Prepared by: Chang Y.

(MA)
Prepared by:- Chang Y. (MA) 1
 cont...
• Strategy: outlines the specific ways in which an organization
plans to position itself, achieve its short-term and long-term
goals, and grow over a period of time.
• All three levels form the strategic framework of an
organization:
• 1. Corporate Level: Corporate level strategies are the strategic
plans of an organization's top management.
• They form the mission and vision statement and have a
fundamental impact on the firm’s long-term performance.
• They guide decisions around growth, acquisitions, diversification
and investments.

Prepared by:- Chang Y. (MA) 2

 cont...
Focus: The overall direction and purpose of the port authority or
organization.
Scope: Deals with the highest level of decision-making and long-
term objectives.
Key Questions:
 What markets and regions should the port serve?
 How should the port diversify its services (e.g., cargo, passenger, logistics)?
 What are the port’s core values and mission?
Examples in Port Context:
 Expanding port operations to include inland terminals.
 Developing partnerships with other global ports.
 Diversifying revenue streams through tourism or logistics hubs.

Prepared by:- Chang Y. (MA) Prepared by: Chang Y. (MA) 3

 Conti....ed
2. Business Level: Business level strategies integrate into
the corporate vision, but with a focus on a specific
business.
 At this level, the vision and objectives are turned into
strategies that inform how a business is going to
compete in the market.

Prepared by:- Chang Y. Prepared by: Chang Y. (MA) 4

(MA)
 cont....
Focus: Achieving competitive advantage in specific markets or
services.
Scope: Addresses how the port competes in its industry and delivers
value to customers.

 How can the port differentiate itself (e.g., efficiency, capacity, technology)?
 What market segments should be prioritized (e.g., container shipping, bulk
goods)?
 How can the port respond to competition from other regional ports?
Examples in Port Context:
 Enhancing turnaround times to attract shipping companies.
 Investing in green port initiatives to attract eco-conscious clients.
 Implementing digital tools for cargo tracking and process
automation.
Prepared by:- Chang Y. Prepared by: Chang Y. (MA) 5
(MA)
 cont...
3. Functional Level: Functional level strategies are
designed to answer how functional departments like
Marketing, HR or R&D can support the defined business
and corporate strategies of a port.

Prepared by:- Chang Y. Prepared by: Chang Y. (MA) 6

(MA)
 cont....
Focus: Ensuring efficient day-to-day operations that align with
business and corporate strategies.
Involves specific departments and processes, such as
logistics, IT, human resources, and marketing.
Key Questions:
 How can port processes be optimized for efficiency and sustainability?
 What technologies and equipment should be used for cargo handling?
 How can safety and compliance standards be maintained?
Examples in Port Context:
 Scheduling berths to reduce waiting times for vessels.
 Training staff on new cargo-handling equipment.
 Implementing predictive maintenance for cranes and machinery.

Prepared by:- Chang Y. Prepared by: Chang Y. (MA) 7

(MA)
 Integrated View of Strategy Levels in Ports:

Strategy Level Focus Key Objective

Define the port's role

Overall port vision and
Corporate Strategy in global and regional
long-term goals
trade

Gain competitive
Competing in specific
Business Strategy advantage and attract
markets/services
customers

Functional/Operation Day-to-day operations Ensure efficiency,

al Strategy and processes safety, and reliability

Prepared by:- Chang Y. Prepared by: Chang Y. (MA) 8

(MA)
 Strategies Used by Port Authorities to Coordinate
container flows across the transport chain
1. Incentives encourage freight actors (shippers, carriers,
terminal operators) to collaborate and optimize supply chain
performance.
Types of Incentives:
Financial Incentives: Discounts on port fees for eco-friendly
vessels.
Operational Incentives: Priority docking for ships using advanced
scheduling.
Regulatory Incentives: Tax reductions for companies investing in
greener transport options.
Example: The Port of Rotterdam offers reduced tariffs for sustainable
shipping practices.

