0% found this document useful (0 votes)
116 views5 pages

Project Method: Merits and Demerits

The document outlines the project method of teaching, emphasizing its student-centered, collaborative approach that fosters problem-solving and practical learning experiences. It details the characteristics, steps, merits, and demerits of the project method, highlighting its effectiveness in higher education while also acknowledging challenges such as time consumption and resource needs. The lesson concludes with a summary and suggestions for further reading on educational technology.

Uploaded by

Ab hamid
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
116 views5 pages

Project Method: Merits and Demerits

The document outlines the project method of teaching, emphasizing its student-centered, collaborative approach that fosters problem-solving and practical learning experiences. It details the characteristics, steps, merits, and demerits of the project method, highlighting its effectiveness in higher education while also acknowledging challenges such as time consumption and resource needs. The lesson concludes with a summary and suggestions for further reading on educational technology.

Uploaded by

Ab hamid
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

Lesson No.

Project Method

Lesson Structure

.0: Introduction
.1: Objectives
.2: Definitions of Project Method
.3: Characteristic of project Method
.4: Steps of Project Method
.5: Merits of Project Method
.6: Demerits of Project method
.7: Let us Sum Up
.8: Check Your Progress
.9: Further Readings

.0: Introduction

Project method is a teacher facilitate collaborative approach through which


students attain, utilize knowledge and skill to define and get solutions to problem of
relativistic nature by employing or using enquiry of extended type project method is a
dynamic and democratic method of teaching especially feasible for higher education
students. It is students centered method in which students employ or follow standards,
parameters and targets clearly identified by the teacher project method is the method
that demands students to present in concrete form the result of gathered information
about concept, principle or innovation. It is willingly taken activity by students which
emphasized learning by dong.

.1: Objectives

Dear readers after going through this lesson you should be able to:

 Understand the concept of project method


 Enlist the characteristics of project method

1
 Explain the steps of project method
 Comprehend the merits and demerits of project method

.2: Definitions of Project Method

 W.H Kilpatrick, “project is a whole hearted purposeful activity proceeding in a


social environment”.
 Stevenson: “A project is a problematic act carried to completion in its natural
setting”.
 Ballard: “A project is a bit of real life that has been imported into school”.
 Thomas and long: “It is voluntary undertaking which involves constructive
efforts or thought and eventuates into objective results”.
 Good: “ A significant practical unit of activity having education value and
aimed at one or more definite goals of understanding, involves investigation and
solution of problems and is carried to completion by pupils and teachers in
natural real life, manner”.
 Markhom: “Project based learning into grates knowing and doing”.
 According to Dewey: “A project is usually organized in a life like situation
which provides actual and meaningful experiences to the students like that of an
apprentice learning his trade”.

From above definitions it can be asserted that project method is the teaching
method in which students have control over the planning, refining, presenting and
reflecting of the projects. Project method was first used in 1830 in Moscow Russia in a
school for trades and industries train engineers and craftsman. This method allows
students to solve a practical problem with a like possible direction from teacher. It is the
method in which students perform constructivist activities in real life experiences.

.3: Characteristics of Project Method

1. It is student centric and takes them out of the classroom walls.


2. It is making learning realistic and experiential as it is being carried out in natural
setting.
2
3. It develops investigations attitude among learners and makes them able to
develop practical solutions to the problems taken.
4. Fosters scientific enquiry attitude as it involves validation of sources and
information gathered.
5. It improves social skills die to social environment interaction.
6. It is democratic and dynamic as it provides freedom to students to choose for
future life as well as makes them able to enjoy present life.
7. It is an approach to make better usage of experience as the real and best learning
which ca n not be forgotten.
8. Learning activity selected is core part of project and a experiences of learning
are incidental.
9. A project has a definite attainable goal.

