Quantum Mechanics: From Classical Failures
Quantum Mechanics: From Classical Failures
When any radiation enters the body through tiny hole, it suffers repeated reflection from the inner
walluntil it is finally absorbed.
Inside the sphere and directly opposite to the opening there is a projection from the wall preventing
thedirect reflection of radiation. Hence the opening behaves like a perfect absorber.
Conversely, when the sphere is heated the radiation is emitted by the walls and the radiation coming
outof the opening will be of same nature as emitted by black bodySpectrum of Black Body:
• The experimental spectrum of black body radiation was observed by Lummer and Pringsheim in 1900.
• The thermal radiation emitted by black body is thoroughly analysed using spectrograph and bolometers.
The experimental results show that:
o The black body emits all kinds of radiations ranging from lower wavelength to higher wavelengths.
o At a given temperature, the energy is not uniformly distributed in the radiation spectrum.
o The radiation energy density initially increases with wavelength, then peaks at a particular
wavelength λm and after that decreases finally to zero at very high wavelength.
o At a given temperature the intensity of radiation is a maximum at a particular wavelength λm.
o With increase in temperature, λm decreases
o For all wavelengths an increase in temperature causes an increase in the energy of emission.
Stefan-Boltzmann’s law:
The area under each energy spectrum curve represents the total energy emitted at that temperature.
This area increases with increase in temperature of the body.
According to Stefan –Boltzmann’s law the area is directly proportional to the fourth power
of thetemperature of the body.
E α T4 or E = e σ T4
• E- rate of emission of radian energy per unit area (total emissive power)
• T- absolute temperature of the body.
• E-emissivity of the surface.
• σ -Stefan-Boltzman constant = 5.6703 x10-8 W/m2 K4
Wiens Law:
In 1893 Wein derived an expression for the energy density and explained some features of energy
distributionof black body radiation (spectrum) based on thermodynamic consideration.
Wien showed that the product of the wavelength corresponding to maximum energy λm and absolute
tempT is constant.
λmT = constant= 2.898 x10-3 m K
i.e λm α 1/T
This is called Wien’s displacement law.
Wien also showed that maximum energy E m is proportional to the fifth power of absolute
[Link] α T5
He derived expression for the energy emitted at given wavelength range λ and λ+dλ at given temperature
E 0 N 0 N1 2N 2 3N 3 nN n nN n (3)
n 1
According to Maxwell- Boltzmann statistics the number of oscillators with the energy nε is given by
nε
N n N 0exp (4)
K BT
Where KB is Boltzmann constant, substituting the values of N1, N2, N3, ----------- from Eq(4) in Eq(2) and Eq(3) we
get.
The total number of oscillators is
ε 2ε 3ε nε
N N 0 N 0 exp N 0 exp N 0 exp N 0 exp
K BT K BT K BT K BT
ε 2ε 3ε nε
N N 0 {1 exp exp exp exp }
B
K T B
K T B
K T B
K T
N0 1
N (5) (since 1 x x 2 x 3 )
ε 1 x
1 exp
K BT
The total energy E is given by
ε 2ε 3ε nε
E 0N 0 N 0 exp 2N 0 exp 3N 0 exp nN 0 exp
K BT K BT K BT K BT
ε ε 2ε 3ε (n - 1)ε
E N 0 exp 1 2 exp 3 exp 4 exp n exp
K BT K BT K BT K BT K BT
ε 1
E N 0 exp 2
(6)
B
K T ε
1 exp
K B T
1
(since 1 2 x 3x 2 4 x 3 )
1 - x 2
Therefore, the average energy of oscillator is given by
ε ε
N 0exp
1 exp
E K BT K BT
2
N ε N0
1 exp
K B T
ε
exp
K BT hν
(7)
ε ε hν
1 exp exp 1 exp 1
K B T K BT K BT
The number of oscillators per unit volume in frequency range ν and ν +dν is given by
8π 2
N dν (8)
c3
Therefore, the total energy per unit volume in the frequency range ν and ν +dν is
8π 2 hν
E ν dν dν
c hν
3
exp 1
K BT
8h 3 1
E ν dν dν (9)
c 3
hν
exp 1
K BT
This relation is known as Plank’s radiation law. It can be written in terms of wavelength λ as
8hc 1
E d d (10)
5
hc
exp 1
K B T
hc
The plank’s formula reduces to Wien’s formula for small wavelengths. When λ s small then exp 1
K B T
8hc hc
E d exp d
K B T
5
hc hc
exp 1 (neglecting higher powers)
K B T K B T
8K B T
E d d
4
This represents Rayleigh – Jean’s formula. Thus Plank’s formula agrees with experimental results throughout
the whole range of wavelengths.