Prepared by:- Chang Y. 9

(MA)
 cont...
2. Inter-Firm Alliances in Freight & Shipping 🤝
Companies form alliances to enhance efficiency, reduce costs, and
expand market reach.
Types of Alliances:
A) Vertical Integration (Along Transport Chains)
Definition: A company expands by acquiring or partnering with
upstream (suppliers) or downstream (distributors) businesses.
Benefits: Greater control over supply chains, cost reduction, and
efficiency.
Example: Maersk acquired freight forwarder Damco to integrate
shipping with logistics services.

Prepared by:- Chang Y. 10

(MA)
 cont...
B) Horizontal Integration (Between Competitors)
Definition: Companies at the same level of the supply chain
collaborate or merge to strengthen their market position.
Benefits: Reduces competition, expands capacity, and improves
bargaining power.
Example: The 2M Alliance (Maersk & MSC) shares vessel capacity
to optimize global shipping routes.

Prepared by:- Chang Y. 11

(MA)
 cont...
C) Alliance Between a Maritime Shipping Company & a
Terminal Operator
Definition: Partnerships between shipping lines and port terminal
operators to enhance cargo handling efficiency.
Benefits: Faster turnaround times, better coordination, and
improved scheduling.
Example: CMA CGM partnered with PSA Singapore to improve
terminal operations and logistics efficiency.

Prepared by:- Chang Y. 12

(MA)
 cont...
3. Organisational scope
Organizational scope refers to a company's range of activities,
markets, and operational focus. One key strategy for expansion is
vertical integration, where companies expand their control over
supply chain processes.
 Vertical integration where an actor decides to penetrate a new
market.
 A maritime shipping company involved in port terminal
operations.

Prepared by:- Chang Y. 13

(MA)
 cont...
4. Collective Actions in Freight & Logistics
A) Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs) to Create Logistics Parks
Definition: Governments and private companies collaborate to
develop large-scale logistics hubs for efficient cargo handling.
Benefits: Attracts investment, improves transportation efficiency,
and boosts regional economies.
Example:
Dubai’s Jebel Ali Free Zone (JAFZA) was developed as a public-
private initiative, attracting thousands of businesses.
Kenya’s Nairobi Freight Terminal (NFT) was built through PPPs to
improve East African trade connectivity.

Prepared by:- Chang Y. 14

(MA)
 cont...
B) Development of Multiplying Effects
Definition: Economic and business expansion effects triggered by
logistics infrastructure (ports, highways, rail networks).
How It Works:
Better transport systems attract more businesses, increasing
investments.
Employment growth and industrial expansion occur around major
logistics hubs.
Example:
Singapore’s world-class port infrastructure led to the growth of
multinational logistics companies like DHL and FedEx in the region.
China’s development of port-industrial zones in cities like Shenzhen
created economic booms in manufacturing and logistics.
Prepared by:- Chang Y. 15
(MA)
 Ports in SCM
Consistent with the spread of the new paradigm by
which “real competition is not company against company
but rather supply chain against supply chain”
(Christopher, 1992), it has been stated that “competition
is not known between individual ports but between
logistic chains” (Meersman and Van de Voorde, 1996).
According to the SCM perspective, ports have been
considered as part of the chains of companies involved,
through upstream and downstream linkages, in the
processes and activities that create value to the final
client.
Prepared by:- Chang Y. 16
(MA)
 Port within global supply chains
 Ports play an important role in global logistics by acting
as a node for a network of parties engaged in shipping
and receiving goods
 Ports facilitate material transfer and associated
information flow and thereby contribute towards efficient
and effective global transport chains
 Ports serve as logistics platform and coordinate the
requirements placed by several stakeholders such as
shippers, carriers, terminal operators and forwarding
companies
 Ports transform into multimodal transport facilities
integrated to sea and hinterland modes
Prepared by:- Chang Y. 17
(MA)
 Lean & Agile ports
 Agility and leanness are two elements that allow
ports to streamline operations achieve coordination in
order to make best use of available resources.

