A Project Report on

A Dynamic Study: Factors

actors Contributing To High Loss
oss Rate Among
Indian
ndian Retail Options Traders
Submitted in partial fulfillment to the requirements for the degree of
BACHELOR OF COMMERCE

Submitted By Arpan Mahapatra

Roll no: UBC21COM-129
Reg. No:1359/21
Under the supervision of
Dr. Gnyana Ranjan Bal
Assistant Professor
SCHOOL OF COMMERCE
GANGADHARMEHERUNIVERSITY,AMRUTAVIHAR AMRUTA VIHAR,
SAMBALPUR, ODISHA
ODISHA-768004
2024
 DECLARATION

I, Arpan Mahapatra, bearing roll number UBC21COM-129, a student of [Link]

Semester-VI, School of Commerce, G.M. University, Amruta Vihar, do hereby
declare that the project report entitled, “A Dynamic Study: Factors Contributing
To High Loss Rate Among Indian Retail Options Traders” submitted by me
under the guidance of Dr. Gnyana Ranjan Bal, Assistant Professor, School of
Commerce, Gangadhar Meher University, Amruta Vihar, Sambalpur, Odisha for the
degree of Bachelor of Commerce is my original work and any other’s ideas, contents
and materials used in the study have been duly cited and acknowledged. This
project report has not been published or submitted to any other University/ Institution
for award of any other degree. I have taken utmost care and diligence to make it
error free and I will be extremely sorry if any erroneous information being found out
in my work. I will be completely responsible of such act. However, if any errors
identified the same may kindly be intimated.

Place: Sambalpur Name of Student: Arpan Mahapatra

Date: Roll No: UBC21COM-129

2
 ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

I extend my deepest gratitude to all those who have contributed to the completion of this
project.
First and foremost, I would like to express my sincere appreciation to Gnyana Ranjan Bal Sir
whose guidance, expertise, and unwavering support were invaluable throughout this endeavor.
Their encouragement, insightful feedback, and dedication played a pivotal role in shaping the
direction and scope of this project.
I am also immensely grateful to the faculty members of Commerce department, whose
academic guidance and encouragement provided me with the necessary resources and
inspiration to pursue this research.
I extend my heartfelt thanks to my colleagues and friends who provided assistance,
encouragement, and constructive criticism during the various stages of this project. Their input
and discussions greatly enriched the quality of the work.
Furthermore, I would like to acknowledge the support and understanding of my family
members, whose unwavering encouragement and patience sustained me through the challenges
encountered during this project.
Last but not least, I am deeply thankful to all the participants and individuals who generously
shared their time, insights, and expertise, without whom this project would not have been
possible.
In conclusion, I am truly grateful to each and every individual who has contributed in any way
to the completion of this project. Your support and encouragement have been instrumental, and
I am profoundly appreciative of the opportunity to undertake this endeavor.

ARPAN MAHAPATRA
BCOM SEMESTER ‘VI’

3
[Link]
Assistant Professor
SchoolofCommerce,GangadharMeherUniversity,
Amruta Vihar, Sambalpur, Odisha-768004

CERTIFICATE

This is to certify that the project report entitled, “A Dynamic Study: Factors
Contributing To High Loss Rate Among Indian Retail Options Traders” has
been submitted by Arpan Mahapatra, bearing Roll Number: UBC21COM-129 under
my guidance and supervision for partial fulfillment of the requirements for the award
of the degree of Bachelor of Commerce.

Place: Sambalpur Dr. Gnyana Ranjan Bal

Date:

4
 Table of Contents

Sl. No. Contents Page No.

