Journal of Basic and Applied Pharmacology Page: [O81-95]

Vol. 3 No. 2 July - December 2023

Original research article

The link between PM2.5 exposure and

depression: A systematic review
Prayuth Poowaruttanawiwit1,5*, Chanida Chantim2,5, Fasinee Arunrodpanya3,
Kanphitcha Dedmad4, Junjilar Soputaon4
1
Department of Pharmacy Practice, Faculty of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Naresuan University,
Phitsanulok, 65000, Thailand
2
Department of Otolaryngology, Faculty of Medicine, Naresuan University, Phitsanulok, 65000, Thailand
3
Department of Psychiatry, Faculty of Medicine, Naresuan University, Phitsanulok, 65000, Thailand
4
Psychiatric Outpatient Clinic, Naresuan University Hospital, Phitsanulok, 65000, Thailand
5
Medical and Pharmacy Innovation Research and Development Unit, Faculty of Pharmaceutical
Sciences, Naresuan University, Phitsanulok, 65000, Thailand

Received 17 July 2023; Received in revised form 23 September 2023

Accepted 14 October 2023; Available online 5 November 2023

ABSTRACT
Objective: This study aimed to investigate the association between exposure to fine
particulate matter (PM2.5) and depression by conducting a systematic review.
Methods: A comprehensive search of electronic databases was performed to identify
relevant studies. The inclusion criteria were limited to original epidemiological studies that
examined the association between PM2.5 exposure and depression in human populations. Seven
studies met the eligibility criteria and were included in the final analysis. The included studies
were conducted in different countries and utilized varying study designs and sample sizes.
Systematic review was conducted to synthesize the findings from the individual studies.
Results: The results of the systematic review indicated a consistent association between
exposure to PM2.5 and depression. Moreover, the studies suggested that this association might
be bidirectional, with exposure to PM2. 5 leading to depression and depression increasing the
risk of PM2. 5 exposure. However, the strength of the association varied among studies,
indicating that the effect of PM2. 5 exposure on depression might be influenced by contextual
factors such as population characteristics, geographic location, and exposure duration. More
research is needed to establish a causal relationship between PM2.5 exposure and depression.
Conclusion: This systematic review highlights the significant impact of PM2.5 air
pollution on mental health, particularly its association with depression. Elevated levels of
PM2.5 are linked to an increased risk of depression, and long-term exposure to this pollutant
raises the risk of depression and anxiety, especially in males. Addressing PM2.5 pollution is
crucial for promoting mental well-being.

Keywords: fine particulate matter 2.5, mental health, depression, association, systematic review

*Corresponding author: yuth_pu@[Link]

[Link]
 P. Poowaruttanawiwit, et al. | Journal of Basic and Applied Pharmacology | Vol.3 No.2 July - December 2023

1. Introduction the current evidence and inform public health

Fine particulate matter (PM2.5) is a policies aimed at reducing the negative
major global public health concern due to its impact of air pollution on mental health.
association with adverse health outcomes,
including respiratory and cardiovascular 2. Methods
diseases, lung cancer, cognitive decline in This research aims to systematically
older adults, negative pregnancy outcomes, review the epidemiological studies available
and premature death. 1, 2 Recent evidence to investigate the association between
suggests that PM2. 5 exposure may also exposure to fine particulate matter ( PM2. 5)
increase the risk of type 2 diabetes and and depression. The objective is to provide
kidney disease. However, the association valuable insights into the potential relationship
between PM2. 5 exposure and depression between PM2. 5 exposure and depression,
remains unclear, although several potential informing future research and public health
mechanisms have been proposed, including interventions.
inflammation, oxidative stress, neurotransmitter The research design will be a
dysregulation, and epigenetic changes.3-6 The systematic review of epidemiological studies,
association between PM2. 5 exposure and following established guidelines such as
adverse health effects involves complex PRISMA ( Preferred Reporting Items for
mechanisms, including inflammation, oxidative Systematic Reviews and Meta- Analyses) 7
stress, neurotransmitter dysregulation, and and MOOSE ( Meta- analysis of Observational
epigenetic changes. PM2. 5 particles can Studies in Epidemiology).8
trigger an inflammatory response by activating Search terms and Boolean logic:
immune cells and inducing the release of pro- ("PM2.5" OR "Air pollution" OR
inflammatory cytokines and chemokines. "Air Pollutants") AND ("Depression" OR
Moreover, PM2. 5 constituents, such as heavy "Mental health" OR "Mood disorders" OR
metals and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, " Psychological distress" OR " Emotional
generate reactive oxygen species ( ROS) , problems" OR "Psychiatric disorders")
leading to oxidative stress and cellular Searching database:
damage. Additionally, PM2. 5 can perturb To conduct a comprehensive systematic
neurotransmitter systems in the brain, review of the associations between PM2. 5
affecting neurotransmitter release, reuptake, and depression, the following medical and
and signaling, thereby contributing to scientific databases were searched: PubMed,
neurobehavioral disorders and cognitive Embase, Web of Science, PsycINFO, CINAHL,
impairments. Furthermore, PM2. 5 exposure Scopus, Cochrane Library and ProQuest.
has been associated with epigenetic modifications, Systematic review and meta-analysis process:
including DNA methylation, histone modifications, In this study, the search for relevant
and non- coding RNA expression, which can studies is conducted independently by two
result in long- lasting changes in gene reviewers using multiple databases such as
expression patterns. It is crucial to conduct PubMed, Embase, Web of Science, PsycINFO,
further research to gain a comprehensive CINAHL, Scopus, Cochrane Library, and
understanding of the intricate interplay of ProQuest. The search terms and Boolean
these mechanisms and their implications for logic are predetermined and agreed upon in
PM2.5-induced health effects.3-6 While some the research methodology canvas. However,
epidemiological studies have investigated only English language studies are included
this association, the findings have been due to resource and time limitations. The
inconsistent, highlighting the need for a search encompassed the entire available
systematic review and meta- analysis to timeline of the database, ranging from its
provide a comprehensive understanding of inception to the date of the review's search.