 A lean port is one that as a business unit makes the

best use of its available resources (tangible &
intangible assets) and by eliminating all sort of wastes
in the physical and documentary or information
processes related to cargo and modes, delivers
perfect customer service.

Prepared by:- Chang Y. 18

(MA)
 Conti...from Lean & Agile ports
An agile port is one that:
 Requires new management philosophy.
 Can be adaptable, responsive, flexible and a centre of
knowledge.
 Gets involved in partnerships and strategic alliances (with
inland depots).
 Fulfills the requirements of info-structure, infrastructure and
superstructure accessibilities
 Continuously tries to innovate,
 Performs research and evaluation of performance
(anticipate the unanticipated)
Prepared by:- Chang Y. 19
(MA)
 Comparison: Lean vs. Agile Port
Aspect Lean Port Agile Port
Efficiency and cost Flexibility and
Primary Focus
reduction responsiveness

Process standardization Adaptation to dynamic

Approach
and waste reduction and uncertain demands

Dynamic and
Operational Style Predictable and steady
customizable

Focused on automation Focused on real-time

Technology Usage
and optimization data and adaptability

Stable and predictable Volatile or rapidly

Best for
environments changing environments

Prepared by:- Chang Y. Prepared by: Chang Y. (MA) 20

(MA)
 PORT DEVELOPMENT
 Ports have developed in different ways with a
combination of trade, economic, spatial, political,
social, and even cultural and military influences,
and no clear pattern of port development exists.
 Ports have also transformed from labour-intensive
merchant ports into capital and technology-
intensive enterprises.

Prepared by:- Chang Y. 21

(MA)
 conti...ed
• Since the industrial revolution, ports have
progressed into become manufacturing sites
moving vast quantities of goods and commodities
and using larger and expensive equipment.
• Following the process of containerization and the
growing specialization of ships and terminals,
ports became more capital and technology intensive
with sophisticated handling equipment and
technological systems being deployed across
modern ports and terminals.

Prepared by:- Chang Y. 22

(MA)
• More recently, the importance of ports and their
corresponding hinterlands has been influenced by new
factors such as containerisation, inter-modal integration,
shipping networks, logistics patterns, information
technology, environmental sustainability, land use and
policy.

Prepared by:- Chang Y. 23

(MA)
 Port institution and organizational structure

• Institutional dissimilarity also hinders a comprehensive

approach to ports, as there are several organizational
and ownership models applicable to world ports, even
between those performing similar roles and functions.
• Traditionally, ports have been owned, operated and
regulated by state-controlled public organizations.
• However, the introduction of private sector participation
in ports and the emergence of new forms of port
governance have led to the adoption of new models of
port ownership and institutional structuring.

Prepared by:- Chang Y. 24

(MA)
 Conti...ed
 Current models for classifying port organisational
and institutional structure use one or a combination of
the following criteria:
1. Mode of administrative governance (central or local),
 Here a variety of public port models exist—from
centrally controlled ports to ports controlled by local
administrations and municipal authorities.

Prepared by:- Chang Y. 25

(MA)
• Other models include autonomous port is a public
enterprise which enjoys a high degree of autonomy and
independence from the central government, and
• A port corporation is a public company that can be
either government-owned or statutory-owned depending
on the legislation and regulatory regime that govern its
operations and management.
• 2. The institutional framework; public–private status
of port operations and management.
• Here, ports are classified as being either public or
private.

Prepared by:- Chang Y. 26

(MA)
• A more elaborate approach analyses port ownership
through combining the aspects of port facilities and
services with the status.
• Here the port literature provides generic terms where
ports are classified into landlord, service or tool
organizations, or variations and combinations of these.
• The main difference between the above three models
refers back to the aspects of public or private
ownership/operations of port facilities (infrastructure
and/or superstructure) and of the affiliation of port
workforce and labour.

