Project Design Manual for Managers
Project Design Manual for Managers
PROJECT DESIGN
FOR
PROGRAM MANAGERS
Conducting a Workshop on
Planning Community-Based Projects
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . i
Sessions
9. Field Visit . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 73
10. Budgeting . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 79
Project Design for Program Managers is the second volume in The CEDPA Training
Manual Series. It has been developed by the Training Division of The Centre for
Development and Population Activities (CEDPA) with support from the United Nations
Population Fund (UNFPA). It compiles training activities that CEDPA has used in many
programs to strengthen the training capacity of health, family planning, and other
development organizations.
Rationale
In a time of scarce and uncertain resources, carefully designed projects are crucial to an
organization’s effectiveness. This manual approaches project design as an ongoing process
within an organization. This process encompasses needs assessment, problem identification,
development and implementation of solutions, assessment of outcomes, and planning for
the future.
This manual enables trainers to conduct a workshop in all phases of project design. The
workshop content is applicable to managers in any sector. The projects designed by
participants may be in any field. The manual also provides exercises that will be helpful
to managers in improving their skills in planning, implementing, and managing projects.
Trainers are provided with all the necessary information to conduct a project design
workshop including materials, content, teaching and training methods, handouts, and
activities. The sessions can be used together in one five-day workshop or individually.
Purpose
Methodology
Sessions are designed according to the process of experiential learning. Each session
engages participants in some type of experience and allows them an opportunity to reflect
on the experience to draw out key concepts and lessons, develop generalizations about
the lessons learned, and apply the new material. The trainer’s role is to facilitate this
learning process. Care has been taken to respect the principles of adult learning in every
session.
i
It is important for the user of this manual to remember that every training situation is
different and that each training program must address the special needs of the participants.
Trainers using this manual are encouraged to assess the training needs of an individual
group and adapt and modify the sessions presented here as necessary.
Experience Base
CEDPA’s Washington, D.C., and regional training programs have enabled more than 3,700
women and men from over 100 countries in Africa, Asia, Eastern Europe, Latin America,
and the Middle East to develop new skills in leadership, management, and institution
building. Alumni include leaders of private voluntary organizations and governmental and
non-governmental agencies and medical professionals, youth workers, and educators.
The Washington-based workshops are conducted annually in English and either Arabic,
French or Spanish. “Institution Building: Strategic Management for the ’90s” (IB) focuses
on management skills such as strategic planning, resource expansion, and financial systems
and includes a mentor program. “Women in Management: Leadership Training for the ’90s”
(WIM) focuses on women’s roles and challenges and includes sessions on gender awareness,
leadership styles of women and men, and strategies for managing groups. Regional
workshops are conducted in collaboration with alumni organizations and have included
training in project design, supervision, gender issues, evaluation, policy advocacy, strategic
planning, and training of trainers (TOT).
This manual compiles training activities used in CEDPA’s Washington-based and regional
training programs into a six-day curriculum to train project managers to design community-
based projects in health, family planning, and other development areas. It provides a
systematic approach to the process of project development, considering the organizational
environment within which the project is developed and the external environment within
which it is implemented. The curriculum also strengthens participants’ skills in planning,
implementing, and managing projects.
ii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Publication of this Training Manual on Project Design for Program Managers has been
made possible by a grant from the United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA). We wish
to express our sincere appreciation for their support of this production and for their long-
term support for many CEDPA training activities over the years. The authors wish to
acknowledge contributions made by CEDPA staff including Peggy Curlin, Adrienne Allison,
Marjorie Signer, Sue Richiedei, and Danielle Grant, and support from Mary Perriello,
Misbah Sheikh, and Mary Vanderbilt of CEDPA’s Training Division. The participants from
CEDPA workshops in Washington, D.C.; Nairobi, Kenya; and Kiev, Ukraine, have been
the most recent contributors in this effort; the Project Life Cycle was finalized with their
assistance.
iii
HOW TO USE THE MANUAL
The manual is organized into a series of 11 sessions which build upon each other. Each
session has the following components:
Learner Objectives - describe what the participant will be able to do by the end of the
session to demonstrate increased knowledge, improved skills, or attitudinal change.
Time - indicates the approximate amount of time the session will take.
Session Overview - provides a breakdown of the session into sub-topics, including the
time allocation for each sub-topic.
Materials - lists all the materials that will be required for the session.
Handouts - indicates all the handouts that will be required for the session. Handouts are
included at the end of each session.
Steps - provide specific instructions to the trainer about how to conduct the session. Sessions
are designed to move participants through the four components of the Experiential Learning
Model: experience, reflection, generalization, and application. The experience is an exercise
or participatory presentation in which useful information is brought forth for discussion and
learning. The reflection component helps participants ponder and analyze new information
and develop their ideas about a topic. Generalization allows participants to draw broader
conclusions and lessons about the new information, while application enables them to apply
the generalizations to a new situation, or think about how they might apply their new skills
or use their new knowledge in the future. Often, components of the cycle are repeated within
sub-topics in a session. For more information on this learning process, please refer to CEDPA’s
training manual “Training Trainers for Development.”
Tasks - describe small group activities and appear in boxes within each session. A task
provides the instructions participants need to do their group work. The trainer may copy
the tasks on a flipchart.
Trainer’s Notes - are written in italics. They may include expected or possible responses
to a question, definitions, or other key points that the trainer should try to elicit during
the session. In some cases, they refer the trainer to a handout that provides more detailed
information on a particular topic.
Special Preparation - indicates any arrangements that the trainer needs to make prior to
the session.
iv
WORKSHOP OVERVIEW: PROJECT DESIGN
Goal: By the end of the workshop, participants will be able to develop a project proposal and
apply basic skills related to effective project implementation and sustainability.
