Grey Water Treatment via Biofiltration
Grey Water Treatment via Biofiltration
net/publication/316086839
CITATIONS READS
3 2,324
2 authors, including:
Shrinithivihahshini Dandapani
Bharathidasan University
30 PUBLICATIONS 126 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Shrinithivihahshini Dandapani on 13 April 2017.
International
Journal of Recent Research and Applied Studies
(Multidisciplinary Open Access Refereed e-Journal)
Research Scholar, Assistant Professor, Environmental Microbiology and Toxicology Laboratory, Department of Environmental Management, School of
Environmental Sciences, Bharathidasan University, Tiruchirappalli, Tamilnadu, India.
Abstract
Wastewater from household use discharged to the environment without any sort of treatment, which causes
harmful effects to the surroundings and surface ground water pollution. There are various treatment methods available for
treating the grey waters with and without help of physical methods, chemical and biological materials. In the present study,
the grey water samples were collected from the student hostel of Bharathidasan University on a daily basis around 35 days
(300 liters/day). A total of 10,500 liter greywater was treated in this study through continuous (four different bio-bed)
treatment tank processes with the help of natural absorbents such as sand, pea gravel, coir waste, charcoal, and
Lipianodiflora and Canna indica. The combinations of these ingredients were aligned in the treatment tank with different
propositions as well as different orders. The before and after treatment grey water samples were analyzed by
physiochemical analysis. The range of physiochemical parameters such as pH, EC, TDS, total alkalinity (TA), total
hardness (TH), dissolved oxygen (DO), biological oxygen demand (BOD), and chemical oxygen demand (COD) in
untreated and treated grey water were 8.3–8.7, 1812.0–1980.0 µS/cm, 1129.7–1220.0 mg/L, 272–330 mg/L, 384.2–455.0
mg/L, 0.2–0.6 mg/L, 137.6–157.1 mg/L, 362.9–420.0 mg/L; and 7.94–8.2, 642.3–760.0 µS/cm, 410–490.0 mg/L, 136–160
mg/L, 139.6–165.0 mg/L, 3.9–4.9 mg/L, 16.34–20.3 mg/L, and 68.2–78.0 mg/L, respectively. The 1–3-fold level of
pollution was decreased in treated grey water than untreated grey water owing to the efficacy of bio-filters.
Keywords: Grey water, bio-bed filters, Lipianodiflora, Canna indica, physiochemical parameters.
© Copy Right, IJRRAS, 2017. All Rights Reserved.
31
International Journal of Recent Research and Applied Studies, Volume 4, Issue 2 (8) February 2017
Devi et al. 2017 ISSN: 2349 – 4891
32
International Journal of Recent Research and Applied Studies, Volume 4, Issue 2 (8) February 2017
Devi et al. 2017 ISSN: 2349 – 4891
Experimental set-up of bio-bed 2 oxygen demand, and total organic carbon) were
Sand (7 cm), coir waste (6 cm), and sand (7 cm) measured in the laboratory using the standard
materials were filled the TT2 horizontally up to 20 cm procedures(APHA, 2005; Vigneshet al., 2014, 2015,
(h). The remaining 3 cm was unfilled to allow the water 2016). The physiochemical parameters were analyzed in
samples entering into the structure. Similar to TT1, the both raw and treated (after it passed 4 TT) grey water
Lipianodiflorawas transplanted into the TT2 and the set- samples every day.