Prepared by:- Chang Y. 27

(MA)
 Generic institutional port models
Infrastructure Superstructure Workforce Regulation

Landlord Public Private Private Public

Tool Public Public Private Public

(private) (public)

Service (public) Public Public Public Public

Service (private) Private Private Private Private

Prepared by:- Chang Y. 28

(MA)
 Description, strengths and weaknesses of port institutional
models (Continued )
Description Strengths Weaknesses
Public • Owns, develops and allow greater • Handling operations
maintains, both throughput via an not compatible with
service infrastructure and increased efficiency in administrative
port superstructure using the production duties of public entity
• Owns and operates factors • Private sector out of
handling equipment • No redundancy Unity the port business
• Operates and performs on of command and
its own all services management
• Labour for all port services
provided by public sector

Prepared by:- Chang Y. 29

(MA)
 Conti...ed
Description Strengths Weaknesses

Private  Private sector owns,  Port operations and  Risk of market

service develops, and operates management failure, eg
port infrastructure, superstructure, performance monopolistic
and all other port services. not influenced by political behaviour
 Private sector provides decisions.
labour for all port services.  Higher efficiency in
 Regulatory and statutory asset and human
functions may be performed by resources
the public authority management.

Prepared by:- Chang Y. 30

(MA)
 Conti...ed
Description Strengths Weaknesses

Landlord • Owns, develops and • No investment required in • Possible

port maintains the equipment and superstructure conflict
infrastructure, but facilities between
leases/rents it to the • Private sector efficiency and private sector
private sector accountability objectives
• Handling services • Investment by the private and general
performed by private sector ensures strong market public
sector. leadership,longterm relationship interest.
• Labour for handling • Competitive market dynamics.
services provided by • Better management of port
private sector labour.

Prepared by:- Chang Y. 31

(MA)
 Conti..ed
Description Strengths Weaknesses
Tool  Owns, develops and  allow greater  Double entity (public
port maintains the infrastructure throughput via and private)
 Owns superstructure which is an increased undertaking handling
operated by the private efficiency in operations and
sector using the management
 Labour for handling services production  Possibility of conflict
provided by public sector. factors regarding equipment
 No redundancy assignment and
operational efficiency
 No control over labour
efficiency from the part
of the private sector

Prepared by:- Chang Y. 32

(MA)
 Conti..ed
Port Model Ownership Operation Examples

Public Service Port

Public Chittagong,
Public (Government)
(Government) Bangladesh

Tool Port
Public Port of
Public infrastructure
infrastructure Kolkata, India

Landlord Port
Rotterdam,
Public land & Public land &
Singapore,
infrastructure infrastructure
Antwerp

Private Service
Port Felixstowe
Private Private (UK), some
U.S. terminals
Prepared by:- Chang Y. 33
(MA)
 Conti...ed
• Ports, like most other commercial activities, are constantly
changing. Their design and infrastructure change as the
vehicles using them change and their functions develop and
alter as the trade passing through them varies in type and
quantity.
• Cargo-handling technology and changes in labour
requirements and culture have also seen radical
developments.
• In order to understand ports and to try to develop a
general conceptual model for ports, it is important to
grasp the general pattern and causes of these
developments and the solutions, good or bad, attempted by
various port managers.
Prepared by:- Chang Y. 34
(MA)
 Conti...ed
• Many factors can cause ports to change, evolve or die:
 Changes in the inland transport infrastructure
 Changes in trade patterns
 Changes in financial and logistical thinking
 Length of life

Prepared by:- Chang Y. 35

(MA)
 Phases of Port Development

Prepared by:- Chang Y. 36

(MA)
 Management structures and ports personnel
 The port industry strongly depends on human resources
who have to be highly qualified because of the heavy
responsibilities for :
 safety and environmental sustainability,

 expensive equipment and vehicles, and

 tonnes of goods and cargo.

 This requires appropriate planning and implementation

of human resources (HR) capable of operating and
managing a continuously changing and challenging port
environment.

