3D Coal Resource Estimation Using IDW
3D Coal Resource Estimation Using IDW
1, MAR 2022 11
Keywords: Resource Estimation, 3-D Geological modeling, Coal Quality Parameters, Inverse Distance Weighting Method
and zinc mine of Arhada to calculate the reserves and evaluate 1.1 Inverse Distance Weighting Method
the grade of lead, zinc, and silver using Distance Power (IDWM)
Inverse Ratio Method (DPIRM). 3D geological model which
includes fault wireframe model, terrain model & coal and IDWM is an interpolation technique used for estimating the
rock-solid model was built and compared with traditional unknown value by known values. The unknown values are
methods. A block model was also built to calculate the mining more or less influenced by the values which are closer to them.
and stripping quantities [13]. Modeling of coal deposit in N- The IDWM takes the known points and create the surface by
W Greece was conducted to evaluate the lignite resources estimating unknown points. IDWM relies on the inverse of
[25]. Coal quality parameters of a multi-layer coal resources distance raised to a mathematical power. The higher the power
were evaluated with 3 geostatistics approaches (ordinary the more influence on nearest point [33]. The mathematical
kriging, co-kriging, and functional-kriging) by [26, 27]. 3D formula of IDW is shown in Equation 1.
geological modeling of surface, ore deposit, cavity, fault, and
underground openings were constructed. The volume of ore Wi
∑n
i=1 p
d
body and grades of lead, Zinc, and tin were estimated using Wp = 1
i
(1)
ordinary kriging method and their grades were compared to ∑n
i=1 p
d
i
original prospecting results [28]. 3D subsurface modeling was
done at Handeresi metal mine using Inverse Distance where, Wp is estimated weight at unknown point, Wi is the
Weighted (IDW) interpolation for ore grade estimation and weight of known point (measured location) and d i is the
kriging for surface modeling. An intense vegetated area with distance between the location of known value and unknown
irregularly and insufficient boreholes was targeted. Three ore value, p is the power value.
zones were seen intensively [29]. A simple approach called
the horizons method was presented for generating a Solid 1.1.1 Considerable Parameters of IDWM
model [30]. Coal zones of heterogeneous formations were
interpolated and simulated for evaluating the coal resources Power Value: The power in IDWM play a significant role
and reserves [31]. Geostatistical modeling of High for predicting the values at unknown locations. With the
Phosphorous (HP) stockpile at iron mine of Iran was increase of power value, the influence of nearest value
performed to evaluate the reserves and grades using ordinary increases on predicted location and the influence of
kriging method [32]. known value which are far from unknown value
The coal resource of BCF, block-I were estimated using decreases [33]. By increasing the power, the maps
Bore Hole Influence Method (BHIM) of USGS coal resource become so detailed and values are assigned in polygonal
classification standard. Computer aided modeling for way that is the established power for geological deposits.
quantification of coal resources has not been conducted yet. Search radius: By specifying the search radius only those
The major limitation of previous resource estimation points will be used by the interpolation which lie within
technique is a high level of uncertainty due to ignorance of the search radius. With the increase of search radius,
spatial continuity of seam thickness. This study aims to more points are included for predicting the unknown
generate solid model and block model to estimate the coal values.
resource of coal seam using drill-hole database in the
computer-aided software Geovia-Surpac and to develop 1.2 Badin Coal Field (BCF)
spatial distribution maps for various coal quality parameters
using an interpolation method, Inverse Distance Weighted BCF was discovered by Geological Survey of Pakistan (GSP)
Method (IDWM). in 2005. Almost 850 million tons of coal resources in the BCF
PAKISTAN
with coal thickness ranging between 0.55 to 3.1 meters were Table 1 Lithology of BCF, block-I
informed by GSP [34]. The review of data of holes drilled by Formation Thickness
GSP, Sindh Coal Authority, and drilling by Al-Abbas Group Lithology
and age (m)
indicated the presence of six shallow coal beds on the western Alluvium
side of BCF. The detailed exploration of about 50% of 100 sq. 50-95 Silt, clay, and sand.