1 Introduction 6-7
2 Review of Literature 7-9
3 Research Gap 9-10
4 Significance of the Study 10-11
5 Objectives of the study 11
6 11-12
Research and Methodology

7 Analysis & Interpretation 12-16

8 Summary, Findings and 16-17

Implications, Suggestions
9 Conclusion 17-18
10 Limitation and Scope for 18
further research
11 References 19-20

5
 A dynamic study: Factors contributing to high loss rate among Indian retail options
traders
Arpan Mahapatra, School of Commerce, Gangadhar Meher University, Amruta Vihar,
Sambalpur, Odisha, Email: rishimahapatra264@[Link]
Dr. Gnyana Ranjan Bal, Assistant Professor, School of Commerce, Gangadhar Meher
University, Amruta Vihar, Sambalpur, Odisha

1. Introduction
In the ever-evolving landscape of financial markets, options trading stands out as a dynamic
arena where investors seek to capitalize on market movements, hedge risk, and enhance
portfolio returns. In India, the options market has witnessed remarkable growth, propelled by
advancements in technology, increased market accessibility, and a burgeoning interest among
retail investors. However, beneath the surface of this burgeoning market lies a troubling
reality: a significant portion of retail option traders experience substantial losses, with
estimates suggesting that up to 90% face negative returns.
The allure of options trading for retail investors is undeniable, offering the potential for
significant profits through leveraged positions and sophisticated strategies. Yet, the path to
success in options trading is rife with challenges and pitfalls that often elude the uninitiated
trader. From navigating complex derivatives products to managing risk in volatile markets,
retail option traders must contend with a myriad of factors that can impact their trading
outcomes.
You might be wondering what does options and futures mean, well in simple words options
and futures are nothing but derivative contracts based on stocks. The derivative segment of
the market is called Futures and Options or F&O. Our project will mainly cover Options
segment of the derivative market as the largest number of options contracts are traded in
India and options market is what the retail traders are crazy about so much that over 90% of
them lose money. An Option refers to the right to either buy or sell a definite amount of a
particular underlying asset at a pre-determined price by pre-determined expiration time
frame. Option is known as derivative because its value is derived from an underlying asset
and its price shifts as the price of the underlying asset increases or decreases. There are two
types of options; Call option and Put option. A call option is the right but not the obligation to
buy a fixed amount of share at fixed price on or before the expiry period. If the trader is
expecting an upside movement of the stock or market then he should buy call option of that
stock or call option of the market. E.g.-If the trader has bullish view on the banking stocks for

6
near term then he should buy call option of Bank-Nifty. Put option: A put option is the right
but not the obligation to sell a fixed amount of shares at fixed price on or before the expiry
period. If the trader has a bearish view on market or a particular stock then he should buy put
option of the market or put option of that particular stock.
This project seeks to unravel the enigma of high loss rates among Indian retail option traders,
delving deep into the factors that contribute to poor performance and suboptimal outcomes.
By shining a light on the underlying dynamics of the options market and the behavioral
patterns of retail traders, this research aims to provide valuable insights that can inform
strategies for improving trader education, enhancing risk management practices, and fostering
a more conducive trading environment.
At its core, this investigation is driven by a desire to understand the root causes of retail
traders' struggles in the options market and to offer actionable recommendations for
addressing these challenges. The study endeavors to provide a holistic understanding of the
complexities of options trading and pave the way for a more informed and empowered
community of retail traders in India.

2. Review of literature
SEBI (2023) published a research study on its website which showed that 90% of active retail
traders lose money trading options and other derivatives contracts. In the year ended march
2022, investors lost $5.4 billion. It also showed that average loss by a loss maker was over 15
times the average profit of a profit maker during FY22. It mentioned that 98% traded in
options while 11% traded in future during FY22 as compared to 89% and 43%, respectively,
during FY19. The study also found out that on average, loss makers registered net trading
loss close to ₹50000 in FY22. The percentage of loss maker who traded in index options and
stock options went up during FY22 over FY19. Gupta (2023) CIO, Axis mutual Funds wrote
in his study report “Gamification of Indian Equities” posted by Axis Mutual Funds that the
Indian equities market has undergone an exceptional change with derivate trading now
dominating the landscape. Equity derivatives account for a staggering 99.6% of market
volumes, totaling over US$4.3 trillion per day. Alignment of expiries in key indices to
different days of the week now facilitates zero-day expiries, and will further boost volumes.
Change in contract structure, leverage combined with the ease of on boarding and interface of
the new generation trading apps has triggered gamification of this market. As a result, the
number of active derivatives traders has increased eightfold from less than half a million in
2019 to 4 million. He mentioned that Index options are now the preferred choice constituting

