0% found this document useful (0 votes)
90 views10 pages

Right to Repair: E-Waste Solutions

Uploaded by

ahmetfurkanek1
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
90 views10 pages

Right to Repair: E-Waste Solutions

Uploaded by

ahmetfurkanek1
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

Reflect Reading & Writing, Level 5: Unit 2 Assessment

Name: Class: Date:

VOCABULARY
Choose the correct word to complete each sentence.

1. Let’s ____________ instead of working separately. We’ll finish faster and do a better job.
a. eliminate b. extend c. collaborate
2. In their ____________, researchers asked participants for their opinions about recycling.
a. survey b. purchase c. principle
3. I need to ____________ my computer. This one is five years old and doesn’t work very well anymore.
a. extend b. wear out c. upgrade
4. When we moved to a smaller home, we had to give away many of our ____________.
a. principles b. possessions c. components
5. Many cities are trying to ____________ plastic bags and bottles.
a. upgrade b. eliminate c. extract
6. The ____________ in this cell phone are made in many different countries.
a. components b. flaws c. possessions
7. We know that a ____________ is causing the problem with the computer program, but we are not sure
how to fix it.
a. purchase b. principle c. flaw
8. Clean energy, like solar and wind, is the ____________ to slowing climate change.
a. key b. demand c. principle
9. The ____________ for energy is increasing dramatically, especially in the developing world.
a. claim b. key c. demand
10. In the past, we ____________ energy from the earth. Today, we have cleaner sources of energy.
a. eliminated b. extracted c. extended

GRAMMAR
Re-write each sentence with the correct passive verb form.

11. People are using more gas every year.


More gas _______________________ every year.

12. People throw millions of pieces of furniture into landfills every year.
Millions of pieces of furniture _______________________ into landfills every year.

13. The professors reviewed college admission applications last week.


College admission applications _______________________ last week.

14. Engineers are designing products that last longer.


Products _______________________ that last longer.

15. We don’t use the university identity card on campus anymore.


The university identity card _______________________ on campus anymore.

©2021 National Geographic Learning, a Cengage Learning Company 1


16. We could repair devices when they break.
Devices _______________________ when they break.

17. Scientists published the results of the study in an important journal.


The results of the study _______________________ in an important journal.

18. People shouldn’t waste a valuable resource like food.


A valuable resource like food _______________________.

READING FOR MAIN IDEAS


Read the text. Then match the main idea to the correct paragraph. Not all main ideas are used.

THE RIGHT TO REPAIR


A Every year, people throw away thousands of phones, computers, and electric appliances, such
as washing machines and toasters. This is called e-waste, and we produce a lot of it—about 50 million
tons every year. Around 80 percent of it ends up in landfill. In fact, e-waste is the fastest-growing type
of waste on the planet, but we could slow this trend by changing our relationship with our possessions.

B There are two main reasons for this growing problem. First, the quality of many products has
decreased. Manufacturers design their products for a short life so that consumers will buy them more
often. It’s a good plan for business, but not a very good plan for the planet. Second, today’s electronic
products are manufactured in a way that makes them very difficult or even impossible to repair.
Repairing them may require special equipment, replacement components, and instruction books, which
are often not available to consumers or independent repair shops. Therefore, if you want to repair your
phone or computer, you usually have to return it to the manufacturer. These repairs can be very
expensive because the manufacturer can set the price. They can also take a long time, but consumers
often have no other option. If the repair is too expensive or too difficult, consumers may decide to
return the old broken model and upgrade to a newer model instead. Then the manufacturer can
refurbish the old, broken model and resell it. Either way, these companies make a good profit. One
study estimates that they make more than 16 billion dollars a year on repairs and 80 billion dollars a
year on refurbishing.

C According to many experts, much of our e-waste could be eliminated, and consumers are
starting to demand change. European consumers are leading this movement. They are demanding that
manufacturers make products that last longer. Starting from 2019, the European Union has required
household electronics, like washing machines and dishwashers, to last for at least ten years. A similar
law for consumer electronics, such as phones and tablets, was passed two years later. Manufacturers
must also make these products easy to take apart so that their components can be recycled. But
consumers in Europe want more: They are demanding the right to repair their own purchases. Leaders
of this “Right to Repair” movement want consumers to be given access to special equipment,
replacement parts, and instruction books so they can repair these products themselves.

