Radiographic Testing in NDT Explained
Radiographic Testing in NDT Explained
Radiographic Testing
Radiography is used in a very wide range of aplications including medicine,
engineering, forensics, security, etc. In NDT, radiography is one of the most
important and widely used methods. Radiographic testing (RT) offers a
number of advantages over other NDT methods, however, one of its major
disadvantages is the health risk associated with the radiation.
In general, RT is method of inspecting materials for hidden flaws
by using the ability of short wavelength electromagnetic radiation
(high energy photons) to penetrate various materials. The intensity
of the radiation that penetrates and passes through the material is
either captured by a radiation sensitive film (Film Radiography) or
by a planer array of radiation sensitive sensors (Real-time
Radiography). Film radiography is the oldest approach, yet it is still
the most widely used in NDT.
Basic Principles
In radiographic testing, the part to be inspected is
placed between the radiation source and a piece of
radiation sensitive film. The radiation source can either
be an X-ray machine or a radioactive source (Ir-192,
Co-60, or in rare cases Cs-137). The part will stop some
of the radiation where thicker and more dense areas
will stop more of the radiation. The radiation that
passes through the part will expose the film and forms
a shadowgraph of the part. The film darkness (density)
will vary with the amount of radiation reaching the film
through the test object where darker areas indicate
more exposure (higher radiation intensity) and lighter
areas indicate less exposure (lower radiation intensity).
This variation in the image darkness can be used to
determine thickness or composition of material and
would also reveal the presence of any flaws or
discontinuities inside the material.
PHYSICS OF RADIATION
are not influenced by electrical and magnetic fields and will generally travel in straight
lines. However, they can be diffracted (bent) in a manner similar to light.
Electromagentic radiation act somewhat like a particle at times in that they occur as
small “packets” of energy and are referred to as “photons”. Each photon contains a
certain amount (or bundle) of energy, and all electromagnetic radiation consists of these
photons. The only difference between the various types of electromagnetic radiation is
the amount of energy found in the photons. Due to the short wavelength of X-rays and
gamma rays, they have more energy to pass through matter than do the other forms of
energy in the electromagnetic spectrum. As they pass through matter, they are
scattered and absorbed and the degree of penetration depends on the kind of matter
and the energy of the rays.
Properties of X-Rays and Gamma Rays
They are not detected by human senses (cannot be seen, heard, felt, etc.).
They travel in straight lines at the speed of light.
Their paths cannot be changed by electrical or magnetic fields.
They can be diffracted, refracted to a small degree at interfaces between two
different materials, and in some cases be reflected.
They pass through matter until they have a chance to encounter with an atomic
particle.
Their degree of penetration depends on their energy and the matter they are
traveling through.
They have enough energy to ionize matter and can damage or destroy living cells.
X-Radiation
X-rays are just like any other kind of electromagnetic radiation. They can be produced
in packets of energy called photons, just like light. There are two different atomic
processes that can produce X-ray photons. One is called Bremsstrahlung (a German
term meaning “braking radiation”) and the other is called K-shell emission. They can
both occur in the heavy atoms of tungsten which is often the material chosen for the
target or anode of the X-ray tube.
Both ways of making X-rays involve a change in the state of electrons. However,
Bremsstrahlung is easier to understand using the classical idea that radiation is emitted
when the velocity of the electron shot at the tungsten target changes. The negatively
charged electron slows down after swinging around the nucleus of a positively charged
tungsten atom and this energy loss produces X-radiation. Electrons are scattered
elastically or inelastically by the positively charged nucleus. The inelastically scattered
electron loses energy, and thus produces X-ray photon, while the elastically scattered
electrons generally change their direction significantly but without loosing much of their
energy.
Bremsstrahlung Radiation
X-ray tubes produce X-ray photons by accelerating a
stream of electrons to energies of several hundred
kiloelectronvolts with velocities of several hundred
kilometers per hour and colliding them into a heavy
target material. The abrupt deceleration of the charged
particles (electrons) produces Bremsstrahlung photons.
X-ray radiation with a continuous spectrum of energies is
produced with a range from a few keV to a maximum of
the energy of the electron beam.
The Bremsstrahlung photons generated within the target material are attenuated as
they pass through, typically, 50 microns of target material. The beam is further
attenuated by the aluminum or beryllium vacuum window. The results are the
elimination of the low energy photons, 1 keV through 15 keV, and a significant reduction
in the portion of the spectrum from 15 keV through 50 keV. The spectrum from an X-ray
tube is further modified by the filtration caused by the selection of filters used in the
setup.
Gamma Radiation
Gamma radiation is one of the three types of natural radioactivity. Gamma rays are
electromagnetic radiation just like X-rays. The other two types of natural radioactivity
are alpha and beta radiation, which are in the form of particles. Gamma rays are the
most energetic form of electromagnetic radiation.
Gamma radiation is the product of radioactive atoms. Depending upon the ratio of
neutrons to protons within its nucleus, an isotope of a particular element may be
stable or unstable. When the binding energy is not strong enough to hold the nucleus of
an atom together, the atom is said to be unstable. Atoms with unstable nuclei are
constantly changing as a result of the imbalance of energy within the nucleus. Over
time, the nuclei of unstable isotopes spontaneously disintegrate, or transform, in a
process known as “radioactive decay” and such material is called “radioactive
material”.
Alpha Particles
Certain radioactive materials of high atomic mass
(such as Ra-226, U-238, Pu-239), decay by the
emission of alpha particles. These alpha particles are
tightly bound units of two neutrons and two protons
each (He-4 nucleus) and have a positive charge.
