HFC Quota System: EU Implementation Insights
HFC Quota System: EU Implementation Insights
Natasha Kochova
June 14, 2023
UNIDO KIP workshop
Quota allocation (market measure)
Vienna,
14 June 2023
Main logic of the EU F-gas Regulation
➢Companies importing or producing HFCs (bulk!) get HFC quota every year (in
CO2eq) → more metric tonnes for climate-friendlier substances can be sold
➢A company can only place quantities of HFCs on the EU market up to their anual quota
limit
➢All HFCs in pre-charged RAC equipment need to be accounted for in the quota system
Implementation of quota system
• Less burden for economic operators, customs and authorities, but better control
o real-time license check
o quota debit system
o flagging of suspicious activties
o tracking of shipment data
2014 F-gas Regulation
Quota System
Incentive for innovation
• Prohibitions are easier to implement and predictable, but more difficult to design (need for
exemptions, timing of the dates, definitions of scope..)
→ A combination of quota system and add. prohibitions („signpost“) has worked well in the EU
• Today feasible in many areas to eliminate HFCs, or at least reduce GWP significantly
o R404A/R507A/R410A is obsolete today!
o One-way cylinders should be banned!
• HFC fees implemented in some countries (ES; FR;..); additional fiscal measures may be useful, but
charge at upper level (imports/production), not at enduser level
• Awareness raising is crucial for quota system, also with customs; close cooperation with competent
authorities important
Refrigeration – EU market situation today
Supermarket systems Transcritical CO2 systems with high energy efficiency are now the
standard solution for new supermarket refrigeration systems.
Components and specialized technical personnel are widely available.
Stand-alone commercial Systems running on R290 as a refrigerant are the standard solution
systems for small shops and discounters (refrigerated shelves, freezers etc.)
Transport refrigeration Research and development as well as market introduction of CO2 and
propane solutions for refrigerated trucks and vans
Refrigerant recycling and Specialized refrigerant handling companies collect recovered refrigerants
reclaim from service companies and gas distributors and perform analytical
checks. On the basis of the analysis, reclamation is carried out in
dedicated facilities or the refrigerant is sent for destruction.
AC & heatpumps – EU market situation today
Moveable room AC Hydrocarbons (R290; propane) are the standard refrigerant is small moveable air
conditioning systems in the EU since 2020
Split AC HFC reduction through the use of the interim solution R32, with the prospect of a broader use
of natural refrigerants in line with the revised safety standard IEC 60335-2-40.
Market introduction of hydrocarbons (R290; propane) in split air conditioners.
Conventional HFC refrigerants are hardly used any more.
Chillers Mini-chillers with R290 (5-30 kW; 2-4 kg charge, with a secondary glycol/water loop) represent
a solution for various applications.
For large chillers, ammonia (R717) has long been established on the market (high efficiency).
Propane (R290), CO2 (R744) and water (R718) are also entering the market.
Bus AC CO2 heat pumps systems in electric and hybrid buses are common
Passenger car AC CO2 heat pumps systems in electric passenger cars (AC and range extension) are common
Heat pumps Research and development of low-charge R290 systems (12.8 kW heating capacity with 124 g
of R290 → refrigerant charge ca. 10 g/kW). Many EU suppliers offer propane solutions,
especially in the heating capacity range <12 kW.
Increasing use of heat pump solutions also in larger applications.
New European Commission Proposal
45
40
millition tonnes CO2 equivalent
35
30
25
Current law
20
15
10
Newly proposed
phase-down
5
0
2024 2027 2030 2033 2036 2039 2042 2045 2048
Some newly proposed, additional prohibitions
• Refrigeration sector mostly covered by existing Regulation
• NEW: AC/heatpumps:
• Export bans? …not in the Commission proposal, but now on the table…
What do we expect out of this?
