Breakdown Maintenance Overview
Breakdown Maintenance Overview
Introduction to Maintenance
5
History of Maintenance
•The History of Maintenance engineering is a reflection of the
evolution of industrial practices, driven by technological
advancements and the need for efficient operation of
machinery and equipment.
• Terotechnology – Study and practice of managing the entire lifecycle of physical assets, including Design, Installation,
Operation, Maintenance, and eventual disposal.
• Integrates various disciplines – Engineering, Economics, and Management to optimize the performance, reliability, and
cost-effectiveness of assets.
• The goal is to minimize the total cost of ownership over the life of the asset while ensuring it meets the required
performance standards. 11
Maintenance
British Standard Glossary of terms (3811:1993) defined maintenance as:
Supervisory actions:
Managerial actions: • Overseeing the technical teams
• Setting up maintenance protocols • Ensure safety compliance
• Training staff • Verifying that the maintenance procedures are
• Allocating budgets for tools and resources. carried out correctly and efficiently
Together, these actions ensure that the maintenance process runs smoothly and that
machinery remains operational and efficient. 13
Engineering and Maintenance
• Engineering – Responsible for the specification, acquisition, and deployment of new
plant efforts
• Maintenance – all aspect after the plant has been commissioned.
Example: A beverage company is expanding its production capacity and needs to install a new bottling line.
Engineering team responsible for:
Specification :
- production speed, size of the bottles, and material used.
- Engineers has to research and define the specifications for the machines that will meet production needs.
Acquisition:
- Sourcing and purchasing the appropriate bottling machines from suppliers based on the specification.
- Includes negotiating contracts, ensure compliance with safety standards, and verifying energy efficiency ratings.
Deployment:
- Overseeing the installation and setup of the bottling line at the factory.
- Ensure the equipment is properly placed, connected, and integrated into the existing system before handing over for
operation. 14
Maintenance: Once the new bottling line has been installed and commissioned, the
maintenance team take over.
Their responsibilities include:
• Routine maintenance : Performing regular checks, lubrication, and cleaning of the
bottling line to ensure smooth operation and prevent breakdown.
• Repairs: Fixing any issues that arise, such as replacing worn-out conveyor belts, repairing
sensors, etc.
• Preventive Maintenance: Scheduling inspections and replacing parts before they fail to
minimize downtime and extend the life of the equipment.
In General, the engineering team handles the technical planning and setup,
while the maintenance team ensures the equipment continues to function
efficiently after it’s operation. 15
Maintenance Engineering (MEPP 408)
Introduction to Maintenance
By integrating these four components – Look, Listen, Analyze, and Act – Organizations can
create robust maintenance strategy that enhances operational efficiency and reduces the
risk of unexpected failures.
26
Type of Maintenance
27
Unplanned Maintenance
Unplanned maintenance refers to repairs or maintenance that occur
unexpectedly usually due to sudden failure or breakdown of equipment.
Example:
• A machine in a production line suddenly stops working
because of motor has failed.
• Fix car when it suddenly breaks down in the middle of
the road.
• Not scheduled - the equipment has stopped working, causing downtime or delays.
• Disturb production, cost more time and money to fix. 28
Planned Maintenance
Planned maintenance refers to scheduled maintenance activities that are
done regularly to keep equipment in good working order and prevent
unexpected breakdowns.
Example:
1. A company schedules monthly inspection of its conveyor belts to check for
wear and tear and to replace any work parts before they cause a
breakdown.
2. regular check-up of car,
3. scheduling a dentist appointment every 6 month.
You plan it ahead to keep everything running smoothly and to avoid problems.
29
Reactive and Proactive Maintenance
Reactive Maintenance (Unplanned Maintenance)
• Maintenance culture dependent on failures & breakdowns
• Work is executed without advance preparation
• This should only be the most urgent repairs & maintenance i.e.
emergency/breakdown maintenance
• Emergency/breakdown maintenance should be < 2% of total
maintenance workload.
Note: Breakdown maintenance system cannot work in a big industry having large
number of equipment.
Breakdown Maintenance
•Breakdown maintenance is defined as the process of addressing
equipment that has ceased functioning.