up was not disturbed up to 60 days for allowing
sufficient growth of L. nodiflora. The separate pipeline Results and discussion
(outlet) from TT1 was connected with TT2, and the TT1 The range of physiochemical parameters such
treated grey water was passed through this pipeline. as pH, EC, TDS, total alkalinity (TA), total hardness
(TH), dissolved oxygen (DO), biological oxygen demand
Experimental set-up of bio-bed 3 (BOD), and chemical oxygen demand (COD) in
The gravel (2 cm) was added in the bottom of untreated grey water were 8.3–8.7, 1812.0–1980.0
the TT3 followed by creamy layer of clay (which was µS/cm, 1129.7–1220.0 mg/L, 272–330 mg/L, 384.2–
collected from where it grew), red soil (14.5 cm), and 455.0 mg/L, 0.2–0.6 mg/L, 137.6–157.1 mg/L, 362.9–
humus (partially degraded plant debris) (3 cm). The 420.0 mg/L, respectively. The mean concentration of
remaining 3 cm was unfilled to allow the water samples physiochemical parameters such as phenolphthalein
entering into the structure. Then, the Canna indica(60 alkalinity (PA), total alkalinity (TA), total hardness (TH),
tillers) was transplanted into the TT3 with 15 cm depth, calcium hardness (CH), carbonate (CO32-), bicarbonate
and each plant was transplanted with 5-cm gap. This set- (HCO3-), calcium (Ca), magnesium (Mg), chloride (Cl -),
up was not disturbed upto 60 days for allowing sufficient nitrate (NO3-), phosphate (PO43-), sulphate (SO42-),
growth of Canna indica. A separate pipeline (outlet) sodium (Na), and potassium (K) in untreated grey water
from TT2 was connected with TT3, and the TT2 treated were 15.3, 272, 384.2, 205.5, 18.3, 294.6, 82.5, 43.4,
grey water was passed through it. 270, 18.09, 3.5, 45.20, 118.4, and 18.97 mg/L,
respectively. During this study period (around 35 days),
Experimental set-up of Filter bed 4 the parameters were not highly fluctuated and the
The TT4 was filled horizontally from the untreated gray samples were collected from same place.
bottom with sand (8 cm) followed by charcoal (7cm) and The EC value of untreated grey water (routine kitchen
sand (5cm).The remaining 3 cm was unfilled to allow the waste of the Bharathidasan University hostel) was not
water samples entering into the structure. No plant crossed 1000 µs/cm as well as standard permissible level
materials were transplanted in the TT4.A separate of WHO (2003) and BIS (1991). The physiochemical
pipeline (outlet) from TT3 was connected with TT4, and parameters of untreated and treated grey water samples
the TT3 treated grey water was passed through it. were summarized in (Figures II–XV).
A total of 10,500 liter of grey water was treated Waite (2006) reported that grey water in two
through TT system over a period of 35 days. The reason sites at Oman had a mean EC of 817.0 μS/cm and 1045.2
for keeping the standard 8-hour running period is in real- μS/cm, respectively. Various studies on grey water
time situation, grey water generation at homes is taking quality in different countries have been published and the
place on an average for 8 hours (morning 10.30 a.m to EC ranges from 325.0 to 1140.0 μS/cm (Jeppesen, 1996).
evening 5.30 p.m). Based on the Jeppesen (1996) report, the average EC
level in our study was slightly increased when compared
Treatment processes to the previous reports. According to the standard
Physicochemical parameters such as pH, classification of EC of grey water (Eriksson et al., 2002),
electrical conductivity (EC), total dissolved solids (TDS) the results from the studied samples were within the
(Henna, HI 9811-5), and dissolved oxygen (DO) (Lutron, range of around 1700–2000. This untreated grey water
DO-5509) were measured using field kit on the site, and may be used for garden irrigation and the EC increases
other parameters (total alkalinity, carbonate, bicarbonate, on a frequent basis, and for a prolonged period, certain
total hardness, calcium hardness, calcium, magnesium, sensitive plants could suffer salt injury (Eriksson et al.,
chloride, nitrate, phosphate, sulphate sodium, potassium, 2002).
