused by human errors .

The delay in emergency response significantly contributed to the fatality; the crash was unnoticed for 3 hours, and the ambulance arrived 1 hour after being alerted. This delay reduced the chances of survival for the passenger, who might have survived with faster medical intervention. Improving emergency response times is vital in reducing mortality rates in crashes, suggesting the need for systems like automated crash alerts and quicker dispatch protocols to ensure timely assistance in rural areas .

Using the Safe System approach in rural road design could involve implementing features such as clear and durable road markings, 'Curve' warning signs before bends, rumble strips, crash barriers at hazardous locations, and improved lighting. Introducing these measures would account for human error, vehicle limitations, and environmental factors, thereby reducing crash risks by providing clear guidance and physically safeguarding users. These changes create a more forgiving environment that reduces the severity of errors and accidents, ultimately minimizing fatalities and injuries .

The Safe System approach suggests interventions focusing on better driver behavior, vehicle maintenance, police enforcement, emergency service responses, and crucially, road design and maintenance. By addressing multiple factors together, this comprehensive approach effectively mitigates the risk of fatal crashes. For example, forgiving road design, like implementing crash barriers and clear road markings, can reduce the severity of crashes, while improved enforcement policies discourage risky driving behaviors. Enhanced emergency response can reduce fatality rates if injuries occur .

Road infrastructure and vehicle design play complementary roles in preventing crashes. Good infrastructure, such as well-maintained roads with clear signage and barriers, supports safe vehicle operation by guiding drivers and mitigating errors. Simultaneously, advanced vehicle design, including features like stability control and crash-absorbent structures, enhances safety by preventing loss of control and reducing the impact of collisions. Together, these elements form an integrated safety network that reduces crash likelihood and severity, aligning with the Safe System approach .

The case study identified multiple contributing factors to the crash: the driver was speeding and had a high alcohol content; vehicle defects were found in brakes, steering, headlights, and seatbelts; poor road design included a sharp bend with no warning signs, faded road markings, and no crash barriers. To mitigate these issues and prevent future incidents, improvements in driver behavior through stricter enforcement of alcohol limits and speeding laws, better vehicle maintenance and design, enhanced road signage and marking maintenance, and the implementation of forgiving road designs such as crash barriers and adequate warning signs are necessary .

Forgiving road design includes elements like crash barriers, effective signage, road markings, and well-maintained surfaces. These elements contribute to road safety by minimizing the impact of driver errors and reducing crash severity. For instance, crash barriers prevent vehicles from leaving the road at high speeds, while clear signage and markings provide drivers with timely information that aids in decision-making and prevents accidents. By considering human error and vehicle limitations, forgiving design creates a safer environment that reduces the likelihood and impact of crashes .

Vehicle maintenance is crucial in preventing road accidents, as demonstrated in the case study. The inspection revealed faults in the brakes, steering, headlights, and seatbelts, which could have contributed to the driver's loss of control and the crash's severity. Regular maintenance can prevent such mechanical failures, ensuring that vehicles remain roadworthy and less likely to contribute to or worsen crashes. Emphasizing vehicle maintenance, along with driver education and regulations, can significantly reduce accident rates .

The severity of the crash was increased by the absence of several critical road design features. The lack of a 'Curve' warning sign, faded centreline markings, absence of edge line markings, and missing crash barriers all contributed to the driver's inability to navigate the sharp bend safely. The lack of these features meant that the driver was not adequately warned of the danger, and there was no infrastructure in place to mitigate the crash's impact, such as barriers that could have absorbed some of the collision force .

Single-vehicle crashes typically occur in rural areas and often involve loss of control or running off the road, usually due to factors like high speeds and overtaking opportunities. On the other hand, vehicle-to-vehicle crashes such as side-on and rear-end collisions usually occur in urban areas with more intersections and stationary vehicles, and are often caused by turning movements or vehicles waiting at intersections .

You might also like