• Refers to fixing and repairing machinery or equipment after it has completely
stopped functioning or broken down.
37
Unplanned Breakdown Maintenance
(Emergency Maintenance)
•This occurs without warning when critical equipment's fails
unexpectedly.
•It often leads to significant downtime and can incur high costs
due to expedited repairs and potential operational disruptions.
•Organizations typically strive to minimize unplanned
breakdowns through better planning and resource allocation.
38
Planned Breakdown Maintenance
(Run-to-Failure)
•This strategy involves allowing certain equipment to
operate until it fails, which is anticipated.
•It is most effective for non-critical assets that are
inexpensive to replace or do not pose safety risks during
failure.
•For instance, light bulbs in a facility might be replaced
only after they burn out. 39
Objectives of Breakdown Maintenance
The objectives of implementing breakdown maintenance include:
1. Cost reduction
By avoiding unnecessary preventive maintenance on less critical assets, organizations can
save money.
2. Efficient Downtime management
Consolidating repairs can help minimize overall downtime, making operations more
efficient.
3. Resource Allocation
Focusing maintenance efforts on high-value assets ensures that critical equipment
receives the attention it needs while reducing staffing requirements for less important
machinery.
40
Advantages:
• Lower immediate Costs
Reduces expenditure on preventive measures for non-essential equipment.
• Simplified Resource Management
Requires fewer staff and resources for ongoing maintenance tasks
Disadvantages:
• Potential for Higher Long-term costs
Unplanned failures can lead to expensive emergency repairs and lost productivity.
• Safety Risks
Equipment failures can pose safety hazards, especially in critical operations where reliability
is paramount.
41
Effective management of breakdown maintenance often involves using
Computerized Maintenance Management Systems (CMMS) to track failures,
schedule repairs, and analyze data for future improvements.
42
Maintenance Engineering (MEPP 408)
Introduction to Maintenance
In the British Standard 3811:1993 Glossary of terms, corrective maintenance is defined as:
the maintenance carried out after recognition and intended to put an item into a state in
which it can perform a required function.
Corrective Maintenance (CM)
• The main objectives of corrective maintenance are the maximisation
of the effectiveness of all critical plant systems, the elimination
of breakdowns, the elimination of unnecessary repair, and the
reduction of the deviations from optimum operating conditions.
• Aimed at restoring an asset to a condition in which it can perform its
intended function.
• Subdivisions:
1. Immediate Corrective Maintenance (Begins immediately after
failure)
2. Deferred Corrective Maintenance (delayed as per maintenance
rules)
The way to perform corrective maintenance activities is by conducting
four important steps:
1. Fault detection.
2. Fault isolation.
3. Fault elimination.
4. Verification of fault elimination.
55
Preventive Maintenance
• It is good for those machines and facilities which failure would cause
serious production losses.
57
Necessity of Preventive Maintenance
1. Reduce production downtime, resulting in fewer machine breakdowns.
2. Better conservation of assets and increased life-expectancy of assets, thereby eliminating premature
replacement of machinery and equipment's.
3. Reduce overtime costs and more economical use of maintenance workers due to working on a
scheduled basis instead of a crash basis to repair breakdowns.
4. Timely routine repairs circumvent fewer large-scale repairs.
5. Reduced cost of repairs by reducing secondary failures. When parts fail in service, they usually
damage other parts.
6. Reduced product rejects, rework, and scrap due to better overall equipment conditions.
7. Identification of equipment with excessive maintenance costs, indicating the need for corrective
maintenance, operator training, or replacement of obsolete equipment.
8. Improved safety and quality conditions. 58
Preventive Maintenance (PM) Risks
1. Damage to an adjacent equipment during PM task.
2. Damage to the equipment receiving the PM task.
3. Damage during the performance of an inspection, repair, adjustment, or
installation of a replacement part.
4. Installing material that is defective, incorrectly installing a replacement part,
or incorrectly reassembling material.