dissolved oxygen, biological oxygen demand, chemical
33
International Journal of Recent Research and Applied Studies, Volume 4, Issue 2 (8) February 2017
Devi et al. 2017 ISSN: 2349 – 4891
Table 1
Comparison of untreated and treated grey water: physicochemical parameters in Canna plant (T-test)
Greywater
Untreated Treated t value P value
Parameters Mean±SD Mean±SD
pH 8.33±00.21 7.94±00.10 9.722 <0.001**
EC (µS/cm) 1812.00±92.86 642.29±60.30 62.503 <0.001**
TDS (mg/L) 1130±00.06 410±00.04 60.839 <0.001**
TA (mg/L) 272.00±32.00 136.00±12.59 23.399 <0.001**
PA (mg/L) 15.29±15.00 0 6.030 <0.001**
CO32- (mg/L) 18.34±18.00 0 6.030 <0.001**
HCO3- (mg/L) 294.66±12.26 166.03±15.37 38.699 <0.001**
TH (mg/L) 384.29±36.74 139.66±14.31 36.709 <0.001**
CaH (mg/L) 205.60±18.50 78.86±08.68 36.697 <0.001**
Ca+2 (mg/L) 82.34±07.41 31.60±03.46 36.697 <0.001**
+2
Mg (mg/L) 43.40±04.63 14.80±02.23 32.887 <0.001**
Cl- (mg/L) 270.00±17.37 102.69±08.45 51.237 <0.001**
NO3- (mg/L) 18.09±03.33 5.57±00.85 21.550 <0.001**
PO4-3 (mg/L) 3.55±00.17 0.93±00.09 80.239 <0.001**
SO4-2 (mg/L) 45.20±03.27 8.89±01.13 62.084 <0.001**
+
Na (mg/L) 118.40±18.67 25.43±03.23 29.026 <0.001**
K+ (mg/L) 18.97±03.90 3.86±00.81 22.452 <0.001**
DO (mg/L) 0.19±00.16 3.93±00.51 41.446 <0.001**
BOD3 (mg/L) 137.69±10.65 16.34±02.76 65.218 <0.001**
COD (mg/L) 362.91±29.56 68.23±06.70 57.521 <0.001**
Note : 1. ** denotes significance at 1% level
Table 2
Percentage reduction of Physicochemical and biological characteristics of Untreated and Treated greywater
Parameters Untreated grey water Treated grey water % Removal
pH 8.33±00.21 7.94±00.10 5
EC (µS/cm) 1812.00±92.86 642.29±60.30 65
TDS (mg/L) 1130±00.06 410±00.04 64
TA (mg/L) 272.00±32.00 136.00±12.59 100
PA (mg/L) 15.29±15.00 0 50
CO32- (mg/L) 18.34±18.00 0 100
HCO3- (mg/L) 294.66±12.26 166.03±15.37 44
TH (mg/L) 384.29±36.74 139.66±14.31 64
CaH (mg/L) 205.60±18.50 78.86±08.68 62
Ca+2 (mg/L) 82.34±07.41 31.60±03.46 62
Mg+2 (mg/L) 43.40±04.63 14.80±02.23 66
Cl- (mg/L) 270.00±17.37 102.69±08.45 62
NO3- (mg/L) 18.09±03.33 5.57±00.85 69
PO4-3 (mg/L) 3.55±00.17 0.93±00.09 74
SO4-2 (mg/L) 45.20±03.27 8.89±01.13 80
Na+ (mg/L) 118.40±18.67 25.43±03.23 79
K+ (mg/L) 18.97±03.90 3.86±00.81 80
DO (mg/L) 0.19±00.16 3.93±00.51 95
BOD3 (mg/L) 137.69±10.65 16.34±02.76 88
COD (mg/L) 362.91±29.56 68.23±06.70 81
(Concentration is reported as Mean values ± Std. deviation).