O82
 P. Poowaruttanawiwit, et al. | Journal of Basic and Applied Pharmacology | Vol.3 No.2 July - December 2023

The reviewers screen the titles and analysis is conducted using random- effects
abstracts of all identified studies and exclude models.
those that do not meet the predefined The reviewers interpret the findings
inclusion criteria or are clearly irrelevant. in the context of the research question and
The inclusion criteria involve investigating critically evaluate the strengths and
the association between exposure to PM2. 5 limitations of the included studies. Finally,
and depression in human populations, with a conclusions are drawn about the strength of
requirement for quantitative data on the the evidence linking PM2. 5 exposure and
association, standardized measures of depression, gaps in the literature are
depression or validated diagnostic tools, data identified, and recommendations for future
on PM2. 5 exposure levels, and adjusted research are made. Overall, this study uses
estimates of the association controlling for rigorous epidemiological methodology to
potential confounding factors. investigate the association between PM2. 5
Full- text screening is performed on exposure and depression, providing a reliable
the remaining studies, and any discrepancies and trustworthy evidence base for future
are resolved through discussion or by a third research and policymaking.
reviewer. The quality and risk of bias of the
included studies are assessed using 3. Results
appropriate tools, such as the Cochrane Risk Literature search and study characteristics:
of Bias Tool9 or the Newcastle- Ottawa After applying inclusion and
Scale,10 depending on the study design. The exclusion criteria, seven studies were
Assessment of Multiple Systematic Reviews included in the systematic review. The
( AMSTAR) 11 tool is used to evaluate the studies had low to moderate risk of bias and
quality of meta-analysis. five were observational while two were
Addressing disagreements in screening systematic review and meta-analysis. (figure
and extracting processes during a systematic 1 and 2) Based on the findings from five
review is crucial for maintaining integrity observational studies, the following key
and reliability. This can be achieved by observations can be made,12- 16 as shown in
referring to the established protocol, Table 1.
engaging in open discussions, identifying 1. Elevated levels of air pollutants, particularly
points of contention, and striving for ozone and PM2.5, were associated with an
consensus through compromises aligned increased risk of depression onset. For
with scientific rigor. In case of challenges, every 10-parts-per-billion increase in
seeking guidance from impartial third ozone, there was a 6% higher risk of
parties, documenting discussions, and depression onset, and for every 10-μg/m³
decisions, conducting sensitivity analyses, increase in 1-year PM2.5, there was an 8%
and obtaining external peer review or higher risk of depression onset.
consultation can enhance transparency, 2. NO2 exposure was linked to a 32%
credibility, and quality of the review. increased rate of mental health service
The relevant data are extracted from use for every 10 μg/m³ increase. However,
each study using a standardized data no significant association was found for
extraction form that captures study design, particulate matter exposure.
sample size, exposure and outcome measures, 3. Long-term exposure to various air pollutants,
statistical methods, and other key information. including PM2.5, was associated with an
The extracted data are synthesized using increased risk of depression and anxiety.
appropriate statistical methods, and the The effect was stronger at lower pollutant
findings are presented in a table or forest concentrations. Male individuals showed a
plot. If sufficient data are available, a meta- stronger association between PM2.5