5. Reintroducing infant mortality by installing new parts and materials.
6. Damage due to an error in reinstalling equipment into its original location.
Note: These errors go unnoticed until they cause unplanned shutdown. 59
Preventive Maintenance Frequency
Equipment
Health
x1 Y1 x2 Y2 x3 Y3 x4
Time
X1, X2, X3, X4 indicates the actual operation periods during which the equipment conditions
deteriorates and periods Y1, Y2, Y3,… are the period of capital repairs/overhauls during which a
deteriorated equipment is restored back to near its original conditions.
Note: X1, X2, X3, X4 and Y1, Y2, Y3 may or may not be equal.
Bathtub Curve
61
• The bathtub curve is a
critical concept in a preventive
maintenance, illustrating the
failure rates of assets over their
lifecycle.
• It consists of three distinct phases:
Infant mortality, normal life, and
Wear-out.
• Understanding this curve helps
maintenance teams to apply
appropriate strategies at different Failure rate Wear-out
Infant
stages to enhance reliability and Mortality
Useful life
extend asset life. Time 62
Phases of the Bathtub Curve
1. Infant Mortality Period:
• This initial phase is characterized by a high
failure rate due to early defects or issues
that arise shortly after the asset is put into
service.
• Because of incorrect operation, incorrect
foundation, incorrect understanding of
the machines, some design defect, etc.
• Preventive maintenance strategies during
this phase focus on intensive testing and
quality checks to identify and rectify
potential problems before they lead to
significant failures.
• Once these are taken care of, the failures
reduce and come down.
• And then enter useful period. 63
2. Normal Life Period
• In this stage, the failure rate
stabilizes, and failures become
less frequent and more random.
• Preventive maintenance
becomes essential, involving
regular inspections and
schedule maintenance tasks to
ensure optimal performance
and prevent unexpected
breakdowns. 64
3. Wear-Out Period
• As assets age, they enter the wear-out
phase where the failure rate increases
significantly due to deterioration and
reaching to the end of their useful life.
• At this point, predictive maintenance
techniques are crucial.
• Maintenance teams analyze data to
anticipate failures and perform
maintenance just in time to avoid
breakdowns.
Note: Toward the end of the life of the machine, wear/tear increases and the failure engage with time and time would have
come, when it is not wise to do any maintenance and it would be necessary for to almost replace the machine. 65
• During the infant mortality phase, focus
on rigorous quality assurance.
• In the Normal Life phase, implement
routine preventive maintenance
measures.
• As assets approach the Wear-Out period,
shift towards predictive maintenance
to manage increasing failure rates
effectively.
66
Preventive maintenance schedules to be two types:
•Fixed Time Maintenance (FTM)
•Condition Based Maintenance (CBM)
Fixed Time Maintenance: - Simple routine or cycles of work loads are
established for different day, week, month, year, etc.
Hourly: Lubricant Level, Sharpness of tool
Daily: Cleaning of Machine, Tightening of nuts, minor
adjust of parts.
Weekly: Major displacement, Lubrication
Monthly: Corrosion
Parameter (Machine Condition)
Normal trend
Month
Just by a trend, Maintenance Engineer can planned necessary activities to reduce repair downtime and other
to match the high demand related to cost.
Predictive Maintenance (PDM)
• Predictive maintenance is a set of activities that detect changes in the
physical condition of equipment (signs of failure) in order to carry out the
appropriate maintenance work for maximising the service life of
equipment without increasing the risk of failure.
• It is classified into two kinds according to the methods of detecting the signs
of failure:
• Condition-based predictive maintenance
• Statistical-based predictive maintenance 69
Predictive Maintenance (PDM)
1400.00 100
minutes
P2pk P1pk
Tc left
Th right
Th left Tc right
Condition-Based Monitoring (CBM)
•Condition monitoring means the use of advanced technologies in
order to determine equipment condition, and potentially predict failure.
•CBM involves the actual condition of equipment to determine
whether maintenance is needed, rather than relying on a fixed
schedule.
•The goal of CBM is to perform maintenance only when there are
indicators that equipment performance is deteriorating or that
failure is imminent.
74
CBM
• Focuses on assessing the current state of equipment through various
monitoring techniques, including sensors and data analysis.
• The primary goal is to perform maintenance only when specific indicators
signal that action is required, thereby optimizing maintenance efficiency and
minimizing downtime and costs.
