0% found this document useful (0 votes)
10 views2 pages

Housing as Homemaking in South Africa

The design-research paper 'Housing as Homemaking' focuses on the critical exploration of historical and contemporary constructions of home within South African cities, emphasizing the relationship between housing and the concept of home. It requires students to engage with critical thought, produce a structured argument, and explore alternative mapping practices related to homemaking. The paper must be 2,000 – 2,500 words, include a signed plagiarism declaration, an abstract, and a bibliography, and is due on June 5, 2025.

Uploaded by

emlin.hendricks
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
10 views2 pages

Housing as Homemaking in South Africa

The design-research paper 'Housing as Homemaking' focuses on the critical exploration of historical and contemporary constructions of home within South African cities, emphasizing the relationship between housing and the concept of home. It requires students to engage with critical thought, produce a structured argument, and explore alternative mapping practices related to homemaking. The paper must be 2,000 – 2,500 words, include a signed plagiarism declaration, an abstract, and a bibliography, and is due on June 5, 2025.

Uploaded by

emlin.hendricks
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

APG4039F CONTEMPORARY CRITICAL THEORY AND THE CITY

BAS[hons] 2025 I school of architecture planning and geomatics university of cape town

DESIGN-RESEARCH PAPER

Housing as Homemaking

Yet what makes a city a city are people not walls. “A city [civitas] is a number of men joined by a social
bond. It takes its name from the citizens [cives] who dwell in it. As an urbs it is only a walled structure,
but inhabitants, not building stones, are referred to as a city.”
– Sheldrake (2007) A spiritual city? Place, memory and city making

Ideas about staying, leaving, and journeying are integrally associated with notions of home. The home
can be understood as the place of origin as well as the point of destination, as searching for a home is
seen as a basic trait of human nature. The relationship between home and away is often represented
as oppositional, but home can encompass strangers and encounters with newcomers and is not merely
the familiar base to start the journeying. It has also been argued that when one moves away from
home, the movement occurs in relation to home, and as such is part of the constitution of home. Leaving
home is not always about choice, and a wide range of geographical literature focus on the change
made under duress, on emplacement and displacement, the loss of home due to domicile or old age
that can have equally shattering consequences for a person who has lost control over the organization
of their own life (...) or feeling homeless.
– Peil (2009) Home

Despite the brutal reality of racial apartheid, of domination, one’s homeplace was the one site where
one could freely confront the issue of humanization, where one could resist. Black women resisted by
making homes where all black people could strive to become subjects, not objects, where we could be
affirmed in our minds and hearts despite poverty, hardship, and deprivation, where we could restore
to ourselves the dignity denied us on the outside in the public world.
– hooks (2015) Homeplace: a site of resistance

The conditions of bondage did not foreclose black geographies but rather incited alternative mapping
practices during and after transatlantic slavery, many of which were/are produced outside the official
tenets of cartography: fugitive and maroon maps, literacy maps, food-nourishment maps, family maps,
music maps were assembled alongside ‘real’ maps.
– McKittrick (2011) Plantations, prisons, and a black sense of place

But it’s all gone now. It’s gone with the wind. It’s my feelings that make me feel sick here in this place
if I see all my homeground where I was (...) There was the kitchen. This was our room. And everything,
I feel so at home here. There was the gate. There is the school they attended. Look how happy the
children are. A man feels so sad to stand on your own homeground where you were born and
everything. I feel so at home here. My mother was born here and my whole family was born here. You
see, I picked this thing up. It belongs to me! Yes, I picked it up! It belonged to me.
– Amin and Latiefa, quoted in Wilson (1983) Last Supper on Horstley Street
Housing as Homemaking is a design-research paper that constitutes the cumulative component and
integrative assessment of Contemporary Critical Theory and the City. The urgency and complexity of
housing provision in South African cities has been identified and explored across your design-research
studios this semester. The aims of your design-research paper complements these investigations.
However, its content must neither describe your design process or products nor replicate dominant
tropes of urban housing as discrete ‘typology’ or utilitarian ‘delivery’. Rather, its aims are to critically
explore historical and contemporary constructions of home in the South African city. The content of
your paper is threefold:

1. Demonstrate your understanding and engagement with critical thought in relation to the built
environment such as which is explored throughout the course that supports the expansion of ‘housing’
to the making/unmaking of ‘home’;

2. Produce a well-structured and theoretically-informed argument that integrates coursework with an


interrogation of Housing as Homemaking using (2.1) the texts provided above, (2.2) literatures covered
in the course as a whole in primary/ secondary sources, as well as (2.3) literature drawn from your own
independent study;

3. Explore your own ‘alternative’ mapping practices of homemaking/unmaking in a South African city
that visually informs, supports, and illustrates your argument. You may choose to include or
concentrate your mapping exploration in line with your studio project locales though this is not a
requirement. In either case, your own individual and independent work is required and the reuse of
groupwork studies is not permissible.

Requirements:

A 2,000 – 2,500 word research paper that contributes 60% towards your final grade. Include the word
count on the title page. Word count excludes title, abstract, and bibliography.

