0% found this document useful (0 votes)
302 views5 pages

Page Quality Rating Guidelines

The Page Quality Task Guide provides a framework for assessing the quality of landing pages and websites using a PQ grid, where users must select checkboxes that best describe the page. The grid's color coding indicates the quality level, ranging from Lowest to Highest, and users must assign an overall rating based on their observations. Comments are required to justify the assigned ratings, especially when there is a discrepancy between the grid and the overall assessment.

Uploaded by

Ahmed Al Galib
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
302 views5 pages

Page Quality Rating Guidelines

The Page Quality Task Guide provides a framework for assessing the quality of landing pages and websites using a PQ grid, where users must select checkboxes that best describe the page. The grid's color coding indicates the quality level, ranging from Lowest to Highest, and users must assign an overall rating based on their observations. Comments are required to justify the assigned ratings, especially when there is a discrepancy between the grid and the overall assessment.

Uploaded by

Ahmed Al Galib
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

Page Quality Task Guide

The PQ grid is designed to be your "notepad". You can record your observations about the landing
page and website it belongs to. You must check at least one checkbox in each row that best
describes the landing page or website. You may check other checkboxes in the row, but for most
tasks, 1-2 boxes at most will apply per row.
Each square in the PQ grid will be colored (and shaded) based on your response per the table
below:
● Blue is used for Low or Lowest quality characteristics. Green is used for High or Highest
page quality characteristics (note: these options have high/very high standards).
● Lighter shades of blue/green indicate that the response should play a smaller role in
assigning the overall PQ rating. Darker shades of blue/green indicate that the response
should play a bigger role in the overall rating.

Assigning an Overall Page Quality Rating

After recording your observations in the grid, please assign an overall PQ rating using the slider.
Your responses in the grid should inform and support your overall PQ rating.

Color of Grid Overall PQ Ratings


Squares

Dark Blue Pages with one dark blue grid square should usually be rated Lowest.

Medium Blue Pages with one medium blue grid square should usually be rated Low.

Gray Pages with mostly gray grid squares should usually be rated Medium.

Light Green Light green is a "use your judgment" color. Pages with gray and light green squares should
usually be rated Medium, but may be rated Medium+ depending on the purpose of the page
and other PQ characteristics.

Medium Green Pages with all green and gray grid squares, and at least one medium green square, should
usually be rated High.
Note: there is a high standard for using these checkboxes.

Dark Green Pages with all green and gray grid squares, and a dark green square, should usually be rated
Highest.
Note: there is a very high standard for using these checkboxes.

Comments are necessary. Kindly explain your PQ rating using your observations, without simply
restating what's on the grid. Here's a good example of a comment: "Because this is a YMYL
health page, high quality MC and very positive reputation as a medical authority website justify
the Highest rating."

Sometimes, the grid might not fully clarify or support your rating. When you think there's a
difference between the grid and your rating, please provide additional information in your
comments. For instance: "I feel the best overall rating is High. The website was created by a
photography expert and has high quality content, even though the navigation is a bit clumsy."

TELUS International Digital Solutions This material contains information that is proprietary and confidential to TELUS International. It cannot be
shared with third parties without TELUS International written consent. DO NOT COPY. DO NOT DISTRIBUTE.
Sample Task: Questions

The questions and grid are


there to guide you to help
determine your overall
Page Quality rating.

TELUS International Digital Solutions This material contains information that is proprietary and confidential to TELUS International. It cannot be
shared with third parties without TELUS International written consent. DO NOT COPY. DO NOT DISTRIBUTE.
Sample Task: Grid

TELUS International Digital Solutions


Page Quality Examples:

[Link]
d1/the_queen_is_dead

Rating Explanation:
The purpose of this page is to share a
conspiracy theory that the late Queen had
passed (at the time this was posted she had
not). Although the page is on a conspiracy
subReddit (the content is not being
presented as factual), some responses to
this thread were facetious and others
appeared to be engaging seriously which
could be seen as “mildly harmful”. Because
the MC is inaccurate and misleading the
accepted rating is Lowest to Low.

