.

Comprehensive Analysis of Sherman Alexie’s Evolution

Sherman Alexie’s Evolution, published in 1992, is a poignant critique of the commodification and
erosion of Native American culture under the weight of colonialism and capitalism. Through a
narrative poem structured in five tercets, Alexie employs irony, humor, and potent symbolism—
embodied in Buffalo Bill, the pawn shop, and the museum—to explore the devastating impact of
colonial oppression on Native American identity while subtly highlighting resilience amidst
profound loss. This analysis addresses the poem’s thematic depth, literary devices, and symbolic
elements, weaving together the interplay of cultural commodification, colonial legacy, and systemic
exploitation.
The theme of cultural commodification is central to Evolution, depicted through the transformation
of Native American heritage into a marketable product. Buffalo Bill, a modern incarnation of the
historical William F. Cody, opens a pawn shop on a reservation, strategically located “right across
the border from the liquor store. ” This placement exploits Native American vulnerabilities,
particularly alcoholism, a legacy of colonial disruption. The Indians pawn their possessions —
jewelry, electronics, and a “full-length beaded buckskin outfit / it took Inez Muse 12 years to finish”
—symbolizing the gradual surrender of cultural artifacts. The poem’s climax, where Buffalo Bill
converts the pawn shop into “ THE MUSEUM OF NATIVE AMERICAN CULTURES ” and
“charges the Indians five bucks a head to enter,” is a searing indictment of how colonial powers
repackage and profit from indigenous heritage. This commodification strips Native Americans of
agency, forcing them to pay to access their own identity, a process rooted in systemic exploitation.
The impact of colonialism on Native American identity is intricately woven into the poem ’ s
narrative. Colonialism, historically enacted through land treaties, forced displacement, and cultural
erasure, manifests in the poem as a relentless stripping away of Native identity. The progression of
pawning escalates from material goods to body parts—“their hands, saving the thumbs for last,”
“their skeletons, falling endlessly from the skin,” and finally “his heart” for “twenty bucks.”
This gruesome imagery symbolizes the dehumanization of Native Americans, reducing them to
mere commodities. The heart, a metaphor for cultural and spiritual essence, being pawned for a
trivial sum underscores the colonial devaluation of Native identity. The museum’s creation further
alienates Native Americans from their heritage, reflecting how colonial institutions like museums
and reservations gatekeep indigenous culture, perpetuating a cycle of dispossession.
The interplay of loss and resilience is a subtle yet powerful undercurrent in Evolution. The poem
vividly portrays loss—material, cultural, and existential—as Native Americans pawn everything,
culminating in the loss of their heart. This trajectory mirrors historical traumas like the Trail of
Tears and reservation policies that eroded Native sovereignty. However, resilience emerges through
Alexie ’ s act of writing the poem itself. By exposing the mechanics of cultural theft with biting
clarity, Alexie reclaims narrative control, asserting a Native voice in the face of silencing. The
poem’ s accessibility and humor make it a tool for cultural survival, inviting readers to confront
these injustices and recognize Native resilience, a hallmark of Alexie’s broader oeuvre.
Alexie’s use of irony and humor sharpens his critique of capitalist exploitation. The irony is stark in
the pawn shop’s transformation into a museum, which glorifies Native culture after plundering it.
The name The Museum of Native American Cultures is a satirical jab at colonial hypocrisy, as it
charges Native Americans to view their own heritage. Humor, though dark, surfaces in absurd
images like pawning skeletons or a heart for “ twenty bucks, ” making the grotesque reality of
exploitation palpable. This blend of irony and humor critiques capitalism ’ s role in perpetuating
colonial harm, as Buffalo Bill ’ s 24/7 pawn shop preys on economic desperation, a direct
consequence of reservation poverty.
Symbolism reinforces the poem ’ s themes of cultural loss and exploitation. The pawn shop
represents systemic exploitation, functioning as a capitalist mechanism that extracts Native wealth
and culture under the guise of fair trade. Its proximity to the liquor store symbolizes how colonial
legacies like addiction are weaponized to deepen economic dependency. The museum, conversely,
symbolizes the ultimate commodification, where Native culture is curated for profit, inaccessible to
its creators without payment. These symbols collectively illustrate how colonial systems —
economic, cultural, and institutional—dismantle Native identity.
Buffalo Bill’s role as a symbol of colonial oppression ties these elements together. As a historical
figure who popularized Wild West shows, Buffalo Bill exploited Native American imagery for
entertainment. In the poem, he embodies colonial and capitalist greed, orchestrating the systematic
dispossession of Native Americans. His actions—cataloguing pawned items, closing the shop, and
opening the museum — mirror historical patterns of land theft, forced assimilation, and cultural
appropriation. Buffalo Bill ’ s omnipresence in the poem underscores the enduring presence of
colonial power in modern systems.
In conclusion, Evolution is a masterful critique of cultural commodification, colonial impact, and
systemic exploitation, achieved through irony, humor, and symbolism. The pawn shop and museum
encapsulate the mechanisms of cultural loss, while Buffalo Bill personifies colonial oppression. Yet,
amidst profound loss, Alexie’s narrative voice asserts resilience, making Evolution a vital text in
American Literature for understanding Native American experiences. By exposing these injustices,
Alexie challenges readers to confront the ongoing legacy of colonialism and recognize the enduring
strength of Native identity.