O83
 P. Poowaruttanawiwit, et al. | Journal of Basic and Applied Pharmacology | Vol.3 No.2 July - December 2023

exposure and anxiety compared to underscores the link between ambient

females. particulate matter pollution and mental
Given the observational nature and health risks. This study highlights the
notable limitations of the included studies, it importance of reducing air pollution for
is not recommended to proceed with a meta- mental health. A recent epidemiological
analysis. Undertaking such an analysis would study ( Braithwaite et al., 2019) 18 conducted
diminish the internal validity, credibility, and a thorough review of 1,826 studies on the
practical applicability of the research findings. relationship between air pollution exposure
However, the study underscores the significance and mental health outcomes. Of those
of addressing environmental pollution and studies, only 22 met the criteria for inclusion,
social disparities in mental health interventions and 9 were analyzed in the meta- analysis,
and policies. Further research is warranted to which aimed to investigate the association
elucidate the mechanisms underlying the between particulate matter air pollution and
association between air pollution and mental mental health disorders. The study
health. discovered a statistically significant positive
Two meta- analysis studies with low correlation between long- term exposure to
bias were found. Liu et al. (2021)17 investigated PM2. 5 and both depression and anxiety.
the association between PM air pollution Specifically, the results showed a pooled
exposure and depression/suicide risk. Results odds ratio of 1. 10 per 10 μg/ m3 increase in
showed that exposure to ambient particulate PM2. 5 exposure. Additionally, the study
matter, particularly PM2.5 and PM10, is found a significant link between short- term
significantly associated with an increased exposure to PM10 and suicide. These
risk of depression and suicide. A 10 μg/m³ findings emphasize the importance of
increase in short-term exposure to PM2.5 led reducing air pollution to prevent mental
to a 2% increased risk of depression and health disorders.
suicide, while a 10 μg/m³ increase in long- Two meta- analyses show a positive
term exposure to PM2.5 resulted in an 18% association between PM air pollution
increased risk of depression. Short-term exposure and depression/ suicide risk,
exposure to PM10 was also associated with a highlighting the importance of reducing air
2% increased risk of depression and a 1% pollution for mental health. Long- term
increased risk of suicide. Notably, these exposure to PM2. 5 is linked to depression
associations were more pronounced in and anxiety, while short- term exposure to
individuals over 65 years old and in PM10 is associated with suicide risk.17,18
developed regions, and the strength of the
associations varied based on study design
and quality. Overall, this meta-analysis

O84
 P. Poowaruttanawiwit, et al. | Journal of Basic and Applied Pharmacology | Vol.3 No.2 July - December 2023

Fig. 1. PRISMA flow .

O85
 P. Poowaruttanawiwit, et al. | Journal of Basic and Applied Pharmacology | Vol.3 No.2 July - December 2023

Fig. 2. Risk of bias in observational studies.

Table 1 The characteristics of the observational studies12-16

Details Kioumourtzoglou Newbury et al, Reuben et al., Yang et al., Qiu et al.,
et al., 201712 202113 202114 202316 202315
Study A prospective A A population- A prospective, A population-
design cohort study retrospective based cohort population- based
cohort study study based cohort longitudinal
study cohort study
Participants Married Mental health Part of the Participants This study
registered service- Environmental- without prior involved over
nurses aged 30 seeking Risk (E-Risk) depression or 8.9 million US
to 55, enrolled individuals Longitudinal anxiety Medicare
in the Nurses' with first Twin Study, diagnoses at enrollees aged
Health Study episode of involving baseline, with 65+ from 2005
in 1976. They psychotic or 2,232 twins complete to 2016.
were followed mood disorder. born in exposure and
over time to England and covariate data,
collect health- Wales in were analyzed
related data. 1994-1995. from May 1 to
They were October 10,
followed from 2022.
age 5 to 18,
representing
diverse
socioeconomic
conditions in
the UK.
Ethical
approval and
consent were
obtained.
Number of 121,701 61,270 2,232 389,185 8,907,422
participants

O86
 P. Poowaruttanawiwit, et al. | Journal of Basic and Applied Pharmacology | Vol.3 No.2 July - December 2023