3. Developing a To enable participants to formulate a focused problem statement based on the results of a needs assessment. 3 hours
Problem
2 Statement
4. Goals and To emphasize how goals and objectives focus and guide the development of project activities and to allow 3 hours
Objectives participants to practice writing them.
5. Project Imple- To introduce an implementation plan as a tool for project development, organization, and monitoring. 3 hours
mentation Plan
3 To enable participants to determine project staffing and training needs based on project activities.
6. Job Descriptions, 3 hours
Staffing Patterns,
and Training Plan
7. Monitoring and To examine the reasons for observing and measuring progress and to provide participants with specific tools and 4 hours, 20
Evaluation strategies for doing so. minutes
4
8. Recordkeeping and To design systems for collecting the information needed to monitor project progress. 2 hours, 30
Reporting minutes
5 9. Field Visit To visit community-based projects and assess project implementation; to apply observations and lessons to 8 hours
project design process.
10. Budgeting To provide participants with practice in estimating costs, preparing a budget, and using a budget as a monitoring 3 hours
6 tool.
11. Project To explore strategies for achieving institutional, financial, and political sustainability and to assist participants in 3 hours
Sustainability developing a plan for sustainability.
v
SESSION ONE
O V E R V I E W O F T H E P R O J E C T L I F E C Y C L E
Materials Flipchart
Colored markers for flipchart
Small ball or similar object
Optional: Overhead projector, transparency of Handout 1A,
transparency pens
Step 1 Greet participants and read aloud the posted learner objectives for the
session.
Step 2 Ask the participants to stand in a circle for a game called hot potato.
The rules of the game are as follows:
TASK #1
Time: 10 minutes
Step 4 After participants have completed the task, tell them to find a few
other participants with similar drawings. Explain that each small group
will become an organization, providing a context for the project design
activities.
Step 5 Once the groups have been formed, introduce the following task:
Time: 30 minutes
Step 6 Ask each organizational group to present its vision and mission
statement, and ask the following questions:
• What did you find difficult or easy about drawing your joint
visions?
• What did you find difficult or easy about writing your mission
statement?
Step 1 Ask participants the following question: “What are the questions/issues
that your organization needs to address before implementing a
project?” Allow participants to brainstorm, recording their responses
on a flipchart. Ask probing questions until all components of the
Project Life Cycle are listed.
Step 2 Present the Project Life Cycle using an overhead projector, if available,
or draw the cycle on a flipchart. Ask questions to ensure that the
following key points are made:
TASK #3
Time: 20 minutes
Step 5 Explain that each of the components of the Project Life Cycle will
be discussed in depth over the following days and that this was an
introductory session to provide an overview of the whole project
process.
Assess
Needs
Develop a
Staffing and
Training Plan
Establish Develop
Recordkeeping Monitoring and
System Evaluation Plan
C O M M U N I T Y N E E D S A S S E S S M E N T
Materials Flipchart
Flipchart markers
Role Description Sheets
Step 1 Greet participants and read aloud the posted learner objectives for the
session.
Step 2 Ask for two volunteers to act in a role play. Brief each volunteer
separately on her or his role and give each a copy of the appropriate
role description (Handout 2A). Introduce the role play to the group
as follows:
“Two project managers, Zuzu and Lulu, are relaxing at the end of a
long, hard day. Zuzu, an agricultural project manager, is older than
Lulu and has about ten years of experience in the field. Lulu recently
completed University and is working in the area of community health.
Lulu is telling Zuzu about a nutrition project for which she has just
completed the design.”
Step 3 Have the volunteers act out their roles, while the others observe.
Step 4 When the role play is finished, thank the volunteers and ask them if
they enjoyed role playing. Ask the observers the following questions:
• What happened?
• What mistakes did Lulu make?
• What do you think will be the results of her mistakes?
• What could she have done differently?
Refer to Handout 2B, Assessing Needs, for additional key points and
concepts.
Refer to Handout 2C, Learning From, With, and About the Community,
for additional responses.
Time: 1 hour
Step 2 Ask each group to present one method only. Continue in this manner
until all the groups have presented and all the methods have been
discussed. For each method, ask the following questions:
TASK #2
Time: 1 hour
Step 2 Have each group present its plan for needs assessment. The following
questions can be used to generate discussion:
• How will you use what you learned today when you go back
to your organization?
• What technique(s) will you use in the future to increase
beneficiary participation?
Refer to Handout 2F, Collecting and Analyzing Data, for key points
and concepts.
LULU
You are a new project manager and have put the finishing touches on a nutrition project
for Kazimba District. The project includes a strong emphasis on nutrition education and
preparation of proper weaning foods, promotion of breastfeeding, and promotion of fluids
available in the home to prevent dehydration from diarrhea. You developed the project
after discussions with the health clinic staff and a review of their records, which indicate
a high prevalence of malnutrition in the community. It is now the end of the day, and you
are relaxing with your friend, Zuzu, proudly describing your new project.
ZUZU
You are an experienced agricultural project manager. Your friend Lulu is telling you about
a nutrition project she has designed for Kazimba District. You yourself were in Kazimba
District last month meeting with the village leaders. They told you about a problem they
have been having with elephants. The elephants have been passing through their fields to
get to the river. The problem has been escalating for over a year since the development
of a resort lodge displaced the elephants’ usual drinking spot. As a result, the village crops
have been destroyed, food supplies are insufficient, and children are suffering from hunger.
You are concerned that Lulu has not met with community members in the design of her
project.
ASSESSING NEEDS
Successful projects are those which have been designed on the basis of a good understanding
of the project setting. Project success is rarely the result of chance or luck—it is almost
always related to good planning.
