TECHNICAL COMPARISON TABLE
PROJECT TG 2149B Zayed Military University (ZMU)
CLIENT Zayed Military University (ZMU)
CONSULTANT AECOM Middle East- Abu Dhabi
MAIN CONTRACTOR Trojan General Contracting LLC
Sub CONTRACTOR Aquarius Contracting L.L.C
SUPPLIER Safe Line Electrical & Mechanical LLC
COMPLIANCE STATEMENT
CLAUSE COMPLY / Proposed
SPECIFICATION
Section 26 51 00 PRODUCTS
INTERIOR
LIGHTING
2.01 LUMINAIRES AND COMPONENTS, GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
A. Incandescent Fixtures: Where LER/LOR is specified, provide a test certificate from an approved testing Proposed fittings are LED.
laboratory.
B. Fluorescent Fixtures: Where LER/LOR is specified, provide a test certificate from an approved testing Proposed fittings are LED.
laboratory.
C. HID Fixtures: Where LER/LOR is specified, provide a test certificate from an approved testing laboratory Proposed fittings are LED.
D. LED Fixtures: Where LER/LOR is specified, provide a test certificate from an approved testing laboratory. Comply
E. Luminaires shall be complete with connecting leads, auxiliaries, lamps, diffusers, and suspension gear. Comply
Cables for interconnecting lamps and control gear shall be heat-resistant cables suitable for operating at
a maximum temperature of 105°C.
F. Metal Parts: Free of burrs and sharp corners and edges. All cabling through a metal edge or hole in the Comply
luminaries shall be protected by approved grommets.
G. Sheet Metal Components: Steel, unless otherwise indicated. Form and support to prevent warping and Comply
sagging.
H. All luminaires shall be provided with earthing terminals for earthing connection. Comply
I. Doors, Frames, and Other Internal Access: Smooth operating, free of light leakage under operating Noted
conditions, and designed to permit relamping without the use of tools. Designed to prevent doors,
frames, lenses, diffusers, and other components from falling accidentally during relamping and when
secured in operating position.
j. All diffusers for linear fluorescent light fittings shall be hinged at one side for ease of maintenance and Noted. Proposed fittings are LED
shall be able to snap back and fit into position
K. Reflecting surfaces shall have minimum reflectance as follows, unless otherwise indicated: Noted
1. White Surfaces: 85 percent.
2. Specular Surfaces: 83 percent.
3. Diffusing Specular Surfaces: 75 percent.
4. Laminated Silver Metallized Film: 90 percent.
L. Plastic Diffusers, Covers, and Globes: Comply as applicable.
1. Acrylic Lighting Diffusers: 100 percent virgin acrylic plastic. High resistance to yellowing and other
changes due to aging, exposure to heat, and UV radiation.
a. Lens Thickness: At least 0.5 mm minimum unless a different thickness is indicated.
b. UV stabilized.
2. Glass: Annealed crystal glass, unless otherwise indicated.
2.09 LIGHT EMITTING DIODES (LEDs)
A. Comply
1. Discrete light emitting diodes (LEDs) shall be manufactured by a reputable or equal manufacturer such
as Osram, Lumileds (Luxeon), and Nichea, or an acceptable equivalent with proven experience in LED
Manufacturer production. The luminaire manufacturer shall meet any certification available from the LED
manufacturer. Failure to comply with manufacturer recommendations shall impact upon LED lifetime
and reliability.
c. Comply
Optical Parameters 2 LED batches shall be from the same color bin, no greater than 5 mm wide.
2 LED suppliers shall provide LED batch bin number, recording the luminous flux, wavelength/color, and
forward voltage of the LED. Batch information shall be included as part of the Operations and
Maintenance (O+M) Manual or as part of the fixture's order/serial number.
D. Comply
Color Rendering Index White LEDs shall have a CRI greater than 80.
E. Comply
1. The LED minimum lamp life shall be:
LED Lamp Life
a) Forward Current Lamp Life to 50% Lumen
b) Output of Original Output
1. 350 mA 50,000 hours.
2. 700 mA 50,000 hours.