• CBM process typically involves three key components:
1. Data Collection: Sensors gather real-time data on various parameters such as
vibration, temperature, pressure, etc.
2. Data Analysis: A software system, often a computerized maintenance management
system (CMMS), analyzes this data to identify patterns or anomalies.
3. Decision making: Maintenance teams use the analyzed data to decide when to
perform maintenance activities based on the actual condition of the equipment.
75
76
Benefits include:
• Reduction/elimination of unplanned failures
• Reduced overall maintenance costs
• Improved equipment performance - Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)
• Increased asset life
• Reduction/elimination of collateral damages
• Prioritized actions and jobs made easier
• Increased efficiency of maintenance management
• Avoiding opening up of equipment at fixed intervals
• Increased uptime/reduced downtime
Challenges in Condition-Based Maintenance
• Initial Costs: Implementing a CBM program may require significant
upfront investment in technology and training.
• Data Management: Handling large volumes of data from sensors can
be complex and requires robust analytical capabilities.
• Cultural Shift: Transitioning from traditional maintenance practices to a
CBM approach may requires changes in organizational culture and
mindset.
78
Summary - CBM
• Arise when equipment need preservation.
• Monitors the actual condition of the asset to decide what
maintenance needs to be done.
• CBM dictates that maintenance should only be performed when
certain indicators show signs of decreasing performance or
upcoming failure.
• Checking a machine for these indicators may include visual inspection,
performance data, scheduled tests, etc.
Routine Maintenance
• Means carrying out minor maintenance job at regular intervals.
• involves minor jobs such as cleaning, lubrication , inspection.
OR
minor adjustment of pressure , flow , tightness, tightening of loose
part.
• Also includes inspection of bearing, v-belts, coupling, jointing
foundation bolts, and protective covers, etc
• The small and critical defects - observed during such inspection are rectified
immediately and biggest jobs are planned for rectification during next availabl
shutdown.
Routine maintenance is essential for effective scheduled and preventive maintenance
Design – out maintenance
Assignment 1
DOM – redesign equipment to fix problems permanently so it doesn’t need as much maintenance.
Maintenance cost
• Maintenance cost are a critical aspect of manufacturing operations, impacting both
financial performance and operational efficiency.
• Maintenance costs can significantly influence overall production expenses and should be
carefully managed to optimize profitability.
• Maintenance cost refers to the expenses associated with the upkeep of equipment,
machinery, and facilities to ensure they remain operational.
• Maintenance costs can be categorized into several components:
• Labor costs: This includes salaries for maintenance staff and any external contractors hired for
repair.
• Parts and Materials: Expenses for consumables like lubricants, filters, and replacement parts.
• Downtime: Periods when equipment is non-operational due to maintenance, leading to lost
productivity.
83
Total Maintenance Cost Calculation
The total cost of maintenance (TC) can be calculated using the formula:
TC = FC + VC +AC + FCS
Where,
FC = Fixed cost (e.g. Labor for scheduled maintenance)
VC = Variable cost (e.g. Labor and materials for corrective actions)
AC = Administrative costs (e.g. Spare parts inventory)
FCS = Failure Costs (Cost incurred due to equipment failure)
Note: Understanding this total cost helps organizations evaluate their maintenance
strategies and make informed decisions about resource allocation. 84
85
A manufacturing company has a critical machine with the following annual costs:
• Maintenance Cost: $20,000.
• Production Downtime Cost (per hour): $5,000.
• Downtime Hours Due to Poor Maintenance: 30 hours.
• Cost of New Equipment: $150,000.
By analyzing these costs, business can make informed decisions to maximize uptime and profitability.
86
Maintenance commitment refers to dedication of resources – both financial and human – to
ensure that equipment is maintained properly. This includes:
• Preventive maintenance programs: Regularly scheduled inspections and maintenance tasks aimed at
preventing equipment failures.
• Predictive maintenance programs: Utilizing data analytics to forecast potential equipment failures
before they occur, thereby reducing unexpected downtime.
• Training and development – investing in training programs for staff to enhance their skills in
performing maintenance tasks efficiently. 87
End of module 1 & 2
88