0% found this document useful (0 votes)
33 views3 pages

Ghana's Constitutional Law Principles Explained

The document outlines a series of tutorial questions related to Constitutional Law in Ghana, focusing on various topics such as the principles of the 1992 Constitution, legal disputes involving mobile money vendors, the doctrine of mootness, and the relationship between constitutionalism and judicial review. It also includes tasks like analyzing specific court cases, explaining constitutional definitions, and reviewing constitutional articles for potential amendments. The questions aim to deepen understanding of constitutional principles and their application in Ghana's legal framework.

Uploaded by

cliffasante1
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
33 views3 pages

Ghana's Constitutional Law Principles Explained

The document outlines a series of tutorial questions related to Constitutional Law in Ghana, focusing on various topics such as the principles of the 1992 Constitution, legal disputes involving mobile money vendors, the doctrine of mootness, and the relationship between constitutionalism and judicial review. It also includes tasks like analyzing specific court cases, explaining constitutional definitions, and reviewing constitutional articles for potential amendments. The questions aim to deepen understanding of constitutional principles and their application in Ghana's legal framework.

Uploaded by

cliffasante1
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

CONSTITUTIONAL LAW

Tutorial Questions

1. You are an intern at Asamoah-Gyan & Associates. Your boss, Kenneth


Asamoah-Gyan Esq. is working on a Constitutional law case for a client. He has
requested that you conduct a thorough research on any five of the underlying
principles of the 1992 Constitution of Ghana as he will need that information to
effectively make a case for his client. Write a memo to him reporting on your research
findings.

2. The Association of Mobile Money Vendors (AMMV) is the sole organization that
issues licenses for Mobile Money Vendors as provided for under Regulation 2 of the
Mobile Money Regulation 20X9 (LI 666). Adwoa Gyantoa recently withdrew her
membership and decided to go “solo”. She set up her shop at Ababio Avenue and her
business is doing really well. The Executives of the Association of Mobile Money
Vendors are not pleased with Adwoa’s public display of rebellion and breach of the
LI 666. The executives have decided to sue Adwoa in the High Court on the grounds
that only members of the AMMV who have been issued a licence can set up a Mobile
Money business. The President of the AMMV, Mr. Asempa has come to you in your
Chambers to ascertain the Association’s likelihood of success should they proceed to
file a suit against Adwoa. Advise him.

3. Critically analyse and reconcile the decision of the courts in J.H. Mensah v.
Attorney General [1996-97] SCGLR 320 and Amidu v. President Kufuor [2001-2002]
SCGLR 86 in relation to the doctrine of mootness.

4(a). Ama, your colleague who also takes the Constitutional Law class has come to
see you to explain to her certain parts of Thomas Paine’s definition of a Constitution
which she did not understand in class. Her difficulty is with understanding the last
part of the definition which says, “A government without a constitution is power

1
without a right”. Explain this statement to Ama taking into consideration the basic
tenets of Constitutional Law.

(b) Glen and Edem are having an argument. They both come and see you to settle the
dust since you are a Constitutional Law student. Glen’s argument is that Ghana has a
written Constitution while the United Kingdom does not. Glen further argues that the
Ghanaian Constitution is a presidential one while the unwritten Constitution of the
UK is a parliamentary one. Edem on the other hand, disagrees with Glen. In Edem’s
opinion, the UK cannot be said to have an unwritten constitution when the sources
can be found in written texts. Edem also thinks Ghana’s constitution is not
presidential properly-so called. Write your opinion on this matter.

5. A Constitutional Review Committee has been set up to review the 1992


Constitution and made recommendations for necessary amendments that will enhance
better democratic governance of Ghana. You have been appointed as a member of the
Committee and have been assigned to review article 3 of the 1992 Constitution on the
defence of the Constitution. Article 3(4) of the 1992 Constitution of the Republic of
Ghana grants citizens of Ghana the right and duty to defend the Constitution, resist
and do all in their power to restore the Constitution. Write your review report to be
presented to the Committee on the scope, benefits and limitations of article 3 and
make recommendations if any.

6. Write short notes on any four of the Constitutions of Ghana since 1916 : pre and
post-independence Constitutions.

7. A Constitution is “a things antecedent to a government and a government is only


the creation of a Constitution. A Constitution is not the act of a government but of a
people constituting a government. A government without a constitution is power
without a right”.