Photoelectric Effect:
The emission of electrons from a metal surface when illuminated by light or any other radiation
suitable frequency (or wavelength) is called photoelectric effect. The emitted electrons are called
photoelectrons and the current constituted by these electrons is known as photo current.
• This phenomenon was first observed by Heinrich Hertz in 1887, when ultra violet light falls on zinc
plateand it was studied in detail by Philip Lenard, a student of Hertz. Lenard received Nobel prize
in Physics in 1905 for his work on cathode rays.
• The phenomenon was experimentally verified by Hallwachs, Lenard, [Link], R.A. Millikan
and others.
• After wards it was discovered that alkali metal like sodium, lithium, potassium, rubidium and cesium
ejected electrons when visible light falls o them.
• Millikan, investigated the effect with number of alkali metal over a wide range of light frequencies
andwas given Noble prize 1923
Experimental Study of photoelectric effect:
• A simple experimental study of photo electric effect is shown in above fig.
• The apparatus consists of two photosensitive surfaces A and B enclosed in an evacuated quartz bulb.
• The plate A is connected to the negative terminal of a potential divider while the plate B is connected to
the positive terminal through an Ammeter A.
• In the absence of any light, there is no flow of current and hence the Ammeter reading is zero.
• But when monochromatic light is allowed to fall on plate A, a current start flowing in the circuit which is
indicated by Ammeter at non-zero.
• The current is known as photo current. This shows that when light falls on the metallic surface, electrons
are ejected.
• The number of electrons emitted and their kinetic energy depend up on the following factors:
• The potential difference between the two electrodes i.e. between plate A and B
• The intensity of incident radiation.
• The frequency of incident radiation.
• The photo metal used.
Characteristics of photo electrons:
• For a given photo metallic surface A, keeping the intensity and frequency of the incident radiation
fixed, let us consider the effect of potential difference as shown in fig.
• When the positive potential of the plate B is increased, phototelectric current is also increased.
• However, if the positive potential is further increased such that it is large enough to collect all the
photo electrons emitted from plate A, photo electric current reaches a certain maximum value,
knownas saturation current.
• If the potential difference is kept zero, it is observed that photo electric current still flows in same
direction. This shows that the incident radiation not only eject the photo electrons but also gives
theman electromagnetic fore.
• If the potential of the plate B is made negative i.e. the retarding potential is increased, the photo current
decreased and finally becomes zero at a particular value.
• The negative potential of the plate B at which the photo electric current become zero is called as
cutoffpotential or stopping potential.
2. Effect of intensity of incident radiation
• Let us observe the effect of intensity of incident radiation, of course of the same frequency.
• Above figure shows the variation of photo current as a function of potential difference between the
plates for different intensities of incident radiation.
• If the intensity of incident radiation is increased from I to 2I and the experiment is repeated, then the
photo electric current increases in the same ratio for all positive values of V.
• As V is made negative, the photoelectric current decreases sharply and reaches to zero at the same
value of the V0.
Conclusion:
• The Stopping potential is independent of intensity of incident radiation.
• The saturation current is proportional to the intensity of incident radiation.