D Some consumers are not waiting for companies to act. They are creating their own instruction
books and putting them on an internet site. This site offers repair instruction books for 70,000 different
products in eleven languages. Ten million people visit the site every month looking for ways to extend
the life of products they own. This is convenient for many consumers, and for others, the right to repair
their possessions is essential to their business. For example, farmers today use very complicated
equipment that uses advanced software. When this equipment breaks, farmers may have to wait weeks
or even months for expensive repairs by the manufacturer. But that’s often too late; their crops cannot
wait.

©2021 National Geographic Learning, a Cengage Learning Company 2


E The negative impact of e-waste is more than just landfill. Electronics like phones and
computers contain components that harm the environment. Furthermore, the manufacture of these
electronics uses non-renewable energy, so it is a factor in global warming. Upgrading to new models
frequently causes a real environmental problem. According to one source, 83 percent of a phone’s
contribution to global warming comes from mining raw materials and manufacturing, so extending its
life would make a big difference. One study estimates that if we could extend the life of our cell
phones for one year, this would have an impact similar to taking 636,000 cars off the road.

F Most manufacturers oppose the Right to Repair movement. They claim that their rules protect
consumers because consumers and independent repair shops might make mistakes that would damage
these complicated electronic products. Supporters of the Right to Repair disagree. They believe that if
you bought a product, you own it. If you own it, you should be able to repair it. They say it’s the right
thing to do for consumers, their businesses, and for the planet.

a. Paragraph B
b. Paragraph C
c. Paragraph D
d. Paragraph E
e. Paragraph F
19. ____Some people are finding ways to repair their devices without the manufacturers’ help.
20. ____E-waste can harm the environment when products are made, and also when they are thrown away.
21. ____People are throwing away electronic products because the quality is poor, and they are hard to
repair.
22. ____Many consumers want to be able to repair their electronic devices, but the manufacturers
disagree.
23. ____Consumers in some countries are demanding higher quality products and the right to repair them.

READING FOR DETAILS


Read. Then write T (true) or F (false). Correct the underlined section in a false statement.

THE RIGHT TO REPAIR


A Every year, people throw away thousands of phones, computers, and electric appliances, such
as washing machines and toasters. This is called e-waste, and we produce a lot of it—about 50 million
tons every year. Around 80 percent of it ends up in landfill. In fact, e-waste is the fastest-growing type
of waste on the planet, but we could slow this trend by changing our relationship with our possessions.

B There are two main reasons for this growing problem. First, the quality of many products has
decreased. Manufacturers design their products for a short life so that consumers will buy them more
often. It’s a good plan for business, but not a very good plan for the planet. Second, today’s electronic
products are manufactured in a way that makes them very difficult or even impossible to repair.
Repairing them may require special equipment, replacement components, and instruction books, which
are often not available to consumers or independent repair shops. Therefore, if you want to repair your
phone or computer, you usually have to return it to the manufacturer. These repairs can be very
expensive because the manufacturer can set the price. They can also take a long time, but consumers
often have no other option. If the repair is too expensive or too difficult, consumers may decide to
return the old broken model and upgrade to a newer model instead. Then the manufacturer can
refurbish the old, broken model and resell it. Either way, these companies make a good profit. One
study estimates that they make more than 16 billion dollars a year on repairs and 80 billion dollars a
year on refurbishing.

©2021 National Geographic Learning, a Cengage Learning Company 3


C According to many experts, much of our e-waste could be eliminated, and consumers are
starting to demand change. European consumers are leading this movement. They are demanding that
manufacturers make products that last longer. Starting from 2019, the European Union has required
household electronics, like washing machines and dishwashers, to last for at least ten years. A similar
law for consumer electronics, such as phones and tablets, was passed two years later. Manufacturers
must also make these products easy to take apart so that their components can be recycled. But
consumers in Europe want more: They are demanding the right to repair their own purchases. Leaders
of this “Right to Repair” movement want consumers to be given access to special equipment,
replacement parts, and instruction books so they can repair these products themselves.