Details Kioumourtzoglou Newbury et al, Reuben et al., Yang et al., Qiu et al.,
et al., 201712 202113 202114 202316 202315
Exposure The level of Individuals Annualized Annual air Residential
PM2.5 at each with high air estimates of pollution long-term
participant's pollution outdoor levels, exposure
residence, exposure. pollutants, specifically included
estimated specifically PM2.5, PM2.5
using a model nitrogen PM2.5-10, (µg/m³), NO2
that considers oxides (NO2) NO2, and NO, (ppb), and O3
factors like and PM2.5, estimated at (ppb).
location, were each
weather, and calculated for participant's
emissions. participants' residential
They home address.
calculated 1-, addresses at Additionally,
2-, and 5-year ages 10 and an air
average 18, and these pollution score
exposures. estimates were was derived
then averaged. using principal
components
analysis to
reflect their
combined
exposure.
Amount of Average 1- The average PM2.5 The median The amount of
PM2.5 year PM2.5 PM2.5 exposure PM2.5 PM2.5
exposure concentration: concentration (µg/m³) during exposure was exposure was
(µg/m3) 12.6 µg/m³ during the childhood and 9.9 µg/m³ 9.6 µg/m³ (SD
(standard study period adolescence (with an 2.7).
deviation, 2.9) was 14.8 ranged from interquartile
PM2.5 µg/m3, with a 2.92 to 19.34 range of 9.3-
concentrations range of 4.4 to µg/m³, with a 10.6 µg/m³)
decreased 33.1 µg/m3. mean exposure
during the of 11.59
follow-up µg/m³. Most
period, from participants
13.1 µg/m³ in (84.2%)
1996 to 11.7 exceeded
µg/m³ in 2008. WHO
guidelines of
10 µg/m³.
Non- Individuals with low air pollution exposure.
exposure
Outcome The onset of Mental health General The The diagnosis
depression, service use psychopatholo occurrence of of late-life
which is was assessed gy, measured clinically depression,
defined as the as the count of as continuous diagnosed identified
first report of outpatient, mental health cases of through
either a inpatient, and disorder depression Medicare
physician emergency symptoms (coded as F32- claims data.
diagnosis or department standardized F33) and
the initiation contacts in the to a mean anxiety (coded
of 5-year period (SD) of 100 as F40-F48)

O87
 P. Poowaruttanawiwit, et al. | Journal of Basic and Applied Pharmacology | Vol.3 No.2 July - December 2023

Details Kioumourtzoglou Newbury et al, Reuben et al., Yang et al., Qiu et al.,
et al., 201712 202113 202114 202316 202315
antidepressant following the (15) at 18 was
medication. initial years of age. determined
diagnosis of a using the
psychotic or International
mood disorder. Statistical
Classification
of Diseases
and Related
Health
Problems,
Tenth
Revision
(ICD-10)
codes.
Main The study NO2 exposure Each rise in Long-term Each 5-unit
results found that was associated NO2 exposure exposure to increase in
elevated levels with a 32% equivalent to various air long-term
of these increased rate an interquartile pollutants, mean exposure
pollutants of mental range including to PM2.5,
were health service increment was PM2.5, is NO2, and O3
associated use for every linked to a linked to an was associated
with an 10 μg/m3 1.40-point rise increased risk with adjusted
increased risk increase (95% CI, 0.41- of depression percentage
of depression (adjusted HR: 2.38; P = .005) and anxiety, increases in
onset. 1.32, 95% CI: in overall with a stronger depression
Specifically, 1.16-1.50), psychopathology. effect at lower risk: 0.91%
for every 10- while no pollutant (95% CI,
parts-per- significant concentrations 0.02%-1.81%)
billion association . Male for PM2.5,
increase in was found for individuals 0.61% (95%
ozone, there particulate showed a CI, 0.31%-
was a 6% matter stronger 0.92%) for
higher risk of exposure. association NO2, and
depression between 2.13% (95%
onset, and for PM2.5 CI, 1.63%-
every 10- exposure and 2.64%) for O3,
μg/m³ increase anxiety based on a
in 1-year compared to tripollutant
PM2.5, there females. model.
was an 8%
higher risk of
depression
onset.
Extracted A possible link Air pollution Increased Long-term Higher
key between long- exposure is exposure to exposure to air exposure to
content term exposure associated NO2, a pollutants, these air
to air with increased component of including pollutants is
pollutants likelihood of air pollution, PM2.5, raises associated
(ozone and mental health was linked to a the risk of with an
PM2.5) and service use, 1.40-point depression and increased risk
the onset of particularly for increase in anxiety, with a of depression.

O88
 P. Poowaruttanawiwit, et al. | Journal of Basic and Applied Pharmacology | Vol.3 No.2 July - December 2023

Details Kioumourtzoglou Newbury et al, Reuben et al., Yang et al., Qiu et al.,
et al., 201712 202113 202114 202316 202315
depression in a psychotic general mental stronger effect
cohort of disorders, with health at lower
41,844 a 27% increase problems, pollution
women. in odds for even after levels,
Stronger every 10 considering especially in
associations µg/m3 increase other factors. males.
were observed in NO2 Those with
when defining exposure. high PM2.5
cases based on These findings exposure also
antidepressant highlight air had more
use. pollution's mental health
potential role issues. When
as a risk factor both pollutants
for mental were
health considered,
disorders and NO2 had a
the need for stronger
further impact. NO2
research. exposure was
associated
with different
mental health
problems, with
thought
disorders
showing the
strongest
connection.
Importantly,
these
associations
remained even
in
neighborhoods
with
challenging
living
conditions.
Major Key Unmeasured Limitations The crucial Potential
limitations limitations confounding include limitation of misclassificati
of the include factors, like reliance on the study is on of
research potential socioeconomic modeled that it cannot depression
outcome status, may exposure establish cases due to
misclassificati have estimates, lack causation; it the use of
on, exposure influenced of prenatal and only shows Medicare data.
measurement observed preschool associations Unmeasured
errors, and a associations. exposure data, between air individual-
lack of precise The study was focus on NO2 pollution and level risk
timing of limited to and PM2.5 mental health factors for
depression London, UK, only, potential outcomes. depression.
onset. The and influence of Other factors