3. The effect of frequency of incident radiation.
• Let us observe the effect of varying frequency of the incident radiation while keeping the
sameemitting surface and same intensity of the incident radiation.
• The above figure shows the variation of stopping potential with frequency of incident radiation.
• The graph shows that at frequency , the stopping potential is zero.
• The frequency is called threshold frequency and the corresponding wavelength as threshold
wavelength.
Threshold frequency:
The minimum frequency of incident radiation which can cause photoelectric emission i.e. this
frequencyis just able to liberate electron without additional energy.
4. Effect of photometal used
• The above figure shows a graph between stopping potential V0 and frequency for a number of
photometals.
• From the graph it is clear that all the lines have the same slope but their interactions with with the
frequency axis are different.
• Thus we conclude that the threshold frequency is a function of photometal used.
Fundamental laws of photoelectric effect:
• Electrons are emitted from photosensitive surfaces. Each material has a definite minimum
frequencyνo below which the photoelectric emission does not occur. This minimum frequency is
called threshold frequency
• For 𝜈 > νo, photocurrent is proportional to the intensity of incident radiation.
• For 𝜈 > νo, The KE of photoelectrons increase with increase in frequency of incident light.
• For a given metal, stopping potential V0 is directly proportional to frequency but is independent
of the intensity of incident radiation.
• Emission of photo electrons is instantaneous (less than 10-8s) no matter how feeble the
incident light may be.
• The rate at which electrons are emitted from a photocathode is independent of its temperature,
whichshows that photoelectric effect is different from thermoionic emission.
Einstein theory of photo electric effect:
• According to Einstein’s explanation, in photo electric effect one photon is completely absorbed by one
electron, which there by gains the quantum of energy and may be emitted from the metal.
• A part of its energy is used to free the electron from the atom and away from the metal surface. This
energy is known as “Photoelectric work function” for the metal and denoted by Wo.
According to law of conservation of energy:
Energy of photon = Energy needed to liberate the electron + Maximum KE of liberated electron.
Equations (1) and (2) are known as Einstein photoelectric equations. Equation (2) is also written as
When the photon energy is just sufficient to emit the electron from metal, then KE of electron is zero
Equation (3) becomes
Where νo is called threshold frequency. Threshold frequency may be defined as the minimum frequency
which can cause the photo emission.
mv 2mqV
h
2mqV
If the charged particle is electron, then
h
2meV
For an electron e = 1.602×10-19 C , mass m = 9.1 X 10-31 kg
6.626×10−34
∴ 𝜆 = +
√2×9.1×10−31×1.602×10−19 × 𝑉
150 12.26
λ= √ = A0
𝑉 √𝑉
1.226
nm
V
Case 3. de Broglie wavelength in terms of Kinetic energy:
If ‘m’ is mass and Ek is KE of the material particle then
1
KE mv2 Ek
2
mv 2mEk
h
2mEk
Properties of matter waves
1) Lighter the particle, greater is the wavelength associated with it
2) Lesser the velocity of the particle, longer the wavelength associated with it.
3) When v=0 then i.e. wave behaves indeterminate and of v then 0 . This shows that matter
waves are generated by motion of the particles.
4) These waves are produced whether the particles are charged or uncharged. This fact reveals that these waves
are not electromagnetic waves but they are new kind of waves (EM waves are produced only by the motion
of charged particles)
5) The velocity of matter waves depends on the velocity of material particle i.e. it is not constant while the
velocity of EM wave is constant.
6) The velocity of matter wave is greater than the velocity of light.
7) Wave and particle aspects of moving bodies can never appear together in the same experiment.
8) The wave nature of matter introduces an uncertainty in the location of the position of the particle. Because a
wave cannot be said exactly at this point or at that point. However, when the wave is large (strong) there is a
good chance of finding the particle, while, where the wave is small(Weak) there is very small chance of
finding the particle.
