ALL SUBJECTS STUDY MODULES

SUBJECT PAGE
NUMBERS
PRINCIPLES OF TAXATION (10.1) 2-14

GROUP- A: TAX (DEFINITION, FEATURES, USES, CLASSIFICATION)

TAXATION SYSTEM IS A FR
INSURANCE LAW (10.2) 15-24

MODULE-1: INTRODUCTION
BANKING LAW (10.3) 25-45

Module-6: NEGOTIABLE INSTRUMENT ACT, 1881

GENDER JUSTICE AND FEMINIST
JURISPRUDENCE (10.4)

Module 1: INTRODUCTION

Module 2: CONSTITUTION OF INDIA AND THE POSITION OF 46-61

WOMEN

Module 3: CRIMINAL LAW AND WOMEN

Module 4: SPECIAL WOMEN WELFARE LAWS

Page 1 of 61
 PRINCIPLES OF TAXATION (10.1)
GROUP- A: TAX (DEFINITION, FEATURES, USES, CLASSIFICATION) TAXATION
SYSTEM IS A FR

Q1. Discuss the Fundamental provisions of the Constitution for enacting taxing
statute. (16)
Ans. Fundamental provisions of the Constitution for making taxing statutes are
as under:

1) Power to Tax (Article 265):

• It states that no tax shall be charged or collected except by the legal
authority.
• Any tax must have a valid legal basis.
• No tax can be charged randomly or illegally.

2) United funds and public accounts (Article 266): It deals with the united funds
and public accounts of India and the States.

3) Duties (Article 268):

• It deals with duties charged by the Union government.
• It is collected and claimed by the State governments.
• These duties include stamp duties, excise on medicinal & toilet
preparations etc.

4) Collection of tax (Article 269 & 270): Taxes that are charged and collected by
the Union Government but shared with the States.

5) GST Collection (Article 269(A)): It gives the power to collect GST on supplies
in trade from 1 state to another.

6) Overcharge (Article 271): Union can overcharge taxes to meet its financial
requirements.

7) Grant by Union Government (Article 275):

• Union government gives grants to the States.
• These are used for the development of the States and people.

8) State Tax (Article 276):

• Taxes are charged and collected by States.
• For e.g., Sales tax, Value-added tax (VAT), Professional tax and Stamp duty.
Page 2 of 61
9) Tax before commencement of Constitution (Article 277): States and the local
authorities can continue to collect taxes that were already being charged
before the commencement of the Constitution.

10) Special grant (Article 282):

• Union Government gives grants to States for any public purpose.
• The grants can be used for special or temporary schemes.

11) Restriction on tax (Article 286): States cannot charge taxes on:
• Imports or exports.
• Sales or purchases outside the territory of the State.
• Special goods.

12) Property taxation (Article 289): Property and Income of the States are not
liable to taxation.
Exceptions:
 If the Parliament makes a law to that effect.
 If the State government agrees to such taxation.

Page 3 of 61
Q2. (a) Classify the taxes in respect of structure. [OR] Classify taxes as
constituted in India. [OR] Discuss the classification of taxes. (5X) (6/8/16)
Ans. Types of Taxes are as follows:

1) Direct Taxes: Taxes that are directly charged on individuals or companies and
paid to the Government. The burden of direct tax cannot be shifted.
2) Indirect Taxes: Taxes that are charged on goods and services. The burden of
Indirect tax can be shifted.
3) Progressive Taxes: Taxes that ensure that the tax burden increases as the
income of a person increases.
4) Regressive Taxes: Taxes on lower-income people remains the same,
regardless of their income.
5) Proportional Taxes: These taxes are charged at a fixed rate, regardless of the
income level.
6) Central Taxes: These taxes are charged by the central government and are
collected at the national level. It is used for national expenditure.
7) State Taxes: These taxes are charged by state governments. It is used for state
expenditures.
8) Production Taxes: These are charged on the production of goods and
services.
9) Income Taxes: These taxes are charged on a person’s or business’s income.
10) Wealth Taxes: These taxes are charged on the total value of a person's
wealth, including assets like property and stocks.
11) Cess: A cess is an additional tax charged for a specific purpose. It is used
for education, health, or development.
12) Surcharge: A surcharge is an additional tax charged over the basic tax rate,
applicable to higher-income people or companies.