7
99% of derivative volume within which weekly account for 95% of trades. He discovered
that on an average a retail trader just holds an option for 30 minutes only. He also wrote that
Fantasy sports offer better odds than options trading for retailers. Kamath (2021), The CEO
and founder of Zerodha, the most famous and biggest stock broker of India in his online post
titled “Option buying: the riskiest trade out” explained the main reason retail traders lose
money continuously in trading option is that traders usually transition from trading stocks or
futures to trading options. And so, they end up trading options like the way they traded stocks
which is a sure-shot way to their downfall. In his own words Nitin wrote, “What attracts
people to options is leverage, the ability to get exposure to large trading positions with small
amounts of money. This induces greed and the notion that you can make money quickly”.
Business Today (2023) In an online news article quoted the words of Siddhartha Bhaiya, a
Mumbai-based money manager, who said at an event organized by The Indian Association of
Investment Professionals (IAIP) that the boom in derivative trading has turned options
trading into "India's Las Vegas". He said that the biggest form of gambling in India at the
moment is the derivatives. He called it India's Las Vegas without any of the glamour. The
fund manager said that retail traders believe they can beat the odds and make money off
options trading despite data suggesting otherwise. He suggested retail traders to get rid of
their trading accounts. He explained that it is the global FIIs that make money in the
derivative market. A retail trader pays 42% tax on his derivative transactions while All the
FIIs are based out of tax-free jurisdictions, They pay zero taxes on the derivative transactions.
Bhaiya said, “It's like going to a casino and knowing it is rigged in their favour. Data says
there is an 80% probability that you're not going to make money but the problem is everyone
thinks that they are part of the other 20%. So, get rid of your derivatives account. I don't think
so anyone in our team has a derivatives account”. Hofeza (2023) explained in one of
Economics Times news article why trading derivative is popular but not profitable. It goes on
to state that While many reasons fuel the popularity of derivative trading in the stock market,
there are three prime reasons for the raging demand for options trading, that is, Low capital
investment, Plethora of social media content and influence, and Lure of quick money. The
main factors that contribute to derivative trading not being profitable are - Lack of
Knowledge, Understanding & Practical Applicability, Choosing the wrong strike price, Not
knowing when not to trade. At the end it stated, “Options trading requires a solid
understanding of market dynamics, risks, and strategies to succeed. Blindly following tips,
social media trends or peer pressure can lead to losses”. Times of India (2024) wrote in one
of its newspaper article about how finfluencers like Mohammad Nasiruddin Ansari, sells

8
dream of stock market riches to India’s fast growing cadre of small investors. The article
mentioned that SEBI took action against Ansari for improperly promoting himself as a stock
market expert, promising near certain profits and acting as an unregistered investment
advisor. SEBI ordered Ansari and an associate to refund Rs. 172 million which they had
charged for online training courses. The article then goes to explain how rapidly the Indian
stock market has changed within the last few years and how people without proper
knowledge about stocks are entering into the stock market thinking it would make them
millionaire. Kriplani, & Sharma (2023) wrote an article in Mint’s newsletter stating that
buying options was like buying a lottery. It gave a real life example of Mohit Mehta, a 32
year old dentist in Mumbai, who had been trading in the stock market since 2018. He had
incurred a huge loss of nearly ₹4 lakhs but was able to recover it in lockdown by buying put
options. After this he was influenced to trade in derivatives by an expert who would appear
on television channels. He subscribed to his premium services. Initially all was good but it
started to fall down after some time which led Mohit to incur even more losses. There are
thousand like him who get allured to derivative trading to make quick money. Incessant
trading calls by experts on television channels or finfluencers in youtube fill their greed.
Gandhi (2023) wrote a research study published it on the website ICICI direct titled “Indian
brokerage industry”. She explained in the research that the Indian brokerage industry had
undergone rapid changes in its business environment in the last few fiscals, starting with a
surge in customer accretion (client base rising from ~2.1 crore in FY20 to 8.1 crore in
February 2023), business volume (~15.8 lakh crore in FY20 to ~163 lakh crore in Q3FY23),
pick-up in flat brokerage model to rising proportion of derivatives volumes. In the research it
showed that the brokerage firms were earning most their revenue from the brokerage
collected from the options trades. With the rise in the volume of transactions in derivative
market the brokerage firms started to decrease their brokerage charges on options so that
more people would trade in options. The research showed that the Zerodha is the largest
brokerage in India followed by Groww, Angel Broking, 5 Paisa, Kotak Securities, MOSL and
IIFL securities.