Experimental verification of matter waves:
According to de Broglies hypothesis, a beam of material particles must possess were like characteristics. This
conclusion was experimentally proved by C.J Davisson and [Link] in 1927 with low velocity electrons. Later
in 1928 [Link] using high velocity electron.
Davisson and Germer electron diffraction experiment:
The first experimental support for the concept of matter waves i.e. wave nature of atomic particles come from
experiments done by Davisson and Germer. They succeeded in measuring the de Broglie wavelength associated with
slow electrons.
Davisson and Germer were studying the reflection of electrons from nickel target. Accidentally the nickel target
was subjected to such a heat treatment that the reflection became anomalous. Now the reflected intensity showed
striking maxima and minima. Thus they suspected that electrons are diffracted like x-rays i.e. they behave like waves
under certain conditions.
The experimental arrangement is shown in fig.1. The electron beam is produced from electron gun. The electron
gun consists of a tungsten filament (F) coated with barium oxide, when heated to dull red (by a low tension battery)
the electrons are emitted due to thermo ionic emission. These electrons can be accelerated to desired velocity by an
electric field of known potential difference which can be varied from 40 to 70 Volts. The electrons are collimated
by a suitable slit to obtain a fine beam. The beam of electrons is directed to fall on a large single crystal of nickel.
The target can be rotated about an axis parallel to the axis of incident beam, the electrons are reflected from the
nickel crystal in different directions. The angular distribution is measured using a electron detector (Faraday
cylinder) which is connected to a galvanometer. The faraday cylinder can be moved along a graduate circular scale
between 200 to 900 to receive the reflected electrons. The faraday cylinder consists of two walls insulated from each
other. A retarded potential is applied between them so that only fast moving electrons produced by the collision with
atoms from nickel target are reflected by the faraday cylinder.
The faraday cylinder was moved on a circular scale and for a given accelerating voltage ‘V’, the scattering curve
showed a peak in a particular direction ‘ф’. When the electron beam incident perpendicular to the crystal surface,
the pronounced scattering direction was found to be 500 for the electron accelerated to 54Volts.
Under these conditions, the surface rows of atoms acts like the ruling of diffraction grating, producing the first
order spectrum of 54V, electron at ф = 500 as shown in fig (2).
From x-ray diffraction technique, the inter planer spacing (d) is measured as
d = 0.91 x 10-10 m
The Bragg angle θ = 90 – 25 = 650
From the Bragg formula
2d Sinθ = nλ
1 x λ = 2 x 0.91 x 10-10 Sin 650
λ = 1.65 x 10-10m =1.65 A0
The theoretical value of de Broglie electron wave is given by
12.26 12.26
1.66 A0
V 54
The close agreement between the two values confirms de Broglie hypothesis of matter waves.
Wave packet:
According to Schrodinger postulate material particle is equivalent to a wave packet. Which consists of a
group of waves with slightly different velocities and wavelengths. The phases and amplitudes are such that there is
a constructive interference over a small region of space where the particle can be located and there is destructive
interference outside of this region where the amplitude is zero. The envelope of the packet has finite special extent
and the sum of amplitude of all the plane wave component is zero except the place where particle is localized.
dω
The velocity with which the wave packet moves is called the group velocity v𝑔 =
dk
ω
The average velocities of individual waves are called phase velocities. v𝑝 =
k
In this way uncertainty of momentum involves uncertainly in positions and certainty in positions involves uncertainty
in momentum.
Other forms of uncertainty principle
In more general form uncertainly principle state that “It is impossible to specify precisely and simultaneously
the value of both members of particular pairs of physical variables that describe the behavior of an atomic system”
The pairs other than positions and momentum are energy and time, angular momentum and angle. Thus
according to uncertainty principle
∆E ∆t≈
and ∆J ∆θ≈
where ΔE and Δt are uncertainties in determining energy and time, while ΔJ and Δθ are uncertainties in
determining angular momentum and angle.
The exact statement of uncertainty principle is “The product of uncertainties in determining positions and
momentum of a particle can never be smaller than the order of ”.