• A family planning project attracts very few clients because women are embarrassed
to go to the clinic, which only provides family planning services. The project
developer knew that the same women had expressed interest in family planning and
that they regularly take their children to monthly clinics for weighing, immunization,
and nutrition lessons. She had assumed the women would also be willing to attend
a monthly family planning clinic.
• A project to provide child health and nutrition education classes to mothers is poorly
attended and results in minimal improvements in child health. When asked, mothers
had told the project developer that they were interested in their children’s health.
However, they had not indicated that they had little time for an activity such as a
class or that they preferred a project to provide opportunities to earn income. The
project developer had not asked specific questions to determine this need.
Each of these projects was designed by people with good intentions but limited
understanding of the project setting. They failed because they did not address local needs
in a realistic way.
Before beginning a needs assessment, it is helpful to make a list of the pieces of information
you require to understand both needs and resources, the source of each piece of information,
and the means of gathering each piece of information. Formats for lists like these are shown
on the next pages. Such lists allow you to summarize all the information you want to collect
from a particular source, making information collection more efficient. They also pinpoint
gaps in the information that you need.
If there are critical gaps in existing information, you may have to develop a questionnaire
or survey to gather specific bits of information. The development of questionnaires should
be avoided if possible because it can be a long, involved process and is very costly. However,
if a questionnaire is necessary, you may wish to refer to guides for project pre-
implementation surveys or request technical assistance from appropriate agencies.
All of the information you gather is valuable. You will use it as a basis for defining the
problem and needs to be addressed and determining the goal, objectives, and appropriate
activities for your project.
The main job of a health worker in a community-based program is not to deliver services.
And it is not simply to act as a link between the community and the outside health system.
It is to help people learn how to meet their own and each other’s health needs more
effectively.
In order to do this, the health worker needs a deep understanding of the community’s
strengths, problems, and special characteristics. Together with the people in the community,
the health worker will want to consider:
NEEDS
SOCIAL FACTORS
RESOURCES
• people with special skills: leaders, healers, story tellers, artists, craftspeople, teachers
• land, crops, food sources, fuel sources (firewood, etc.), water
• building and clothing supplies
• markets, transportation, communication, tools
This looks like a lot of information, and it is! But fortunately, a health worker who is
from the community already knows most of the important facts. She or he does not need
to run around collecting a lot of data. All she or he needs to do is sit down with a group
of community people and look carefully at what they already know.
Handout 2C-2
• How do the combined facts of our situation—needs, social factors, and resources—
affect our health and well being?
• How can we work with these facts—using some, changing or reorganizing others—
to improve our health and well being?
Handout 2D-1
1Training for Women Project Managers: A Trainers’ Manual. Module Four: Situation Analysis and Needs
Identification. FIT and ICOMP, December 1989.
1. STRUCTURED DISCUSSIONS
Beneficiaries begin with a problem and state why a solution is needed. The causes
of the problem are listed and then a solution is proposed. Possible solutions may
be discussed with the development worker, who should take into account both the
causes of the problem and the reasons why a solution is wanted. The solution is
examined to determine who will benefit, what problems will remain, and whether
new problems will be created. A decision is made as to whether the new problems
are acceptable or alternative solutions are required. The process will normally be
repeated three or four times before people feel they have fully analyzed the situation.
The depth of analysis of the problem usually increases with each cycle.
2. POPULAR THEATER
Popular theater has been used as an effective tool for non-formal education in
developing countries. It has a number of purposes:
3. QUESTIONNAIRES
• Will any of the questions be seen as threatening? Why? How are people likely
4. OBSERVATION
• What are the skills required for good observation? Are these skills readily
available? Do we have the resources to train people in observation techniques?
• Will taking notes or recording conversations offend anyone? How might they
affect the results of observation? What might be done to minimize these
effects?
• To what extent can beneficiaries carry out the observation of their own
situation? How could this affect the selection of observers?
• What are the strengths and weaknesses of observation? How can project
beneficiaries become involved in the observation process?
• What gender issues can arise in observation?
5. GAMES
Playing a board game can help beneficiaries decide how to distribute limited
resources to priority activities. It provides a non-threatening environment in which
players can express their feelings and opinions relating to issues in their own
community.
Handout 2D-3
2 Training for Women Project Managers: A Trainers’ Manual. Module Four: Situation Analysis and Needs
Identification. FIT and ICOMP, December 1989.
ASSESSING NEEDS
Session 2/Page 20
INFORMATION SOURCE OF MEANS OF GATHERING COMMENTS
REQUIRED INFORMATION INFORMATION
CEDPA/Project Design
COLLECTING AND ANALYZING DATA
Having developed an understanding of the overall needs and having selected the particular
problems your project will address, you are ready to collect more detailed information
about these problems, about the community, and about the resources available. This is
important because you need facts in order to plan further.
The information required will vary according to the particular problems you are addressing.
For example, if the decision is to undertake a family planning project, the information
needed includes the following:
• Family planning and other health services: What is available, where, at what cost?
• Family composition: What is the average number of children/ages?
• Beliefs and culture: What do people believe about family size and composition?
Are there cultural restrictions regarding the use of family planning?
• Knowledge of family planning: How much do women and men already know?
• Health status and practices: What are the major causes of infant and maternal
mortality? What are the weaning practices?
There are many sources of information that can be used when planning a project. Here
is a list of some valuable sources:
Here are some of the elements that together make up the setting of a project and that may
have an effect on project success:
If the first step in the project development process is to broadly define what kind of project
is needed and wanted in a particular village or setting, you will want to gather basic
information related to:
You will not require detailed information on every area of activity (e.g., agriculture,
education, health) or every problem or need (e.g., lack of water, child malnutrition, high
rates of maternal death in childbirth), since your project will not address all of these issues.