Emission of an alpha particle from the nucleus results
in a decrease of two units of atomic number (Z) and
four units of mass number (A). Alpha particles are
emitted with discrete energies characteristic of the
particular transformation from which they originate.
All alpha particles from a particular radionuclide
transformation will have identical energies.
Beta Particles
A nucleus with an unstable ratio of neutrons to
protons may decay through the emission of a
high speed electron called a beta particle. In beta
decay a neutron will split into a positively
charged proton and a negatively charged
electron. This results in a net change of one unit
of atomic number (Z) and no change in the mass
number (A). Beta particles have a negative
charge and the beta particles emitted by a
specific radioactive material will range in energy
from near zero up to a maximum value, which is
characteristic of the particular transformation.
Gamma-rays
A nucleus which is in an excited state (unstable nucleus) may emit one or more photons
of discrete energies. The emission of gamma rays does not alter the number
of protons or neutrons in the nucleus but instead has the effect of moving the nucleus
from a higher to a lower energy state (unstable to stable). Gamma ray emission
frequently follows beta decay, alpha decay, and other nuclear decay processes.
In order to find the remaining activity of a certain material with a known half-life value
after a certain period of time, the following formula may be used. The formula
calculates the decay fraction (or the remaining fraction of the initial activity) as:
𝐴
𝑓𝐷 = = (0.5)𝐿𝐻
𝐴
Where;
𝑓𝐷 : decay fraction (i.e., remaining fraction of the initial activity)
𝐿𝐻 : Half-Life value (hours, days, years, etc.)
𝑡 : Elapsed time (hours, days, years, etc.)
Or alternatively, the equitation can be solved to find the time required for activity to
decay to a certain level as:
log𝑓𝐷
𝑡=𝐿
Radiation Energy
The energy of the radiation is responsible for its ability to penetrate matter. Higher
energy radiation can penetrate more and higher density matter than low energy
radiation. The energy of ionizing radiation is measured in electronvolts (eV). One
electronvolt is an extremely small amount of energy so it is common to use
kiloelectronvolts (keV) and megaelectronvolt (MeV). An electronvolt is a measure of
energy, which is different from a volt which is a measure of the electrical potential
between two positions. Specifically, an electronvolt is the kinetic energy gained by an
electron passing through a potential difference of one volt. X-ray generators have a
control to adjust the radiation energy, keV (or kV).
The energy of a radioisotope is a characteristic of the atomic structure of the material.
Consider, for example, Iridium-192 and Cobalt-60, which are two of the more common
industrial Gamma ray sources. These isotopes emit radiation in two or three discreet
wavelengths. Cobalt-60 will emit 1.17 and 1.33 MeV gamma rays, and Iridium-192 will
emit 0.31, 0.47, and 0.60 MeV gamma rays. It can be seen from these values that the
energy of radiation coming from Co-60 is more than twice the energy of the radiation
coming from the Ir-192. From a radiation safety point of view, this difference in energy
is important because the Co-60 has more material penetrating power and, therefore, is
more dangerous and requires more shielding.
Ionization
As penetrating radiation moves from point to point in matter, it loses its energy
through various interactions with the atoms it encounters. The rate at which this energy
loss occurs depends upon the type and energy of the radiation and the density
and atomic composition of the matter through which it is passing.
The various types of penetrating radiation impart their energy to matter primarily
through excitation and ionization of orbital electrons. The term “excitation” is used to
describe an interaction where electrons acquire energy from a passing charged particle
but are not removed completely from their atom. Excited electrons may subsequently
emit energy in the form of X-rays during the process of returning to a lower energy state.
The term “ionization” refers to the complete removal of an electron from an atom
following the transfer of energy from a passing charged particle.
Because of their double charge and relatively slow velocity, alpha particles have a
relatively short range in matter (a few centimeters in air and only fractions of a
millimeter in tissue). Beta particles have, generally, a greater range.
Since they have no charge, gamma-rays and X-rays
proceeds through matter until there is a chance of
interaction with a particle. If the particle is an
electron, it may receive enough energy to be
ionized, whereupon it causes further ionization by
direct interactions with other electrons. As a result,
gamma-rays and X-rays can cause the liberation of
electrons deep inside a medium. As a result, a given
gamma or X-ray has a definite probability of passing
through any medium of any depth.
𝐼1𝑑12 =𝐼 2𝑑22
Where 𝐼1 & 𝐼2 are the intensities at distances 𝑑1 & 𝑑2 form the source, respectively.
These materials have been adapted from [Link] and are reused with permission.
ASNT LEVEL III - RADIOGRAPHIC TESTING (RT)
All measures of exposure or dose rate will drop off by the inverse square law. For
example, if the received dose of radiation is 100 mR/hr at 2 cm from a source, it will be
0.01 mR/hr at 2 m.
𝐼=𝐼
Where;
𝐼0 : initial (unattenuated) intensity
𝜇 : linear attenuation coefficient per unit distance
𝑥 : distance traveled through the matter
Half-Value Layer
The thickness of any given material where 50% of the incident energy has been
attenuated is known as the half-value layer (HVL). The HVL is expressed in units of
distance (mm or cm). Like the attenuation coefficient, it is photon energy dependant.
Increasing the penetrating energy of a stream of photons will result in an increase in a
material's HVL.