O89
 P. Poowaruttanawiwit, et al. | Journal of Basic and Applied Pharmacology | Vol.3 No.2 July - December 2023

Details Kioumourtzoglou Newbury et al, Reuben et al., Yang et al., Qiu et al.,
et al., 201712 202113 202114 202316 202315
study's cohort generalizabilit unmeasured not considered Exposure
of middle- y to traffic-related may influence measurement
aged and older populations pollutants and the results. error from
women may with different noise, and More research using
limit air pollution uncertainty is needed to residential zip
generalizabilit levels and about confirm codes instead
y. Despite sources may generalizabilit causation and of specific
these be limited. y to highly understand the addresses.
limitations, the The study polluted mechanisms
findings design regions. This involved.
suggest a link identifies observational
between air associations study cannot
pollution and but not causal establish
depression relationships. causation but
onset, calling considered
for further various factors
research and to address
cautious alternative
interpretation. explanations at
different
levels.
Assessable Moderate Moderate Low Low Moderate
bias level

4. Discussion increased risk of depression associated with

Evidence suggests that exposure to exposure to PM2. 5. Additional studies have
PM2. 5 may be linked to depression through reported similar associations between PM2.5
mechanisms involving inflammation, exposure and depressive symptoms among
oxidative stress, and disruption of the various age groups and genders. Collectively,
hypothalamic- pituitary- adrenal ( HPA) these studies provide compelling evidence
axis. 19 PM2. 5 particles can enter the brain supporting a significant link between PM2. 5
through the olfactory bulb and activate exposure and depression. Further research is
microglia, leading to the release of pro- necessary to elucidate the underlying
inflammatory cytokines and oxidative stress. mechanisms and develop effective interventions
This can impact neurotransmitter systems to mitigate the harmful effects of PM2. 5
such as serotonin and dopamine, which are exposure on mental health. 22- 24 Based on the
involved in regulating mood and emotions. 20 information provided, the association
Additionally, PM2. 5 exposure has been between PM2.5 exposure and depression can
shown to increase cortisol levels and reduce be considered a strong association. The
the sensitivity of the HPA axis, leading to consistent findings across numerous studies
dysregulation of the stress response and and a meta-analysis support a significant link
potentially contributing to the development between the two. However, further research
of depression.21 is still necessary to fully understand the
Numerous studies have explored the underlying mechanisms and develop
relationship between PM2. 5 exposure and effective interventions.
depression, with consistent findings indicating a The differential impact of PM2.5 and
positive association between the two. A PM10 on mental health can be attributed to
meta- analysis of 16 studies demonstrated an their disparate size and composition, which

O90
 P. Poowaruttanawiwit, et al. | Journal of Basic and Applied Pharmacology | Vol.3 No.2 July- December 2023

give rise to distinct molecular mechanisms.22-24 should include individuals diagnosed with
PM2. 5, characterized by a diameter of 2. 5 depression or exhibiting depressive symptoms
micrometers or smaller, can penetrate deeply residing in areas with varying PM2. 5 levels.
into the respiratory system, potentially Exposure to different PM2.5 levels should be
reaching the bloodstream and the brain. the intervention, with changes in depression
Consequently, PM2. 5 particles can directly symptoms as the primary outcome measure
influence neuronal cells and the central and secondary outcomes such as cognitive
nervous system. Molecularly, PM2.5 induces function and quality of life. Adequate study
oxidative stress through the generation duration and appropriate statistical analysis
of reactive oxygen species ( ROS) , resulting methods are crucial. In cases where high
in cellular damage and neurotoxicity. pollution exposure is not ethical, natural
Additionally, inflammatory responses mediated experiments or trials with smaller populations
by pro-inflammatory cytokines and chemokines can be employed. Despite challenges, such a
contribute to synaptic plasticity disruption trial can enhance understanding of the
and cognitive impairments. On the other PM2.5-depression association.
hand, PM10, with a diameter up to 10 The study's strength lies in its
micrometers, tends to deposit in the upper comprehensive search of electronic databases,
respiratory tract and lungs due to its larger inclusion of studies conducted in different
size. Although PM10 particles do not countries with varying sample sizes and
penetrate as deeply, they carry a broader study designs, and the consistency of the
range of toxic constituents, including metals association found across studies. Additionally,
and organic compounds, which can trigger the study highlighted the potential
respiratory inflammation. This inflammation, bidirectional association between PM2. 5
in turn, indirectly affects mental health exposure and depression, which may inform
through systemic and neuroinflammation. the development of interventions that target
Moreover, the composition of PM2. 5, often both factors. However, the study's weakness
enriched with heavy metals and polycyclic is that the strength of the association between
aromatic hydrocarbons, further contributes PM2.5 exposure and depression varied among
to neurotoxic effects, oxidative stress, studies, which may be due to differences in
and neuroinflammation. Nevertheless, the measurement methods, exposure assessment,
precise molecular mechanisms underlying and confounding variables. Furthermore, the
the differential effects of PM2. 5 and PM10 study did not establish a causal relationship
on mental health necessitate further between PM2. 5 exposure and depression,
investigation, considering variables such as which highlights the need for further research
particle composition, individual susceptibility, to determine the underlying mechanisms and
and potential genetic and epigenetic causal pathways of the association. Despite
interactions.22-24 these limitations, this study provides critical
To further investigate the association evidence for the harmful effects of air
between PM2.5 exposure and depression, an pollution on mental health, emphasizing the
intervention trial can be designed. This need for policies aimed at reducing air
involves a prospective cohort or nested case- pollution levels.
control study with appropriate sample size To implement the knowledge of the
determination, accurate PM2. 5 exposure association between PM2. 5 and depression
assessment, validated depression outcome in clinical practice in Thailand, healthcare
measures, control of confounding factors, practitioners should undertake several
participant follow- up, sensitivity analyses, measures. They should educate patients on
peer review, transparent reporting, and the harmful effects of PM2. 5 and its link to
adherence to ethical guidelines. The trial depression, as well as encourage them to take

