Types and Analysis of Retaining Walls
Types and Analysis of Retaining Walls
2 RETAINING WALLS
A retaining wall is defined as a structure whose primary purpose is to provide
lateral support for soil or rock. In some cases, such as basement walls and certain types of bridge
abutments, it may also support vertical loads. The more common
types of retaining walls are shown below;
a) gravity walls
b) cantilevered walls
c) counterfort walls or buttressed
d) Crib walls.
e) semi gravity wall (often steel reinforcement is used)
f) crib wall
Gravity retaining walls are routinely built of plain concrete or stone, and the wall depends
primarily on its mass. When constructed of stone, brick, or plain concrete, their Weight provides
overturning and sliding stability.
Granular soils (sands or gravels) are the standard recommendation for backfill material. There
are several reasons for this recommendation:
1. Predictable Behavior. Import granular backfill generally has a more predictable behavior in
terms of earth pressure exerted on the wall. If silts or clays are used as backfill material,
expansive soil-related forces could be generated by these soil types.
Active earth pressure, which is exerted on the back side of the wall,
Passive earth pressure, which acts on the front of the retaining wall footing,
Bearing pressure, this acts on the bottom of the retaining wall footing.
In order to calculate the active earth pressure resultant force (PA), in kN per linear meter of wall
or pounds per linear foot of wall, the following equation is used for granular backfill:
………….q1
where Ф= friction angle of the granular backfill. The Equation is known as the active Rankine
state .this Equation is valid only for the simple case of a retaining wall that has a vertical rear
face, no friction between the rear wall face and backfill soil, and the backfill ground surface is
horizontal. For retaining walls that do not meet these requirements, the active earth pressure
coefficient (kA) is often determined using the Coulomb equation. Often the wall friction is
neglected (ẟ= 0), but if it is included in the analysis, typical values are ẟ= 3⁄4Ф
for the wall friction between granular soil and wood or concrete walls and ẟ= 20 for the wall
friction between granular soil and steel walls such as sheet-pile walls. Note that in the figure
above when wall friction angle is used in the analysis, the active earth pressure resultant force
(PA) is inclined at an angle equal to . Additional important details concerning the active earth
pressure are as follows:
1. Sufficient Movement. There must be sufficient movement of the retaining wall in order to
develop the active earth pressure of the backfill. For dense granular soil, the amount of wall
translation to reach the active earth pressure state is usually very small (i.e., to reach active state,
wall translation 0.0005 H, where H height of wall).
2. Triangular Distribution. As shown in Figs. 6.34 and 6.35, the active earth pressure is a
triangular distribution and thus the active earth pressure resultant force (PA) is located at a
distance equal to 1⁄3H above the base of the wall.
3. Surcharge Pressure. If there is a uniform surcharge pressure (Q) acting upon the entire
ground surface behind the wall, then there would be an additional horizontal pressure exerted
upon the retaining wall equal to the product of kA times Q. Thus, the resultant force (P2), in kN
per linear m of wall or lb per linear ft of wall, acting on the retaining wall due to the surcharge
(Q) is equal to P 2 QHkA, where Q uniform vertical surcharge acting upon the entire
ground surface behind the retaining wall, kA active earth pressure coefficient (Eq. (6.30) or Fig.
6.35), and H height of the retaining wall. Because this pressure acting upon the retaining wall is
PREPARED BY MR. MUANKANG EMMANUEL AKAH Page 3
uniform, the resultant force (P2) is located at midheight of the retaining wall.
4. Active Wedge: The active wedge is defined as that zone of soil involved in the development
of the active earth pressures upon the wall. This active wedge must move laterally in order to
develop the active earth pressures. It is important that building footings or other load-carrying
members are not supported by the active
wedge, or else they will be subjected to lateral movement. The active wedge is inclined at an
angle of 45 /2 from the horizontal.
b) Passive Earth Pressure. As shown in Fig. above, the passive earth pressure is developed
along the front side of the footing. Passive pressure is developed when the wall footing moves
laterally into the soil and a passive wedge is developed.
Where
pp= passive resultant force in kN per linear m of wall or lb per linear ft of wall
where Ф= friction angle of the soil in front of the wall footing. The Equation is known as the
passive Rankine state. In order to develop passive pressure, the wall footing must get more
laterally into the soil. The wall translation to reach the passive state is at least twice that required
to reach the active earth pressure state. Usually it is desirable to limit the amount of wall
c) Footing Bearing Pressure. In order to calculate the footing bearing pressure, the
first step is to sum the vertical loads, such as the wall and footing weights. The
vertical loads can be represented by a single resultant vertical force, per linear m
of wall that is offset by a distance (eccentricity) from the toe of the footing.