3. Research Gap
The literature review presents a stark portrayal of the pitfalls surrounding F&O trading,
emphasizing the detrimental impact on retail investors. While existing research offers
valuable insights into the challenges faced by retail option traders in India, several gaps
remain in our understanding of the factors contributing to the high loss rate among this

9
demographic. Identifying and addressing these gaps is crucial for developing effective
interventions and strategies to improve trader outcomes and foster a more resilient options
market. While studies have identified behavioral biases such as overconfidence, loss
aversion, and herd mentality as influential factors in retail traders' decision-making processes,
there is a need for deeper exploration into the underlying mechanisms driving these biases.
Understanding the psychological factors that influence trader behavior and how they manifest
in different market conditions can provide valuable insights for designing targeted
interventions to mitigate their impact. Risk management is widely recognized as a critical
determinant of trader success, there is limited research examining the effectiveness of
different risk management strategies employed by retail option traders in India. Further
exploration is needed to assess the prevalence and efficacy of risk management techniques
such as stop-loss orders, position sizing, and portfolio diversification, as well as their impact
on trader performance and outcomes. Despite the growing emphasis on trader education and
financial literacy initiatives, there is a lack of empirical research evaluating the impact of
these programs on retail option traders' knowledge, skills, and decision-making abilities.
Further exploration is needed to assess the efficacy of different educational interventions in
enhancing trader performance, promoting informed decision-making, and reducing the
incidence of costly mistakes.

4. Significance of the study

This study holds significant importance as it delves into the intricacies of options trading
within the Indian market, shedding light on critical aspects that impact retail traders,
regulatory bodies, and market dynamics at large. By uncovering the factors contributing to
the high loss rate among Indian retail option traders, this research serves as a catalyst for
informed decision-making and strategic interventions across various sectors.
For retail traders, the study provides invaluable insights into the challenges and risks
associated with options trading, empowering them to make more informed decisions and
adopt effective risk management strategies. Armed with a deeper understanding of market
dynamics and trader behavior, retail traders can navigate the complexities of options trading
with greater confidence and resilience, ultimately reducing the incidence of losses and
enhancing their long-term success in the market. Regulatory bodies, such as the Securities
and Exchange Board of India (SEBI), stand to benefit from the findings of this study by
gaining a clearer understanding of the regulatory gaps and challenges faced by retail option
traders. By leveraging these insights, regulators can develop targeted interventions and policy

10
reforms aimed at strengthening investor protection, promoting market integrity, and fostering
a level playing field for all market participants. Furthermore, brokerage firms and trading
platforms can leverage the insights from this study to tailor their services, enhance customer
education initiatives, and develop innovative solutions to address the needs of retail option
traders. By aligning their strategies with the identified trends and preferences of retail traders,
brokerage firms and trading platforms can enhance customer satisfaction, foster trust, and
drive sustainable growth in the options market. Academically, this study contributes to the
growing body of research on options trading behavior and regulatory frameworks, providing
empirical evidence and insights that can inform future research endeavors and scholarly
debates in the field of financial markets and investments. Overall, the significance of this
study lies in its potential to drive positive change and foster a more transparent, efficient, and
investor-friendly options market in India. By addressing the challenges and opportunities
identified in this research, stakeholders can work collaboratively to build a stronger, more
resilient financial ecosystem that benefits all participants and contributes to the long-term
prosperity of the Indian economy.