- Thomas Paine

2
Explain this definition to Fred, a classmate of yours who is having difficulty
understanding it.

8. With the aid of decided cases and relevant authorities explain the doctrine of
separation of powers as it applies to the 1992 Constitution of Ghana.

9. The Modern formulation of the Rule of Law is divided into two, namely the formal
theories of rule of law and substantive theories of rule of law. Explain the two theories,
indicating whether the modern formulation of Rule of Law exists in Ghana today.

10. (a) Carefully analyse the links between Constitutionalism and judicial review.

(b) Compare and contrast the decision in Re Akoto and 7 others with that of Marbury
v. Madison in relation to the doctrine of Constitutionalism.

11. There have been arguments that the hybrid system of separation of powers as it
exists under the 1992 Constitution has somewhat created an imperial executive
presidency. Do you agree? Explain your answer with the aid of decided cases and
relevant authorities.

Common questions

Powered by AI

The 1992 Constitution of Ghana implements separation of powers by clearly delineating the roles of the executive, legislative, and judicial branches. This ensures no branch exceeds its mandate. Compared to other democracies, Ghana's system is a hybrid that incorporates aspects of both presidential and parliamentary systems, allowing for a more balanced and flexible governance model .

Adwoa Gyantoa's decision to operate independently without a license from the Association of Mobile Money Vendors may be challenged legally. AMMV's Regulations require membership and licensing, and her breach may subject her to legal action for non-compliance with LI 666. This reflects the regulatory framework within Ghana that mandates compliance to maintain business standards .

Formal theories of the Rule of Law focus on the procedures by which laws are administered, requiring laws to be clear, publicized, and stable. Substantive theories emphasize justice, equality, and fairness within laws. In Ghana, modern formulations of these theories exist; laws are procedurally enforced while aiming to uphold substantive justice through constitutional safeguards and judicial review .

Ghana's written constitution provides a clear legal framework detailing the powers and duties of government branches, thereby ensuring accountability and transparency. In contrast, the UK's unwritten constitution comprises statutes, judicial decisions, and conventions, offering flexibility but potentially leading to adaptation challenges. These systems impact how each government operates, with Ghana having formalized structures and the UK relying on evolving precedential sources .

The 1992 Constitution of Ghana is founded on several key principles relevant for legal analysis: separation of powers, checks and balances, rule of law, sovereignty of the people, and fundamental human rights. These principles ensure a balanced distribution of government power, protect individual rights, and maintain democratic governance .

Article 3 of the 1992 Constitution empowers citizens to defend and restore the constitution if challenged. However, in practice, this empowerment faces limitations such as practical enforcement mechanisms, potential political interference, and varying interpretations of 'restoration' . It underscores the potential gap between constitutional provisions and their real-world applicability.

Judicial review in Ghana plays a crucial role in reinforcing constitutionalism by ensuring that laws and executive actions comply with constitutional principles. Key cases, such as Marbury v. Madison on a broad scale, and Re Akoto domestically, illustrate how courts interpret constitutional limits to prevent governmental overreach and uphold citizens' rights . It affirms the judiciary as a guardian of constitutional integrity.

The doctrine of mootness in Ghana prevents courts from deciding cases where no actual controversy exists at the time of hearing. In J.H. Mensah v. Attorney General, the court held that legal questions must have a practical effect on the parties involved. Similarly, in Amidu v. President Kufuor, the matter was dismissed as moot because the subject of litigation had already occurred . This doctrine underscores the judiciary's role in resolving only live disputes, ensuring judicial resources are used efficiently.

Thomas Paine’s statement highlights the foundational role of a constitution in legitimizing governmental power. Without a constitution, government power lacks a legal framework defining its limits and responsibilities. This absence undermines the idea of lawful governance, as the government's authority is not derived from the people's consent through a constitutional framework .

There is an ongoing debate whether Ghana's separation of powers creates an imperial executive presidency. The hybrid system grants significant powers to the president, which, according to some interpretations, might lead to executive overreach. Legal precedents that illustrate such concerns include challenged executive actions in parliamentary and judicial settings, affirming the necessity for clear checks and balances .

You might also like