0 ratings 0% found this document useful (0 votes) 13 views 17 pages Dispute Resolution Chapter 1
The document discusses various methods of dispute resolution in the Philippines, emphasizing the importance of alternative dispute resolution (ADR) systems like mediation and arbitration. It outlines the legal framework supporting these systems, including Republic Act No. 9285, which promotes party autonomy and efficient justice. Additionally, it highlights the role of local justice systems, such as the Barangay justice system and indigenous practices, in resolving conflicts amicably.
AI-enhanced title and description
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content,
claim it here .
Available Formats
Download as PDF or read online on Scribd
Go to previous items Go to next items
f. Professional Crisis ea
g. Management Crisis
Lesson 3- How to Mitigate Nature Induced Crisis 101
a. The DRRM rules 101
b. The IATF protocols
sson 4- How to Mitigate and Avert
lesson ® framan Induced Crisis ae
a. Law on Abduction 47
b. Law on serious illegal detention v0
and kidnapping 179
c RA18
190
References
iv
sesneesnssiensnenisnnennnsennsannsnnensnaincsntaie,
connate
CHAPTER I
DISPUTE RESOLUTION
In the Philippines disputes are resolved in various
ways where the objective is to come up with a win- win
situation and restore the peace between the parties:
Hence, the following are adopted:
LESSON 1: SCOPE
ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION, BARANGAY
JUSTICE, ARBITRATIONS SYSTEM AND
RESTORATIVE JUSTICE SYSTEM
Introduction
In the Philippines, we are one of the very fortunate
in terms of justice system and processes. Why? We are
allowed by law and by custom to choose from different
options to resolve our conflicts.
It can be observed that the three sets of justice
system namely; the Barangay justice system which
admits or serve as an alternative justice for easy and
or summary resolution of disputes, Outside ‘of it,
when a resolution was not met, then it can pass on
to the regular or mainstream justice process after a
certification of non-resolution passed by the LUPON.
Another distinct justice system is the existence of
several tribal or indigenous justice systems which the
law on Indigenous Peoples Rights Act (IPRA) recognized
as binding agreement of parties in dispute
We can also gleaned that our Philippine justi
system is both restorative and retributive in the se:
that it allows resolution of disputes by parties thro.
Chapter I: Dispute Resolutioni i 4. penalties
mediation and arbitration where claims an
can be waived or lessen depending on the agreement of
the parties in dispute. Under the spirit of the alternative
dispute resolution (ADR), the parties will make amends,
with their conflict and come again as close friends as i
nothing happened.
wir justice system may be considered as
retributive as gleaned from the regular or mainstream
justice system were all crimes have corresponding
penalties attached to it as means of reparation and or
Fetribution to the affected party. Nevertheless, within
the regular process, there are stages where it allows the
dispute to be resolved amicably; these are manifesta
of restorative processes.
Objectives: At the end of the course, the students
should be able to: -_
1. Recognize the summary nature of justice
resolution at the Barangay level;
2. Compare the pillars of the criminal justice
system;
3. Explain the general function and operation
of the criminal justice system;
4, Identify the loop holes and recommended
solution to some problems; oe
Comprehend fully the importance of the
© Sve pillars of the CJS;
6, Analyze the objectives of the CJS; and
5 ir respective responsibility in
7 Byaluats genance of peace and order in thelr
own community;
8. Generate foundational knowledge on the
different tribal/indigenous justice system
practiced in the Philippines.
.s / Incident Management
|
|
Vocabulary. For purposes of this text, the words are
defined operationally to suit its usage in the discussion.
a
b.
Justice. Refers to giving what is due to anybody,
preservation and respecting the rights accorded
y law to anybody.
Justice system. by operation, it means the
processes and procedures to be observed in the
verification and investigation of any untoward
acts committed by somebody that tarnishes the
rights of somebody in order to determine what is
due to be awarded to the affected person.
Alternative dispute resolution. Thi
action sanctioned by law to resolve
manner that is immediate and inexpen
an end in view of restoring peace bet
affected parties.
Arbitration agreement, shall mean an agreement
by the parties to submit to one or more arbitrators
the resolution of all or certain civil disputes which
have arisen or which may arise in respect of a
defined legal relationship (whether contractual
or not) and to abide by their award (hereinafter
referred to as “arbitral award”).
's to any
spute ina
ve, with,
cen two
. Arbitral tribunal. Shall mean a sole arbitrator or
a panel of two or more arbitrators, who, based on
an arbitration agreement, conduict proceedings
and make an arbitral award in respect of civil
disputes subject thereto.
Written statement, Shall mean a document that a
party prepares and submits to an arbitral tribunal
in arbitral proceedings and which states the case
of that party.
Punong barangay. Refers to the chairman of
a barangay duly voted by its constituents, he
held executive authority over the barangay and
uses his authority to promote the welfare of the
barangay as a whole
Sangguniang pambarangay. Refers to the
barangay legislative body tasked to develop
Chapter I: Dispute Resolution 3ordinances to regulate the affairs of the barangay
duly
es tagapayapa. A pangkat (group)
* Glsnifed by the punong barangay to arbitrate
Sfeertain complaints that were not successfully
resolved under the mediation of the punong
barangay. —
j. Lupong tagapagkasundo. A special bo
J eperited by the punong barangay through the
Selection of parties of a disputes that will serve as
a go between or act as mediators for the speedy
Tesolution of the dispute not successfully resolved
by the lupong tagapayapa. .