5. Objective of the Study

5.1 To analyze the factors contributing to high loss rate among Indian retail option traders
5.2 To understand a retail option trader’s behavior.
5.3 To review regulatory framework.

6. Research and methodology

6.1 Nature of Study
This study employs a retrospective observational research design, focusing on analyzing
existing data to investigate the factors contributing to the high loss rate among Indian retail
option traders. It is primarily descriptive and exploratory in nature, aiming to identify
patterns, trends, and relationships in the data to gain insights into trader behavior and market
dynamics.

6.2 Nature of Data: The data utilized in this study are secondary in nature, collected by other
researchers, organizations, and regulatory bodies for purposes unrelated to the current
research. These datasets encompass a variety of sources, including market reports, academic
studies, regulatory documents, and trading platforms' data repositories. The data consist of

11
both quantitative and qualitative information, offering a comprehensive view of the Indian
options market and retail trader behavior.

6.3 Source of Data: The primary sources of secondary data for this study includes reports
published by stock exchanges, regulatory bodies, and market research firms provide insights
into market trends, trading volumes, and participant behavior in the Indian options market

6.4 Scope of research:

This research aims to comprehensively analyze the factors contributing to the high loss rate
among Indian retail option traders. The scope of the study encompasses trader behavior, risk
management practices, market dynamics, and regulatory environment.

By addressing these aspects comprehensively, this study aims to provide valuable insights
into the challenges in Indian retail options trading.

7. Analysis and Interpretation

7.1 Individual trader participation in F&O segment
Individual trader's participation in the Equity F&O (Futures and Options) segment refers to
the involvement of retail investors or individual traders in trading derivative instruments,
such as futures contracts and options contracts, on equities listed on stock exchanges. In the
case of this research the study includes the number of individual participants during the year
2022 as compared to the number of participants during the year 2019.
Table 1: Individual trader participation in F&O segment of Indian Stock market

All indivi dual tra ders

FY19 FY22
Total number of i ndividual traders 706757 4524841
% of total 100% 100%
% of los s makers during the yea r 85% 89%
% of profi t ma kers during the year 15% 11%
Source: [Link]
The data has been collected from the top 10 brokers in equity F&O segment of NSE. These
top 10 brokers account for than 50% of the Futures and Options trading user base in India.
The given table shows that total number of unique individual traders in the sample who

12
traded in equity F&O segment was 45.2 lakhs during FY22, up from 7.1 lakhs during FY19
(significant increase by over 500% in FY22 as compared to FY19). 89% of the individual
traders (i.e. 9 out of 10 individual traders) in equity F&O segment incurred losses during
FY22, up from 87% in FY19. This sudden increase in the number of individual F&O traders
shows that more and more people started to trade in the F&O segment of the derivative and
majority of them almost were making loss in F&O which tells us that the futures and options
markets are way more difficult to trade in and people without proper knowledge of the
derivative should stay away from. This also tells us that options market is not the easy money
market that everyone thinks it to be. It is a very volatile and risky segment of the market
which people should stay away from if they don’t know how options work.

7.2 Comparison of derivative to cash volume ratio of India and rest of the world
The comparison of derivative to cash volume ratio between India and the rest of the world
examines the relative significance and utilization of derivative instruments in the Indian
financial market compared to global financial markets. Specifically, it evaluates the
proportion of trading activity in derivative products, such as futures and options, in relation to
trading activity in the underlying cash or spot markets. This comparison provides insights
into the unique characteristics of the Indian derivatives market.
Graph 1: Comparison of derivative to cash volume ratio of India and rest of the
world
450
400 Derivative to cash volumes ratio
350
300
250
200
150
100
50
0

Source: WFE, ICICI securities

The above graph shows in most markets, derivatives volumes now account for 5-15x their
cash market volumes. In India today however, derivative volumes are more than 400x higher
than that of underlying cash market today, having grown from 3x in 2010. Total derivatives