O91
 P. Poowaruttanawiwit, et al. | Journal of Basic and Applied Pharmacology | Vol.3 No.2 July- December 2023

measures to decrease exposure, such as using to be relevant to mental health conditions,

air purifiers, wearing masks, and staying exemplified by depression.
indoors during high pollution periods. 25- 27 The absence of high-quality randomized
Healthcare providers should also integrate studies in this systematic review necessitated
depression screening into routine medical an adaptation of the research strategy,
check- ups to identify at- risk patients who incorporating meta- analysis data. Although
may be more susceptible to the effects of this approach may deviate from conventional
PM2. 5 exposure. Patients should also be practice, the researcher contends that it
advised to adopt healthy lifestyle changes, represents a superior alternative to solely
including regular exercise and a healthy diet, pooling together observational studies of
that can enhance mental health and reduce moderate quality. By leveraging the available
the risk of depression. Consistent monitoring meta- analysis data, the review aimed to
of local air quality levels is necessary, and enhance the overall strength of evidence and
healthcare providers should educate patients provide a more robust assessment of the
on ways to protect themselves during high association under investigation. While the
pollution levels.28-32 inclusion of observational studies introduces
In the pharmacological and medical inherent limitations, such as potential biases
research context, pinpointing a specific and confounding factors, the incorporation of
chemical compound within PM2. 5 that is meta- analysis data allowed for a broader
predominantly responsible for its potential synthesis of available evidence and facilitated
contribution to depression proves challenging. the identification of potential trends and
Ongoing scientific investigations into the patterns. Nevertheless, it is crucial to
intricate relationship between PM2.5 exposure acknowledge the limitations associated with
and depression suggest that it is the this methodology and the need for caution
comprehensive exposure to fine particulate when interpreting the results. Future research
matter, coupled with ensuing inflammatory endeavors should strive to include well-
and oxidative stress responses, that designed randomized studies to provide more
potentially underlie its impact on mental definitive insights into the topic at hand.
health, including depression. 33,34 Prominent As evidence linking exposure to
constituents frequently identified within PM2.5, PM2. 5 and increased risk of depression
and pertinent to its health implications, continues to accumulate, healthcare
encompass heavy metals (e.g., lead, mercury, practitioners must be vigilant in addressing
cadmium) , polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons this issue. Collaboration with public health
stemming from combustion processes, metals officials is crucial in advocating for policies
like arsenic with recognized neurological aimed at reducing PM2. 5 levels in the
implications, endocrine-disrupting agents, and a environment. Healthcare providers should
spectrum of organic compounds, including offer emotional support and resources to
volatile organic compounds. 35,36 These patients with depression or other mental
compounds collectively contribute to a health issues, including referrals to mental
complex mixture, wherein the mechanisms health professionals, support groups, or other
through which PM2.5 may influence depression resources. When treating patients exposed to
remain subjects of ongoing research. high levels of PM2. 5, healthcare providers
Consequently, the identification of a single must make individualized decisions about
chemical agent as the exclusive causative adjustments to antidepressant medication
factor remains elusive. Rather, it is the dosage or changes to medication based on
cumulative exposure to this multifaceted various factors, including medical history,
blend of pollutants and the resultant current health status, and medication
physiological responses that is hypothesized regimen. While PM2.5 exposure may impact