_ refers not only to barrios which were
k. Barangay Jarangays by vittue of Presidential
Decree No. 557 but also to barangays otherwise
known as citizens assemblies pursuant to
Presidential Decree No. 86.
Captain. Refers to the Barangay
Captain of the barrios which declared barangay
by virtue of Presidential Decree No. 557 and to
the’ Chairmen of barangays otherwise Imown
fas citizens assemblies pursuant to Presidential
Decree No. 86.
LESSON 2. ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION
Objectives: At the end of the lesson, the learners
will be able to:
| Recognize the significance of the alternative
dispute resolution;
Demonstrate appreciation all about the
alternative dispute resolution;
Infer deeper importance of the alternative
dispute resolution;
4. Relate to the wisdom of the use of alternative
dispute resolution.
4 Dispute Resolution and Crises / Incident Management
Pre-test. This pre-test will try to determine your basic
knowledge regarding alternative dispute resolution as
an instrument of keeping peace at the grassroots level.
1. What do you understand of the word dispute
resolution?
2. Do you know of any restorative process of dispute
resolution?
3. What are the benefits of amicable settlements?
4, What do you understand about the barangay
justice system?
5. What is your idea about indigenous justice
processes?
Definition of Alternative Justice Resolution
Any method of resolving disputes other than by
litigation. (Abbreviated as ADR) Public courts may be
asked to review the validity of ADR methods, but they
will rarely overturn ADR decisions and awards if the
disputing parties formed a valid contract to abide by
them. Arbitration and mediation are the two major
forms of ADR. This relates to civil form of justice where
the agreement of the parties are binding between them
and should be recognized by law.
OVERVIEW
Alternative Dispute Resolution (‘ADR’) refers to
any means of settling disputes outside of the courtroom.
ADR typically includes early neutral evaluation,
negotiation, conciliation, mediation, and arbitration. AS
burgeoning court queues, rising costs of litigation, and
time delays continue to ‘plague litigants, more states
have begun experimenting with ADR programs. Some
of these programs are voluntary; others are mandatory.
While the two most common forms of ADR are
arbitration and mediation, negotiation is almost always
Chapter I: Dispute Resolution 5attempted first to resolve a dispute. It is the preeminent
mode of dispute resolution. Negotiation allows the
parties to meet in order to settle a dispute. The main
Advantage of this form of dispute settlement is that it
allows the parties themselves to control the process and
the solution.
Mediation is also an_ informal alternative
to litigation. Mediators are individuals trained, in
negotiations, which bring opposing parties together
and attempt to work out a settlement or agreement that
both parties accept or reject. Mediation is used for a
wide gamut of case-types ranging from juvenile felonies
to national government negotiations. Mediation has
also become a significant method for resolving disputes
between investors and their stock brokers.
A. Pertinent Provisions of the ADR law
Republic Act No. 9285, April 2, 2004, an act
to institutionalize the use of an alternative dispute
resolution system in the Philippines and to establish
the office for alternative dispute resolution, and for
other purposes
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of
Representatives of the Philippines in Congress
assembled:
GENERAL PROVISIONS
SEC. 2. Declaration of Policy. it is hereby declared the
policy of the State to actively promote party autonomy
jn the resolution of disputes or the freedom of the
party to make their own arrangements to resolve their
disputes. Towards this end, the State shall encourage
and actively promote the use of Alternative Dispute
Resolution (ADR) as an important means to achieve
speedy and impartial justice and declog court dockets.
As such, the State shall provide means for the use of
‘ADR as an efficient tool and an alternative procedure for
the resolution of appropriate cases. Likewise, the State
6 Dispute Resolution and Crises / Incident Management
shall enlist active private sector partici
settiement of disputes through ADR. This Act shall be
without prejudice to the adoption by the Supreme Court
of any ADR system, such as mediation, conciliation,
arbitration, or any combination thereof as a means of
achieving speedy and efficient means of resolving cases
pending before all courts in the Philippines which shall
be governed by such rules as the Supreme Court may
approve from time to time.
MEDIATION
SEC. 7. Scope. The provisions of this Chapter shail cover
voluntary mediation, whether ad hoc or institutional
other than court-annexed. The term “mediation’ shall
include conciliation.
SEC. 8. Application and Interpretation. In applyin
construing the provisions of this Chapter, consideration
must be given to the need to promote candor or parties
and mediators through confidentiality of the mediation
process, the policy of fostering prompt, economical, and
amicable resolution of disputes in accordance with the
principles of integrity of determination by the parties,
and the policy that the decision-making authority in the
mediation process rests with the parties. -
SEC. 9. Confidentiality of Information. Information
obtained through mediation proceedings shall be
subject to the following principles and guidelines:
a) Information obtained through mediation shall be
privileged and confidential.
b) A party, a mediator, or a nonparty participant
may refuse to disclose and may prevent any
other person from disclosing a mediation
communication,
¢) Confidential Information shall not be subject
to discovery and shall be inadmissible if any
adversarial proceeding, whether judicial or quasi-
judicial, However, evidence or information that
Chapter I: Dispute Resolution 7