Preface your paper with a title page and signed plagiarism declaration provided.

Provide a 200 – 250 word abstract as the first paragraph of the paper that summarises the argument
of the work. The abstract should also indicate primary theoretical concept/s that have been engaged
in formulating the study.

Provide a full bibliography at the end of the paper that includes the sources of all literatures and images
consulted (including if they are your own). You must use the Chicago Reference Style for footnotes, in-
text citations and bibliographic references. Bibliography includes identification of prompts used in
artificial intelligence software.

Design-Research paper (PDF) due on Amathuba by 11:59pm on Thursday 05 June 2025

Common questions

Powered by AI

Homeplace serves as a critical site of resistance against racial oppression, particularly for black women during apartheid. It represents a space where individuals could confront and resist dehumanization and strive to achieve subjectivity, building dignity despite external societal hardships. The nurturing of a home environment offered a refuge and a means of empowerment, allowing resistance against the oppressive structures of the outside world .

The duality of home as both a site of origin and a journey influences city infrastructure and policies by necessitating a balanced approach that addresses the static needs of a home as well as the dynamic requirements of mobility and transition. Infrastructure needs to be adaptable to accommodate these oppositional yet interconnected aspects, ensuring spaces that provide stability and continuity for inhabitants while also facilitating integration and inclusion of newcomers. Policies must therefore be sensitive to the cultural narratives surrounding home and movement, promoting diversity and cohesion within urban development plans .

Alternative mapping practices have provided a deeper understanding of black geography by challenging traditional cartographic norms. These practices, including fugitive maps, maroon maps, and music maps, among others, subverted conventional cartography to reflect the lived experiences and spatial realities of black communities. By focusing on aspects like family connections and cultural nourishment, these maps not only documented physical spaces but also highlighted the socio-cultural dimensions of black space, shaping a unique geographical identity that resisted erasure and marginalization .

Integrating theoretical frameworks in the discussion of home within South African urban housing is crucial for uncovering complex socio-cultural dynamics and historical contexts that shape housing practices. These frameworks help in critically analyzing the transformation of 'housing' from merely physical structures to comprehensive concepts of 'homemaking,' reflecting the intertwined relationships between people, places, and policies. They provide a multidimensional perspective that challenges traditional views of urban housing, enabling more inclusive and culturally aware approaches to address housing issues .

Independent mapping practices are significant in illustrating arguments about homemaking as they offer unique insights and visual representations that traditional methods may overlook. These practices enable researchers to capture the nuanced and personal aspects of home, revealing relationships and cultural symbolism tied to specific locales. In a design-research context, such maps become instrumental in challenging normative perceptions, fostering creativity, and grounding theoretical arguments with empirical and experiential data. They allow for the exploration of non-linear narratives of home, facilitating a deeper understanding of spatial and social dynamics within urban environments .

The movement away from home significantly contributes to one's home identity by fostering a deeper understanding of 'home' through contrast and reflection. Leaving home initiates a relational dynamic where the idea of 'home' evolves as one engages with new environments and experiences. This process challenges preconceived notions of familiarity and belonging, thereby broadening one's conception of home to include new perspectives and encounters. Such movement is not just a physical displacement but also a critical aspect of self-discovery and identity formation .

Producing a theoretically-informed argument about housing as homemaking in South African cities involves understanding complex historical, cultural, and socio-economic factors. Challenges include addressing the legacy of apartheid and ongoing socio-economic inequalities that shape housing practices. Considerations involve integrating diverse sources, including primary and secondary literatures, and alternative storytelling or mapping techniques to fully capture the multi-faceted nature of what constitutes 'home.' The argument must critically engage with contemporary and historical contexts, questioning the conventional roles of housing, while also proposing inclusive, culturally sensitive solutions .

Spatial displacement profoundly affects individuals' sense of belonging and identity by disrupting the familiar physical and emotional anchors of home. When individuals are uprooted, whether due to economic, political, or social pressures, the sense of control over their personal environment diminishes, often leading to feelings of homelessness and disorientation. This loss challenges identity construction, as individuals must navigate new, unfamiliar spaces while dealing with the nostalgia and memory of what was left behind, complicating their sense of where and how they fit into the world .

The concept of home is pivotal in social geography as it functions both as a place of origin and a destination. Home is seen not only as the starting point for one's journey but also as the goal of finding a place to belong. This makes the journey of leaving and returning central to human nature, reflecting the dichotomy of familiarity and discovery. Moving away from home is not just physical relocation but also a part of understanding and constituting one's notion of home .

Home as a site of memory plays a profound role in urban city-making by serving as an anchor for cultural and personal histories within the cityscape. This relationship underscores the importance of place-making amidst modern urban developments. Memory associated with home provides continuity and context, allowing cities to retain their cultural essence despite the dynamic nature of urban transformation. By embedding these memories into urban planning and design, cities can foster a sense of belonging and identity, ensuring that development respects and reflects the lived histories of their inhabitants .

You might also like