2
So we have
h
∆x ∆P ≥ =
2 4𝜋
Similarly ∆E ∆t≥
2
∆J ∆θ ≥
2
Consequences of uncertainty principle:
1) Explains the absence of electron in the nucleus
2) Proof for existences of protons and neutrons inside the nucleus
3) Energy of electron in atom
Schrodinger time dependent wave equation
In order to explain the de Broglie wave associated with a material particle, Schrodinger developed a wave
equation. This is the basic equation for quantum mechanics. In quantum mechanics, without giving a specific value
for a physical quantity, the probability of possessing that particular value is discussed. The function which expresses
the probability of finding a particle at a position is called wave function ψ.
Let us consider a free particle of mass m moving with velocity v, the total energy of the particle (electron)
is the sum of its KE and PE.
Total energy = KE + PE
1 2
E mv V ( x, t )
2
1 m2v 2
V ( x, t )
2 m
p2
E V ( x, t )
2m
V can be a function of both position ‘x’ and time ‘t’
p2
E V ( x, t ) - - - - - - - - - (1)
2m
The wave function 𝜓 for a particle moving freely in the positive x-direction has the same form as the solution
for un-damped, harmonic waves in the positive x-direction.
𝜓(𝑥, 𝑡) = 𝐴 exp(−𝑖 (𝜔t − kx)) − −→ (2)
ℎ
Where wave function 𝜓 is a function of ‘x’ and ‘t’. From de Broglie’s relation 𝜆 = 𝑝
h 2𝜋
p= × = k
2𝜋 𝜆
p
⇒ k=
From Planks relation
hω
E=hν= = ω
2𝜋
E
⇒ ω=
Substituting the values of k and ω in equation (2)
E p
𝜓(𝑥, 𝑡) = 𝐴 exp (−𝑖 ( t - 𝑥))
𝑖
𝜓(𝑥, 𝑡) = 𝐴 exp (− (Et − px)) − − − − − − (3)
The equation (3) is correct only for freely moving particle. Hence a fundamental differential equation is required for
ψ which may be then solved in the specific situation.
Differentiation equation (3) with respect to time‘t’ once
i iE
A exp Et px
t
iE
E - - - - - - - (4)
i t
Differentiating the equation (3) with respect to ‘x’ twice
i ip
A exp Et px
x
2
2
i ip
A exp
Et px
x 2
p2
2
2
p
2 2
- - - - - (5)
x 2
Substituting the values of E and p from equation (4) and (5) in equation (1) we get
2
2 2
V
i t 2m x 2
2 2
i V
t 2m x 2
2 2
V - - - - - - - (6)
i t 2m x 2
This equation (6) is known as one dimensional Schrodinger’s time dependent wave equation. This equation is a
complex equation because of the presence of factors i. This means that ψ is a complex function, but of real variables
x and t. ψ cannot, therefore, be observed like displacement of a string.
In three dimensions the time dependent Schrodinger 's wave equation is
2
𝜕𝜓 − 𝜕2 𝜓 𝜕2 𝜓 𝜕2 𝜓
𝑖 = ( + + ) + V 𝜓 − − − − (5)
𝜕𝑡 2𝑚 𝜕𝑥 2 𝜕𝑦 2 𝜕𝑧 2
2
𝜕𝜓 − 𝜕2 𝜕2 𝜕2
𝑖 = ( + + )𝜓 + V 𝜓
𝜕𝑡 2𝑚 𝜕𝑥 2 𝜕𝑦 2 𝜕𝑧 2
Here 𝜓 is a function of x, y, z & t
2
𝜕𝜓 −
𝑖 = ∇2𝜓 + V 𝜓 − − − (6)
𝜕𝑡 2𝑚
𝜕2 𝜕2 𝜕2
Where ∇2 = 2
+ 2
+ Laplacian operator
𝜕𝑥 𝜕𝑦 𝜕𝑧 2
iEt ipx
A exp exp
iEt ipx
Let t exp and x exp
Then x, t = x 𝜙(𝑡)
iEt
x, t A x exp (2)
iE iEt
A x exp (3)
t
iEt x
A exp
x x
2 iEt x
2
A exp (4)
x 2 x
2
2 2 ( x)
E ( x) V ( x)
2m x 2
2 2m
E V 0 (6)
x 2 2
Here ψ is a function of position ‘x’ only and it is independent of time ‘t’. Equation (6) is one dimensional time
independent Schrodinger equation. In three dimensions equation can be written as
2 2 2 2m
E V 0
x 2 y 2 z 2 2
2
2m
E V 0 (7)
2
8 2 m
2 E V 0 (8)
h2
probability of finding the particle there at that time. Knowledge of ψ enables us to establish the linear momentum,
2
energy and other parameters. ψ is called probability density.