13
volumes have risen to over US$4.3tn per day roughly translating to 125% of the underlying
companies’ market capitalization or over 200% of its free float being traded every day. The
growth of derivatives market is not unique to India, in most markets today derivatives volume
outstrips the cash market volumes. In the US, derivatives account for 70% of traded volumes,
compared to 99.6% currently for the Indian markets. A key reason for attractiveness of the
product is the embedded leverage, where only a fraction of the notional value is needed to
transact that ends up magnifying the potential gains (as well as losses) for the participant.

7.3 Product wise net Profit and Loss of individual traders

Product-wise net profit and loss of individual traders refers to the calculation and analysis of
the financial outcomes generated by traders in various derivative products which consist of
stock options, stock futures, index options, and index futures. This analysis involves tracking
the profits and losses incurred by individual traders on each specific type of derivative
contract over a given period. By examining the net profit or loss attributed to each product
category separately, we can gain insights into their trading performance.
Table2: Product wise net Profit and Loss of individual traders
Average P&L
Product category
FY19 FY22
Index Futures -46755 -53267
Index Options -50068 -58058
Stock Futures -154292 -59007
Stock options -38144 -42947
Profit Makers
Index Futures 45152 66244
Index Options 56515 92321
Stock Futures 191367 240705
Stock options 55002 63388
Loss Makers
Index Futures -71718 -96338
Index Options -72192 -77230
Stock Futures -242565 -208977
Stock options -59916 -66217
Source: [Link]
The given data signifies that During FY22, the average loss incurred by loss makers in stock
futures was Rs. 2.1 lakh, highest across all products, followed by an average loss of Rs. 0.96
lakh in index futures. Further, the average loss made by loss makers in index options and
stock options were Rs. 0.77 lakh and Rs. 0.66 lakh, respectively during FY22. The average

14
profit earned by profit makers was highest in stock futures (Rs. 2.4 lakh), followed by index
options (Rs. 0.92 lakh). During FY22, 11% of the individual traders in index options made
profit, down from 17% in FY19, however, the average profit made by profit makers went up
by 63% during FY22 over FY19. Overall, the data suggests that the retail traders incurred
higher average losses in options trading compared to other products. It also showed that while
profits can be made in options trading, the average profits for profit makers in options were
lower compared to other products like stock futures. Given these factors, the data suggest that
options trading present great challenges for retail traders.

7.4 ADTO trajectory in Indian Market

ADTO stands for "Average Daily Turnover" and refers to the average value of securities
traded on a particular exchange or market on a daily basis over a specific period, typically
measured in terms of currency value (e.g., INR). ADTO provides insight into the level of
trading activity and liquidity within a market, reflecting the total value of securities bought
and sold by investors over the course of a trading day. It is calculated by dividing the total
value of securities traded over a specified period by the number of trading days in that
period. ADTO Trajectory in the Indian market defines the historical pattern or trend of the
Average Daily Turnover (ADTO) of securities traded on Indian stock exchanges over a
specific period.
Table3: ADTO trajectory in Indian Market

Daily exchange turnover(₹ lakh crore) FY21 FY22

Cash total (I) 0.66 0.72
Futures 1.1 1.2
Options 26.2 69.8
F&O total (II) 27.3 71
Total (I+II) 28 72
Source: NSE, BSE, SEBI, ICICI Direct Research
The given table shows us that Brokerage firms earn a significant portion of their revenue
from brokerage charges associated with options and futures trading. These charges typically
comprise a commission fee based on the volume or value of trades executed by clients. The
revenue from the options alone is more than the combined revenue of cash and futures.
Options trading allow retail traders to control a larger position with a relatively small amount
of capital, thanks to the use of leverage. As a result, traders may execute larger trades in these

15
markets, leading to higher brokerage fees based on the larger transaction sizes. This just goes
on to show that brokerage firms want their users to trade in options because the more the
people trade in options the more the company earns. Whether the trader makes money or
loses money the brokerage firm will benefit from both.