• Emission reductions: By 2050, avoid (cumulatively) 310 MtCO2eq (ca. total annual emissions of
Belgium, Luxemburg and Netherlands together), on top of 430 MtCO2eq to be saved by the existing
Regulation
• Climate neutrality: Remaining EU F-gas emissions in 2050 will be only ca 14 MtCO2eq (2019:
92MtCO2eq)
• Modest Costs: In most cases will be low compared to those asked of non-Fgas sectors on the road to
climate neutrality, and will in all cases be proportionate
• Stimulating effects (output, innovation, employment), particularly on the equipment sector and its
supply industry,
• Significantly improved control over the policy, allowing effective enforcement in the Member States,
at a moderate increase in administrative burden to companies and authorities
[Link]
UNIDO Kigali Implementation Plan workshop. Session 2: Quota allocation, instruments and country experiences | 14 June 2023 | Vienna | Peder Gabrielsen
HFC phase-
Bans Labelling Reporting
down
Reporting
Recovery &
Leakage Training &
waste
control certification
management
Source: Annual European Union greenhouse gas inventory 1990–2021 and inventory report 2023. Submission to the
UNFCCC Secretariat, 15 April 2023. EEA greenhouse gases — data viewer
[Link]
HFC phase-down (under the EU F-gas Regulation)
Data from the past is used as basis for designing a system to allocate HFC quota
Reporting used as basis for tracking progress of the EU HFC phase-down
Reference period 2009-2012
Initial total quota allocation
183.1 Mt CO2e in 2015
(baseline)
EU-wide placing on the
market (POM) of HFCs in
2021 was 4 % below the
market limit.
Reporters in 2021
• 2213 data reports
• 2377 NIL reports
(no reportable activity)
Number of equipment
importers stabilised during
the last few years
Non-electronic vs. electronic reporting
Example 1: Non-electronic reporting Example 2: Electronic reporting
Companies report using different data formats Companies report via an electronic webform
Company Company
2 Company 2
Company Company
1
1 3
Company
3
Central Data
Repository
Company
Company 2 Company
1 3
National Reporting
Agency (e.g. NOU)
31
Comparison of reporting data flows: communication
Non-electronic reporting Electronic reporting
Company
Company 2 Company
1 3
National Reporting
Agency (e.g. NOU)
32
Comparison of reporting data flows: data quality
Non-electronic reporting Electronic reporting
Company
Company 2 Company
1 3
National Reporting
Agency (e.g. NOU)
Companies distributed
across all EU Member
States
Companies are mainly
from Poland, Italy,
France, Germany and
Other non-EU countries
(mainly China)
Institutional arrangements and products
1st Kigali
Amendment
HFC
submission
in 2020
43
HFC LICENSING, QUOTA AND REPORTING
-TÜRKİYE-
ECEM ERSOY
June 14, 2023
Vienna International Center
OUTLINE
1. Country Profile
2. Legislative background
3. HFC annual reporting
4. HFC licensing
5. HFC quota allocation
45/14
Country Profile
46/14
Country Profile
Türkiye ratified the Vienna Convention and Montreal Protocol in 1991 and
accepted its all amendments.
o On 10 November 2021, Türkiye ratified the Kigali Amendment and
entry into force on 8 February 2022.