Where ‘a’ and ‘b’ are real functions of variable x,y,z and t and i 1 . The complex conjugate of ψ which is
denoted by ψ* is obtained by changing i to –i
ψ* x, y, z, t a ib - - - - (2)
multiplying above two equation
ψψ* (a ib)(a ib) a 2 b 2 - - - - (3)
The product on the left side of this equation denoted by P
P ψx, y, z, t ψψ * a 2 b 2 - - - - (4)
2
Thus
Thus the product ψ and ψ* is real and +ve if ψ ≠ 0. x, y, z, t is called probability density. The fact
2
expressed in equation (4) has been used by Max Born (1882 -1970) a German physicist to give the interpretation of
2 2
ψ. According to Born’s interpretation ψψ * or ψ is probability density. ψ dv gives the probability of finding
ψx, y, z, t dv
2
Is the probability that the particle will be found in a volume element dv. Surrounding the point at position (x,y,z) at
the instant ‘t’.
Is the probability that the particle will be found over a small distance dx at a position ‘x’ at the instant‘t’. ψx, t
2
ψ dv 1
2
ψ dv 1
2
This condition is known as normalized condition. A wave function that satisfies the above condition is said to be
normalized
If the particle does not exist
ψ dv 0
2
The probability value lies between 0 and 1. If it has a value of 0.2 or 0.6 it means that there is a 20% or 60%
chance of locating the particle within the selected volume.
Limitations
1) Ψ must be finite for all values of x,y,z
2) Ψ must be single valued i.e. for each set of values of x,y,z . Ψ must have only one value.
3) Ψ must be continuous in all regions except those where the potential energy V(x,y,z) = ∞
4) The first derivative of Ψ must be continuous
Particle in a box
When the motion of a particle is confined to a limited region such that the particle moves back and forth in
the region, then the particle is said to be in a bound state. If one dimensional motion of a particle is assumed to be
takes place with zero potential energy over a fixed distance and if the potential is assumed to became infinite at the
extremities of the distance, then it is described as a particle in one dimensional box.
Let us consider a particle of mass ‘m’ bouncing back and forth between the walls of one dimensional box.
Suppose that the particle moves only along x axis and confined between x=0 and x=a, the particle does not loose any
energy due to the collision with the walls.
2 ψ n 2m
2 E n V ψ n 0
x 2
As V=0
2 ψ n 2m
2 En ψn 0
x 2
2mE n 2mE n
Let k2 ⇒ k
2
2ψn
k 2 ψ n 0 (3)
x 2
The solution of equation (3) is of the form of sin kx or cos kx. The general solution is given by
ψ n x ASinkx BCoskx - - - - - - (4)
where A and B are constants. The values of these constants can be obtained by applying the boundary conditions
of the problem.
a) At x=0; ψ n x 0
0=Asin k(0) + Bcos k (0)
⇒ B=0
∴ ψ n x ASinkx - - - - (5)
b) At x=a ; ψ n x 0
ψ n a ASinka 0
Here either A = 0 or Sinka =0, but A ≠0 because if A =0 the entire function will be zero
∴ Sin ka = 0
⇒ ka = nπ where n= 1,2,3,……..