Page 4 of 61
Q2. (b) What is Res-Judicata? Discuss the Principle of Res-Judicata in Taxation.
(8) (2X)
Ans.
 Res-Judicata is a legal doctrine that stops multiple hearings.
 It means that once a matter has been solved, it cannot be re-argued in future
proceedings between the same parties on same subject matter.
 It saves time, resources, and judicial effort.

In taxation, Res-Judicata ensures that once a tax-related issue has been decided
by a court or tribunal, the same issue cannot be challenged again between the
same parties.

Key Features of Res-Judicata in Taxation:

(a) Final Decisions:

 It states that once a case has been decided by a competent court or
tribunal.
 The decision is final and binding.
(b) Preventing Multiple Suits:
 It prevents multiple suits on the same tax matters.
 This reduces the burden on courts.
(c) Binding Nature of Decisions:
 A decision made by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) or any other
relevant authority.
 It is binding on the parties in future proceedings on the same issue.

Exceptions to Res-Judicata in Taxation:

The issue can be re-examined in some cases:
a) If there is a change in the law or the facts.
b) If new evidence comes.
c) If an appeal is pending in a higher court, the lower court's decision is not
final.

Page 5 of 61
Q2. (c) Explain Estoppel in Taxation. (8)
Ans. In taxation, Estoppel states that once a position is adopted by either the
taxpayer or the tax authorities, it cannot be challenged without a valid reason.

Key Features of Estoppel in Taxation:

1) Prevents Contradiction:
 Tax authorities have officially made a representation to a taxpayer.
 They cannot later challenge that representation.

 Taxpayer has previously represented their position in a certain way to the

authorities.
 They cannot later challenge the position if it benefits them.

2) Estoppel Against Tax Authorities: Once the tax authorities have decided, to
agree to a certain tax treatment, they are bound to do so, unless any valid
reason.

3) Estoppel and the Doctrine of Fairness:

 It promotes fairness in taxation.
 It states that neither the taxpayer nor the tax authorities can change their
positions after a decision or action has been taken.

4) Limitations of Estoppel in Taxation:

a) When there is a clear legal provision, estoppel does not apply.
b) If the tax authorities or taxpayer acted fraudulently, estoppel will not
apply.

Page 6 of 61
 Q3. (a) Define tax with its features, objectives, characteristics, uses and cases.
(7X) (16)
Ans.
Definition • A tax is a compulsory financial contribution.
• It is charged by a government on its citizens.
• Government uses it for its expenditures.
• Taxes are charged on income, property, goods, and services.
Features a) Compulsory Payment:
• Taxes are compulsory payments.
• It cannot be avoided legally by the taxpayers.
b) No Direct Benefit: Taxpayers do not receive direct benefits in return.
c) Charged by Law:
• Taxes can only be charged by law.
• Government must follow a clear legal framework for tax collection.
d) Government Expenditure: Taxes are used to clear Government
expenditure.
e) Non-Refundable: Taxes are not refundable, except in cases of mistakes or
overpayments.
Objectives a) Profit Making: The primary objective of taxation is profit making.
b) Redistribution of Wealth:
• Taxes reduce inequalities by charging higher taxes on the rich people.
• It provides benefits to the poor people.
c) Encourage Specific Activities: The government uses taxes to encourage
activities like startups.
d) Social Welfare: Taxes fund various social welfare schemes to improve the
standard of living for citizens.
Characteristics a) Taxes must be charged according to law.
b) Taxes are continuous in nature but rates and structures may change.
c) Taxes should be charged as per taxpayer’s ability to pay.
d) Taxpayers should know when and how much tax they need to pay.
e) The tax system should be helpful for both the taxpayer and the tax
authorities.
f) The tax system should remain politics-free.

Page 7 of 61
Uses a) Tax profit is used to improve infrastructure, public health, defense,
education, and other welfare programs.
b) Taxes are used to give salaries for civil servants, maintenance of law and
other services.
c) Taxes are used to pay public debt like interest payments on loans or bonds.
d) Taxes are used to promote economic growth.
Cases a) In CIT vs. N. C. Budharaja & Co. (1993), the Supreme Court stated that:
• Tax liability rises on the basis of earned income.
• It is based on the scope and nature of the income.

b) In Raj Kumar Jain vs. Union of India (1995), the court held that:
• Customs duties should show the true cost of imported goods.
• It must not be used to create stop trade.

Page 8 of 61
Q3. (b) “Taxation system is a fundamental right under Indian Constitution.”—
Justify. (7X) (8/10/12/16)
Ans. The statement "Taxation system is a fundamental right under the Indian
Constitution" needs understanding of the constitutional provisions related to
taxation.
1) Taxation under the Indian Constitution:
• Taxation is not a Fundamental right under Indian Constitution.
• A.246 of the Constitution distributes the taxing powers between the
Central and State Governments.
• A.265 states that no tax shall be charged or collected except by the legal
authority.