HFC Phase-Down Schedule
A5 Group 1 Countries 10%
30%
50%
80%
47/14
Country Profile
2022 2024
48/14
Legislative background
REGULATION
➢ Regulation on Substances that Deplete the Ozone Layer - 2017
➢ Regulation on Fluorinated Greenhouse Gases - 2018 (Repealed)
➢ Regulation on Fluorinated Greenhouse Gases – 2022 (New)
COMMUNIQUE
➢ Communiqué on Certification of Natural and Legal Persons Interfering with Equipment
Containing Fluorinated Greenhouse Gases or whose Operation Relies on These Gases –
2020
➢ Communiqués on HFC trades by the Ministry of Trade – 2022/2023
CIRCULAR
➢ Halon Circular - 2017
➢ Circular on Import and Use of Ozone Depleting Substances – 2016
➢ Circular on the Management of F-gases - 2023
49/14
Legislative background
REGULATION
➢ Regulation on Substances that Deplete the Ozone Layer - 2017
➢ Regulation on Fluorinated Greenhouse Gases - 2018 (Repealed)
➢ Regulation on Fluorinated Greenhouse Gases – 2022 (New)
517/2014 EU
KIGALI
COMMUNIQUE
➢ Communiqué on Certification of Natural and Legal Persons Interfering with Equipment
Containing Fluorinated Greenhouse Gases or whose Operation Relies on These Gases –
2020
➢ Communiqués on HFC trades by the Ministry of Trade – 2022/2023
CIRCULAR
➢ Halon Circular - 2017
➢ Circular on Import and Use of Ozone Depleting Substances – 2016
➢ Circular on the Management of F-gases - 2023
50/14
Legislative background
Regulation on Fluorinated Greenhouse Gases – 2022 (New)
CERTIFICATION
OF NATURAL LEAK
AND LEGAL CONTROLS
PERSONS
HFC QUOTA
AND LABELLING
LICENSING
51/14
Legislative background
Regulation on Fluorinated Greenhouse Gases – 2022 (New)
RULES AND
PRINCIPLES
52/14
Online System
130
Registered Company
70+
Annual Reporting
60+
Licensing
Licensing
Quota
50+
Quota Request
Annual Reporting
53/14
F-gas Reporting
By 31 March each year, f-gas activities during preceding year shall be reporting through the online system.
• Importer/Exporter Country
• Types of product/equipment
• Amount of product/equipment
• F-gas in product/equipment
• Importer/Exporter Country
• Amount of F-gas
• Types of product/equipment
• Amount of
product/equipment
• F-gas in product/equipment
• Intended use
• Amount of f-gases
• Destruction method
• Waste code
54/14
HFC Licensing
• Licensing system for import & export of bulk HFCs is activated as of 10 May 2023
• Licensing is required per import & export
• The system is integrated single-window system of Customs Directorates
55/14
HFC Licensing
HFC type
- New HFCs list tons CO2e Label SDS
- Recycled HS codes Country
- Reclaimed of Origin
Quantity
56/14
Licensing, Reporting and Quota Allocation via Online System
OPPORTUNITIES
57/14
HFC Quota
58/14
THANK YOU !
W W W. İ K L İ M . G O V.T R
W W W. O Z O N T U R K I Y E . C S B . G O V.T R
@TC_İKLİM
Country experiences and
achievements: HFC licensing,
quota system and reporting
Tatjana Boljevic
Environmental Protection Agency
Montenegro
Relevant legislation
Montreal Kigali
Protocol: October 2006 Amendment On April 23, 2019
ratified the
Montenegro has
Vienna Convention
became a party to
and Montreal
the Kigali
Protocol and four
Amendment
Amendments
63
National Legislation
Rulebook on the closer manner and necessary documentation for issue permits for
import/export ODS and alternative substances
• (Off Gazz MNE, no 69/2020)
64
Competent authority for issuing permits
65
ODS LICENSING/QUOTA SYSTEM
• Quota for ODS/CFC was established in 2007 by Government decision as a new Party to the Montréal
Protocol in 2007 was prepared and approved CP, TPMP, IS
2007
66
HFC LICENSING/QUOTA SYSTEM
2011
• Licencing system for import/export of HFC was established
2021
• HFC phase down schedule in accordance with the Montreal
protocol provision for A5 group 1 country;
• Quota system for HFC is prescribed and will start from 1 January
2024 (first control measure), will be in tones CO2eq;
67
Steps before import/export HCFC/HFC
◈ The annual import quota is determined by the Agency based on the share in the
total amount of imported substances in the period of base consumption.
◈ A quota in the amount of 10% of the total annual quota is determined for legal
entities (importers) who imports HCFC/HFC for the first time.
◈ Annual quota for HCFC is in Mt, and for HFC is in tones CO2eq;
◈ Permits for imports and exports of HCFC/HFC are issued for each shipment
68
separately
Documentation for import/export
72
THANK YOU!
73
For possible consideration…