34
International Journal of Recent Research and Applied Studies, Volume 4, Issue 2 (8) February 2017
Devi et al. 2017 ISSN: 2349 – 4891
This treatment study demonstrated that there is loss of efficiency in biological things (Campos et al.,
potential for application of low-technology grey water 2002). The treatment system successfully reduced the
treatment at small-scale level. The pollutant (organic load of the pollution in a large extent due to the
matter, nutrients, and bacteria) removal efficiencies absorption efficacy of plants.
achieved by treating grey water with a sand, gravel, and
two important plants indicated that the bio-filters could Conclusion
reduce (1-3-fold) the pollution load in grey water. The The continuous treatment (bio-bed) system
range of physiochemical parameters such as pH, EC, greatly improved the grey water quality with a low-cost
TDS, total alkalinity (TA), total hardness (TH), dissolved process and the process is less time consuming. The
oxygen (DO), biological oxygen demand (BOD) and different bio-bed filters were designed with low cost and
chemical oxygen demand (COD) in treated grey water easily available raw materials and eco-friendly materials
were 7.9–8.2, 642.3–760.0 µS/cm, 410–490.0 mg/L, for treatment process. The bio-bed filters gradually
136.0–160 mg/L, 139.6–165.0 mg/L, 3.9–4.9 mg/L, reduced the pollution due to use of natural filters such as
16.34–20.3 mg/L, and 68.2–78.0 mg/L, respectively. The sand, pea gravels, and plants. Even though the different
mean concentration of physiochemical parameters such bio-beds reduced the level of physiochemical parameters
as phenolphthalein alkalinity (PA), calcium hardness in grey water, the treated water contained low range of
(CH), carbonate (CO32-), bicarbonate (HCO3-), calcium all the parameters, except a few parameters. Based on the
(Ca), magnesium (Mg), chloride (Cl-), nitrate (NO3-), findings of this study, this treatment technology could be
phosphate (PO43-), sulphate (SO42-), sodium (Na), considered as an alternative methodology to treat the
potassium (K) in treated grey water were 0.0–0.0, 78.8– grey water in both small- and large-scale level. The
95 mg/L, 0.0–0.0, 166.03–195.2 mg/L, 31.60–38.1,14.8– benefits found are low energy demand, less operating
19.4, 102.69–117, 5.5–6.9, 0.9–1.2, 8.8–13.7, 25.43– and maintenance cost, highly effective purification, and
33.2, and 3.8–5.1 mg/L, respectively. Pollutant removal less area occupied. Hence, this study concluded that bio-
processes may delay through the usage of different filters bed-based treatment is effective than other natural
and also biofilm formation, particle agglomeration, and treatment processes.
Figure
1. pH of Untreated greywater and Treated Greywater
pH
8.8
8.6
8.4
8.2
8.0
7.8 Untreated
7.6 Treated
7.4
7.2
D13
D15
D17
D19
D21
D23
D25
D27
D29
D31
D33
D35
D1
D3
D5
D7
D9
D11
Number of Days
35
International Journal of Recent Research and Applied Studies, Volume 4, Issue 2 (8) February 2017
Devi et al. 2017 ISSN: 2349 – 4891
Electrical Conductivity
2500
2000
EC(µs/cm)
1500
1000
Untreated
500
Treated
0
D13
D15
D17
D19
D21
D23
D25
D27
D29
D31
D33
D35
D1
D3
D5
D7
D9
D11
Number of Days
0.80
0.60
Untreated
0.40
Treated
0.20
0.00
Number of Days
36
International Journal of Recent Research and Applied Studies, Volume 4, Issue 2 (8) February 2017