Bearing pressure is routinely at the toe of the footing and it should not exceed the
allowable bearing pressure.
Once the active earth pressure resultant force (PA) and the passive resultant force (Pp) have been
calculated, the design analysis is performed as indicated in the figure abov. The retaining wall
analysis includes determining the resultant location of the forces (i.e., calculate d, which should
be within the middle third of the footing), the factor of safety for overturning, and the factor of
safety for sliding. The adhesion (ca) between the bottom of the footing and the underlying soil is
often ignored for the sliding analysis.
where b = buoyant unit weight of the soil below the groundwater table
and d2 = depth from the groundwater table to the bottom of the sheet pile wall. For a sheet pile
wall having assumed values of H and D (see Fig. 6.38), and using the calculated values of active
earth pressure at Points A and B, the active earth pressure resultant force (PA), in kN per linear m
of wall or lb per linear foot of wall, can be calculated. The soil in front of the wall is assumed to
exert a passive earth pressure on the sheet pile wall. The passive earth pressure at Point C in Fig.
6.38 is equal to kpbD, where the passive earth pressure coefficient (kp) can be calculated from
Eq. (6.32). Similar to the analysis of cantilever retaining walls, if it is desirable to limit the
amount of sheet pile wall translation, then a reduction factor can be applied to the passive
pressure. Once the allowable passive pressure is known at Point C, the passive resultant force
(Pp) can be readily calculated. As an alternative solution for the passive pressure, Eq. (6.31) can
be used to calculate Pp with the buoyant unit weight (b) substituted for the total unit weight (t)
and the depth D as shown in Fig. 6.38.
(1) evaluation of the earth pressure resultant forces PA and Pp as previously described,
(3) calculation of the maximum bending moment (Mmax) which is used to determine the
maximum stress in the sheet pile,
(4) selection of the appropriate piling type, size, and construction details.
A typical design process is to assume a depth D (Fig. 6.38) and then calculate the factor of safety
for toe failure (i.e., toe kick-out) by the summation of moments at the tieback anchor (Point D).
The factor of safety is defined as the moment due to the passive force divided by the moment due
to the active force. Values of acceptable factor of safety for toe failure are 2 to 3. Once the depth
D of the sheet pile wall is known, the anchor pull (Ap) must be calculated. The anchor pull is
determined by the summation of forces in the horizontal direction, or: Ap PA Pp/F, where PA
and Pp are the resultant active and passive forces and F is the factor of safety that was obtained
from the toe failure analysis. Based on the earth pressure diagram (Fig. 6.38) and the calculated
value of Ap, elementary structural mechanics can be used to determine the maximum moment in
the sheet pile wall. The maximum moment divided by the section modulus can then be compared
with the allowable design stresses.
2.2.5 TEMPORARY RETAINING WALLS
Temporary retaining walls are often used during construction, such as for the support of the sides
of an excavation that is made below-grade in order to construct the building foundation. If the
temporary retaining wall has the ability to develop the active wedge, then the basic active earth
pressure principles described in the previous sections can be used for the design of the temporary
retaining walls. Especially in urban areas, movement of the temporary retaining wall may have
to be restricted to prevent damage to adjacent property. If movement of the retaining wall is
restricted, the earth pressures will typically be between the active (kA) and at-rest (k0) values.
For some projects, the temporary retaining wall may be constructed of sheeting (such as sheet
piles) that are supported by horizontal braces, also known as struts. Near or at the top of the
temporary retaining wall, the struts restrict movement of the retaining wall and prevent the
development of the active wedge. Because of this inability of the retaining wall to deform at the
top, earth pressures near the top of the wall are in excess of the active (kA) pressures. At the
bottom of the wall, the soil is usually able to deform into the excavation, which results in a
reduction in earth pressure, and the earth pressures at the bottom of the excavation tend to be
constant or even decrease as shown in Fig. 6.39. The earth pressure distributions shown in Fig.
6.39 were developed from actual measurements of the forces in struts during the construction of
2.3.0 INTRODUCTION
Till now we discussed the different structural elements eg. beams, slabs, staircases and columns,
which are placed above the ground level and are known as superstructure. The superstructure is
placed on the top of the foundation structure, designated as substructure as they are placed below
the ground level.