O92
 P. Poowaruttanawiwit, et al. | Journal of Basic and Applied Pharmacology | Vol.3 No.2 July- December 2023

a patient's overall health, it should not be the connect. J Air Waste Manag Assoc. 2006;56:
sole factor in determining medication 709-742.
adjustments. Patients experiencing depression [2] Liu C, Chen R, Sera F, Vicedo-Cabrera AM,
and exposed to high levels of PM2. 5 should Guo Y, Tong S, et al. Ambient particulate air
pollution and daily mortality in 652 cities. N
communicate changes in symptoms or
Engl J Med. 2019;381:705-715.
medication requirements with their healthcare [3] Brook RD, Cakmak S, Turner MC, Brook
provider. Individuals should also take JR. Ischemic heart disease and ambient
measures to minimize their PM2.5 exposure, particle air pollution. Circulation. 2013;127:
such as avoiding outdoor activities during 704-711.
periods of high pollution or using indoor air [4] Cai Y, Zhang B, Ke W, Feng B, Lin H, Xiao
filters. It is crucial to address both medication J, et al. Associations of short-term and long-
and environmental factors in managing term exposure to ambient air pollutants with
depression in individuals exposed to high hypertension: a systematic review and meta-
levels of PM2.5. Although numerous studies analysis. Hypertension. 2018;71:1073-1081.
[5] Kim SH, Kim YK, Park SY, Hong YC.
have shown an association between exposure
Long- term fine particulate matter exposure
to higher concentrations of PM2.5 and symptoms and major depressive disorder in a
of depression and anxiety, the exact nature of community- based urban cohort. Environ
the relationship remains uncertain. Further Health Perspect. 2019;127:107008.
research is needed to better understand the [6] Kim YJ, Hong YC, Lee BE, Park H. PM2. 5
relationship between PM2. 5 and depression, exposure and the risks of stroke mortality in
including whether there is a direct causal the elderly. Environ Health Prev Med.
relationship between the two. Despite this 2019;24:1-9.
uncertainty, the evidence gathered thus far [7] Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, Altman DG,
underscores the importance of reducing PRISMA Group. Preferred reporting items
for systematic reviews and meta- analyses:
exposure to PM2. 5 to promote better mental
the PRISMA statement. PLoS Med. 2009;6:
health outcomes. e1000097.
[8] Stroup DF, Berlin JA, Morton SC, Olkin I,
5. Conclusion Williamson GD, Rennie D, et al. Meta-analysis
This study reveals that elevated of observational studies in epidemiology: a
PM2.5 levels are associated with an proposal for reporting. JAMA. 2000;283:2008-
increased risk of depression onset. Long- 2012.
[9] Higgins JP, Altman DG, Gøtzsche PC, Jüni
term exposure to PM2.5 is also linked to P, Moher D, Oxman AD, et al. The Cochrane
higher rates of depression and anxiety, Collaboration’s tool for assessing risk of bias
particularly in males and at lower in randomised trials. BMJ. 2011;343:d5928.
pollution concentrations. These findings [10] Wells GA, Shea B, O’Connell D, Peterson J,
emphasize the potential influence of Welch V, Losos M, et al. The Newcastle-
Ottawa Scale (NOS) for assessing the quality
PM2.5 air pollution on mental health, of nonrandomised studies in meta- analyses.
underscoring the importance of further Ottawa Hospital Research Institute [ Internet] .
research and pollution control efforts to [ cited 2023 Mar 30] . Available from:
reduce these risks. [Link]
Conflicts of Interest iology/[Link]
[11] Pieper D, Mathes T, Eikermann M. The
The authors declare no conflict of assessment of multiple systematic reviews
interest. (AMSTAR) 2: five years of experience in its
application. Res Synth Methods. 2021;12:
References 193-202.
[1] Pope CA, Dockery DW. Health effects of [12] Kioumourtzoglou MA, Power MC, Hart JE,
fine particulate air pollution: lines that Okereke OI, Coull BA, Laden F, et al. The

O93
 P. Poowaruttanawiwit, et al. | Journal of Basic and Applied Pharmacology | Vol.3 No.2 July- December 2023