The HVL is inversely proportional to the attenuation coefficient. If an incident energy of
1 and a transmitted energy of 0.5 are plugged into the intensity attenuation equation
introduced earlier, solving for 𝑥 which will correspond to the HVL gives:
0.693
0.5 =1𝑒 −𝜇𝑥 𝐻𝑉𝐿=
𝜇
𝐼
𝑟 = = (0.5) Sometimes instead of specifying the
𝐼 HVL, the Tenth Value Layer (TVL) is
specified. The TVL is the thickness
Where 𝑟𝐼 is intensity reduction ratio.
that attenuates 90% of the intensity
Or alternatively, the equitation can be solved to find the (only 10% passes through).
material thickness required for reducing the intensity to In that case, the equation becomes:
a certain level as:
𝐼
𝑟 = = (0.1)
log𝑟𝐼 𝐼
𝑇ℎ𝑖𝑐𝑘𝑛𝑒𝑠𝑠=𝐻𝑉𝐿
Approximate HVL for various materials when radiation is from a gamma-ray source:
Half-Value Layer (mm)
Approximate HVL for some materials when radiation is from an X-ray source:
Sources of Attenuation
The attenuation that results due to the interaction between penetrating radiation and
matter is not a simple process. A single interaction event between a primary X-ray
photon and a particle of matter does not usually result in the photon changing to some
other form of energy and effectively disappearing. Several interaction events are
usually involved and the total attenuation is the sum of the attenuation due to different
types of interactions. These interactions include the photoelectric effect,
scattering, and pair production.
Photoelectric (PE) absorption of X-rays occurs when the X-ray photon is absorbed,
resulting in the ejection of electrons from the outer shell of the atom, and hence
the ionization of the atom. Subsequently, the ionized atom returns to the neutral
state with the emission of an X-ray characteristic of the atom. This subsequent
emission of lower energy photons is generally
absorbed and does not contribute to (or hinder) the
image making process. Photoelectron absorption is
the dominant process for X-ray absorption up to
energies of about 500 keV. Photoelectric absorption
is also dominant for atoms of high atomic numbers.
Compton scattering (C) occurs when the incident X-ray photon is deflected from its
original pathby an interaction with an electron. The electron gains energy and is
ejected from its orbital position. The X-ray
photon loses energy due to the interaction but
continues to travel through the material along an
altered path. Since the scattered X-ray photon has
less energy, it, therefore, has a longer wavelength
than the incident photon.
Pair production (PP) can occur when the X-ray photon energy is greater than 1.02
MeV, but really only becomes significant at energies around 10 MeV. Pair
production occurs when an electron and positron are created with the annihilation
of the X-ray photon. Positrons are very short lived and disappear (positron
annihilation) with the formation of two
photons of 0.51 MeV energy. Pair production
is of particular importance when high-energy
photons pass through materials of a high
atomic number.
X-ray Generators
The major components of an X-ray generator are the tube, the high voltage generator,
the control console, and the cooling system. As discussed earlier in this material, X-rays
are generated by directing a stream of high speed electrons at a target material such as
tungsten, which has a high atomic number. When the electrons are slowed or stopped
by the interaction with the atomic particles of the target, X-radiation is produced. This
is accomplished in an X-ray tube such as the one shown in the figure.
The tube cathode (filament) is heated with a low-voltage current of a few amps. The
filament heats up and the electrons in the wire become loosely held. A large electrical
potential is created between the cathode and the anode by the high-voltage generator.
Electrons that break free of the cathode are strongly attracted to the anode target. The
stream of electrons between the cathode and the anode is the tube
current. The tube current is measured in
milliamps and is controlled by regulating
the low-voltage heating current applied to
the cathode. The higher the temperature of
the filament, the larger the number of
electrons that leave the cathode and travel
to the anode. The milliamp or current
setting on the control console regulates the
filament temperature, which relates to the
intensity of the X-ray output.
The high-voltage between the cathode and the anode affects
the speed at which the electrons travel and strike the anode.
The higher the kilovoltage, the more speed and, therefore,
energy the electrons have when they strike the anode.
Electrons striking with more energy result in X-rays with more
penetrating power. The high-voltage potential is measured in
kilovolts, and this is controlled with the voltage or kilovoltage
control on the control console. An increase in the kilovoltage
will also result in an increase in the intensity of the radiation.
The figure shows the spectrum of the radiated X-rays
associated with the voltage and current settings. The top figure
shows that increasing the kV increases both the energy of
X-rays and also increases the intensity of radiation (number of
photons). Increasing the current, on the other hand, only
increases the intensity without shifting the spectrum.
A focusing cup is used to concentrate the stream of electrons to a small area of the
target called the “focal spot”. The focal spot size is an important factor in the system's
ability to produce a sharp image. Much of the energy applied to the tube is
transformed into heat at the focal spot of the anode. As mentioned above, the anode
target is commonly made from tungsten, which has a high melting point in addition to
a high atomic number. However, cooling of the anode by active or passive means is
necessary. Water or oil re-circulating systems are often used to cool tubes. Some low
power tubes are cooled simply with the use of thermally conductive materials and heat
radiating fins.
In order to prevent the cathode from burning up and to prevent arcing between the
anode and the cathode, all of the oxygen is removed from the tube by pulling a
vacuum. Some systems have external vacuum pumps to remove any oxygen that may
have leaked into the tube. However, most industrial X-ray tubes simply require a
warm-up procedure to be followed. This warm-up procedure carefully raises the tube
current and voltage to slowly burn any of the available oxygen before the tube is
operated at high power.
In addition, X-ray generators usually have a filter along the beam path (placed at or
near the x-ray port). Filters consist of a thin sheet of material (often high atomic number
materials such as lead, copper, or brass) placed in the useful beam to modify the spatial
distribution of the beam. Filtration is required to absorb the lower-energy
X-ray photons emitted by the tube before they reach the target in order to produce a cleaner
image (since lower energy X-ray photons tend to scatter more).