8. Summary, Findings, Implication and Suggestions of the study

The implications of the study shed light on the multifaceted dynamics of options trading in
India, with significant ramifications for various stakeholders. Firstly, the study underscores
the substantial revenue streams generated by brokerage firms through options trading
commissions. Given the complex nature of options contracts and the potential for higher
transaction volumes, brokerage firms stand to earn substantial commissions from facilitating
options trades. This underscores the importance of options trading as a key revenue driver for
brokerage firms, incentivizing them to promote and facilitate options trading activities among
their client base. Change in contract structure, leverage combined with the ease of on
boarding and interface of the new generation trading apps has triggered gamification of this
market (Gupta, 2023). Additionally, the study highlights the revenue implications for
regulatory bodies such as the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI). SEBI earns a
significant portion of its revenue from taxes and fees collected from market participants
engaged in options trading. As options trading volumes continue to grow, SEBI's revenue
from transaction charges, turnover fees, and regulatory levies also increases, providing vital
funding for the regulator's operations and market oversight activities. However, this revenue
dependence may create a potential conflict of interest, as SEBI's regulatory mandate to
protect investors may be perceived as being at odds with its financial interest in promoting
options trading activity. Furthermore, the study brings attention to the risks associated with
options trading, particularly for retail investors. While options trading offer the potential for
substantial profits, it also carries inherent risks, including the potential for significant losses.
“What attracts people to options is leverage, the ability to get exposure to large trading
positions with small amounts of money. This induces greed and the notion that you can make
money quickly” (Kamath, 2021). The study suggests that retail investors may be lured into
options trading under the guise of quick profits and speculative opportunities, often without
fully understanding the complexities and risks involved. This raises concerns about investor
protection and highlights the need for enhanced investor education, awareness campaigns,
and regulatory safeguards to prevent retail investors from being misled or exploited by
unscrupulous actors in the options market. In summary, the implications of the study

16
underscore the financial incentives driving options trading activities for brokerage firms and
regulatory bodies, while also highlighting the potential risks and pitfalls faced by retail
investors. By recognizing these dynamics, policymakers, regulators, and market participants
can work collaboratively to promote transparency, investor education, and responsible trading
practices in the options market.

9. Conclusion
In conclusion, our investigation into the high loss rate among Indian retail option traders has
revealed a sobering reality: a significant majority of traders experience losses in the options
market. This phenomenon underscores the challenges faced by retail investors in navigating
the complexities of options trading, often resulting in financial setbacks and disillusionment.
Despite the potential for substantial profits, many traders are ill-prepared to mitigate risks
effectively, leading to a pervasive pattern of losses that characterizes the landscape of options
trading in India. The biggest form of gambling in India at the moment is the derivatives. Its
India's Las Vegas without any of the glamour (Bhaiya, 2023). Many retail investors get easily
influenced by the media or finfluencers and jump into F&O trading (Jasani, 2023).
Interestingly, amidst the backdrop of retail traders' losses, brokerage firms emerge as
significant beneficiaries, reaping substantial profits from options trading commissions. The
reliance of brokerage firms on commission charges underscores the financial incentives
driving the promotion and facilitation of options trading activities among retail investors.
This symbiotic relationship between brokerage firms and retail traders highlights the inherent
tension between profit motives and investor interests within the financial ecosystem.
Moreover, regulatory bodies such as the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) also
stand to benefit financially from the proliferation of options trading. Through taxes, fees, and
levies collected from market participants engaged in options trading activities, SEBI
generates a substantial portion of its revenue, supporting its market oversight and investor
protection efforts. However, this financial dependency raises concerns about potential
conflicts of interest and underscores the need for robust regulatory oversight to ensure market
integrity and investor confidence. In light of these findings, it is evident that options trading
in India present a complex landscape characterized by a delicate balance between profit
motives, investor protection, and regulatory oversight. Moving forward, it is imperative for
stakeholders to prioritize measures that promote transparency, investor education, and
responsible trading practices. By fostering a more inclusive and resilient options market,

17
policymakers, regulators, brokerage firms, and retail traders alike can work collaboratively to
enhance market integrity, mitigate risks, and create a level playing field for all participants.