D Some consumers are not waiting for companies to act. They are creating their own instruction
books and putting them on an internet site. This site offers repair instruction books for 70,000 different
products in eleven languages. Ten million people visit the site every month looking for ways to extend
the life of products they own. This is convenient for many consumers, and for others, the right to repair
their possessions is essential to their business. For example, farmers today use very complicated
equipment that uses advanced software. When this equipment breaks, farmers may have to wait weeks
or even months for expensive repairs by the manufacturer. But that’s often too late; their crops cannot
wait.

E The negative impact of e-waste is more than just landfill. Electronics like phones and
computers contain components that harm the environment. Furthermore, the manufacture of these
electronics uses non-renewable energy, so it is a factor in global warming. Upgrading to new models
frequently causes a real environmental problem. According to one source, 83 percent of a phone’s
contribution to global warming comes from mining raw materials and manufacturing, so extending its
life would make a big difference. One study estimates that if we could extend the life of our cell
phones for one year, this would have an impact similar to taking 636,000 cars off the road.

F Most manufacturers oppose the Right to Repair movement. They claim that their rules protect
consumers because consumers and independent repair shops might make mistakes that would damage
these complicated electronic products. Supporters of the Right to Repair disagree. They believe that if
you bought a product, you own it. If you own it, you should be able to repair it. They say it’s the right
thing to do for consumers, their businesses, and for the planet.

24. To access the components inside electronic devices, you usually have to take it to a repair shop.
________________________

25. Manufacturers make a big profit from refurbishing and reselling their electronic devices.
________________________

26. E-waste could be reduced if cell phones used renewable energy.


________________________

27. The right-to-repair website receives 10 million visits a month.


________________________

28. Repairs by the manufacturer can cost a lot and take a long time.
________________________

©2021 National Geographic Learning, a Cengage Learning Company 4


READING SKILL
Read the paragraphs that a student has annotated. Then choose the correct words to complete
the sentences.

B There are two main reasons for this growing problem. First, the quality of many products
has decreased. Manufacturers design their products for a short life so that consumers will buy them
more often. It’s a good plan for business, but not a very good plan for the planet. Second, today’s
electronic products are manufactured in a way that makes them very difficult or even impossible
to repair. Repairing them may require special equipment, replacement components, and instruction
books, which are often not available to consumers or independent repair shops. Therefore, if you want
to repair your phone or computer, you usually have to return it to the manufacturer. These repairs can
be very expensive because the manufacturer can set the price. They can also take a long time, but
consumers often have no other option. If the repair is too expensive or too difficult, consumers may
decide to return the old broken model and upgrade to a newer model instead. Then the manufacturer
can refurbish the old, broken model and resell it. Either way, these companies make a good profit. One
study estimates that they make more than 16 billion dollars a year on repairs and 80 billion dollars a
year on refurbishing.

E The negative impact of e-waste is more than just landfill. Electronics like phones and
computers contain components that harm the environment. Furthermore, the manufacture of these
electronics uses non-renewable energy, so it is a factor in global warming. Upgrading to new models
frequently causes a real environmental problem. According to one source, 83 percent of a phone’s
contribution to global warming comes from mining raw materials and manufacturing, so extending its
life would make a big difference. One study estimates that if we could extend the life of our cell
phones for one year, this would have a similar impact to taking 636,000 cars off the road.

29. The student bolded the sentence in paragraph B because it has ________________.
a. the main idea b. a supporting idea c. an important detail
30. The student bolded the sentence in paragraph E because it is ________________.
a. the main idea b. a supporting idea c. a summary
31. The student probably underlined parts of paragraph B because they are ________________.
a. unknown words b. supporting ideas c. examples
32. The student probably underlined parts of paragraph E because they are ________________.
a. example b. statistics c. summaries
33. The student probably underlined twice the word in paragraph E because it is ________________.
a. an unknown word b. an important detail c. a statistic

WRITING SKILL
Choose the two correct answers.