The other important component of an X-ray generating
system is the control console. Consoles typically have a
keyed lock to prevent unauthorized use of the system. They
will have a button to start the generation of X-rays and a
button to manually stop the generation of X-rays. The three
main adjustable controls regulate the tube
voltage in kilovolts, the tube amperage in milliamps, and the
exposure time in minutes and seconds. Some systems also
have a switch to change the focal spot size of the tube.
sources are very portable are the main reasons that gamma sources are widely used
for field radiography. Of course, the disadvantage of a radioactive source is that it can
never be turned off and safely managing the source is a constant responsibility.
Physical size of isotope materials varies between manufacturers, but generally an
isotope material is a pellet that measures 1.5 mm x 1.5 mm. Depending on the level of
activity desired, a pellet or pellets are
loaded into a stainless steel capsule and
sealed by welding. The capsule is
attached to short flexible cable called a
pigtail.
The source capsule and the pigtail are housed in a
shielding device referred to as a exposure device
or camera. Depleted uranium is often used as a
shielding material for sources. The exposure device
for Iridium-192 and Cobalt-60 sources will contain
22 kg and 225 kg of shielding materials,
respectively. Cobalt cameras are often fixed to a
trailer and transported to and from inspection sites.
When the source is not being used to make an
exposure, it is locked inside the exposure device.
To make a radiographic exposure, a crank-
out mechanism and a guide tube are
attached to opposite ends of the exposure
device. The guide tube often has a
collimator (usually made of tungsten) at
the end to shield the radiation except in
the direction necessary to make the
exposure. The end of the guide tube is secured in the location where the radiation
source needs to be to produce the radiograph. The crank-out cable is stretched as far
as possible to put as much distance as possible between the exposure device and the
radiographer. To make the exposure, the radiographer quickly cranks the source out of
the exposure device and into position in the collimator at the end of the guide tube. At
the end of the exposure time, the source is cranked back into the exposure device.
There is a series of safety procedures, which include several radiation surveys, that
must be accomplished when making an exposure with a gamma source.
Radiographic Film
X-ray films for general radiography basically consist of an emulsion-gelatin containing
radiation-sensitive silver halide crystals (such as silver bromide or silver chloride). The
emulsion is usually coated on both sides of a flexible, transparent, blue-tinted base in
layers about 0.012 mm thick. An adhesive undercoat fastens the emulsion to the film
base and a very thin but tough coating covers the emulsion to protect it against minor
abrasion. The typical total thickness of the X-ray film is approximately 0.23 mm.
Though films are made to be sensitive for X-ray or gamma-ray, yet they are also
sensitive to visible light. When X-rays,
gamma-rays, or light strike the film, some
of the halogen atoms are liberated from
the silver halide crystal and thus leaving
the silver atoms alone. This change is of
such a small nature that it cannot be
detected by ordinary physical methods
and is called a “latent (hidden) image”.
When the film is exposed to a chemical
solution (developer) the reaction results in
the formation of black, metallic silver.
Film Selection
Selecting the proper film and developing the optimal radiographic technique for a
particular component depends on a number of different factors;
Composition, shape, and size of the part being examined and, in some cases, its
weight and location.
Type of radiation used, whether X-rays from an X-ray generator or gamma rays
from a radioactive source.
Kilovoltage available with the X-ray equipment or the intensity of the gamma
radiation.
Relative importance of high radiographic detail or quick and economical results.
Film Packaging
Radiographic film can be purchased in a number of different packaging options and they
are available in a variety of sizes. The most basic form is as individual sheets in a box. In
preparation for use, each sheet must be loaded into a cassette or film holder in a
darkroom to protect it from exposure to light.
Industrial X-ray films are also available in a form in which each sheet is enclosed in a
light-tight envelope. The film can be exposed from either side without removing it
from the protective packaging. A rip strip makes it easy to remove the film in the
darkroom for processing.
Packaged film is also available in the form of rolls where that allows the radiographer
to cut the film to any length. The ends of the packaging are sealed with electrical tape
in the darkroom. In applications such as the radiography of circumferential welds and
the examination of long joints on an aircraft fuselage, long lengths of film offer great
economic advantage.
Film Handling
X-ray film should always be handled carefully to avoid physical strains, such as
pressure, creasing, buckling, friction, etc. Whenever films are loaded in semi-flexible
holders and external clamping devices are used, care should be taken to be sure
pressure is uniform. Marks resulting from contact with fingers that are moist or
contaminated with processing chemicals, as well as crimp marks, are avoided if large
films are always grasped by the edges and allowed to hang free. Use of envelope-
packed films avoids many of these problems until the envelope is opened for
processing.
Radiographic Sensitivity
The usual objective in radiography is to produce an image showing the highest amount
of detail possible. This requires careful control of a number of different variables that
can affect image quality. Radiographic sensitivity is a measure of the quality of an
image in terms of the smallest detail or discontinuity that may be detected.
Radiographic sensitivity is dependant on the contrast and the definition of the image.
Radiographic contrast is the degree of density (darkness)
difference between two areas on a radiograph. Contrast makes it
easier to distinguish features of interest, such as defects, from the
surrounding area. The image to the right shows two radiographs of
the same stepwedge. The upper radiograph has a high level of
contrast and the lower radiograph has a lower level of contrast.
While they are both imaging the same change in thickness, the high
contrast image uses a larger change in radiographic density to
show this change. In each of the two radiographs, there is a small
dot, which is of equal density in both radiographs. It is much easier
to see in the high contrast radiograph.