Devi et al. 2017 ISSN: 2349 – 4891
Total Alkalinity
350
300
250
200
mg/L
150
Untreated
100
Treated
50
0
D19
D1
D3
D5
D7
D9
D11
D13
D15
D17
D21
D23
D25
D27
D29
D31
D33
D35
Number of Days
Carbonate
70
60
50
40
mg/L
30 Untreated
20 Treated
10
0
D1 D4 D7 D10 D13 D16 D19 D22 D25 D28 D31 D34
Number of Days
37
International Journal of Recent Research and Applied Studies, Volume 4, Issue 2 (8) February 2017
Devi et al. 2017 ISSN: 2349 – 4891
Bicarbobate
350
300
250
200
mg/L
150 Untreated
100 Treated
50
0
D1 D4 D7 D10 D13 D16 D19 D22 D25 D28 D31 D34
Number of Days
Total Hardness
500
450
400
350
300
mg/L
250
200 Untreated
150
100 Treated
50
0
Number of Days
38
International Journal of Recent Research and Applied Studies, Volume 4, Issue 2 (8) February 2017
Devi et al. 2017 ISSN: 2349 – 4891
Calcium Hardness
300
250
200
mg/L
150
100 Untreated
Treated
50
Number of Days
Calcium
120
100
80
mg/L
60
Untreated
40
Treated
20
0
D1 D4 D7 D10 D13 D16 D19 D22 D25 D28 D31 D34
Number of Days
39
International Journal of Recent Research and Applied Studies, Volume 4, Issue 2 (8) February 2017
Devi et al. 2017 ISSN: 2349 – 4891
Magnesium
60
50
40
mg/L
30
Untreated
20
Treated
10
0
D17
D31
D11
D13
D15
D19
D21
D23
D25
D27
D29
D33
D35
D1
D3
D5
D7
D9
Number of Days
Chloride
350
300
250
200
mg/L
150
Untreated
100
Treated
50
0
D13
D21
D11
D15
D17
D19
D23
D25
D27
D29
D31
D33
D35
D5
D1
D3
D7
D9
Number of Days
40
International Journal of Recent Research and Applied Studies, Volume 4, Issue 2 (8) February 2017
Devi et al. 2017 ISSN: 2349 – 4891
Nitrate
30
25
20
mg/L
15
Untreated
10
Treated
5
0
D1 D4 D7 D10 D13 D16 D19 D22 D25 D28 D31 D34
Number of Days
Phosphate
4.5
4.0
3.5
3.0
mg/L
2.5
2.0
1.5 Untreated
1.0 Treated
0.5
0.0
D29
D9
D1
D3
D5
D7
D11
D13
D15
D17
D19
D21
D23
D25
D27
D31
D33
D35
Number of Days
41
International Journal of Recent Research and Applied Studies, Volume 4, Issue 2 (8) February 2017
Devi et al. 2017 ISSN: 2349 – 4891
Sulphate
60
50
40
mg/L
30
Untreated
20
Treated
10
0
D1 D4 D7 D10 D13 D16 D19 D22 D25 D28 D31 D34
Number of Days
Sodium
160
140
120
100
mg/L
80
60 Untreated
40 Treated
20
0
D23
D11
D13
D15
D17
D19
D21
D25
D27
D29
D31
D33
D35
D1
D3
D5
D7
D9
Number of Days
42
International Journal of Recent Research and Applied Studies, Volume 4, Issue 2 (8) February 2017
Devi et al. 2017 ISSN: 2349 – 4891
Potassium
30
25
20
mg/L
15
10 Untreated
Treated
5
0
Number of Days
Dissolved Oxygen
6.0
5.0
4.0
mg/L
3.0
2.0 Untreated
Treated
1.0
0.0
Number of Days
43
International Journal of Recent Research and Applied Studies, Volume 4, Issue 2 (8) February 2017
Devi et al. 2017 ISSN: 2349 – 4891
80
Untreated
60
Treated
40
20
0
D1 D4 D7 D10 D13 D16 D19 D22 D25 D28 D31 D34
Number of Days
250
200
150 Untreated
100 Treated
50
0
Number of Days
44
International Journal of Recent Research and Applied Studies, Volume 4, Issue 2 (8) February 2017
Devi et al. 2017 ISSN: 2349 – 4891
Please cite this article as: Rengaraj Chithra Devi & Nirmaladevi D. Shrinithivihahshini (2017). Removal of
Physicochemical Parameters of Grey Water Using Biofiltration Techniques. International Journal of Recent 45
International
Research and Journal of Recent
Applied Research
Studies, and31-45.
4, 2(8), Applied Studies, Volume 4, Issue 2 (8) February 2017