D E V E L O P I N G A P R O B L E M S T A T E M E N T
Time 3 hours
Materials Flipchart
Flipchart markers
Optional: Overhead projector, transparencies, and transparency pens
Step 1 Greet participants and read aloud the posted learner objectives for the
session.
Step 2 Begin a general discussion around the word “problem” by asking the
following questions:
Ask the participants to pretend that they are donors who receive this
problem statement. What more do they need to know about the
situation? Record all the responses on a flipchart.
Refer to the list developed in Step 3 above. What are the elements
or characteristics of a good problem statement?
Step 1 Distribute Handout 3C, Stoneland Case Study. Introduce the following task,
to be carried out in the organizational groups formed in Session 2:
TASK #1
Time: 1 hour
TASK #2
Time: 40 minutes
Step 3 Ask each organization to present its problem statement to the larger
group. Ask other participants for comments and suggestions.
The Statement
Causes
Consequences
The overview you get from your basic needs assessment will help you to determine major
needs and problems. You can then select the problem or problems your organization has
the skills to address. This is important because a project will be most successful if it is
concerned with a small number of specific problems. Everything cannot be done at once,
and a project should be limited to something that can be done in a relatively short time
by your organization.
Once the problems to be addressed by the project have been identified and selected, more
detailed information is gathered on the local circumstances surrounding the particular
problems.
For example, your organization has decided to undertake a project in one town. Your
organization works mainly in the areas of health, nutrition, and family planning and has
a staff of nurses, midwives, and family planning educators. Thus, you already know that
you are not qualified to do an irrigation project, an agriculture extension project or a project
to teach women handicraft production.
Interviews with the town residents reveal that there are many maternal deaths in childbirth
and that this concerns the community as a whole. By direct observation, you see many
malnourished children under the age of five, whose mothers are either pregnant or have
new babies. You learn that another voluntary agency has just begun a project to educate
mothers about child nutrition, to initiate regular weighing of children, and to provide high
protein foods to the most severely malnourished.
All of the basic information leads your group to support a project that addresses problems
of maternal/child health in a village through family planning education and service delivery.
A spot check of village leaders and residents confirms that there is an interest in this.
One primary health care center serves the entire population. This center has a doctor who
comes in two times a week, and health workers who come in everyday but do not go out
into the villages. Negligible health services and weak health and family planning education
programs have resulted in high child mortality and morbidity rates.
Stoneland has co-educational primary schools, but the students must leave Stoneland to
attend middle and high schools. Parents willingly send their boys to these schools. However,
most parents are reluctant to send their daughters, believing that they should not be exposed
to the outside world. Some girls do leave for higher schooling but they often have to drop
out because they get no support from their parents (who are not educated themselves).
Girls are married at an early age of 14-16 years without any preparation for adult life.
The elders of the community believe that women are not capable of accomplishing anything
beyond marriage.
Most of the people are impoverished. Most men and women work in the quarries that are
located in the villages. The men earn less than the minimum wage and the women fare
even worse, receiving a pittance for the same work. There are serious environmental and
health hazards in this work, but the workers have no knowledge of their legal rights and
the stone crushing contractors do not provide safeguards such as masks. As a result,
pulmonary problems such as tuberculosis and silicosis are rampant.
Housing facilities are sub-standard, with many families sharing one small room; as a result,
people often just sleep outside their homes. The houses do not have any toilets or baths,
and so the people use the fields. There is an acute shortage of safe drinking water and
women must walk 3-4 kilometers and wait in long lines to fetch a pail of water. Many
children die from diarrhea.
Your organization, which is located in the center of the universe, has heard about the
situation in Stoneland and wishes to design development programs for the area.
AIDS in Ghana
The rapid spread of HIV/AIDS in Ghana is a major national concern. Between 1986, when
the first AIDS case was reported, and 1990, the number of cases reported annually increased
from 26 to 1,011.1 Eighty-five percent of the 2,237 cases reported during this four-year
period occurred in 1989 and 1990. 2 HIV/AIDS transmission in Ghana occurs primarily
through heterosexual sex and contaminated blood supplies, as it does in much of sub-
Saharan Africa. As in the rest of the world, HIV/AIDS predominantly affects young adults
ages 20-49, the most vital segment of the population in terms of economic and social
development. Men and women ages 20-39 account for 74% of all AIDS cases in Ghana.
The epidemic thus has the potential to “create massive economic problems stemming from
losses of productivity, training, and diversion of funds from development to crisis health
care,”3 in addition to the human costs in pain and suffering.
HIV seroprevalence is high among groups involved in high-risk behaviors, such as long-
distance truck drivers and prostitutes. Among urban high-risk groups, the seroprevalence
rate is 25.2%, while in urban low-risk groups the rate is 2.2%. 4 Although 78% of all cases
are found in three regions of the country containing only 42.5% of the population, AIDS
cases have been reported in all ten regions. The number of AIDS patients continues to
increase all over the country. Moreover, WHO/GPA estimates that for every reported AIDS
case, there are 50 unreported cases. The incidence of HIV, therefore, is probably even
higher than the death and seroprevalence rates indicate. (See Appendix 1 for further statistics
on AIDS in Ghana.)
Between 1986 and 1990, there has been a four-fold increase in the number of AIDS cases
in individuals without a history of travel outside the country. Frequent travel between cities
and rural areas will probably result in an increase in rural prevalence.
Government Response
In response to the threat of a national HIV/AIDS epidemic, the Government of Ghana
adopted its Medium Term Plan (MTP) for the Prevention and Control of AIDS in 1989.