Radiographic definition is the abruptness of change in going from one area of a given
radiographic density to another. Like contrast, definition also makes it easier to see
features of interest, such as defects, but in a totally different
way. In the image to the right, the upper radiograph has a high
level of definition and the lower radiograph has a lower level of
definition. In the high definition radiograph it can be seen that a
change in the thickness of the stepwedge translates to an abrupt
change in radiographic density. It can be seen that the details,
particularly the small dot, are much easier to see in the high
definition radiograph. It can be said that a faithful visual
reproduction of the stepwedge was produced. In the lower
image, the radiographic setup did not produce a faithful visual
reproduction. The edge line between the steps is blurred. This is
evidenced by the gradual transition between the high and low
density areas on the radiograph.
𝐷𝑒𝑛𝑠𝑖𝑡𝑦= log
𝐼
Similar to the decibel, using the log of the ratio allows ratios of significantly different
sizes to be described using easy to work with numbers. The following table shows
numeric examples of the relationship between the amount of transmitted light and the
calculated film density.
Transmittance Transmittance (%) Inverse of Transmittance Density
(It/I0) (I0/It) (Log(I0/It))
1.0 100% 1 0
0.1 10% 10 1
0.01 1% 100 2
0.001 0.1% 1000 3
0.0001 0.01% 10000 4
From the table, it can be seen that a density reading of 2.0 is the result of only one
percent of the incident light making it through the film. At a density of 4.0 only 0.01% of
transmitted light reaches the far side of the film. Industrial codes and standards
typically require a radiograph to have a density between 2.0 and 4.0 for acceptable
viewing with common film viewers. Above 4.0, extremely bright viewing lights is
necessary for evaluation.
Film density is measured with a “densitometer” which simply measures the amount of
light transmitted through a piece of film using a photovoltic sensor.
Radiographic Contrast
As mentioned previously, radiographic contrast describes the differences in
photographic density in a radiograph. The contrast between different parts of the
image is what forms the image and the greater the contrast, the more visible features
become. Radiographic contrast has two main contributors; subject contrast and film
(or detector) contrast.
Subject Contrast
Subject contrast is the ratio of radiation intensities transmitted through different areas
of the component being evaluated. It is dependant on the absorption differences in the
component, the wavelength of the primary radiation, and intensity and distribution of
secondary radiation due to scattering.
It should be no surprise that absorption differences within the subject will affect the
level of contrast in a radiograph. The larger the difference in thickness or density
between two areas of the subject, the larger the difference in radiographic density or
contrast. However, it is also possible to radiograph a
particular subject and produce two radiographs
having entirely different contrast levels. Generating
X-rays using a low kilovoltage will generally result in
a radiograph with high contrast. This occurs because
low energy radiation is more easily attenuated.
Therefore, the ratio of photons that are transmitted
through a thick and thin area will be greater with
low energy radiation.
There is a tradeoff, however. Generally, as contrast sensitivity increases, the latitude of
the radiograph decreases. Radiographic latitude refers to the range of material thickness
that can be imaged. This means that more areas of different thicknesses will be visible
in the image. Therefore, the goal is to balance radiographic contrast and
latitude so that there is enough contrast to identify the features of interest but also to
make sure the latitude is great enough so that all areas of interest can be inspected with
one radiograph. In thick parts with a large range of thicknesses, multiple
radiographs will likely be necessary to get the necessary density levels in all areas.
Film Contrast
Film contrast refers to density differences that result due to the type of film being
used, how it was exposed, and how it was processed. Since there are other detectors
besides film, this could be called detector contrast, but the focus here will be on film.
Exposing a film to produce higher film densities will generally increase the contrast in
the radiograph.
A typical film characteristic curve, which shows how a film responds to different
amounts of radiation exposure, is shown in the figure. From the shape of the curves, it
can be seen that when the film has not seen many photon interactions (which will
result in a low film density) the slope of the curve is low. In this region of the curve, it
takes a large change in exposure to produce a small change in film density. Therefore,
the sensitivity of the film is relatively low. It can be
seen that changing the log of the relative exposure
from 0.75 to 1.4 only changes the film density from
0.20 to about 0.30. However, at film densities above
2.0, the slope of the characteristic curve for most films
is at its maximum. In this region of the curve, a
relatively small change in exposure will result in a
relatively large change in film density. For example,
changing the log of relative exposure from 2.4 to 2.6
would change the film density from 1.75 to 2.75.
Therefore, the sensitivity of the film is high in this
region of the curve. In general, the highest overall
film density that can be conveniently viewed or
digitized will have the highest level of contrast and
contain the most useful information.
As mentioned previously, thin lead sheets (called “lead screens”) are typically placed on
both sides of the radiographic film during the exposure (the film is placed between the
lead screens and inserted inside the cassette). Lead screens in the thickness range of 0.1
to 0.4 mm typically reduce the scattered radiation at energy levels below 150 kV.
Above this energy level, they will emit electrons to provide more exposure of the film,
thus increasing the density and contrast of the radiograph.
Other type of screens called “fluorescent screens” can alternatively be used where they
produce visible light when exposed to radiation and this light further exposes the film
and increases density and contrast.
Radiographic Definition
As mentioned previously, radiographic definition is the abruptness of change from one
density to another. Both geometric factors of the equipment and the radiographic
setup, and film and screen factors have an effect on definition.
Geometric Factors
The loss of definition resulting from geometric factors of the radiographic equipment
and setup is refered to as “geometric unsharpness”. It occurs because the radiation
does not originate from a single point but rather over an area. The three factors
controlling unsharpness are source size, source to object distance, and object to
detector (film) distance. The effects of these three factors on image defenetion is
illustrated by the images below (source size effect; compare A & B, source to object
distance; compare B & D, and object to detector distance; compare B & C).
