Understanding Advertising Strategies
Understanding Advertising Strategies
1. Introduction
1.1. Advertisements you have seen this week (p11)
1.2. Arguments (p11-12)
2. Definition of an advertisement
-for communication intended to inform and/or persuade one or
Advertising has long been viewed as a method of mass promotion in that a single
message can reach many people: mass media such as newspapers, magazines,
television or radio commercials, outdoor advertising or direct mail; or new digital
media such as blogs or websites and social media sites. But, this mass promotion
approach presents problems since many people exposed to an advertising message
1
L. Copetti Audrey Vlieghe
2020 2021
2
L. Copetti Audrey Vlieghe
2020 2021
Objectives should identify where you currently are (A) and tell you where you want to get
to (B)
3
L. Copetti Audrey Vlieghe
2020 2021
If you look at any ad from the 19th there has been a shift in focus from
ads focusing on facts, on the product itself and how it functioned to ads concentrating on
end-benefits Today product ingredients and formulations will only be mentioned to back
up and justify the end-benefit the product provides
The benefits that consumers want from products are X only factual and functional
Consumers want and accept psychological and emotional + functional end benefits from
the goods they buy
They also want their purchases to make them feel good, in any number of ways
They want to brand image to be right for them
Brand image = The halo of feelings and emotions that brands inspire
needs
Emotional advertisements are, on average, more effective than unembellished factual
advertisements
Should we focus entirely on the emotional value and disregard the product itself?
No! -
versa)
No matter how clever an advertising campaign is, advertising cannot make consumer
think a weak bear is strong for example
Clever (but foolish) advertising may persuade consumers to buy the product once, but
they will quickly discover they have been cheated
The functional and the image benefits that a brand offers must interlock as tightly as
pieces in a wooden jigsaw, ff the pieces do not fit together perfectly consumers will find
the brand confusing, therefore unacceptable
4
L. Copetti Audrey Vlieghe
2020 2021
Maya Angelou, the great American poet and writer once said
forget what you said, people will forget what you did, but people will never forget how you
with EE (p.22-23°)
5
L. Copetti Audrey Vlieghe
2020 2021
Idea: Controlling everyone Turning the whole society into the perfect system
Perfect system = A society based on a dyad, a pair
4.1.1. 3 examples:
Economics: Markets are based on informed consumers making rational choices
With a system like that ads would be informative
Advertising: The point is to create uninformed consumers who will make
irrational choices
Elections: Creating an uninformed electorate making irrational choices
advertising it. If you tell lies, you do your client a disservice, you increase your load of
guilt, and you fan the flames of public resentment against the whole business of
6
L. Copetti Audrey Vlieghe
2020 2021
The Price
A product is only worth what an end- customer is prepared to pay for it
Needs to be competitive, but not necessarily the cheapest
Must also provide a profit
How to think about Price?
- Is the price of a product being set against its competitors? For example,
-label products compete with brands often by charging less for
similar products
- What is the relationship between price and sales?
- Could the price be adjusted based on market demand or the profile of the buyer?
- Will a change in price adversely affect the desire consumers have for a product?
+ People
Making sure you have the right people to do the job. They must be appropriately trained,
well-motivated and have the right attitude
7
L. Copetti Audrey Vlieghe
2020 2021
+ Process
How the product or service will reach the end-customer
The
encouraged to dialogue with the company
+ Physical evidence
Various, diverse signals that the brand gives off to reinforce its credentials
Ex: Physical premises, website design, consumer reviews, etc.