Prepared by:- Chang Y. 37

(MA)
 Management structures and ports personnel
• Modern organisations categorise port activities in
terms of planning, execution, and monitoring functions,
and this has helped them streamline specific tasks and
responsibilities while ensuring transparency and
quality assurance in port employment.
• The type and range of job profiles and classifications
in ports not only denote the nature and labour
intensity of port operations, but they also reflect the
extent of institutional structuring and reform

Prepared by:- Chang Y. 38

(MA)
 United Nations Conference on Trade and
Development (UNCTAD)’s port generations model

• The United Nations Conference on Trade and Development

(UNCTAD)'s Port Generations Model explains how ports have
evolved over time in response to changes in trade patterns,
logistics, and technological advancements.
• It categorizes ports into different "generations," each with
distinct characteristics and levels of integration into global
supply chains.

Prepared by:- Chang Y. 39

(MA)
 cont....
1st Generation Ports (Traditional Ports):
 Focus: Cargo handling (loading and unloading)
 Role: Primarily a transit point for goods
 Infrastructure: Basic facilities, break-bulk cargo
handling
• Services: Minimal, limited to port operations only
• Connectivity: Limited inland connectivity
• Example: Small or early-stage ports focused mainly
on manual cargo handling

Prepared by:- Chang Y. 40

(MA)
 cont....
2nd Generation Ports:
Focus: Cargo handling + added services (warehousing, storage)
Role: Extended logistics services, basic value-added activities
(e.g., packaging, simple assembly)
Infrastructure: Improved, mechanized cargo handling (e.g.,
container terminals)
Management: Still managed by public authorities, but more
professionalized
Connectivity: Better inland transport connections (rail, road)
Example: Regional ports integrating warehousing and
distribution centers

Prepared by:- Chang Y. 41

(MA)
 cont...
3rd Generation Ports:
Focus: Integration into supply chains & industrial development
Role: Act as logistics platforms and hubs
Infrastructure: Advanced facilities, multimodal transport links
(sea, rail, road, air)
Comprehensive logistics services, free trade zones,
industrial parks near port
Management: Increasing private sector involvement, port
authorities act as facilitators
Example: Major hub ports like Rotterdam, Singapore, Dubai

Prepared by:- Chang Y. 42

(MA)
 cont...
4th Generation Ports (Networked & Sustainable Ports):
Global integration + environmental sustainability +
digitalization
Role: Become supply chain coordinators and integrate
information and communication technologies (ICT)
Infrastructure: Smart port technologies (IoT, automation), green
port initiatives
Services: Full-service providers, including digital trade
facilitation, customs processing, energy management
Governance: Strong public-private partnerships (PPP),
decentralized management
Example: Ports implementing blockchain for trade, automated
terminals, sustainable operations (e.g., Port of Los Angeles’ Green
Port Policy)
Prepared by:- Chang Y. 43
(MA)
 cont...
Generation Key Features Management Services

1st Generation Basic cargo handling Public authority Loading/unloading

Cargo handling + Storage, minor

2nd Generation Public authority
warehousing value-added

Integrated logistics,
Advanced logistics,
3rd Generation multimodal Public-private mix
trade zones
connections

Smart, green, ICT-enabled,

PPPs,
4th Generation digitalized, supply sustainable, full
decentralized
chain-focused services
Prepared by:- Chang Y. 44
(MA)
 Issues in Developing a Unified Port Model
• From the above categorization, it seems that the
interactions between port missions, institutions and
functions have resulted in a variety of approaches to
port operations and management.

• Probably, the major obstacle against adopting a

unified model for port development and strategy
refers back to the complexity and diversity of the
port business at more than one level, including:

Prepared by:- Chang Y. 45

(MA)
 Conti...ed
1. Organisational differences; issues of ownership (public versus
private), institutional status (landlord/tool versus service) etc.
2. Operational differences; types of cargo handled, ships
serviced, terminals operated, etc.
3. Physical and spatial differences; location, access, connectivity,
available capacity, etc.
4. Legal and regulatory differences; trade and transport policy,
administrative procedures, safety and security regulations,
environment, etc.

Prepared by:- Chang Y. 46

(MA)
 END OF CHAPTER FOUR

Prepared by:- Chang Y. 47

(MA)