6
nπ
k
a
Now the wave function becomes
ψ n x ASin
nπ
x - - - - (7)
a
From equation (6)
2
nπ
k2
a
2
2mE n nπ
2 a
n 2h 2
En (8)
8ma 2
i) The lowest energy of the particle is obtained by taking n=1
h2
E1
8ma 2
4h 2
E2 4 E1
8ma 2
E n n 2 E1
E1 is the zero point energy of the system.
ii) The possible values of energy of the particle in a potential box are discrete corresponding to n =
1,2,3……i.e energy is quantized.
The spacing between nth energy level and next higher level increases as n 1 E1 n 2 E1 (2n 1)E 1
2
iii)
The values of En for which steady state equation of Schrodinger can be solved is called eigen value. The wave
function ψn corresponding to En is called Eigen function of the particle. The integer ‘n’ corresponding to the energy
En is called quantum number of the energy level E n.
The constant ‘A’ in equation (7) can be determined by using the condition that the probability of finding the
particle somewhere on the line is unity i.e.
a a
ψ x .ψ x dx ψ x dx 1
* 2
n n n
0 0
nπ
a
A Sin x dx 1
2 2
0 a
A2 2nπ
a
A2
a 1
2
2
A (9)
a
Substituting equation (9) in equation (7), we get normalized wave function as
ψ n x
2 nπ
Sin x - - - - (10)
a a
1. Classical free electron theory: The first theory was developed by Drude and Lorentz
in 1900. According to this theory, metal contains free electrons which are responsible for
the electrical conductivity and electrons obey the laws of classical mechanics.
2. Quantum Free Electron Theory: In 1928 Sommerfeld developed the quantum free
electron theory. According to Sommerfeld, the free electrons move with a constant
potential. This theory obeys quantum laws.
3. Zone Theory: Bloch introduced the band theory in 1928. According to this theory,
free electrons move in a periodic potential provided by the lattice. This theory is also
called “Band Theory of Solids”. It gives complete informational study of electrons.
Drude and Lorentz proposed this theory in 1900. According to this theory, the metals
containing the free electrons obey the laws of classical mechanics.
2. What are the merits and demerits of classical free electron theory?
Success or Advantages or Merits classical free electron theory
1) It verifies ohm’s law.
2) It explains electrical and thermal conductivities of metals.
3) It derives Widemann-Franz law.
4) It explains optical properties of metals.
Limitations or drawbacks or Demerits classical free electron theory
1) It fails to explain the electrical conductivity of semiconductors and insulators.
2) It fails to explain the temperature variation of electrical conductivity at low
temperature.
3) It fails to explain the concept of specific heat of metals.
4) It fails to explain the mean free path of the electrons.
5) The phenomenon like photo electric effect, Compton effect and black body radiation
could not be explained by classical free electron theory.
6) It fails to explain temperature dependence of paramagnetic susceptibility and
ferromagnetism.
4. What are the merits and demerits of quantum free electron theory?
Merits of quantum free electron theory
1. It successfully explains the electrical and thermal conductivity of metals.
2. It can explain the Thermionic phenomenon.
3. It explains temperature dependence of conductivity of metals.
4. It can explain the specific heat of metals.
5. It explains magnetic susceptibility of metals.
6. It can explain photo electric effect, Compton Effect and block body radiation etc.
7. It gives the correct mathematical expression for the thermal conductivity of metals.
The potential is minimum at the positive ion sites and maximum between the two ions.
The one-dimensional Schrödinger equation corresponding to this can be written as
²
+ ( − #)ψ=0 where ђ = h / 2 Π
² ħ
² $
+ ( − #(&))ψ=0 −−−−−(1)
² %
The periodic potential V(x) may be defined by means of the lattice constant ‘a’ as
This means that the electron is not localized around ones particular atom and the
probability of finding the electron is same throughout the crystal.
ikNa
Hence in eq(5), e =1
k=(2Πn)/Na
k=(2Πn)/L
Where L is the length of the chain of atoms and n= ±1, ±2, ±3, ±4, ………
When n=N/2, we have k=Π/a. This is the edge of first Brillouin zone.