Businesses can control their packaging, have some limited control over the retail
environment in which they are sold, and no control over people reviewing their products
online. All of these areas should be considered as part of a marketing strategy
For many advertisers, advertising will be their main means of marketing communication, on
which they spend considerable sums of money If your target markets are large, you will
use mass media to reach them and advertising in mass media is expensive
But for other advertisers, advertising will be a far smaller component in their marketing
communications mix
Addressing relatively small, tightly defined target markets
Will include: Business selling to other business rather than to the public (B2B vs. B2C), or
selling to hobbyists who read specialist hobby magazines, or selling to people from a narrow
demographic sector
These companies might prefer to devote less money to advertising and more to another
aspect of their marketing mix
8
L. Copetti Audrey Vlieghe
2020 2021
Within most media, there is a rigorous separation between the advertising and the
editorial operations, and this is the way the editorial people prefer it
6.2. Steps to develop a persona : Draw a large cross on an A2 piece of paper that
(each will contain
different information)
9
L. Copetti Audrey Vlieghe
2020 2021
10
L. Copetti Audrey Vlieghe
2020 2021
7. Research
The Golden Key = Rules, which, like scientific laws, will guarantee results in advertising
D What does exist in advertising is research, namely, how to gather as much
scientific evidence (in terms of psychology e.g.) as to claim to have understood the prospects
Walter Dill, The Psychology of Advertising The first of countless studies that have aimed
to show, in psychological terms, how advertising works
Claude Hopkins, Scientific Advertising Specialized in direct response, coupon
advertising, where the results of advertisements can be exactly measured by counting the
coupons sent in
First attempt at turning advertising into science
This trend was interrupted during the 1930s because of the Great Depression that
led to a fall in worldwide advertising expenditures
Early 1950s Advertising started to boom again
USA: Movement that believed it had found the Golden Key emerged in New York and
Chicago Was called motivation research (or depth research)
Was loosely based on Freudian psychoanalytic theory: C
was more often emotional than rational, and was influenced indeed controlled by
at all
But Vicary had never persuaded anyone, subliminally He admitted the whole
thing had been a hoax
Subliminal advertising has never existed!
11
L. Copetti Audrey Vlieghe
2020 2021
Wilson Bryan Key, 70s Gave subliminal advertising a new twist His thesis was that
obscene words and images are secretly "embedded" in ads to make people buy things they
do not want or need
The belief that all advertising works by promising sexual success has stuck.
Countless media articles and debates are built on the belief that sex constantly perks
up advertising, and that sex will sell anything: sex is the long-searched-for Golden Key
This is also completely false
The USP = Starts out by stating that all advertising campaigns should search for the single
fact about a brand which differentiates it from its competitors and will make people buy: the
USP. But once this USP has been identified, incorporated into a campaign, the research
aspects of the system kicks it (Mais une fois que cet USP a été identifié, incorporé dans une
campagne, les aspects de recherche du système le déclenchent).
When
two figures are calculated:
1. The percentage of the public who buy the brand and who know the advertising USP
2. The percentage of the public who buy the brand but do not know the advertising USP
T usage pull
As long as 1 is larger than 2 the extent by which it was larger represented the additional
percentage of the population the USP had persuaded to buy the brand. This sounds logical: if
more people who know the USP buy the brand, presumably it is the USP that has persuaded
them to buy. And the greater the difference between 1 and 2, the greater the power of USP.
If 2 was more or less the same as 1, then the USP was not persuading anybody extra to
buy the brand: the USP was unpersuasive.
And in those unusual cases where 2 was larger than 1, the USP was actually putting
people off, the usage pull was negative. A campaign that did not demonstrate sufficiently
positive usage pull would itself be pulled off air.
Ross Reeves claimed that by accurately identifying USPs, and then measuring their usage
pull, they could significantly increase advertising effectiveness
HOWEVER, over the decades, three changes occurred that seriously undermines the USP
system:
Research shows that people who regularly use a brand - any brand- are far more likely to
.
the advertising that persuades you to use a brand: if you use a brand, you tend to know its
12
L. Copetti Audrey Vlieghe
2020 2021
advertising. All to be still more exact, both things happen at once and causation either way is
impossible to prove
As economies grew more affluent, and more and more products came onto the market,
the functional differences between brands often became imperceptible. The main
differences were brand image differences - the public perceived the brand differently,
sometimes knowing full well they had all but indistinguishable product specifications. So,
brand image advertising grew in importance, and importance of traditional USP advertising
dwindled
The USP system was highly verbal. A USP must be a fact expressed in words, so the
images may be more visual than
verbal, and many commercials may also employ powerful wordless music. We know that
consumers often buy products for emotional rather than rational reasons- reasons they
themselves may not be able to identify, let alone put into words.
The USP system went out of fashion. However, the basic principle of identifying a single
fact which differentiates a brand from its competitors, where one such fact can be identified,
remains a key factor in most advertising strategies
7. 2. Research Today
Advertising research today has naturally absorbed much of this historic learning and has long
ago stopped searching for an over-arching golden key. Research today deals with the
separate parts of the advertising process bit by bit, seeking to improve potency and
effectiveness incrementally as the campaign develops. Everyone recognizes that advertising
is far too complex, and too heterogeneous, for this to be possible.
The principal division in campaign research today is between pre-testing (carried out by the
creative agencies) and post-launch tracking (carried out by the advertisers, employing their
own chosen research companies).