The source size is obtained by referencing manufacturers specifications for a given X- ray
or gamma ray source. Industrial X-ray tubes often have focal spot sizes of 1.5 mm
squared but microfocus systems have spot sizes in the 30 micron range. As the source
size decreases, the geometric unsharpness also decreases. For a given size source, the
unsharpness can also be decreased by increasing the source to object distance, but this
comes with a reduction in radiation intensity. The object to detector distance is usually
kept as small as possible to help minimize unsharpness. However, there are situations,
such as when using geometric enlargement, when the object is separated from the
detector, which will reduce the definition.
In general, in order to produce the highest level of definition, the focal-spot or source
size should be as close to a point source as possible, the source-to-object distance
example, if one film is exposed at 100 kV for 6 [Link] and a second film is exposed at
the same energy for 3 [Link], then the relative exposure would be 2.
The location of the characteristic curves of different films along the x-axis relates to the
speed of the film. The farther to the right that a curve is on the chart, the slower the
film speed (Film A has the highest speed while film C has the lowest speed). The shape
of the characteristic curve is largely independent of the wavelength of the X-ray or
gamma ray, but the location of the curve along the x-axis, with respect to the curve of
another film, does depend on radiation quality.
Film characteristic curves can be used to adjust the exposure used to produce a
radiograph with a certain density to an exposure that will produce a second radiograph
of higher or lower film density. The curves can also be used to relate the exposure
produced with one type of film to exposure needed to produce a radiograph of the same
density with a second type of film.
Example 1: Adjusting the Exposure to Produce a Different Film Density
A type B Film was exposed with 140 kV at 1 mA for 10 seconds (i.e., 10 mA.s) and
the resulting radiograph had a density of 1.0. If the desired density is 2.5, what
should be the exposure?
From the graph, the log of the relative exposure of a density of 1.0 is 1.62 and the log
of the relative exposure when the density of the film is 2.5 is 2.12.
The difference between the two values is 0.5.
10 0.5 = 3.16
Therefore, the exposure used to produce the
initial radiograph with a 1.0 density needs to be
multiplied by 3.16 to produce a radiograph with
the desired density of 2.5.
So the new exposure must be:
10 mA.s x 3.16 = 31.6 mA.s (at 140 kV)
Exposure Calculations
Properly exposing a radiograph is often a trial and error process, as there are many
variables that affect the final radiograph. Some of the variables that affect the density
of the radiograph include:
The spectrum of radiation produced by the X-ray generator.
The voltage potential used to generate the X-rays (kV).
The amperage used to generate the X-rays (mA).
The exposure time.
The distance between the radiation source and the film.
The material of the component being radiographed.
The thickness of the material that the radiation must travel through.
The amount of scattered radiation reaching the film.
The film being used.
The use of lead screens or fluorescent screens.
The concentration of the film processing chemicals and the contact time.
The current industrial practice is to develop a procedure that produces an acceptable
density by trail for each specific X-ray generator. This process may begin using
published exposure charts to determine a starting exposure, which usually requires
some refinement.
However, it is possible to calculate the density of a radiograph to an acceptable degree
of accuracy when the spectrum of an X-ray generator has been characterized. The
calculation cannot completely account for scattering but, otherwise, the relationship
between many of the variables and their effect on film density is known. Therefore, the
change in film density can be estimated for any given variable change. For example,
from Newton's Inverse Square Law, it is known that the intensity of the radiation varies
inversely with the square of the distance from the source. It is also
known that the intensity of the radiation transmitted through a material varies
exponentially with the linear attenuation coefficient and the thickness of the material.
By calculating the intensity from these equations one can directly calculate the required
exposure knowing that the exposure is inversely related to the intensity as:
𝐼𝑛𝑡𝑒𝑛𝑠𝑖𝑡𝑦 1 × 𝐸𝑥𝑝𝑜𝑠𝑢𝑟𝑒 1 =𝐼𝑛𝑡𝑒𝑛𝑠𝑖𝑡𝑦 2 × 𝐸𝑥𝑝𝑜𝑠𝑢𝑟𝑒 2
The figure below shows exemplary exposure charts for two materials for a specific X-
ray generator for the flowing parameters: film density of 2.0 without screens, 910 mm
source-to-film distance, Industrex AA film & 7 minutes development time.
For gamma-ray sources, however, the required exposure can be more easily calculated
since the radiation spectrum is well known for each different radiation source. The
exposure is usually expressed in Curie-Time units and the data can be represented in the
form of chars or in
tabulated form. The figure
shows a typical exposure chart
for Ir-192 at the following
parameters: film density of
1.75 without screens, 455 mm
source-to-film distance, II-ford
film & 6 minutes development
time.
It should be noted that such charts are valid for the specified parameters, but of course
using the data in the charts one can calculate the exposure for different set of
parameters such as different source-to-film distance, different type of film, or different
density.
Example 1:
A 25 mm thick Aluminum plate is to be radiographed on type C film without screens
using X-ray generator at 80 kV and 500 mm distance. What is the minimum required
exposure time to get 3.0 density (for same development parameters as used for the
chart, and considering the film used for the chart to be type A) knowing that the max
current setting for the X-ray machine is 20 mA?
Answer: 190 s
Example 2:
A 12.5 mm thick Steel plate is to be radiographed without screens using Ir-192 source
at 455 mm distance. Knowing that the source activity was 100 Ci before 30 days, what
is the required exposure time (for same density, film type, and development parameters
as used for the chart) if the plate is to be place behind a 50 mm thick concrete wall
while it is being exposed?