The goals of the MTP are “to prevent further transmission and spread of HIV and to
decrease the impact of AIDS on the affected individuals, family groups, and communities
at large.” In the absence of a vaccine or cure, the plan emphasizes prevention of sexual
transmission of HIV by discouraging casual sexual relationships, multiple sexual partners,
and “prostitution-like” activities. Strategies focus on intense public information and
education programs and counseling of high-risk groups and HIV positive individuals,
utilizing a multi-faceted approach designed to ensure maximum coverage of the population.
The plan emphasizes implementation of project activities at community and district levels.
The National AIDS Control Programme (NACP) of the Ministry of Health (MOH) has
collaborated with NGOs to provide education to specific target groups and the public in
general. For example, the MOH has conducted workshops in the provision of psychosocial
support for people with AIDS for both MOH staff and some nongovernmental organizations
(NGOs). The YWCA participated in these workshops.
G O A L S A N D O B J E C T I V E S
Time 3 hours
Materials Flipchart
Markers
Step 1 Greet participants and read aloud the posted learner objectives for the
session.
Step 2 Pass out Handout 4A, Case Study: Nita’s Dream, and read it aloud.
Initiate a brief discussion using the following questions:
Possible response: “To attend university in the capital city and study
business.”
Step 4 Divide the participants into their organizational groups and introduce
the following task:
Time: 20 minutes
Step 5 As each group presents its goal, ask other participants to assess
whether or not the goal meets the two criteria mentioned above. Help
each group to refine their goal statements as necessary.
Develop a list of tips for writing a goal statement. The tips can be
listed on a flipchart and hung on the wall for reference.
Step 1 Refer back to the Case Study: Nita’s Dream. Remind participants of
Nita’s goal. Ask participants how they would describe the list Nita
developed.
TASK #2
Time: 45 minutes
Step 5 As each group presents its objectives, ask other participants to review
the objectives to ensure that they meet the SMART criteria. Objectives
should be revised as necessary.
Step 6 To wrap up, discuss the difference between goals and objectives and
list the differences on a flipchart for reference.
Nita is a 16-year-old girl who lives in a small village. She has grown up in this village
with her brothers and sisters, cousins, aunts, and uncles. She goes to school fairly regularly,
and helps her mother in the house and the garden. Although Nita has never left her village,
she dreams of attending the university in the capital city where she can study business
and have a career, like her cousin Nafta. Nafta visits a few times a year with stories of
city life. This dream of going to the university has been with Nita for many years, but
lately it is all she can think about, especially as her family begins to talk about marriage
for her.
One hot and quiet evening, Nita is lying restlessly in her bed, tossing and turning and
trying to sleep. Her mind is whirling with images of the city and school and life outside
her village. She abruptly gets up and quietly finds a candle. She tears a sheet of paper
from her school notebook. At the top she writes, “University.” Then she begins to make
a list:
3. Study mathematics at least one hour per day for the next term.
She rereads what she has written and, satisfied with her plan, crawls into bed to sleep.
GOALS
A project goal briefly describes what you expect the project setting to be like after your
project has completed its intervention.
• A goal is the solution to the problems you described earlier. Your problem statement
was limited to those specific problems that could be solved by the project. Your
goal statement represents the solution.
• A goal is realistic. Do not state that your project will accomplish more than it
possibly can.
It is important to develop a goal statement in order to define the scope of the project activity.
Handout 4C
P R O J E C T I M P L E M E N T A T I O N P L A N
Time 3 hours
Materials Flipcharts
Flipchart markers
Step 1 Greet participants and read aloud the posted learner objectives for the
session.
Step 4 Refer to the flipchart with the objectives for Nita’s dream from the
previous session and select one objective. Ask participants to list the
tasks that need to be carried out in order to accomplish that objective.
List all responses on a flipchart. This can be repeated for another
objective.
Step 6 Divide participants into their organizational groups to carry out the
following task:
TASK #1
Time: 30 minutes
Step 7 Ask each group to select one objective and present the list of activities
it has developed for that objective. Ask other participants if they can
think of any other activities that could be listed under the objective.
Time: 1 hour
Step 4 Ask each group to present a section of its plan. For each group, discuss
whether:
Activities to Be Done
Session 5/Page 46
OBJECTIVE: __________________________________________________________________________________
CEDPA/Project Design
SESSION SIX
J O B D E S C R I P T I O N S , S T A F F I N G P A T T E R N S ,
A N D T R A I N I N G P L A N
Time 3 hours
Materials Flipchart
Flipchart markers
Step 1 Greet participants and read aloud the posted learner objectives for the
session.
TASK #1
Time: 1 hour
Step 4 Ask each group to present its staffing plan (number and kind of project
staff). Discuss any difficulties participants may have had with the task.
Time: 1 hour
Step 2 Have each group present its training plan to the rest of the participants
(5 minutes per group). Solicit further recommendations or
clarifications from the group.
M O N I T O R I N G A N D E V A L U A T I O N
Materials Flipchart
Markers
Optional: Overhead projector, transparencies
Handouts 7A Monitoring
7B Information for Monitoring Program Operations
7C Information for Monitoring Program Operations (example) and
Performance Information That Can Be Used to Measure Family
Planning Program Results and Impact
7D Evaluation
7E Indicators
7F Sample Indicators for Objectives
7G Developing a Monitoring and Evaluation Plan
Step 1 Greet participants and read aloud the posted learner objectives for the
session.
Monitoring
• What is monitoring?
• When do we monitor?
• Who monitors?
• How do we monitor?
Step 4 Explain that in order to ensure access to complete, timely, and accurate
information for monitoring a project, a management information
system (MIS) should be established. Ask participants to define MIS.
TASK #1
Time: 30 minutes
Step 8 Have each group present its monitoring plan. Distribute Handout 7C,
Information for Monitoring Program Operations (example), for
participants to compare with their answers.