.4: Steps of Project Method

Following Steps are involved in project method of teaching:


a) Creating Situations: First the proper situation is created by the teachers for students
inside the classroom. Every knowledge about project method procedure, steps and uses
are given to the students. It should arise out of a fact need of students and should never
be put by force on them.
b) Selection of Problem:- Here in this step the problem is selected by the help of teachers
as well as guidance, this is being done with full freedom to the students to select
problem as per their abilities and interest. It should be based on real experiences and
purpose.
c) Planning:- In this step problem is being discussed by the teacher from different
perspectives after receiving free will opinion from students. Teacher write down the
whole plan for executing the project with little role as guide only.
d) Execution:- this is the step where work is started by the students. Here information
and other materials are collected as per their own speed, interest and ability teacher
here keeps supervisor for not letting students to waste time and materials. So
everything for conducting project is done.
3
e) Evaluation:-This is the step of assessment of work. Here both students and teachers
evaluated the execution process which is done. They determine whether objectives are
accomplished or not, whether project has been completed and executed as per the plan
detained earlier. Difficulties are determined and results achieved are also evaluated.
f) Reporting and Recording:- Each and every step of the work are reported by the
students in this step. This report is recorded in a specific order in book form. It
included everything that was decided in planning, done in execution and result. Finally
it is submitted to the teacher.

.5: Merits of Project Method

1. It follows psychological principles of learning as learner readiness, practice and effect


of learning are in of significant importance.
2. It fosters self learning, self directions and self satisfaction because of freedom on part
of the students.
3. It imbibes social values among individuals through group work like team spirit,
cooperativeness, labour dignity, democratic attitude, belongingness etc.
4. Being problem solving type it makes students active, motivated, involved, responsible
etc.
5. It develops realistic sense among the students because of its practical and social
implications.
6. Most useful in scene subjects, languages, craft etc.
7. It help in developing critical thinking among students.
8. It helps in all round development of students through bodies involvement in a task.
9. It reduced burden of home work as projects are mostly conductive inside classroom.
10. It result all most in permanent learning as student learn though their own efforts.

.6: Demerits of project Method

1. It is time consuming as lot of time is being time taken by students in completing the
single task.

4
2. Single project can not cover different topics as well as it is difficult to have diffident
projects for different topics
3. It needs numerous financial resources for its execution.
4. It is success rate is high only among gifted teachers and pupils.
5. It sometimes became two heavy that students feel it beyond capacity to accomplish.
6. Its draw back incidental learning as teaching is not possible in an organized manner.
7. Progress of work sometimes remains behind the schedule.
8. Communication plays minor role here as a result language development may get
hampered.
9. Learners do not always make the best choices. As such the choices they make do not
reflected their interest and ability.
10. Learners get difficulties in getting relevant books for book- based projects.

.7: Let us Sum up

In this lesson you have learned concept of project method and some definitions. Light has
been also thrown on characteristics, steps, merits and demerits of project method.

.8: Check your progress

1. Define the concept of project method?


2. What are the characteristics of project method?
3. Explain in detail steps involved in executing a project?
4. Enumerate merits and demerits of project method?.

9: Further readings:

 Romesh Verma & Suresh K. Sharma (2006). Modern Trends in Teaching


Technology. New Delhi, Anmol Publications Pvt. Ltd. India.
 Dr. R. A. Sharma (2004). Essentials of Educational Technology and Management.
Meerut, Surya Publications, India.
 Purabi Jain (2008). Educational technology. New delhi, Dominant publishers and
distributors, India.

Common questions

Powered by AI

The project method significantly contributes to the development of social skills by involving students in collaborative activities within a social environment. This approach promotes interactions that require communication, cooperation, teamwork, and the democratic sharing of ideas, fostering a sense of community among students . Group work promotes values such as team spirit, cooperativeness, and a democratic attitude . Such experiences can lead to improved social competencies and a stronger sense of belonging, essential for personal growth in educational settings .