34. ____Which elements are usually in an opening paragraph?


a. a summary c. a hook
b. a thesis statement d. a topic sentence
35. ____Which elements are usually in a thesis statement?
a. a hook c. supporting ideas
b. a topic d. a claim

©2021 National Geographic Learning, a Cengage Learning Company 5


36. ____Which elements are usually in a body paragraph?
a. details c. supporting ideas
b. a thesis statement d. a summary
37. ____Which elements are often in a concluding paragraph?
a. a summary c. a topic sentence
b. new information d. an evaluation

CRITICAL THINKING SKILL


Rank the items in order from what you think is the largest number to the smallest (1-5).

number of number of cell global number of number of new cell


new cell phones thrown population refurbished cell phones in 10 years
phones today away today phones today

38. #1 ________________________________

39. #2 ________________________________

40. #3 ________________________________

41. #4 ________________________________

42. #5 ________________________________

WRITING PRACTICE 1
Rewrite the underlined section of each sentence in the passive voice.
NARREND

43. We can recycle many of the components in cell phones.


Many of the components in cell phones ______________________________________.

44. Experts claim that we could reduce most of our current e-waste.
Experts claim that most of our current e-waste _________________________________.

45. People offer thousands of instruction books on the right-to-repair website.


Thousands of instruction books _____________________on the right-to-repair website.

46. With the right to repair, we can extend the life of electronics.
With the right to repair, the life of electronics _________________________________.

47. If farmers wait too long for repairs to their equipment, it may ruin their crops.
If farmers wait too long for repairs to their equipment, __________________________.

©2021 National Geographic Learning, a Cengage Learning Company 6


WRITING PRACTICE 2
What is your opinion about this question?

“Which is more beneficial for consumers: ownership or


usership?”

Support your answer with reasons and examples.