7.3. Pre-testing
The campaign starts to take shape when agency account planners have drawn up an
advertising strategy, and this has been agreed by their colleagues and by their client. The
strategy will include what the advertising campaign must communicate, and to which target
market. Once the creative team has come up with its initial ideas and concepts, the account
planners return to the campaign development process. At this stage, they test out the
concepts on a sample of the target market.
This testing is almost always carried out in focus groups of 8 to 10 people (one to one
interviews may also occasionally be used). It is vitally important for the interviewees -
whether in groups or individually - to be drawn from members of the target market (ex: with
the sports car)
13
L. Copetti Audrey Vlieghe
2020 2021
They discuss the creative concepts shown to, under the guidance of a skilled group
leader - usually an experienced market researcher or account planner
ADVANTAGES DISADVANTAGES
Far less expensive The individuals will not have much time to
express their personal views; consequently,
it is almost impossible to probe deeply into
individual responses; and shy individuals
may get trampled upon by others
Faster: interviewing 8 to 10 people at once Even experienced group leaders tend to
is inevitably quicker to accomplish than influence what the respondents say, try as
interviewing them individually they may to avoid doing so
The group members provoke reactions from
each other interactively, which the group
leader will be able to encourage them to
explore together
Several focus groups will be carried out - relying on a single group is far too chancy - and
the person who has handled them will consolidate the findings, listening again and again to
tape recordings of the discussion, and studying the responses carefully
He or she will then meet the creative team, together with the account executive, and go
through the findings. If certain of the findings are negative, the creative team will usually be
able to amend the advertisement concepts so that it overcomes the target markets
concerns. But sometimes this is not possible, and the idea or ideas have to be totally
abandoned. Then it is back to the drawing board!
Only when an advertisement concepts has come through this process will it be presented,
together with the findings of the research, to the client
14
L. Copetti Audrey Vlieghe
2020 2021
of respondents Even the tiniest changes in question wording or in simple structure can
produce wild and seemingly inexplicable fluctuations in response levels
When Gone with the wind was a runaway bestseller, we asked a cross-section of the adult
population whether they had read it. The number of yes replies was obviously inflated;
Waiting for a train in Pennsylvania station one evening, I was accosted by an interviewer and
asked questions which I had written two days before. They were impossible to answer. I
went back to my office and cancelled the survey.
A food manufacturer had to decide whether to sell his products in cans or glass jars. He
guessed that some housewives would vote for glass because they thought glass sounded
more prestigious, so he gave out samples of his products in glass and other samples cans.
Two weeks later he called back and asked housewives which samples tasted better. A large
majority declared the product of jars tasted better than the same product in the cans.
Without knowing it, they were voting for glass.
15
L. Copetti Audrey Vlieghe
2020 2021
8. Influencers - Part 1
Influencer Marketing = An action plan by which you strengthen marketing messages from
consumer to consumer through people who communicate in a manner that is so
contextually relevant and meaningful that they persuade others to take action
16
L. Copetti Audrey Vlieghe
2020 2021
In other words: As a marketeer, you influence how influencers influence their public about
your brand
How?
By providing exclusive information to the influencer
By providing them with ready-to-use content
By creating new content together
17
L. Copetti Audrey Vlieghe
2020 2021
8.6. Critiques
Lack of control of marketeers over the end marketing product (an influencer gets to decide
what message they wish to spread)
Answer: The conversation will take place with or without you, better to be sitting around
the table. How can you control what influencers will say about you otherwise?
European influencers have a smaller reach than Americans, is it worth the effort?
Answer: The European context is a blessing in disguise: you are less tempted to focus on
quantity and reach (ok for massmedia) but more on quality, the real thing!
9. Influencers Part 2
9.1. Influencers
Influencer
meaningful enough to elicit actions from others
= Not an organization, not stakeholders, not PR
who expressions a contextually relevant message = By working with
distribute your message the right way, at the right time and the right people
that is meaningful enough = They can help your brand to build credibility by guiding you to
produce content that truly meets the needs of your consumers, because they are so close to
the reality
to elicit actions from others = Research findings suggest that more than 90% of all
consumers read online reviews before they buy
communication. Very few influencers have the same reach as adverts on national TV or ads
in the printed press.
Moreover, the influencer with the biggest reach the biggest effect on the behaviour of
his followers. How can they remain relevant for their entire community?