(recent)
km granted to Roadways Pakistan (Pvt) limited as
Sub-recent Sandstone, siltstone,
reconnaissance license has been carried out by Al-Abbas 20-50
formation and claystone.
group in august 2007. Table 1 shows the lithology of BCF,
block-I and Figure 1 shows location map presenting boreholes Bara Sandstone,
and boundary of BCF, block-I. formation >230.30 carbonaceous
(Paleocene) claystone, and coal
2 Materials and Methods
Table 2 Summary of drill--hole information
2.1 Exploratory data analysis Depth of drillhole
Average (m)
No. of drillholes
The exploratory data of thirty-three boreholes drilled by Al- DS1 (m)
Min2 Max3 Avg4
Abaas group in 2007 was collected and examined in order to
create a high-quality database. The obtained data includes 33 1200 109.72 251.76 180.74
collar information, lithological data, and coal quality Note: Drillhole Spacing, Minimum, Maximum, 4Average
1 2 3
2.2.1 Solid modeling average drill-hole spacing. Block model was created in the
computer aided software Geovia-Surpac. After generating the
Solid modeling is a computer-aided modeling of an objects in block model, a constrained coal seam model was created from
which data is triangulated using two methods known as top to solid seam model (.dtm). The constrained model was used to
bottom surface method and section method. In the section generate the spatial maps of coal seam. The constrained model
method, the vertical sections of the coal seam are created and was filled with coal quality parameters values using an
triangulated to produce a 3-D solid seam model whereas in the interpolation method IDWM for estimating the values in
top to bottom surface method, the model is generated by whole seam. After filling the block model properly, a
triangulating and interpolating the top and bottom of the seam. command Block Model Graphics Attribute Colour (BMGAC)
Finally, the top and bottom surface of seam is combined to was used to generate the spatial map.
produce a 3-D solid seam model [10, 11, 19]. In this study top
to bottom surface method was used to produce a 3-D solid 3 Results and discussion
seam model in the computer-aided software Geovia-Surpac
6.6.2. The structural simplicity of seam caused to use the top For estimating the coal resources available in coal seam, a
to bottom surface method for creating the solid model. non-conventional method that uses Surpac 6.6.2. was used.
Geovia-Surpac is a user-friendly and registered software in First of all, a digital geological database was generated which
the department of Mining Engineering. The software is the foundation of all geological modeling. After that the
contained multiple options for modeling. A digital geological coal resources were estimated by generating a solid seam
database is used to create a model. Two compulsory tables model. 3D solid seam model was used to generate a block
(collar and survey table) which contains various fields are the model in order to develop the spatial distribution maps. The
basic for modeling. Whereas, optional tables are also used for minimum depth of coal seam was found as 113 meters below
different purposes. In this study, two optional tables (geology the surface. The maximum thickness of coal seam is 6.2
and survey table) were used. Tables and fields used in meters which is encountered in only one borehole. The coal
Geovia-Surpac for generating 3D geological modeling are seam model estimated a volume of 18.689 million m3. Figure
shown in Table 4. After generating the solid model, the 3 a, b, c, and d shows the spatial distribution maps for
volume of coal seam model was calculated which is Moisture Content (MC), Ash, Gross Calorific Value (GCV),
automated in Geovia-Surpac by using OBJECT REPORT and Sulfur respectively. The spatial distribution maps of coal
(OBJREP) command. The command used will generate a file seam show the increase in moisture content from north-east
reporting the volume of coal seam. Figure 2 shows the process (35-37%) toward south-west (38-39%) with a negligible
used to generate a solid model through Surpac. variation in moisture content of coal seam. The ash content of
coal seam increase from west toward east. The Gross Calorific
2.2.2 Block modeling Value (GCV) is homogeneously distributed with an average
GCV (3750 k. Cal/kg), except in southern block. The sulfur
In this study, the constructed 3-D solid seam model was content of coal seam located in the south-west is less than the
divided into a series of blocks having dimension 250 m × 250 sulfur content from north-east.
m × 0.5 m keeping in view the thickness of coal seam and the
Parameter Moisture Content (%) Ash (%) Gross Calorifc Value (K. Cal/kg) Sulfur (%)
Minimum 36.8 33.2 3097 0.6
Maximum 40.7 35.5 3982 1.7
Average 37.90 33.72 3571.05 0.87
Pakistan," International Journal of Coal Geology, Iran using geostatistical modeling," Mining Science
vol. 140, pp. 84-96, 2015. and Technology (China), vol. 20, pp. 855-860, 2010.
[20] M. C. Moharaj and Y. Wangmo, "Ore body [33] W. Maleika, "Inverse distance weighting method
modelling and comparison of different reserve optimization in the process of digital terrain model
estimation techniques," 2014. creation based on data collected from a multibeam
echosounder," Applied Geomatics, vol. 12, pp. 397-
[21] A. E. Tercan, B. Ünver, M. A. Hindistan, G. Ertunç,
407, 2020/12/01 2020.