• What is evaluation?
• How does evaluation differ from monitoring?
• What is the purpose of evaluation?
• When do we evaluate?
• Who evaluates?
• What should we evaluate?
“To train 300 mothers in the correct preparation and use of Sugar-
Salt Solution (SSS) to prevent dehydration in children under five by
the end of the year.”
Expected responses:
Step 4 Help participants to define each of the three types of indicators. What
are the advantages and disadvantages of each type?
Step 5 Distribute Handouts 7E, Indicators, and 7F, Sample Indicators for
Objectives, for reference.
TASK #2
Time: 90 minutes
Step 7 Have each group present their indicators and monitoring and evaluation
plan. Discuss each presentation.
Summarize by asking what each group found difficult about the task
and discussing.
MONITORING
Monitoring is the process of routinely gathering information on all aspects of the project.
Monitoring provides managers with information needed to:
The first level of monitoring is done by project staff. Supervisors are responsible for
monitoring the staff and tasks under them, and the project manager is responsible for
monitoring all aspects of the project.
The second level of monitoring is done by the donor(s). Through field visits and routine
reports from the project manager, the donor monitors progress and measures performance.
Monitoring can be carried out through field visits, review of service delivery and
commodities records, and management information systems (MIS).
Session 7/Page 58
CATEGORIES OF WHAT TO WHAT RECORDS WHO COLLECTS WHO USES HOW TO USE WHAT DECISIONS
INFORMATION MONITOR TO KEEP DATA DATA INFORMATION CAN BE MADE
1 . Workplan
Activities
2 . Costs and
Expenditures
3 . Staff and
Supervision
4 . Commodities
5 . Results
CEDPA/Project Design
Source: The Family Planning Manager’s Handbook. Editors: James A. Wolff, Linda J. Suttenfield, Susanna C. Binzen. Management Sciences
for Health, Boston.
Handout 7C-1
CATEGORIES OF WHAT TO WHAT RECORDS WHO COLLECTS WHO USES HOW TO USE WHAT DECISIONS
CEDPA/Project Design
INFORMATION MONITOR TO KEEP DATA DATA INFORMATION CAN BE MADE
• Timing of activities • Monthly/quarterly • Project Manager • Project • Ensure staff and • Reschedule
1 . Workplan • Availability of workplans • Supervisors Manager other resources are activities and
Activities personnel, resources • Work schedules • Donor available deployment of
agency resources as needed
• Budgeted amounts, • Ledger of • Financial officer/ • Project • Ensure funds are • Authorize
2 . Costs and
funds on hand and expenditures by accountant Manager available to execute expenditures
Expenditures budget category
expenditures • Auditor activities • Make budget and
• Balance in budget • Receipts • Donor • Ensure compliance project revisions
by approved cost • Bank transactions agency w/funding regulations • Determine need for
categories • Reports to donor • If fee for service, other funding
determine fee sources
structure
3 . Staff and • Knowledge, attitudes • Performance • Supervisors • Supervisors • Motivate staff and • Placement
Supervision and skills of staff reviews • Personnel director • Project resolve employment • Training needs
• Educational level of • Job descriptions • Trainers Manager problems • Promotions
staff • Resumes of staff • Personnel • Advise staff on • Disciplinary action
• Salaries and benefits • Feedback from Director career
• Job performance training attended
Session 7/Page 59
educated agency • Assess approach
appropriateness of
Susanna C. Binzen. Management Sciences
Source: The Family Planning Manager’s Handbook. Editors: James A. Wolff, Linda J. Suttenfield, services
for Health, Boston.
Handout 7C-2
Session 7/Page 60
Information categories Data to gather Using the information Making decisions
Socio-economic · Income levels. · Managers can determine · Allocation of effort and
characteristics of target · Rural-urban breakdown. what influences acceptance resources to maximize
groups · Educational levels of family planning and demand for and utilization of
utilization of services. family planning services.
CEDPA/Project Design
family planning program.
Source: The Family Planning Manager’s Handbook . Editors: James A. Wolff, Linda J. Suttenfield, Susanna C. Binzen. Management Sciences
for Health, Boston.
Handout 7D
EVALUATION
What is evaluation?
Evaluation is the process of gathering and analyzing information to determine 1)
whether the project is carrying out its planned activities and 2) the extent to which
the project is achieving its stated objectives through these activities.
How does evaluation differ from monitoring?
• Timing
• Focus
• Level of detail
What is the purpose of evaluation?
• To find out how effective the project is
• To see whether objectives have been achieved
• To learn how well things are being done
• To learn from experience so future activities can be improved
When do we evaluate?
• Periodically
• Mid-term
• At the end of the project (final evaluation)
Who evaluates?
• Internal evaluation can be carried out by the project manager and/or project
staff
• External evaluations are carried out by donor(s) or by consultants
What should we evaluate?
• Progress in workplan
• Establishment of systems
• Implementation of planned activities
• Achievement of objectives
• Effectiveness of project
• Impact of project
• Efficiency/cost-effectiveness of project
INDICATORS
Indicators are quantitative or qualitative criteria for success that enable one to measure
or assess the achievement of project objectives. There are three types of indicators:
• input indicators - describe what goes into the project, such as the number
of hours of training, the amount of money spent, the number of contraceptives
distributed;
Input and output indicators are easier to measure than impact indicators, but they provide
only an indirect measure of the success of the project. They assume that the achievement
of certain activities will result in change, but they don’t prove it.
Checklist
• explicit
• pertinent
• objectively verifiable
Objectives Indicators
Session 7/Page 64
A monitoring and evaluation plan should be included in each project document and
monitoring activities should be scheduled on the annual implementation/workplan.