The function of any foundation is to safely sustain and transmit to the ground on which it rests
the combined dead, imposed and wind loads in such a manner as not to cause any settlement or
other movement which would impair the stability or cause damage to any part of the building.
However, it is worth mentioning that the design of foundation structures is somewhat different
from the design of other elements of superstructure due to the reasons given below. Therefore,
foundation structures need special attention of the designers.
Subsoil beneath foundation is compressed and reacts by exerting an upward pressure to resist
foundation loading. If foundation load exceeds maximum passive pressure of ground (i.e.
[Link] Basic Sizing; the size of a foundation basically depends on two factors †
1. Load being transmitted, max 70 kN/m (dwellings up to 3 storeys).
2. Bearing capacity of subsoil under proposed foundation.
Bearing capacities for different types of subsoils may be obtained from tables such as those in
Structural design of low rise buildings. Also, directly from soil investigation results.
One of the functions of a foundation can be seen to be the ability to spread its load evenly over
the ground on which it rests. It must of course be constructed of a durable material of adequate
strength. Experience has shown that the most suitable material is concrete. Concrete is a mixture
of cement + aggregates + water in controlled proportions. Another commonly used material is
stone.
This can be considered as a series of steps or stages used in the construction of a foundation ;
1. Assessment of site conditions in the context of the site and soil investigation report.
2. Calculation of anticipated structural loading(s).
3. Choosing the foundation type taking into consideration †
Foundations are usually classified by their type such as strips, pads, rafts and piles. It is also
possible to combine foundation types such as strip foundations connected by beams to and
working in conjunction with pad foundations
These are suitable for most subsoils and light structural loadings such as those encountered in
low to medium rise domestic dwellings where mass concrete can be used. Reinforced concrete is
usually required for all other situations.
Suitable for most subsoils except loose sands, loose gravels and filled areas. Pad foundations are
usually constructed of reinforced concrete and where possible are square in plan.
These are used to spread the load of the superstructure over a large base to reduce the load per
unit area being imposed on the ground and this is particularly useful where low bearing capacity
soils are encountered and where individual column loads are heavy.
These can be used for lightly loaded buildings on poor soils or where the top 450 to 600 mm of
soil is overlaying poor quality substrata.
These can be used where it is necessary to avoid imposing any pressure on an adjacent
foundation or underground service.
These are usually considered in the context of strip foundations and are used mainly on sloping
sites to reduce the amount of excavation and materials required to produce an adequate
foundation.
Concrete is a material which is strong in compression but weak in tension. If its tensile strength
is exceeded cracks will occur resulting in a weak and unsuitable foundation. One method of
providing tensile resistance is to include in the concrete foundation bars of steel as a form of
reinforcement to resist all the tensile forces induced into the foundation. Steel is a material which
is readily available and has high tensile strength.
These can be defined as a series of columns constructed or inserted into the ground to transmit
the load(s) of a structure to a lower level of subsoil. Piled foundations can be used when suitable
foundation conditions are not present at or near ground level making the use of deep traditional
foundations uneconomic. The lack of suitable foundation conditions may be caused by:-
1. Natural low bearing capacity of subsoil.
2. High water table † giving rise to high permanent dewatering costs.
[Link].1 Classification of Piles; piles may be classified by their basic design function or by their
method of construction:-
A) Replacement Piles
These are often called bored piles since the removal of the spoil to form the hole for the pile is
always carried out by a boring technique. They are used primarily in cohesive subsoils for the
formation of friction piles and when forming pile foundations close to existing buildings where
the allowable amount of noise and/or vibration is limited.
These are often called driven piles since the are usually driven into the ground displacing the
earth around the pile shaft. These piles can be either preformed or partially preformed if they are
not cast in-situ and are available in a wide variety of types and materials. The pile or forming
tube is driven into the required position to a predetermined depth or to the required `set' which is
a measure of the subsoils resistance to the penetration of the pile and hence its bearing capacity
by noting the amount of penetration obtained by a fixed number of hammer blows.
These are usually square sawn and can be used for small contracts on sites with shallow alluvial
deposits overlying a suitable bearing strata (e.g. river banks and estuaries.) Timber piles are
percussion driven.
Variety of types available which are generally used on medium to large contracts of not less than
one hundred piles where soft soil deposits overlie a firmer strata. These piles are percussion
driven using a drop or single acting hammer.
jointing with a peripheral steel splicing collar as shown on the preceding page is adequate for
most concentrically or directly loaded situations. Where very long piles are to be used and/or
Used on medium to large contracts as an alternative to preformed piles particularly where final
length of pile is a variable to be determined on site.