3. 1005 mA 20,000 hours.
4. 1400 mA 20,000 hours
F. 1. Wall and ground LED luminaries shall be in IP68 enclosures with IP68 cable glands. Proposed exterior lights are IP 65.
IP Rating
G. Comply as applicable.
1. Generally, transformers shall match the optimum and maximum current to suit the LED over the
whole range of input voltages.
Transformers
2. Dedicated transformers shall be provided with the following features as a minimum:
a) Automatic reset in the event of a fault.
b) Isolation between the primary and secondary sides.
c) Dimming with linear characteristics
d) Operation in ambient temperatures from -20°C to +50°C.
e) Low power loss.
f) Integrated electronic overload protection circuitry.
g) Integrated electronic over temperature protection circuitry.
h) Integrated electronic short circuit protection circuitry.
H. Comply as applicable.
Minimum Luminous 1. Optical light output ratios related to power:
Efficacy
a) White 20 lm/W.
b) Warm White 13 lm/W.
c) Blue 6 lm/W. d) Red 30 lm/W.
e) Green 20 lm/W.
1) Amber 201 mA/W.
2. Manufacturer's luminous efficacy is stated for a 25°C (77°F) ambient with a current of 20 mA, in an
environment that does not build up heat around the LED
Section26 5600
EXTERIOR
LIGHTING
2.01 Refer to Appendix for "Light Fitting Schedule", "Light Fitting Specifications", "Mock-up Light Fitting Noted
GENERAL Schedule" and List of Manufacturers.
A.
2.02 Noted
MANUFACTURERS Provide light fittings, lamps and other equipment for each type according to the Manufactures shown in
A. the Light Fitting Schedule and Light Fitting Specification.
2.03 LUMINAIRES, GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
A. Luminaires shall be listed and labeled for installation in wet locations acceptable to authorities having Comply
jurisdiction
B. Comply with IESNA RP-8 for parameters of lateral light distribution patterns indicated for luminaries as Comply
noted in the Light Fitting Schedule.
C. Light fittings shall be complete with connecting leads, auxiliaries, lamps, diffusers, and suspension gear. Comply
Cables for interconnecting lamps and control gear shall be heat-resistant cables suitable for operating at
a maximum temperature of 105°C.
D. Metal Parts: Free of burrs, sharp comers, and edges. All cabling through a metal edge or hole in the light Comply
fitting shall be protected by approved grommets.
E. Sheet Metal Components: Corrosion-resistant aluminum, unless otherwise indicated. Form and support Comply
to prevent warping and sagging.
F. All light fittings shall be provided with earthing terminals for earthing connection. Comply
G. Housings: Rigidly formed, weather- and light-tight enclosures that will not warp, sag, or deform in use. Comply
Provide a filter/breather for enclosed luminaires.
I. All diffusers for linear fluorescent light fittings shall be hinged at one side for ease of maintenance and Noted. Proposed fittings are LED
shall be able to snap back and fit into position.
H. Doors, Frames, and Other Internal Access: Smooth operating, free of light leakage under operating Noted
conditions, and designed to permit relamping without the use of tools. Designed to prevent doors,
frames, lenses, diffusers, and other components from falling accidentally during relamping and when
secured in operating position. Doors shall be removable for cleaning or replacing lenses. Designed to
disconnect ballast when the door opens.
J. Exposed Hardware Material: Stainless steel. Proposed fittings are Die cast
aluminum body
K. Plastic Parts: High resistance to yellowing and other changes due to aging, exposure to heat, and UV Comply
radiation.
L. Light Shields: Metal baffles, factory installed and field adjustable, arranged to block light distribution to Noted
the indicated portion of the normally illuminated area or field.
M. Reflecting surfaces shall have minimum reflectance as follows, unless otherwise indicated: Comply
1. White Surfaces: 85 percent.
2. Specular Surfaces: 83 percent.
3. Diffusing Specular Surfaces: 75 percent
N. Noted
Lenses and Refractors Gaskets: Use heat and aging-resistant resilient gaskets to seal and cushion lenses
and refractors in luminaire doors.