[Link]
erbrace-in-bordermatrix

Rating Explanation:
The purpose of this page is to discuss
coding languages. The forum is from
2016 and lacks in depth discussion.
Although Stack Exchange is a known
programming community with a large
number of members, there is a lack of
satisfying MC as the one response to the
query does not answer the question. For
these reasons, a range of Low to Low+ is
accepted.

TELUS International Digital Solutions This material contains information that is proprietary and confidential to TELUS International. It cannot be
shared with third parties without TELUS International written consent. DO NOT COPY. DO NOT DISTRIBUTE.
Page Quality Examples:

[Link]

Rating Explanation:
The purpose of this page is to provide
information on the New Jersey RN License
guide. The information given is up to date,
and the page achieves its purpose well.
There is high quality MC providing detailed
information about the New Jersey Board of
Nursing and available jobs. Vivian is a
reputable platform for healthcare jobs with
a high E-E-A-T. However, this is just one of
many online resources for healthcare jobs
and would not be uniquely authoritative on
the subject. For these reasons, the range
Medium+ to High is accepted.

[Link]
y-husband-who-has-dementia-with-lewy-bodies-a-per Rating Explanation:
sonal-account-by-meg-wilkes.109400
This is a Dementia Support Forum page that
discusses an excerpt from the book “Dementia
with Lewy Bodies and Parkinson's Disease
Dementia”. There are many responses
describing how they relate to the excerpt and
their experience with loved ones diagnosed
with dementia. The focus of the page is
experience, not medical advice. The
responses are based on personal experience
and are helpful for this topic. There is a very
high E-E-A-T and a positive website
reputation. For these reasons, the range High
to Highest is accepted.

TELUS International Digital Solutions

Common questions

Powered by AI

Grid squares help evaluators note observations about a page's characteristics, guiding them to inform and support their overall PQ rating assignment. Their colors and shades indicate the level of quality and influence the role in the final rating .

High E-E-A-T positively impacts page quality ratings by providing credibility and trustworthiness. Pages with high E-E-A-T are more likely to be rated High or Highest due to their authoritative and reliable information .

The 'use your judgment' light green color is influenced by both the purpose of the page and additional page quality characteristics. It indicates evaluators should consider context and nuances in cases where the grid does not clearly dictate a standard rating .

The page was rated Lowest to Low because it contained inaccurate and misleading main content. Despite being on a non-factual content platform, the presence of responses treating the content seriously presented a "mildly harmful" element, validating the low rating .

Comments should clarify and justify the rating by providing additional context and details from observations, rather than repeating the grid descriptions. This helps explain the rationale behind the evaluator's decision .

Evaluators should provide additional comments to explain why their rating differs from the grid's suggestion. This involves detailing their observations without merely repeating grid descriptions, thereby justifying the rating effectively .

The Alzheimer’s support forum offers high E-E-A-T and contains valuable, supportive content based on personal experiences rather than medical advice. The positive reputation and helpful responses within personal accounts justify the High to Highest rating .

A lack of satisfying main content in a coding forum, such as inadequate depth or unsatisfactory responses to queries, does not meet user expectations for a quality discussion platform, resulting in a Low to Low+ rating .

The page provides up-to-date information, achieves its purpose well, and presents high-quality main content about the New Jersey Board of Nursing and available jobs. Vivian is recognized as a reputable platform with high E-E-A-T, yet it is not uniquely authoritative, leading to a Medium+ to High rating .

Grid squares are colored based on page quality characteristics where blue is used for Low or Lowest quality traits and green for High or Highest traits. Lighter shades indicate a smaller role in the overall PQ rating, whereas darker shades indicate a larger role. It requires a high standard to assign green ratings due to its implications of quality .

You might also like