[Link] Angelo and Duke’s opinion about virtue?
(Measure for measure)
In "Measure for Measure", Shakespeare presents two characters, Angelo and Duke, with
differing views on virtue.
Angelo believes in a strict, black-and-white view of virtue. When the Duke leaves Vienna and
appoints Angelo to rule in his place, Angelo immediately starts enforcing the city's neglected
laws against sexual immorality. He believes that upholding the law without exception is the key
to maintaining order and virtue in society. For instance, he sentences Claudio to death for
getting his fiancée, Juliet, pregnant out of wedlock. Angelo's approach to virtue is harsh and
unforgiving, showing no mercy or understanding for human frailty.
Angelo believes that virtue is a strict and harsh concept. He thinks that people must follow the
law without exception. He says, "No sweetness that doth lie in sinuous brows can tempt me to
sin." (Act 1, Scene 7). Angelo thinks he is virtuous because he follows the law strictly.
On the other hand, Duke believes that virtue is about showing mercy and compassion. He
thinks that people make mistakes and deserve a second chance. He says, "Mercy is the word of
grace, and grace is the soul of justice." (Act 3, Scene 2). Duke shows his virtue by disguising
himself as a friar and helping others.
In conclusion, Angelo and Duke have opposite views on virtue. Angelo thinks virtue is about
following rules, while Duke thinks virtue is about showing mercy. Shakespeare shows that true
virtue lies in kindness and compassion, not just strict rules.
[Link] of the title measure for measure
The title "Measure for Measure" is significant in William Shakespeare's play because it reflects
the themes of justice, morality, and retribution. The title comes from the Bible, specifically the
book of Matthew 7:2, which says, "For in the same way you judge others, you will be judged,
and with the measure you use, it will be measured to you." This idea of getting what one
deserves is central to the play.
Firstly, the title highlights the theme of justice. Throughout the play, characters seek justice for
wrongs committed against them. Angelo, who enforces strict laws against sexual immorality,
represents a rigid, uncompromising form of justice. He sentences Claudio to death for
impregnating Juliet out of wedlock. However, Angelo himself is later judged and punished for his
own immoral behavior when he tries to coerce Isabella into sleeping with him to save her
brother. This turn of events shows that Angelo receives "measure for measure" for his actions.
Secondly, the title underscores the theme of morality. Characters in the play are constantly
measuring their own actions and the actions of others against moral standards. For example,
Isabella struggles with the moral dilemma of whether to sacrifice her virginity to save her
brother's life. Her decision not to compromise her morals, even in the face of extreme pressure,
reflects the idea that personal integrity and virtue are important measures of one's character.
Additionally, the title suggests the idea of retribution. Those who commit wrongdoings in the play
often face consequences that reflect their actions. Angelo, who judges others harshly, is judged
just as harshly when his own hypocrisy is revealed. The Duke, who disguises himself as a friar
to observe the actions of his subjects, ensures that everyone receives fair treatment by the end
of the play. His interventions help bring about a resolution where characters receive justice
"measure for measure."
Moreover, the title also emphasizes the balance between justice and mercy. While Angelo
represents strict justice, the Duke represents a more balanced approach that includes mercy.
The Duke believes in giving people second chances and allowing for redemption. This balance
is crucial in the resolution of the play, as the Duke’s decisions reflect a more humane and
compassionate form of justice.
In conclusion, the title "Measure for Measure" is significant because it encapsulates the play's
exploration of justice, morality, and retribution. It reflects the biblical idea that people will be
judged by the same standards they use to judge others. Throughout the play, characters face
consequences that mirror their actions, reinforcing the notion that one’s deeds will be measured
and repaid accordingly. By the end of the play, the balance between justice and mercy is
restored, highlighting the importance of fair and compassionate judgment.
3. Measure for measure as Problem play
"Measure for Measure" by William Shakespeare is often considered a "problem play" because it
blends elements of comedy and tragedy while addressing complex social and moral issues. A
"problem play" is one that doesn't fit neatly into the categories of comedy or tragedy and raises
difficult questions about society, justice, and human behavior. Here are the reasons why
"Measure for Measure" fits this description.
Firstly, the play's plot deals with serious and troubling issues. "Measure for Measure" examines
justice, morality, and the abuse of power. Angelo, the strict deputy ruler of Vienna, enforces
harsh laws to clean up the city’s immorality. He sentences Claudio to death for getting his
fiancée, Juliet, pregnant before marriage. This strict enforcement of the law brings up questions
about justice and mercy. Is it fair to punish someone so severely for a common human failing?
Secondly, Angelo’s hypocrisy adds to the play’s complexity. He presents himself as a moral and
upright leader, but he tries to exploit Isabella, Claudio’s sister, by offering to save Claudio in
exchange for sex. Angelo’s actions reveal the corruptibility of those in power and the gap
between public virtue and private vice. This theme of hypocrisy and abuse of power complicates
the play, making it difficult to categorize simply as a comedy or tragedy.
Thirdly, the play's tone shifts between light and dark, adding to its "problem play" status. There
are comedic elements, such as the character of Lucio, who provides comic relief with his witty
remarks and playful behavior. However, these light moments are juxtaposed with dark and
serious scenes, like Isabella’s moral dilemma and Claudio’s impending execution. This mix of
tones creates an unsettling atmosphere, making it hard to pin down the play’s overall mood.
Moreover, the resolution of the play is not entirely satisfying or clear-cut. At the end of "Measure
for Measure," the Duke, who has been observing the events disguised as a friar, steps in to
restore order. He proposes a series of marriages to resolve the conflicts: he offers to marry
Isabella, orders Angelo to marry Mariana (his former fiancée), and reunites Claudio with Juliet.