I. OBJECTIVES II. ACTIVITIES III. INDICATORS IV. DATA V. METHODS/TOOLS VI. PERSON [Link]
SOURCE RESPONSIBLE FRAME
CEDPA/Project Design
SESSION EIGHT
R E C O R D K E E P I N G A N D R E P O R T I N G
Materials Flipchart
Markers
Step 1 Greet participants and read aloud the posted learner objectives for the
session.
Time: 1 hour
Step 4 Ask each group to report to the larger group on the types of records
its project will maintain.
At the end of each presentation, check with the other groups for clarity
and further suggestions and recommendations.
While the groups are presenting, record on a flipchart all the types
of records mentioned by participants so that one comprehensive list
is developed.
Step 1 Remind the group that even though most donors provide their own
formats for reporting, there are some general guidelines that managers
can keep in mind when preparing reports. Initiate a brainstorming
Step 2 Wrap up the session by asking the participants the following questions:
As you develop your project’s recordkeeping system, consider the following suggestions:
• Be complete. Examine your indicators of change. Make a list of all the specific
bits of information/data you need to collect before, during, and at the end of your
project to confirm that objectives have been met. Be sure your system ensures that
you collect all the necessary data. For example, consider the third objective of the
Tokara Women’s Association project, “to refer all cases requiring special
gynecological treatment to the Dando City Municipal Hospital.” You may keep a
list of all women who have been told they require special treatment. But, unless
your recordkeeping system also keeps track of whether these women actually go
to the Dando City Municipal Hospital and receive treatment, you will not know if
this objective is being met.
• Remember data are interrelated. The recordkeeping and data collection for one
indicator of change may involve several interrelated parts or forms. Be sure the
data being collected fit together and are comparable. Consider the example of
referrals to the Dando City Municipal Hospital. The recordkeeping and data
collection system might include these three interrelated parts:
• Test forms before making many copies. After you are satisfied with the system
you have developed, use forms with real people. See if they are understandable.
Use them to gather information. Examine the resulting data to see if it is complete,
meaningful, and comparable.
• Assign responsibility for recordkeeping . Determine who are the logical people to
maintain the various forms and registers you have developed. Be sure these people
understand their responsibilities. Clearly define how often, when, and how the forms
are to be used.
• Practice using the forms. Provide training to those who will be responsible for
keeping the forms and registers. Let them practice completing them in a workshop
or classroom setting. Bring them together to compare results and problems after
they have used them for a short time within the project. Visit them at work to observe
the use of forms and registers and to provide any needed assistance.
• Begin gathering data as soon as possible and keep records up-to-date. Remember,
you are measuring progress over time. You need to be able to clearly state what
the situation is like at the beginning of a project, as well as during project
implementation. Gather important data that documents the situation that existed
before you started activities, then gather comparable data along the way. Keep
records current, because it is extremely difficult to reconstruct data at a later point.
For example, what would happen if a referral to the Dando City Municipal Hospital
is not recorded in the register maintained by the Tokara Women’s Association? It
is likely that no one will later remember that it occurred. Or, the hospital records
will be different from the register maintained at the health post, and you will not
know if the hospital treatment was a direct result of a referral made by the project.
Handout 8B-1
The donor who funds your project will normally require you to submit reports on your
progress at various points during project implementation. Reports every four to six months
are common. Generally, your grant agreement will outline reporting requirements and
provide guidelines related to content and format.
An extremely important point to keep in mind as you report on project progress is that
actual work and achievements must be compared to the planned work and objectives
that were stated in your grant agreement . In this way you will see which activities are
progressing on schedule, which are ahead of schedule, and which are behind schedule.
This comparison helps you to focus attention both on achievements and on the areas where
there are problems to be addressed.
SMART objectives, well planned and scheduled project activities, well chosen indicators
of change, and effective, accurate recordkeeping and data collection are key to assuring
you will have complete information for reporting on your project’s progress.
Although content of a progress report may vary somewhat from one project to another or
from one donor to another, your report should be as detailed and specific as possible. In
general, the following questions should be answered:
• What were planned targets (objectives) and activities for this period? Your time/
task chart will be a valuable reference for answering this question.
• What were the actual achievements and activities for this period and what indicators
of change have you used to determine these? Here you will discuss numbers of
people involved, what they did or learned, and results.
• What resources were used? Were they adequate? Financial reports should be
submitted to account for expenditures made during the same period covered by the
progress report. However, don’t forget to discuss other resources that have been
used, including community participation and any in-kind contributions.
Handout 8B-2
• What lessons have you learned during this period of project activity and how will
this learning be applied to continued project work? Any changes you have made
• What problems did you encounter during this period? How did you or will you solve
these problems?
• What are your plans for the next period of project activity? Do these plans involve
any changes in the project’s objectives, schedule of activities or necessary resources?
Again, the time/task chart will be helpful here.
The following steps will guide you in writing your progress reports:
5. Draft your report and ask another knowledgeable person to review it for
completeness.
F I E L D V I S I T
Time 8 hours
Materials Flipchart
Flipchart markers
If the project director cannot address the group the day before the
visit, the overview can be given on the day of the visit at the project
site. In this case, the trainer should gather enough information to give
a brief overview of the project to participants prior to the visit.
CEDPA/Project Design Session 9/Page 73
A. Preparing for the Visit (2 hours)
Step 1 Greet participants and read aloud the posted learner objectives for the
session.
Step 2 Introduce the project director to provide a brief overview of the project
to participants. (If project director is unavailable, present some basic
information about the project to participants).
Step 3 Ask participants to brainstorm about the types of things they want to
observe during the field visit, based on their experience in project
implementation and what they have learned during the previous few
days about project design.
