0% found this document useful (0 votes)
12 views2 pages

Comparison of Power Electronics Devices

Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
12 views2 pages

Comparison of Power Electronics Devices

Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

Feature DIAC SCR (Thyristor) TRIAC GTO MOSFET IGBT

Type Bidirectional trigger Unidirectional Bidirectional Turn-OFF capable Voltage-controlle Hybrid: MOSFET +
diode controlled switch controlled switch SCR d FET BJT

No. of Terminals 2 3 (Anode, Cathode, 3 (MT1, MT2, Gate) 3 (Anode, Cathode, 3 (Drain, Source, 3 (Collector, Emitter,
Gate) Gate) Gate) Gate)

Control Signal Breakover voltage (no Gate triggering Gate triggering Gate-triggered ON, Gate voltage Gate voltage (VGE)
gate) gate-turned OFF (VGS)

Directionality Conducts in both Unidirectional Bidirectional Unidirectional Unidirectional Unidirectional


directions

Switching Speed Moderate Slow Slow Faster than SCR Very fast Slower than Mosfet

Turn-OFF Method Natural (at zero Natural (line Natural Gate signal (active Gate OFF pulse Gate OFF pulse
current) commutation) turn-OFF)

dv/dt sensitive No Yes Yes Less than SCR No No

Application Triggering TRIAC Rectifiers, inverters, AC phase control High-power SMPS,low-power Motor drives, UPS,
converters (light/fan dimmer) inverters inverters inverters

Major Carriers Both Majority/minority Majority/minority Majority/minority Majority Both (input – MOS,
(minority/majority) (electrons) output – BJT)

Device Type Diode-type Thyristor Dual thyristor Modified SCR Unipolar Bipolar

Snubber Needed? No Yes Yes Yes No No


Device Regions V-I Characteristics Description Important Points in V-I Graph

DIAC Forward & Reverse Conducts only after breakover voltage - Symmetrical- No conduction until VBO- After
(VBO) in both directions VBO, sharp current increase

SCR Forward Blocking, Forward Conducts only when forward biased + - Latching current (IL) to turn ON- Holding
Conduction, Reverse Blocking gate triggered current (IH) to remain ON- In reverse bias:
behaves like a reverse-biased diode

TRIAC Quadrant I, II, III, IV Conducts in both directions with gate - VI graph in all 4 quadrants- Similar to 2 SCRs in
triggering opposite directions

GTO Forward Blocking, Conduction, Conducts with gate pulse, turns off with - Similar to SCR in ON state- Turn-off requires
Turn-off region negative gate pulse gate pulse (not natural like SCR)

MOSFET Cut-off, Triode, Saturation Controlled by VGS – current flows when - Linear region (like resistor)- Saturation region
VGS > threshold (current constant)- Drain current controlled by
VGS

IGBT Cut-off, Active (Saturation), Like MOSFET, voltage-controlled; - Saturation like BJT- Gate control like MOSFET-
Breakdown combines input of MOSFET & output of High input impedance
BJT

You might also like