Schrodinger equation for one dimensional periodic potential field denoted by V(x) can be
written as
² $
+ ( − #(&))ψ=0 −−−−−(1)
² %
According to Bloch theorem the solutions of this equation have the form
Uk (& + () = Uk (&)
As Vo increases the width of the barrier ω decreases so that the product Voω remains
constant. It turns out that solutions are possible only for energies given by the relation
. /01∝3
cos -( = + cos ∝ ( -------------(3)
∝3
4$ 3 $
Where P = Voω and ∝= √28
P is called scattering power of the barrier and Voω is called barrier strength.
The left hand side of the equation (3) is plotted as a function of ‘∝a’ for the value of P
= 3 Π / 2 which is shown in fig, the right hand side takes values between -1 to +1 as
indicated by the horizontal lines in fig. Therefore the equation (3) is satisfied only for
those values of ‘ka’ for which left hand side between ± 1.
From fig , the following conclusions are drawn.
$
From fig. it is clear that energy of electron is continuously increasing from K=0 to . The
3
$
left hand side of above equation becomes +1 or -1 for values of K=± 3
and hence
$
discontinuity appears in E-K graph, at K=± 3 . From fig it is seen that energy spectrum
of electron consists of allowed regions and forbidden regions. The allowed region extends
$ $
from - to + . This is known as first Brillouin Zone. After a discontinuity in energy
3 3
$ $ $ $
called forbidden gap another allowed region extends from - to - and to . This is
3 3 3 3
known as second Brillouin Zone. Similarly other higher order Brillouin zones can be
defined.
The width of energy band depends on the degree of over lapping of electrons of adjacent
atoms and is largest for outermost electrons. The band corresponding to outer most
orbits is called conduction band and next inner band is called valence band. The gap
between these two allowed bands is called forbidden energy gap or band gap Eg.
13. On the basis of band theory how the crystalline solids are classified into
metals, semiconductors and Insulators.
Insulators
Semiconductors: The valence band and conduction bands are separated with a small
energy band gap Eg ≈ 1 eV. At low temperatures (0 K), free electrons are not available in
conduction band. Hence they behave like insulators at low temperatures. The electrical
conductivity increases at high temperatures by the transition of free electrons from
valence band to conduction band. Thus these solids behave like electrical conductors at
high temperatures.
Ex: Silicon Eg = 1.1 ev, Germanium Eg = 0.7ev
Insulators: The valance band and conduction bands are separated by a very large
energy gap Eg ≥ 3 eV. At room temperatures conduction band is empty and valance band
is full of electrons. Hence they these solids are electrical insulators. Even at high
temperatures valence electrons are unable to jump in to conduction band.
Ex: Glass, Mica, Ebonite, Rubber etc.,
Considering the free electron as a wave packet , the group velocity vg corresponding to
the particle’s velocity can be written as
:; :( $=) := 2Π :( =) :@
vg = = = 2Π =( ) = ---------(2)
:< :< :< h :< ħ :<
1D 2
:Vg :( ) 1 D : @ :< : @ :<
Acceleration a = = ħ D-
= ħ [Link] = ( )( ) = ( )( )
:B :B ħ :<.:< :B ħ :< :B
:. :< F
Since ħk = p and = F, =
:B :B ħ
: @
∴a= ( )F
ħ2 :<
Dr. G. Sreenivasulu, Assoc. Professor 15
KHIT, Guntur Applied Physics Study Material Free Electron Theory & Band Theory
ħ
F=[ G H
]a ------------(3)
( )
GI
ħ
m*=[ G H
]---------------(4)
( )
GI
: @
This equation indicates that the effective mass is determined by .
:<