48. Write at least 200 words.


____________________________________________________________________

____________________________________________________________________

____________________________________________________________________

____________________________________________________________________

____________________________________________________________________

©2021 National Geographic Learning, a Cengage Learning Company 7


UNIT 2 Test
Answer Key

1. ANS: C
PTS: 1 REF: L5U2 TOP: Vocabulary NAR: L5U2_MC1

2. ANS: A
PTS: 1 REF: L5U2 TOP: Vocabulary NAR: L5U2_MC1

3. ANS: C
PTS: 1 REF: L5U2 TOP: Vocabulary NAR: L5U2_MC1

4. ANS: B
PTS: 1 REF: L5U2 TOP: Vocabulary NAR: L5U2_MC1

5. ANS: B
PTS: 1 REF: L5U2 TOP: Vocabulary NAR: L5U2_MC1

6. ANS: A
PTS: 1 REF: L5U2 TOP: Vocabulary NAR: L5U2_MC1

7. ANS: C
PTS: 1 REF: L5U2 TOP: Vocabulary NAR: L5U2_MC1

8. ANS: A
PTS: 1 REF: L5U2 TOP: Vocabulary NAR: L5U2_MC1

9. ANS: C
PTS: 1 REF: L5U2 TOP: Vocabulary NAR: L5U2_MC1

10. ANS: B
PTS: 1 REF: L5U2 TOP: Vocabulary NAR: L5U2_MC1

11. ANS: is being used


PTS: 2 REF: L5U2 TOP: Grammar NAR: L5U2_CO1

12. ANS: are thrown


PTS: 2 REF: L5U2 TOP: Grammar NAR: L5U2_CO1

13. ANS: were reviewed


PTS: 2 REF: L5U2 TOP: Grammar NAR: L5U2_CO1

14. ANS: are being designed


PTS: 2 REF: L5U2 TOP: Grammar NAR: L5U2_CO1

15. ANS: isn’t used, is not used


PTS: 2 REF: L5U2 TOP: Grammar NAR: L5U2_CO1

16. ANS: could be repaired


PTS: 2 REF: L5U2 TOP: Grammar NAR: L5U2_CO1

17. ANS: were published


PTS: 2 REF: L5U2 TOP: Grammar NAR: L5U2_CO1

©2021 National Geographic Learning, a Cengage Learning Company 8


18. ANS: shouldn’t be wasted, should not be wasted
PTS: 2 REF: L5U2 TOP: Grammar NAR: L5U2_CO1

19. ANS: C PTS: 2 REF: L5U2 TOP: Reading for Main Ideas
20. ANS: D PTS: 2 REF: L5U2 TOP: Reading for Main Ideas
21. ANS: A PTS: 2 REF: L5U2 TOP: Reading for Main Ideas
22. ANS: E PTS: 2 REF: L5U2 TOP: Reading for Main Ideas
23. ANS: B PTS: 2 REF: L5U2 TOP: Reading for Main Ideas

24. ANS: F, the manufacturer


PTS: 2 REF: L5U2 TOP: Reading for Details NAR: L5U2_MTF1

25. ANS: T
PTS: 2 REF: L5U2 TOP: Reading for Details NAR: L5U2_MTF1

26. ANS: F
were repaired or refurbished
were repaired
were refurbished
PTS: 2 REF: L5U2 TOP: Reading for Details NAR: L5U2_MTF1

27. ANS: T
PTS: 2 REF: L5U2 TOP: Reading for Details NAR: L5U2_MTF1

28. ANS: T
PTS: 2 REF: L5U2 TOP: Reading for Details NAR: L5U2_MTF1

29. ANS: B
PTS: 2 REF: L5U2 TOP: Reading Skill NAR: L5U2_MC2

30. ANS: A
PTS: 2 REF: L5U2 TOP: Reading Skill NAR: L5U2_MC2

31. ANS: C
PTS: 2 REF: L5U2 TOP: Reading Skill NAR: L5U2_MC2

32. ANS: B
PTS: 2 REF: L5U2 TOP: Reading Skill NAR: L5U2_MC2

33. ANS: A
PTS: 2 REF: L5U2 TOP: Reading Skill NAR: L5U2_MC2

34. ANS: B, C
PTS: 3 REF: L5U2 TOP: Writing Skill NAR: L5U2_MR1

35. ANS: B, D
PTS: 3 REF: L5U2 TOP: Writing Skill NAR: L5U2_MR1

36. ANS: A, C
PTS: 3 REF: L5U2 TOP: Writing Skill NAR: L5U2_MR1

37. ANS: A, D
PTS: 3 REF: L5U2 TOP: Writing Skill NAR: L5U2_MR1

©2021 National Geographic Learning, a Cengage Learning Company 9


38. ANS: global population
PTS: 1 REF: L5U2 TOP: Critical Thinking Skill NAR: L5U2_CO2

39. ANS: number of new cell phones in 10 years


PTS: 1 REF: L5U2 TOP: Critical Thinking Skill NAR: L5U2_CO2

40. ANS: number of new cell phones today


PTS: 1 REF: L5U2 TOP: Critical Thinking Skill NAR: L5U2_CO2

41. ANS: number of cell phones thrown away today


PTS: 1 REF: L5U2 TOP: Critical Thinking Skill NAR: L5U2_CO2

42. ANS: number of refurbished cell phones today


PTS: 1 REF: L5U2 TOP: Critical Thinking Skill NAR: L5U2_CO2

43. ANS:
can be recycled
PTS: 3 REF: L5U2 TOP: Writing Practice 1 NAR: L5U2_SA1

44. ANS:
could be reduced
PTS: 3 REF: L5U2 TOP: Writing Practice 1 NAR: L5U2_SA1

45. ANS:
are offered
PTS: 3 REF: L5U2 TOP: Writing Practice 1 NAR: L5U2_SA1

46. ANS:
can be extended
PTS: 3 REF: L5U2 TOP: Writing Practice 1 NAR: L5U2_SA1

47. ANS:
their crops may be ruined
PTS: 3 REF: L5U2 TOP: Writing Practice 1 NAR: L5U2_SA1

48. ANS:
Students’ own answers
PTS: 12 REF: L5U2 TOP: Writing Practice 2 MSC: IELTS|TOEFL
NAR: L5U2_ESSAY

©2021 National Geographic Learning, a Cengage Learning Company 10

Common questions

Powered by AI

Extending the lifespan of cell phones by one year could have significant environmental benefits, potentially equating to the reduction of emissions associated with 636,000 cars being taken off the road. This is due to the fact that 83 percent of a phone's contribution to global warming comes from the mining of raw materials and manufacturing processes, which are energy-intensive and environmentally damaging. Extending phone life reduces these processes, lessening the overall environmental impact .