association between air pollution and onset [22] Liang D, Shi L, Zhao J, Liu P, Schwartz J.
of depression among middle-aged and older Association between short- term exposure to
women. Am J Epidemiol. 2017;185:801-809. air pollution and mental health outcomes in
[13] Newbury JB, Stewart R, Fisher HL, Beevers China: A systematic review with meta-
S, Dajnak D, Broadbent M, et al. Association analysis. Environ Res. 2019;176:108517.
between air pollution exposure and mental [23] Liu X, Chen H, Bo Q. Association between
health service use among individuals with fine particulate matter (PM2.5) and depression
first presentations of psychotic and mood risk: An updated systematic review and
disorders: retrospective cohort study. Br J meta-analysis. ESPR. 2021;28:2466-2478.
Psychiatry. 2021;219:678-685. [24] Yao Y, Sang N, Zhou M, Shi X. Association
[14] Reuben A, Arseneault L, Beddows A, between exposure to PM2. 5 and depressive
Beevers SD, Moffitt TE, Ambler A, et al. symptoms among middle- aged and elderly
Association of air pollution exposure in Chinese women. IJERPH. 2020;17:2026.
childhood and adolescence with psycho- [25] Kongtip P, Nankongnab N, Phaneuf D.
pathology at the transition to adulthood. Environmental pollution in Thailand:
JAMA Netw Open. 2021;4:e217508. Current and future research directions.
[15] Qiu X, Shi L, Kubzansky LD, Wei Y, Castro Chemosphere. 2021;262:127754.
E, Li H, Weisskopf MG, et al. Association of [26] Horsley J, Tan ET. Air pollution and public
long-term exposure to air pollution with late- health: A guidance note for environmental
life depression in older adults in the US. health practitioners. World Health Organization;
JAMA Netw Open. 2023;6:e2253668. 2019.
[16] Yang T, Wang J, Huang J, Kelly FJ, Li G. [27] American Lung Association [Internet]. How
Long-term exposure to multiple ambient air to protect yourself from air pollution. [cited
pollutants and association with incident 2023 Sep 5]. Available from: [Link]
depression and anxiety. JAMA Psychiatry. org/clean-air/at-home/how-to-protect-yourself-
2023;80:305-313. from-air-pollution
[17] Liu Q, Wang W, Gu X, Deng F, Wang X, Lin [28] Reynolds KJ, Day TA, Hughson RL. The
H, et al. Association between particulate effects of air pollution on cardiovascular and
matter air pollution and risk of depression respiratory health and implications for the
and suicide: a systematic review and meta- workplace. OEM. 2018;75:87-95.
analysis. Environ Sci Pollut Res Int. [29] National Institute for Health and Care
2021;28:9029-9049. Excellence. Depression in adults: recognition
[18] Braithwaite I, Zhang S, Kirkbride JB, Osborn and management. Clinical guideline [CG90].
DPJ, Hayes JF. Air pollution ( particulate [ Internet] . 2018 [ cited 2023 Mar 29] .
matter) exposure and associations with Available from: https: / / www. nice. org. uk/
depression, anxiety, bipolar, psychosis and guidance/cg90
suicide risk: A systematic review and meta- [30] World Health Organization. Depression and
analysis. Environ Health Perspect. 2019;127: other common mental disorders: global
126002. health estimates. [Internet]. 2017 [cited 2023
[19] Li J, Li X, Liu Y, Wang Y, Yan H, Zhang M, Mar 29]. Available from: [Link]
et al. The association between exposure to iris/handle/10665/254610
ambient particulate matter and depression: A [31] American Psychological Association.
systematic review and meta- analysis. J Exercise fuels the brain's stress buffers.
Affect Disord. 2020;275:930-939. [Internet]. 2019 [cited 2023 Mar 29]. Available
[20] Li N, Sioutas C, Cho A, Schmitz D, Misra C, from: https: / / www. apa. org/ monitor/ 2019/
Sempf J, et al. Ultrafine particulate pollutants 01/cover-exercise-brain
induce oxidative stress and mitochondrial [32] National Institute of Mental Health.
damage. EHP. 2003;111:455-460. Depression. [Internet]. 2021 [cited 2023 Mar
[21] Zhang Y, Crouch MJ, Yamamoto T. The 29]. Available from: [Link]
impact of fine particulate matter (PM2.5) on health/topics/depression/[Link]
psychiatric disorders: A review. Environ [33] Lin CH, Nicol CJB, Wan C, Chen SJ, Huang
Health Prev Med. 2019;24:1-10. RN, Chiang MC. Exposure to PM2.5 induces
neurotoxicity, mitochondrial dysfunction,

O94
 P. Poowaruttanawiwit, et al. | Journal of Basic and Applied Pharmacology | Vol.3 No.2 July- December 2023

oxidative stress and inflammation in human mediated toxicity in humans: an overview.

SH- SY5Y neuronal cells. Neurotoxicology. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2022;19:7511.
2022;88:25-35. [36] Bhui K, Newbury JB, Latham RM, Ucci M,
[34] Li Z, Tian F, Ban H, Xia S, Cheng L, Ren X, Nasir ZA, Turner B, et al. Air quality and
et al. Energy metabolism disorders and mental health: evidence, challenges and future
oxidative stress in the SH- SY5Y cells directions. BJPsych Open. 2023;9:e120.
following PM2. 5 air pollution exposure.
Toxicol Lett. 2022;369:25-33.
[35] Thangavel P, Park D, Lee YC. Recent
insights into particulate matter ( PM2. 5) -

O95