Answer: 104 s
To make such calculations more easy, radiographic modeling calculators and programs
can be used. A number of such
programs are available from
different sources and some are
available online. These programs
can provide a fair representation
of the radiograph that will be
produced with a specific setup and
parameters. The figure shows a
screen shot of an online calculator
available at the ( [Link])
website.
Hole-Type IQIs
ASTM Standard E1025 gives detailed requirements for the design and material group
classification of hole-type image quality indicators. Hole-type IQIs are classified in eight
groups based on their radiation absorption characteristics.
A notching system is used to indicate the IQI material. The
numbers on the IQI indicate the sample thickness that the
IQI would typically be placed on. Also, holes of different
sizes are present where these holes should be visible on the
radiograph. It should be noted however that the IQI is used
to indicate the quality of the radiographic technique and
not intended to be used as a measure of the size of a
cavity that can be located on the radiograph.
Wire IQIs
ASTM Standard E747 covers the radiographic examination of
materials using wire IQIs to control image quality. Wire IQIs consist
of a set of six wires arranged in order of increasing diameter and
encapsulated between two sheets of clear plastic. Wire IQIs are
grouped in four sets each having different range of wire diameters.
The set letter (A, B, C or D) is shown in the lower right corner of the
IQI. The number in the lower left corner indicates the material
group.
Film Processing
As mentioned previously, radiographic film consists of a transparent, blue-tinted base
coated on both sides with an emulsion. The emulsion consists of gelatin containing
microscopic, radiation sensitive silver halide crystals, such as silver bromide and silver
chloride. When X-rays, gamma rays or light rays strike the crystals or grains, some of
the Br- ions are liberated leaving the Ag+ ions. In this condition, the radiograph is said
to contain a latent (hidden) image because the change in the grains is virtually
undetectable, but the exposed grains are now more sensitive to reaction with the
developer.
When the film is processed, it is exposed to several different chemical solutions for
controlled periods of time. Film processing basically involves the following five steps:
Development: The developing agent gives up electrons to convert the silver halide
grains to metallic silver. Grains that have been exposed to the radiation develop
more rapidly, but given enough time the developer will convert all the silver ions
into silver metal. Proper temperature control is needed to convert exposed grains
to pure silver while keeping unexposed grains as silver halide crystals.
Stopping the development: The stop bath simply stops the development process by
diluting and washing the developer away with water.
Fixing: Unexposed silver halide crystals are removed by the fixing bath. The fixer
dissolves only silver halide crystals, leaving the silver metal behind.
Washing: The film is washed with water to remove all the processing chemicals.
Drying: The film is dried for viewing.
Viewing Radiographs
After the film processing, radiographs are viewed
using a light-box (or they can be digitized and viewed
on a high resolution monitor) in order to be
interpreted. In addition to providing diffused,
adjustable white illumination of uniform intensity,
specialized industrial radiography light-boxes
include magnifying and masking aids. When handing
the radiographs, thin cotton gloves should be worn
to prevent fingerprints on the radiographs.
RADIATION SAFETY
effects of radiation are somewhat less damaging than when cells were rapidly
dividing.
Biological differences. Some individuals are more sensitive to radiation than others.
Studies have not been able to conclusively determine the cause of such differences.
and industrial radiography. By far, the most significant source of man-made radiation
exposure to the average person is from medical procedures, such as diagnostic X-rays,
nuclear medicine, and radiation therapy.
Dose Rate: The dose rate is a measure of how fast a radiation dose is being received.
Dose rate is usually presented in terms of mR/hr, mrem/hr, rad/min, mGy/sec, etc.
Knowing the dose rate, allows the dose to be calculated for a period of time.
Time
The radiation dose is directly proportional to the time spent in the radiation.
Therefore, a person should not stay near a source of radiation any longer than
necessary. If a survey meter reads 4 mR/h at a particular location, a total dose of 4 mR
will be received if a person remains at that location for one hour. The received dose
can be simply calculated as: Dose = Dose Rate x Time
When using a gamma camera, it is important to get the source from the
shielded camera to the collimator (a device that shields radiation in some
directions but allow it pass in one or more other directions) as quickly as
possible to limit the time of exposure to the unshielded source.
Distance
Increasing distance from the source of radiation will reduce
the amount of radiation received. As radiation travels from
the source, it spreads out becoming less intense. This
phenomenon can be expressed by the Newton inverse
square law, which states that as the radiation travels out
from the source, the dosage decreases inversely with the
square of the distance: I1 / I2 = D 22/ D 21
Shielding
The third way to reduce exposure to radiation is to place something between the
radiographer and the source of radiation. In general, the more
dense the material the more shielding it will provide. Lead and
concrete are the most commonly used radiation shielding materials
primarily because they are easy to work with and are readily
available materials. Concrete is commonly used in the construction
of radiation vaults. Some vaults will also be lined with lead sheeting
to help reduce the radiation to acceptable levels on the outside.
Exposure Limits
Over the years, numerous recommendations regarding occupational exposure limits
have been developed by international radiation safety commissions. In general, the
guidelines established for radiation exposure have had two principal objectives: 1) to
prevent acute exposure; and 2) to limit chronic exposure to “acceptable” levels.
Current guidelines are based on the conservative assumption that there is no safe level
of exposure. This assumption has led to the general philosophy of not only keeping
exposures below recommended levels or regulation limits but also maintaining all
exposure “as low as reasonably achievable” (ALARA). ALARA is a basic requirement of
current radiation safety practices. It means that every reasonable effort must be made
to keep the dose to workers and the public as far below the required limits as possible.