Repair and refurbishing practices have a substantial economic impact on manufacturers, providing significant revenue streams. These companies reportedly generate over $16 billion annually from repairs and $80 billion from refurbishing and reselling old models. This economic benefit is derived from the controlled repair processes and the cyclical purchase behavior facilitated by difficult-to-repair product designs .

The increase in e-waste is primarily due to two reasons: the decreased quality of products and the design strategy for short lifespans, compelling consumers to buy new products more frequently. This is compounded by difficult repair processes which make consumers upgrade to newer models rather than repair old ones. The environmental impact is significant, as e-waste components can harm ecosystems, and the manufacturing process for electronics uses non-renewable energy, contributing to global warming .

The Right to Repair movement contributes to reducing global warming by promoting product longevity and reducing the frequency of electronic device purchases. By enabling consumers to repair their devices, the movement aims to decrease demand for new products, thus lowering the energy-intensive processes involved in mining and manufacturing, which account for a significant portion of a device's environmental impact. Fewer new products also mean less e-waste and a smaller carbon footprint associated with disposal and production .

Consumer initiatives, such as the creation and dissemination of online repair manuals, play a critical role in e-waste management by democratizing access to repair knowledge and resources. These community-led efforts enable consumers to extend the life of their products independently, circumventing manufacturer-imposed restrictions, and reducing e-waste. By facilitating self-repair, such initiatives challenge the planned obsolescence tactics of manufacturers and contribute to the sustainability movement .

The Right to Repair movement aims to address the e-waste problem by demanding that manufacturers create products with longer life spans and improve their reparability. In Europe, this has led to regulations requiring that household electronics have at least a ten-year lifespan and are designed for easy recycling. The movement also advocates for making repair tools, parts, and manuals available to consumers to empower them to perform repairs independently, thereby reducing waste and extending product life .

Manufacturers often design electronic products to be difficult to repair to ensure that consumers must return to them for costly repairs or replacement, rather than handling fixes independently. This strategy is financially beneficial for manufacturers because it allows them to control repair pricing and promotes frequent purchases of new models, leading to profits from both repair services and the refurbishing and reselling of returned items. Manufacturers reportedly earn billions annually from these practices .

The manufacturing of electronics with non-renewable energy significantly contributes to global warming due to the carbon emissions released during energy production and raw material extraction. Non-renewable energy sources, such as fossil fuels, are carbon-intensive, and processes involved in mining and manufacturing electronics amplify these emissions. As a result, the carbon footprint of electronic products is substantial, with the majority of emissions occurring during the manufacturing phase, underscoring the importance of extending product lifespan to mitigate these impacts .

Laws mandating longer product lifespans are effective in reducing e-waste and enhancing sustainability by forcing manufacturers to shift away from designs that encourage frequent upgrades. Such regulations, as seen in Europe, require that products like washing machines and consumer electronics last for a decade, thereby reducing the overall volume of e-waste. Furthermore, these laws promote sustainability by ensuring products can be easily repaired or recycled, thus conserving resources and reducing environmental impacts associated with waste disposal and raw material extraction .

The debate over ownership and the Right to Repair reflects broader consumer rights issues centered on the premise that ownership should entail full control over one's goods, including the right to repair them. This perspective challenges manufacturers' restrictions on repairs and refutes their claims that such limits are necessary to protect consumers from improper repairs. Adherents argue this movement is crucial not only for consumer autonomy but also for sustainability and reducing e-waste, as it empowers consumers to extend the life of their products .

You might also like