10. Limitations and Scope for further research

While this project provides valuable insights into the factors contributing to the high loss rate
among Indian retail option traders, it is important to acknowledge several limitations that may
impact the generalizability and robustness of the findings. Firstly, the study relies on
secondary data sources, which may be subject to limitations such as data accuracy,
completeness, and reliability. The use of aggregated data from market reports, academic
studies, and regulatory documents may overlook nuances and variations at the individual
trader level, limiting the depth of analysis and potentially leading to biased conclusions.
Secondly, the study focuses primarily on quantitative analysis, with limited exploration of
qualitative factors such as trader motivations, risk perceptions, and trading strategies. As a
result, the study may overlook important qualitative insights that could provide a more
comprehensive understanding of retail trader behavior and market dynamics in the options
market. Additionally, the study's scope is limited to the Indian options market, which may not
fully capture the broader context of global options trading practices and market structures.
Comparative analysis with other countries or regions could provide valuable insights into
cross-country differences in trader outcomes, regulatory frameworks, and market dynamics.
Moreover, the study does not account for potential confounding variables or external factors
that may influence trader outcomes, such as macroeconomic indicators, geopolitical events,
or market sentiment. Failure to control for these factors may introduce bias into the analysis
and limit the validity of the conclusions drawn. Lastly, the study's findings may be subject to
interpretation and are contingent on the assumptions and methodologies employed in the
analysis. Different analytical approaches or modeling techniques could yield alternative
results or conclusions, highlighting the subjectivity inherent in empirical research.
Despite these limitations, this project serves as a valuable starting point for further inquiry
into the complexities of options trading in the Indian market. By addressing these limitations
and building upon the insights gained, future research can contribute to a more nuanced
understanding of retail trader behavior, market dynamics, and regulatory challenges in the
options market.

18
11. References

Study - analysis of profit and loss of individual traders dealing in Equity F&O segment.
SEBI. (2023, January 25). [Link]
2023/study-analysis-of-profit-and-loss-of-individual-traders-dealing-in-equity-fando-
segment_67525.html

Gupta, A. (n.d.). “gamification” of Indian Equities - Axis Mutual Fund. [Link].

[Link] Gamification
of Indian [Link]

Hofeza, S. K. (2023, March 26). Why is derivative trading popular but not profitable?. The
Economic Times. [Link]
derivative-trading-popular-but-not-profitable/articleshow/[Link]

“it’s India’s Las Vegas”: Mumbai-based money manager equates options trading with
gambling. Business Today. (2023, November 21).
[Link]
mumbai-based-money-manager-equates-options-trading-with-gambling-406404-2023-
11-

Kamath, N. (2021, July 1). Option buying: The Riskiest Trade Out There. [Link].
[Link]

Kriplani, J., & Sharma, A. (2023, November 5). New lottery: human cost of f&o trade.
[Link]. Retrieved from [Link]
news/[Link].

Times of India. (2024, February 13). Retail traders are losing billions in india’s booming
option. [Link]. Retrieved from
[Link]
billions-in-indias-options-market-indian-news/articleshow/[Link].

Gandhi, K. (2023, March 29). Indian brokerage industry. [Link].

[Link]

19
NSE - National Stock Exchange of india ltd: Live share/stock market news & updates,
quotes. NSE India. (n.d.). [Link]

BSE (formerly Bombay Stock Exchange) - live stock/share market updates from Asia’s
premier stock exchange. get all the current Stock/share market news; real-time
information to investors on S&P BSE SENSEX, stock quotes, indices, derivatives and
corporate announcements. BSE (formerly Bombay Stock Exchange) | Live Stock
Market updates for S&P BSE SENSEX, Stock Price, Company News & Results.
[Link]

20