• Community participation
• Staffing, training, and supervision
• Accountability: financial, programmatic, and logistical
• Technical content
Step 4 Divide participants into four groups (these should be different from
the project design groups in which participants have worked all week).
Assign each of the four components listed above to one group. This
can be done randomly or through negotiation with the groups. If several
different project sites are being visited, ensure that all components
will be covered at each project site. Introduce the following task:
TASK #1
Time: 1 hour
The field visit should last approximately one-half day (four hours).
TASK #2
Time: 1 hour
Step 2 Have each group make its presentation. Ask the other groups if they
have any questions or comments.
Step 3 Facilitate a discussion drawing on lessons learned during the field visit
compared to lessons learned during the rest of the workshop by asking
the following questions:
Community Participation
Accountability
Financial
Programmatic
Logistical
Technical Issues
(Further questions should be developed according to the type of projects being visited.)
B U D G E T I N G
Time 3 hours
Step 1 Greet participants and read aloud the posted learner objectives for the
session.
Step 1 Ask participants to refer back to their project activities and staff
requirements and list budget categories for the resources they will
need. Record responses on a flipchart.
Step 1 Explain that estimating costs can be one of the most difficult parts
of budgeting. Ask participants to list some rules for costing.
TASK #1
Time: 1 hour
Step 3 Reassemble the group and ask, “What did you find easy about
preparing budgets? What did you find difficult?”
Definition
A budget is a financial plan providing donors, project implementors, and managers with
financial information on how much it will cost to carry out a particular project.
Purpose
• To ensure that resources are available to carry out objectives as stipulated in project
proposal
• To determine how much it will cost to implement your project
• To ensure that available and possibly limited resources are used in the most effective
and efficient way possible
• To provide a monitoring tool that compares actual costs and budgeted costs
1. Planning Tool
• Compare estimates with actual figures over time to determine whether the
project is achieving program/institutional objectives
7. Develop simple comprehensive budget format with line items, unit costs, and totals.
BUDGET CATEGORIES
I. PERSONNEL
Training Coordinator $1,000.00 1 $1,000.00
Administrative Assistant 500.00 1 500.00
CEDPA/Project Design
SUBTOTAL 1,500.00 1 1,500.00
II. FRINGE BENEFIT 1,500.00 15% 225.00
III. CONSULTANTS
Management Specialist 100.00 14 1,400.00
SUBTOTAL 100.00 14 1,400.00
IV. TRAVEL & PER DIEM
International Airfare 1,500.00 1 1,500.00
In-Country Air 200.00 4 800.00
Ground Travel 75.00 6 450.00
Misc. Transportation 10.00 11 110.00
Per Diem 60.00 11 660.00
Hotel 80.00 880.00
SUBTOTAL $ 1,925.00 $ 4,400.00
V. OTHER DIRECT COSTS
Office Rent 1,000.00 0.5 500.00
Office Supplies 70.00 1 (700.00)
Paper 2.00 12 24.00
Binders 1.50 12 18.00
Cassettes 1.00 4 4.00
Pens 0.50 20 10.00
Markers 0.75 5 3.75
Easel Pads 3.00 3 9.00
Telephone/Faxes/Telegraph 250.00 0.5 125.00
Printing/Reproduction 100.00 0.5 50.00
Postage/Shipping 75.00 0.5 37.50
Utilities 30.00 0.5 15.00
Outside Services 25.00 12.50
SUBTOTAL 1,558.75 108.75
VI. TRAINING
Tuition 1,000.00 10 10,000.00
Session 10/Page 85
TOTAL BUDGET $ 7,583.75 $17,633.75
Handout 10E-1
COSTING EXERCISE
I. PERSONNEL
SALARIES AND WAGES
Trainer
Administrative Assistant
SUBTOTAL
III. CONSULTANTS
Consultant A
Consultant B
SUBTOTAL
Outside Services
SUBTOTAL
VI. EQUIPMENT
Vehicle
Computer
Fax Machine
Photocopier
SUBTOTAL
VII. SUBCONTRACTS/SUBAGREEMENTS
VIII. TRAINING
Tuition
SUBTOTAL
X. FIXED FEES
TOTAL COSTS
FINANCIAL MONITORING
• Your approved budget becomes the basis for spending. Tracking expenditures against
the approved budget monitors progress in relation to cost. Monitoring is an ongoing
process.
• Individuals designing a project should be part of the budgetary process. They know
the program needs better than finance personnel do. Finance needs to work closely
with managers.
P R O J E C T S U S T A I N A B I L I T Y
Time 3 hours
Materials Flipcharts
Flipchart markers
Possible responses:
• Programmatic/institutional sustainability
• Financial sustainability
• Political sustainability
Step 4 Divide the participants into three groups and introduce the following
task:
Time: 30 minutes
Step 5 Allow each group to report. After the presentation, distribute Handout
11A, Strategies for Sustainability, and discuss some of the points that
may not have been mentioned.
TASK #2
Time: 45 minutes
Step 2 Ask each group to present its sustainability plans. Try to elicit further
ideas on sustainability strategies that can be incorporated into each
group’s plans.
Step 3 Ask the whole group the following questions to wrap up the session:
FINANCIAL SUSTAINABILITY
INSTITUTIONAL/PROGRAMMATIC SUSTAINABILITY
POLITICAL SUSTAINABILITY
3. What will the in-country support be: Salaries of government officials participating
in the project? Commodities? Office space? Furniture? Volunteers from the project
site for outreach? Other volunteers? IEC materials? Community raised funds?
Income-generation projects? Fee-for-services?
5. How does the organizational plan to get political support for the project? Government
support? Does the program complement government policies? What about other
organizations? Is there a consortium working for the same goal?
6. Describe plans for continued financial support. Will the organization be contacting
other donors or the local government for further support? What other donors? How
solicited?