In general, most international radiation safety codes specify that the dose rate must
not exceed 2mR/hour in any unrestricted area. The specifications for the accumulated
dose per year differ between radiation workers and non-workers. The limits are as
follows:
The shallow-dose equivalent is the external dose to the skin of the whole-body or
extremities from an external source of ionizing radiation. This value is the dose
equivalent at a tissue depth of 0.007 cm averaged over an area of 10 cm2.
The lens dose equivalent is the dose equivalent to the lens of the eye from an
external source of ionizing radiation. This value is the dose equivalent at a tissue
depth of 0.3 cm.
The deep-dose equivalent is the whole-body dose from an external source of ionizing
radiation. This value is the dose equivalent at a tissue depth of 1 cm.
The total effective dose equivalent is the dose equivalent to the whole-body.
(this is 10% of the dose limit that normally applies to radiation workers). The same limit
also applies to persons under the age of 18 years.
Radiation Detectors
Instruments used for radiation measurement fall into two
broad categories:
Rate measuring instruments.
Personal dose measuring instruments.
Rate measuring instruments measure the rate at which
exposure is received (more commonly called the radiation
intensity). Survey meters, audible alarms and area monitors
fall into this category. These instruments present a radiation
intensity reading relative to time, such as R/hr or mR/hr. An analogy can be made
between these instruments and the speedometer of a car because both are measuring
units relative to time.
Dose measuring instruments are those that measure the total amount of exposure
received during a measuring period. The dose measuring instruments, or dosimeters,
that are commonly used in industrial radiography are small devices which are designed
to be worn by an individual to measure the exposure received by the individual. An
analogy can be made between these instruments and the odometer of a car because
both are measuring accumulated units.
Survey Meters
The survey meter is the most important resource a radiographer has
to determine the presence and intensity of radiation. There are many
different models of survey meters available to measure radiation in the
field. They all basically consist of a detector and a readout display.
Analog and digital displays are available. Most of the survey meters
used for industrial radiography use a gas filled detector.
Gas filled detectors consists of a gas filled cylinder with two electrodes having a voltage
applied to them. Whenever the device is brought near radioactive substances, the gas
becomes ionized. The electric field created by the potential difference between the
anode and cathode causes the electrons of each ion pair to move to the anode while the
positively charged gas atom is drawn to the cathode. This results in an electrical signal
that is amplified, correlated to exposure and displayed as a value.
Film Badges
Personnel dosimetry film badges are commonly used to
measure and record radiation exposure due to gamma rays, X-
rays and beta particles. The detector is, as the name implies, a
piece of radiation sensitive film. The film is packaged in a light
proof, vapor proof envelope preventing light, moisture or
chemical vapors from affecting the film. Film badges need to be
worn correctly so that the dose they receive accurately represents the dose the wearer
receives. Whole body badges are worn on the body between the neck and the waist,
often on the belt or a shirt pocket.
The film is contained inside a film holder or badge. The badge
incorporates a series of filters to determine the quality of the
radiation. Radiation of a given energy is attenuated to a different
extent by various types of absorbers. Therefore, the same quantity of
radiation incident on the badge will produce a different degree of
darkening under each filter. By comparing these results, the energy of the radiation
can be determinedand the dose can be calculated knowing the film response for that
energy. The badge holder also contains an open window to determine radiation
exposure due to beta particles (since beta particles are shielded by a thin amount of
material).
The major advantages of a film badge as a personnel monitoring device are that it
provides a permanent record, it is able to distinguish between different energies of
photons, and it can measure doses due to different types of radiation. It is quite accurate
for exposures greater than 100 mR. The major disadvantages are that it must be
developed and read by a processor (which is time consuming) and prolonged heat
exposure can affect the film.
Safety Controls
Since X-ray and gamma radiation are not detectable by the human senses and the
resulting damage to the body is not immediately apparent, a variety of safety controls
are used to limit exposure. The two basic types of radiation safety controls used to
provide a safe working environment are engineered and administrative controls.
Engineered controls include shielding, interlocks, alarms, warning signals, and material
containment. Administrative controls include postings, procedures, dosimetry, and
training.
Engineered controls such as shielding and door interlocks are used to contain the
radiation in a cabinet or a “radiation vault”. Fixed shielding materials are commonly
high density concrete and/or lead. Door interlocks are used to immediately cut the
power to X-ray generating equipment if a door is accidentally
opened when X-rays are being produced. Warning lights are used
to alert workers and the public that radiation is being used.
Sensors and warning alarms are often used to signal that a
predetermined amount of radiation is present. Safety controls
should never be tampered with or bypassed.
When portable radiography is performed, most often it is not practical to place alarms
or warning lights in the exposure area. Ropes (or cordon off
tape) and signs are used to block the entrance to radiation areas
and to alert the public to the presence of radiation. Occasionally,
radiographers will use battery operated flashing lights to alert the
public to the presence of radiation.
Safety regulations classify the areas surrounding the location where ionizing radiation
is present into restricted areas and controlled areas according to the radiation intensity
level:
Restricted areas: Areas with a dose rate higher than 300 mR/h must be secure so that
nobody can enter this area. If anybody accidently enters this area, radiation must be
terminated and the person must be checked. Access is only permitted under specific
conditions and if there is an absolute need for it, the body dose should be calculated
and the personal dose measured.
Control areas: These are areas with dose rates which are equivalent to or higher than
0.75 mR/h. Control areas must be cordoned off and provided with a radiation warning
signs.