F. Atalay, S. Ünal, et al., "Seam modeling and
resource estimation in the coalfields of western [34] M. S. Malkani, A. M. K. MH, F. Buzdar, and M.
Anatolia," International Journal of Coal Geology, Zahid, "Coal Resources of Pakistan: new coalfields,"
vol. 112, pp. 94-106, 2013. Lasbela University Journal of Science &
Technology, vol. 5, pp. 7-22, 2016.
[22] G. Ertunç, A. Tercan, M. Hindistan, B. Ünver, S.
Ünal, F. Atalay, et al., "Geostatistical estimation of [35] J. M. Thornton, G. Mariethoz, and P. Brunner, "A 3D
coal quality variables by using covariance matching geological model of a structurally complex Alpine
constrained kriging," International journal of coal region as a basis for interdisciplinary research,"
geology, vol. 112, pp. 14-25, 2013. Scientific Data, vol. 5, p. 180238, 2018/10/30 2018.
[23] H. Agrawal, "Modeling of opencast mines using
About Authors
Surpac and its optimization," 2012.
[24] P. Huang, P. Yang, J. Liu, and Q. Meng, Kanwal Nahiyoon is working as Teaching Assistant in the
"Application of Surpac Vision Software in Arhada Department of Mining Engineering, Mehran University of
Lead and Zinc Mine," 2012. Engineering and Technology, Jamshoro. She has recently
completed his Bachelor of Engineering in Mining
[25] I. K. Kapageridis and C. J. Kolovos, "Modelling and
Engineering. His research area focuses on the Computer
resource estimation of a thin-layered lignite deposit,"
Aided Coal Seam Modeling for Resource Estimation.
APCOM 2009 Proceedings, Vancouver, Canada, pp.
95-103, 2009.
Dr. Fahad Irfan Siddiqui is working as Associate Professor in
[26] M. N. Heriawan and K. Koike, "Uncertainty the Department of Mining Engineering, Mehran University of
assessment of coal tonnage by spatial modeling of Engineering and Technology, Jamshoro. He has recently
seam distribution and coal quality," International completed his PhD degree in Mining Engineering with prime
Journal of Coal Geology, vol. 76, pp. 217-226, emphasis on modeling and computational methods in Mining
2008/11/03/ 2008. Engineering. His research area focuses on the modeling of
[27] M. N. Heriawan and K. Koike, "Identifying spatial coal seam and generation of spatial maps.
heterogeneity of coal resource quality in a multilayer
coal deposit by multivariate geostatistics," Dr. Munawar Ali Pinjaro is working as Assistant Professor in
International Journal of Coal Geology, vol. 73, pp. the Department of Mining Engineering, Mehran University of
307-330, 2008/02/01/ 2008. Engineering and Technology, Jamshoro. He has recently
completed his PhD degree in the program of "Environmental
[28] Z.-q. Luo, L. Xiao-ming, S. Jia-hong, W. Ya-bin, and Science and Engineering" from the School of Environment,
L. Wang-ping, "Deposit 3D modeling and Tsinghua University in 2020. His research area focuses on the
application," Journal of Central South University of conversion of conventional borehole database into digital
Technology, vol. 14, pp. 225-229, 2007. database to be utilized for 3D geological modeling.
[29] S. Akiska, I. S. Sayili, and G. Demirela, "Three-
dimensional subsurface modeling of mineralization:
a case study from the Handeresi (Çanakkale, NW
Turkey) Pb-Zn-Cu deposit," Turkish Journal of
Earth Sciences, vol. 22, pp. 574-587, 2013.
[30] A. M. Lemon and N. L. Jones, "Building solid
models from boreholes and user-defined cross-
sections," Computers & Geosciences, vol. 29, pp.
547-555, 2003.
[31] O. Falivene, L. Cabrera, and A. Sáez, "Forecasting
coal resources and reserves in heterogeneous coal
zones using 3D facies models (As Pontes Basin, NW
Spain)," International journal of coal geology, vol.
130, pp. 8-26, 2014.
[32] S. Kasmaee, J. Gholamnejad, A. Yarahmadi, and H.
Mojtahedzadeh, "Reserve estimation of the high
phosphorous stockpile at the Choghart iron mine of