2) Taxation and the Right to Equality (A.14):

• The right to equality demands that taxation must be fair, just, and equal.
• The taxation system must not be random.
• Indian Courts can repeal tax laws that violates the principle of equality.
• Citizens may use public funds.

3) Taxation and the Protection of Fundamental Rights:

• Constitution gives some rights and protections for taxation system.
• These rights indirectly support fairness of tax systems.

4) Right to Life and Personal Liberty (Article 21):

• A.21 includes using basic goods and services with taxation.
• A fair tax system is used to improve the standard of living.

5) The Taxpayer's Rights and Constitutional Safeguards:

• Indian taxpayers are protected under different provisions of the
Constitution.
• These ensures that tax laws are applied fairly.

6) Right to Due Process of Law: Under A.32, Taxpayers can go to the Supreme
Court to challenge any unjust taxation decision.

Page 9 of 61
Q3. (c) Discuss about evolution of taxing system in India. (8)
Ans. The evolution of the taxing system in India is shaped by historical, economic,
and political factors.
1) Ancient and Medieval Periods:
a) Ancient India:
• Taxation was in the form of "Bali" (voluntary tax).
• It was a form of tribute paid by the people, usually in kind to the King.
• The concept of taxation in ancient India was basic.
• It supported the state’s military, religious acts, and governance.

b) Medieval Period:
• The taxation system was more complex.
• Under Mughals, taxes were focused on agricultural production and trade.

2) British Colonial Period:

a) Early British Rule:
• The British introduced a more systematic taxation system.
• The Permanent Settlement fixed a permanent land revenue.

b) Post- British Rule:

• British introduced more clear taxation process.
• Taxes on goods and services were charged.

3) Post-Independence Period
a) Early Years After Independence:
• India’s tax system changed under new government policies.
• The Income Tax Act, 1961 was introduced.
• It governs income tax rules today.

b) GST and Modern-Day Taxation:

• GST was introduced in 2017.
• It was a landmark reform in India’s indirect tax system.
• It replaced a complex tax structure and made it uniform.

Page 10 of 61
 Q4. Discuss in detail the legal and economic concept of tax. (16)
Ans.
LEGAL CONCEPT OF TAX ECONOMIC CONCEPT OF TAX
Concept: Concept:
1. Legal Obligation: Tax is compulsory and 1. Government Expenditure – Taxes fund
not a voluntary payment. government services like healthcare,
2. No Direct Benefit: A taxpayer does not get education, and infrastructure.
a specific service in return for tax paid. 2. Redistribution of Wealth – Taxation
3. Charged by Law: Taxes are applied by ensures the rich pay more to support the
statutes like: poor.
a. the Income Tax Act, 1961 3. Managing Economy – Tax policies help
b. and Goods and Services Tax (GST) control economic growth and trade.
Act, 2017. 4. Encouraging or Discouraging Activities – -
4. Collected by Authority: Only the - High taxes on tobacco and alcohol
government (Central, State, or Local) can discourage their consumption.
charge taxes. - Tax benefits encourage investments and
savings.
Types of Taxes (Legal Classification) Impact of Taxation on Economy
1. Direct Taxes – Paid directly by 1. Higher cost control – Higher taxes
individuals and businesses (e.g., reduce excess money circulation.
Income Tax, Corporate Tax). 2. Investment & Savings – Tax encourages
2. Indirect Taxes – Collected by small business expansion and personal
organisation, then passed on to the savings.
government (e.g., GST, Customs Duty). 3. Employment Generation –
Constitutional Basis Government-funded projects using tax
• Article 265 of the Indian Constitution: No
revenue create jobs and economic
tax shall be charged or collected except by stability.
the legal authority. 4. Foreign Investment – A stable tax
• Taxation Power:
system attracts foreign companies to
o Union List – Taxes charged by the
invest in the country.
Central Government (e.g., Income
Tax, Customs Duty).
o State List – Taxes charged by the
State Government (e.g., Stamp
Duty, State GST).
o Concurrent List – Both Union and
State can make laws (rare for
taxation).

Page 11 of 61
Q5. Write a note on ‘Doctrine of Privilege’ in Taxation. (16)
Ans.
1. Doctrine of Privilege in Taxation: Refers to the government's power to tax
individuals or companies for enjoying certain special benefits.

