2) Definition, Features & Advantages of Incorporation (with Case Laws)

A company is defined under Section 2(20) of the Companies Act, 2013, as a company incorporated under
this Act or under any previous company law. It is a legal entity formed by a group of individuals to engage in
and operate a business—commercial or industrial—enterprise. It possesses a legal personality distinct from
its members.

The concept of a separate legal entity was firmly established by the landmark case of Salomon v. Salomon &
Co. Ltd. (1897). The House of Lords ruled that upon incorporation, a company becomes a separate legal
person from its owners, capable of owning property, incurring liabilities, and being sued in its own name.

Features of a Company:

1. Incorporated Association: A company comes into existence only when it is registered under the
Companies Act.
2. Artificial Legal Person: Though it lacks physical existence, the company is regarded as a legal entity
capable of rights and duties.
3. Separate Legal Entity: The company exists independently of its shareholders. It can enter into
contracts, hold property, and sue or be sued.
4. Perpetual Succession: The company’s existence does not depend on the life of its members. Death,
insolvency, or insanity of members does not affect the company.
5. Limited Liability: The liability of the members is limited to the amount unpaid on the shares held by
them.
6. Transferability of Shares: Shares in a public company are freely transferable, providing liquidity and
flexibility to shareholders.
7. Common Seal: Although no longer mandatory, a company may still adopt a common seal as its
official signature.
8. Capacity to Sue and Be Sued: A company can initiate legal proceedings in its own name.

Advantages of Incorporation:

1. Limited Liability: Members are not personally liable beyond their investment in the company’s
shares.
2. Separate Property: The company can own, enjoy, and dispose of property in its own name.
3. Raising Capital: Corporations can raise substantial capital by issuing shares and debentures.
4. Perpetual Existence: The company’s continuous existence provides long-term stability.
5. Economies of Scale: Companies enjoy benefits of large-scale operations.
6. Professional Management: Companies are generally managed by experts, leading to greater
efficiency.

Relevant Case Laws:

• Salomon v. Salomon & Co. Ltd. (1897): Established the principle of corporate personality.
• Lee v. Lee’s Air Farming Ltd. (1961): Held that a company and its controlling shareholder can enter
into an employment relationship.
• Macaura v. Northern Assurance Co. (1925): Held that shareholders have no legal or equitable
interest in company property.

1
3) Doctrine of Ultra Vires (with Ashbury Case)

The doctrine of ultra vires (beyond powers) limits the activities of a company to those specified in the object
clause of its Memorandum of Association. Acts outside this scope are void and cannot be ratified, even by
unanimous consent of shareholders.

Purpose of the Doctrine:

• Protects shareholders and creditors from unauthorized acts

Legal Consequences:

• Any ultra vires act is void ab initio.

Landmark Case:

Ashbury Railway Carriage and Iron Co. Ltd. v. Riche (1875) - Facts: The company, formed to make railway
carriages, financed a railway construction in Belgium. - Issue: Whether such financing was within the object
clause. - Held: The contract was ultra vires and void. - Principle: Company cannot go beyond its stated
objectives.

Exceptions / Mitigations:

• Modern legislation (Companies Act, 2013) allows companies to have more general object clauses.
• Section 245 allows members and depositors to seek remedies in case of prejudicial ultra vires acts.

4) Lifting of the Corporate Veil

A company is generally regarded as a separate legal entity. However, in certain circumstances, courts may
disregard this separate identity to identify the real actors behind the company. This is known as "lifting the
corporate veil."

Circumstances for Lifting the Veil:

1. Fraud or Improper Conduct:

3. Gilford Motor Co. v. Horne: Injunction granted against a former employee using a company as a cover
to violate a non-compete clause.

4. Tax Evasion or Avoidance of Welfare Laws:

2
 5. Courts have lifted the veil to prevent tax evasion or default on employee welfare payments.

6. Workmen of Associated Rubber Industries v. Associated Rubber Industries (1986)

7. Agency or Sham Companies:

8. When a company is merely an agent or a façade for another person or company.

9. To Determine Enemy Character:

10. Daimler Co. Ltd. v. Continental Tyre and Rubber Co. – Veil lifted to determine enemy ownership during
wartime.

11. Holding and Subsidiary Relationships:

12. To examine actual control in group company structures.

Statutory Recognition:

Though the Companies Act, 2013 does not codify this doctrine, courts apply it as an equitable remedy to
ensure justice.

5) Prospectus, Golden Rule, and Remedies for Misstatement

A prospectus is a formal legal document inviting the public to subscribe to a company’s shares or
debentures.

Definition (Section 2(70)):

A prospectus includes any document described or issued as a prospectus and includes red herring
prospectus or shelf prospectus.

Golden Rule (New Brunswick Railway Co. v. Muggeridge):

"Those who issue a prospectus hold out to the public the facts on which they invite them to act; they are
bound to state everything with strict and scrupulous accuracy."

Essentials of a Prospectus:

• Full disclosure of financials, risk factors, and company background

Misstatement in Prospectus (Sections 34 & 35):

• Civil Liability:

3
 • Investors can claim compensation for loss due to false or misleading statements.

• Applies to directors, promoters, and experts involved.

• Criminal Liability:

• Imprisonment up to 10 years and fine under Section 34.

• Right of Rescission:

• Shareholders can cancel their allotment and demand refund.

Defenses:

• Statement was immaterial

Case Example:

• Peek v. Gurney (1873) – Directors held liable for concealment of material facts.

This concludes detailed answers for Questions 2–5 in Company Law. Each response includes statutory
references, judicial interpretation, and practical implications as per the syllabus of Mumbai University SY
LLB.