While these resolutions seem to bring closure, they also leave many questions unanswered.
Does Isabella truly want to marry the Duke? Will Angelo be a better husband after his
exposure? The ambiguous endings contribute to the play’s classification as a "problem play."
Additionally, the play raises difficult questions about morality and justice without providing clear
answers. It challenges the audience to think about the balance between law and mercy, the
nature of authority, and the complexity of human behavior. These unresolved questions and the
play’s moral ambiguity further establish it as a "problem play."
In conclusion, "Measure for Measure" is considered a "problem play" because it combines
elements of comedy and tragedy, addresses serious social and moral issues, and presents
complex characters and situations. The play’s exploration of justice, hypocrisy, and the abuse of
power, along with its shifting tones and ambiguous resolution, make it difficult to categorize
neatly and leave the audience pondering the deeper questions it raises. Through these
elements, Shakespeare creates a rich and thought-provoking work that continues to engage
and challenge audiences.
*Character of Angelo
Angelo is one of the central characters in William Shakespeare’s play "Measure for Measure."
He is a complex and contradictory figure, whose actions and motivations reveal much about the
themes of justice, power, and hypocrisy in the play.
At the beginning of the play, Angelo is appointed by the Duke to govern Vienna in his absence.
The Duke believes Angelo to be a man of strict morals and firm principles, suitable to enforce
the city's neglected laws. Angelo’s reputation is that of a man who lives by the rules and expects
others to do the same. His initial actions confirm this perception as he immediately starts
enforcing the laws against sexual immorality with harsh penalties, aiming to restore order and
virtue to Vienna.
Angelo’s strict approach to law enforcement is evident when he sentences Claudio to death for
impregnating his fiancée, Juliet, before marriage. Angelo believes that by making an example of
Claudio, he will deter others from similar misconduct. This harsh punishment shows Angelo's
rigid and unforgiving interpretation of justice, where there is no room for mercy or compassion.
He sees the world in black and white, where the law must be upheld at all costs.
However, Angelo’s character is marked by a significant transformation when he meets Isabella,
Claudio’s sister, who comes to plead for her brother’s life. Angelo is struck by Isabella’s beauty
and virtue, and he becomes infatuated with her. This sudden and overwhelming attraction
reveals a hidden side of Angelo’s character. Despite his outward appearance of strict morality,
Angelo harbors desires and impulses that contradict his public persona.
Angelo’s hypocrisy is fully exposed when he propositions Isabella, offering to spare her brother’s
life in exchange for her virginity. This demand is a stark contrast to the image of the morally
upright enforcer of the law. Angelo’s behavior shows that his strict adherence to virtue is a
facade, and he is willing to exploit his power for personal gratification. This hypocrisy is central
to his character and highlights the theme of the corrupting influence of power.
When Isabella refuses his advances and threatens to expose him, Angelo shows his cowardice
and deceit. He pretends to relent but secretly orders Claudio’s execution. Angelo’s actions
reveal his true nature: he is not only hypocritical but also willing to commit further injustices to
protect his reputation.
Angelo’s downfall comes when the Duke, who has been observing these events in disguise,
returns to power. Angelo’s crimes are exposed, and he is forced to confront the consequences
of his actions. The Duke, however, shows mercy and allows Angelo to marry Mariana, a woman
he was previously betrothed to but abandoned. This ending reflects the play’s exploration of
justice and mercy, contrasting Angelo’s rigid enforcement of the law with the Duke’s more
compassionate approach.
In conclusion, Angelo is a complex character whose actions and motivations drive much of the
plot in "Measure for Measure." Initially presented as a strict and moral enforcer of the law,
Angelo’s character is gradually revealed to be hypocritical and deeply flawed. His journey from a
seemingly virtuous leader to a corrupt and self-serving figure highlights the themes of justice,
power, and hypocrisy in the play. Angelo’s ultimate exposure and the Duke’s merciful judgment
underscore the importance of balancing justice with compassion. Through Angelo, Shakespeare
explores the complexities of human nature and the often-corrupting influence of power.
● Duke character
The Duke in William Shakespeare's "Measure for Measure" is a central character who plays a
crucial role in the play’s exploration of justice, mercy, and governance. Disguising himself as a
friar, the Duke observes the actions of his deputy, Angelo, and the impact of his harsh
enforcement of Vienna's laws.
Firstly, the Duke’s decision to leave Vienna and appoint Angelo as his deputy reveals his desire
to see how his city would function under strict rule. He recognizes that the laws have been too
leniently enforced and believes Angelo’s strict morality will restore order. However, the Duke
also knows that harsh justice needs to be tempered with mercy, which is why he disguises
himself to observe the unfolding events.
While disguised, the Duke shows his wisdom and understanding of human nature. He helps
characters in need, such as advising Isabella on how to deal with Angelo’s proposition and
comforting Claudio as he faces execution. The Duke’s actions reflect his belief in compassion
and his awareness of the complexities of justice.
The Duke’s return to power at the end of the play is marked by a careful and fair administration
of justice. He exposes Angelo’s hypocrisy and ensures that justice is served, but he also shows
mercy. For instance, he forgives Angelo and arranges his marriage to Mariana, demonstrating
his belief that even those who have done wrong can be redeemed.
In conclusion, the Duke is a character who embodies the themes of justice, mercy, and good
governance in "Measure for Measure." His actions and decisions throughout the play highlight
the importance of balancing strict enforcement of the law with compassion and understanding.
Through the Duke, Shakespeare presents an ideal ruler who recognizes the complexities of
human nature and the need for a just but merciful approach to governance.