2. Examples of Tax on Privilege

a) Professional Tax – A tax charged on professionals like doctors, lawyers,
and accountants for practicing their profession.
b) License Fees – Fees paid for obtaining business licenses (e.g., liquor
license, driving license).
c) Corporate Tax – Tax on companies for doing business as a corporate
organisation.
d) Import Duty – Tax on imported goods into a country.

4. Key Features
• Not a General Tax: Applied only to those who enjoy specific benefits.
• Based on Economic Benefit: Tax is justified because the taxpayer enjoys
special benefits.
• Ensures Fair Contribution: Prevents unfair advantage to those who
receive government benefits.

5. Legal Basis & Court Rulings:

• Courts have upheld privileged taxes as legal.
• Example: In many cases, the Supreme Court of India has ruled that taxes
on professional income and licenses are reasonable.

Here is some important case laws related to the Doctrine of Privilege in

Taxation:
i. Express Hotels Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Gujarat (1989)
• Facts: The Gujarat government charged a luxury tax on hotels.
• Ruling: The Supreme Court upheld the tax, stating that luxury is a
privilege, and those who enjoy it can be taxed.

ii. State of West Bengal v. Kesoram Industries Ltd. (2004)

• Facts: The case involved cess (a type of tax) on minerals produced
from land.
• Ruling: The Supreme Court held that if a person gets benefits from
natural resources, the government can charge a tax for that privilege.

Page 12 of 61
Q6. Discuss Tax evasion and Tax avoidance with illustration. (16)
Ans. Tax Evasion and Tax Avoidance are two ways in which taxpayers reduce
their tax liability. Tax Evasion is illegal, while Tax Avoidance is legally Using gaps
in the law to pay less tax without breaking any rules.

TAX EVASION (ILLEGAL): Intentionally avoiding tax payments by hiding earnings,

or tampering documents.
• Examples:
o Not showing full income to reduce tax liability.
o Maintaining fake accounts or cash transactions to avoid tax.
o Showing fake invoices.
• Consequences:
o Heavy penalties and fines.
o Legal prosecution or imprisonment.
• Illustration: A businessman earns ₹50 lakh but reports only ₹30 lakh to the
tax department to pay less income tax.
• Case law: Commissioner of Income Tax vs. Ramakanth Mohanlal Gandhi:
The Supreme Court ruled that tax evasion must be a will act with knowledge
that it is illegal.

TAX AVOIDANCE (LEGAL): Using legal provisions to reduce tax liability without
breaking the law.
• Examples:
o Investing in tax-saving instruments.
o Shifting business profits to tax-friendly locations.
o Using Business Arrangements to reduce taxable income.
• Consequences: No legal punishment, but can be discouraged through stricter
tax laws.
• Illustration: A company shifts its headquarters to a low-tax country to pay
lower corporate taxes.
• Case law: Azadi Bachao Andolan vs. UOI: The Supreme Court upheld General
Anti-Avoidance Rule (GAAR)'s validity to prevent tax avoidance.

Page 13 of 61
Q7. Discuss the tax structure in general and tax structure according to taxing
authority in India. (16)
Ans.
1. General Tax Structure: Tax is a compulsory financial charge fixed by the
government on individuals and businesses.
• Types of Taxes:
o Direct Taxes – Paid directly to the government by Individuals and
Other Organisation (e.g., Income Tax, Corporate Tax).
o Indirect Taxes – Collected by agents and passed on to the government
(e.g., GST, Customs Duty).
• Tax Reforms: Introduction of Goods and Services Tax (GST) in 2017 replaced
multiple indirect taxes.

2. Tax Structure According to Taxing Authority

(A) Central Government Taxes:
1. Income Tax – Charged on income of individuals and companies.
2. Corporate Tax – Tax on company profits.
3. Goods and Services Tax (GST) – Tax on supply of goods and services.
4. Customs Duty – Tax on import/export of goods.
5. Excise Duty – Earlier charged on manufactured goods (mostly covered in
GST).
6. Securities Transaction Tax (STT) – Tax on trading in securities.
(B) State Government Taxes:
1. State GST (SGST) – Collected by states on sale of goods and services within
the state.
2. Stamp Duty – Tax on legal documents and property transactions.
3. State Excise Duty – On alcohol, liquor, drugs.
4. Motor Vehicle Tax – Tax on vehicle registration.
5. Entertainment Tax – On cinema, amusement parks (partially added with
GST).
(C) Local Government (Municipal/ Panchayat) Taxes
1. Property Tax – Charged on property owners.
2. Water Tax – For water supply services.
3. Sewerage Tax – For sanitation and drainage services.
4. Advertisement Tax – On advertisements in public spaces.