18
L. Copetti Audrey Vlieghe
2020 2021
Engagement = The more interactions (likes, shares, reactions) an influencer can generate,
the stronger his connection with his followers
Relevance = The success of your influencer marketing depends on the match between
your influencer and your company
Is it a magic formula?
No, you must apply the right weighting to the 3 variables
=> A way to choose between an influencer with 50.000 and one with 3.000 followers: when
taking the relevance and the engagement of the one with 3.000, you could decide to go for
them!
19
L. Copetti Audrey Vlieghe
2020 2021
Sales
A positive contact via an influencer can guide your potential customer further into the
sales funnel
Retention
Let influencers stimulate the loyalty of your existing customers
In crisis situations, having the right influencers can be a key factor in limiting the damage
to your image
20
L. Copetti Audrey Vlieghe
2020 2021
Example: B
forward to your fantastic new product. Then, follow this up with an online video in which the
influencer tests the product and praises its virtues. The results will be:
You increase the name awareness of your product with a specific and relevant target
group
The image of your product is boosted in part
in part through their enthusiasm for the product
product
Awareness campaigns
You (brand/product) must remain visible Need to develop sustainable, long-term
relationships with the influencers : (also without a new product!)
Invite them for a tour of your factory
Plan a meeting with the management
Give them exclusive information
In a nutshell : develop your relationship into a real partnership! The results will be:
Influencers will also pick up on your small items of news
They will more frequently produce spontaneous content about your product, service or
organisation
They will more quickly make the connection to your company when they are discussing
related products and markets
Affiliate links = They lead straight to a sales page. The influencer can get a commission on
the sale if they spread the link. The influencer is rewarded and you know what addition sales
have resulted from his influencing activities.
Downside: It looks very much like paid advertising How original are you ?
Use you segmentation to determine which influencer is going to use your affiliate links and
which is not
An independent journalist will lose all credibility with affiliate links
21
L. Copetti Audrey Vlieghe
2020 2021
Celebrity
Ok for their network.
Crisis management
that has
a negative image in the news.
Who should communicate ?
Press release: Ok to nuance the context of the crisis
Spokesperson: Ok to explain on TV what corrective measure you intend to take
Managing director: Ok to outline the external factors that contributed to this situation
BUT ... What about the credibility of these messages? Role for the influencers (esp. if you
have good relations with the influencer in question)
10.5. Conclusion
Determine WHAT you want to communicate
Product-oriented (product leadership)
Price-oriented (operational excellence)
Customer-oriented (customer intimacy)
The objective is to spend as much time as possible on the app and to follow as many people
as possible. Why? For them to collect as much personal data as possible and to show ads
that are as targeted as possible. In order to reach this, they must make the users addicted.
Social validation = One or more passive individuals follow or conform to the actions of others
within a group. It is a basic need.
22
L. Copetti Audrey Vlieghe
2020 2021
We are social animals, always looking for approval, constantly looking to rate themselves
through the eyes of others
Position themselves in the group and
Validate their self-esteem
Instagram => The ultimate social validation tool
You check the number of likes and followers, which your brains considers to be rewards.
And getting a reward releases dopamine
Albert Bandura of Stanford says that human beings are always trying to be part of a group:
23
L. Copetti Audrey Vlieghe
2020 2021
Why?
Because very difficult for our brains to make the difference between natural content
posted by our friends who are self-promoting themselves and the commercial content of
brands which add their products to the pictures of influencers
12.1. Rationale
Representation of men in advertising = monolithic
Cult of virility
Questioning masculinity as a social construct to question the relationships between men
and women and to understand how men imagine their role in relation to women and other
men.
12.2. Masculinities
Plural = Variety of male profiles, their evolution, and their hierarchy in society. There are
many different masculinities and femininities:
Historically constructed
Culturally constructed
Redefined
24
L. Copetti Audrey Vlieghe
2020 2021
: homosexual masculinity)
The object
Exacerbated virility
A Greek god
Perfumes /luxury goods
Target = women
The expert
Linked with science
82% of experts in TV ads are men
They invent the products and solve the problems
At the top of the social and professional hierarchy
The father
Can be completely overwhelmed (Voo)
A has been
Father + « feminine » tasks = loss of virility
Hopefully, the product will help them
Responsible, loving, dominant father figure
25
L. Copetti Audrey Vlieghe
2020 2021
The ideal
Stripping everyday objects of their gendered characteristics
very precise target audience leads to problematic stereotypical representations
Social disparities and inequalities
Diet yoghurt to men ? Or broghurt
26