The project method fosters critical thinking by requiring students to investigate problems, validate sources, and develop practical solutions . As students plan and execute projects, they engage in problem-solving activities that enhance their ability to think analytically and creatively. This method involves multiple steps such as problem selection, planning, execution, and evaluation, each of which demands critical thinking to address real-world issues in a structured manner . Consequently, students are better equipped to analyze situations, consider various variables, and devise effective solutions .

The project method aligns with democratic education principles by providing students with the freedom to choose their projects, encouraging collaborative learning in a social environment, and promoting self-directed learning. This approach can enhance student engagement and result in deeper learning outcomes as students take ownership of the learning process, develop social skills, and cultivate a sense of responsibility . The democratic and dynamic nature of the project method allows students to choose projects relevant to their interests and future goals, thereby potentially increasing motivation and satisfaction .

The project method promotes lifelong learning by encouraging self-direction, critical thinking, and problem-solving skills, which are crucial for adapting to future challenges and career demands . By allowing students to engage in realistic and experiential learning situations, this method fosters skills that are directly transferable to the workplace, such as adaptability, decision-making, and the ability to work collaboratively . Furthermore, the freedom to choose project topics relevant to individual interests prepares students for future endeavors by aligning educational experiences with potential career paths .

The project method strikes a balance between teacher guidance and student autonomy by defining clear roles for both parties in the learning process. Teachers act as facilitators who create the learning environment and provide the initial framework and necessary resources . Students, on the other hand, have the autonomy to select their projects and take charge of planning, executing, and evaluating their work. This balance ensures that while students have the freedom to explore and learn through self-directed activities, they are supported by the structured guidance of their teachers, ensuring the projects align with educational goals .

The project method enhances experiential learning by immersing students in real-world scenarios where they can apply their knowledge and skills to solve practical problems, as opposed to passively receiving information . Unlike traditional methods that often emphasize rote learning, the project method provides opportunities for students to engage directly with the material, thus promoting deeper understanding and retention . Through activities that reflect real-life tasks, students experience education that is relevant and meaningful, allowing them to make connections between theory and practice, thereby enhancing the overall learning experience .

Teachers may face several challenges when implementing the project method, such as time constraints, limited resources, and managing diverse student abilities . Projects are time-consuming and may not cover all necessary topics, potentially hindering curriculum goals . Financial resources may also pose a limitation for necessary materials . To address these challenges, teachers can implement a phased approach to projects, ensuring alignment with curriculum objectives while balancing the project scope with available resources. Additionally, differentiation strategies, such as tailoring projects to accommodate varying student abilities, can help in managing diverse classrooms. Providing clear guidance and maintaining a supportive environment can also mitigate these challenges .

The project method may face limitations in traditional educational settings due to factors like time constraints, resource availability, and the rigid structure of curricula that prioritizes standardized outcomes over individualized learning experiences . These limitations can be addressed by integrating project-based learning into existing curricula in a way that complements traditional teaching methods, using projects as a means of reinforcing rather than replacing subject-specific content. Additionally, schools can focus on professional development to help teachers effectively manage time and resources to integrate this method successfully .

The project method is underpinned by several psychological principles, including learner readiness, practice, and the effect of learning, each playing a significant role in enhancing the learning experience . By focusing on these principles, the project method fosters an environment where students are mentally prepared and motivated to learn, engage in practical applications of knowledge, and experience meaningful effects from their efforts. This alignment with psychological readiness and involvement encourages self-learning and provides a sense of achievement and satisfaction, thereby making learning more effective and memorable .

Evaluation in the project method plays a critical role in determining the success of both the learning process and its outcomes. It involves assessing the execution of projects, the achievement of objectives, and the extent to which students have applied critical thinking and problem-solving skills . This evaluation not only provides feedback to students but also helps identify areas for improvement, ensuring that future projects are more effectively executed. The comprehensive nature of evaluation within this method significantly impacts learning outcomes by reinforcing students’ understanding through reflection and aligning their efforts with educational goals .

You might also like