Page 14 of 61
INSURANCE LAW (10.2)
MODULE-1: INTRODUCTION
Q1. Define ‘Insurance’ [OR] What is the Contract of Insurance? [4/5] {6x}
Year: 2017/2019/2023 (5yrs)-2018/2020/2021 (3yrs)
Ans:
1. Definition: A contract where one party promises to compensate the other for
financial loss due to uncertain events, in exchange for a premium. It involves two
parties:
1. Insurer (insurance company)
2. Insured (policyholder)
The Insurance Act, 1938, does not expressly define 'insurance,'.
The Indian Contract Act, 1872, provides basic features applicable to insurance
contracts, such as:
• Section 2(h): Defines a contract as an agreement enforceable by law.
• Section 10: Lists the essentials of a valid contract, like free consent, lawful
consideration, and lawful object.
2. Types of Insurance Contracts:
a) General Insurance – Includes health, fire, marine, and motor insurance.
b) Life Insurance – Provides financial support in case of death or survival
benefits.
c) Marine Insurance – Covers losses related to ships, cargo, and marine
transportation.
d) Fire Insurance – Protects against damages caused by fire.
e) Health Insurance – Covers medical expenses due to illness or accidents.
f) Motor Insurance – Provides coverage for damages and liabilities related
to vehicles.

Page 15 of 61
Q2. Explain the essential features of Contract of Insurance. [4/8/12] {6x}
Year: 2017/2019/2023 (5yrs)-2018/2020/2024 (3yrs)
Ans: The essential features of an insurance contract match with general contract
principles given in the Indian Contract Act, 1872, particularly:
Section 10. It deals with essentials of a valid contract.
These following features check that insurance remains fair, legally binding, and
beneficial for both the insurer and insured, which are as follow:
1. Agreement – A legal contract between the insurer (company) and the insured
(policyholder).
2. Legal Contract – It is a legally binding contract with terms & conditions.
3. Financial Interest – The insured must have a financial interest in the subject
matter (life, property, health, etc.).
4. Utmost Good Faith – Both parties must disclose all important facts honestly.
5. Indemnity – The insurer compensates only for actual losses (except in life
insurance).
6. Risk Coverage – Protection is given against specific risks like accidents, illness,
or damage.
7. Premium Payment – The insured must pay a regular amount (premium) to
keep the policy active.
8. Subrogation – If the insurer pays for the loss, they gain the right to recover
the amount from a third party (if responsible).
9. Contribution – If multiple policies cover the same risk, each insurer pays a
fair share of the loss.
10. Loss Reduction – The insured must take reasonable care to reduce loss or
damage.

Page 16 of 61
 Q3. “Every Contract of Insurance is a Contract of Ubi- Rimaefidae (Utmost Good
Faith)” Discuss. [8] {5x}
Year: 2018/2023(5yrs) Year: 2017/2021/2023/2024 (3yrs)
Ans: 1. Meaning of Ubi- Rimaefidae (Utmost Good Faith)
• The principle of Ubi- Rimaefidae means “utmost good faith.”
• It is explained u/S.17 of the Marine Insurance Act, 1906 and later The
Consumer Insurance (Disclosure and Representations) Act 2012 and the
Insurance Act, 2015 also introduced this principle
• Both the insurer (insurance company) and the insured (policyholder) must
disclose all material facts honestly.
• It prevents fraud and unfair advantage in insurance contracts.

Duties of the Insured (Policyholder) Duties of the Insurer (Insurance Company)

• Disclose all material facts (e.g., existing • Clearly define the policy coverage,
illnesses in health insurance). terms, and exclusions.
• Do not provide false information about • Explain risks and limitations properly to
risks (e.g., concealing a smoking habit in life the insured.
insurance).
• Settle claims fairly without unnecessary
• Follow policy conditions (e.g., regular delays.
premium payments).

Legal Cases on Ubi- Rimaefidae in India

➢ LIC of India v. Smt. G.M. Channabasamma (1991)
o The insured hid a serious illness while buying life insurance.
o The Supreme Court ruled in favor of LIC and rejected the claim due to
non-disclosure.
➢ Mithoolal Nayak v. LIC of India (1962)
o The insured lied about his health while taking an insurance policy.
o The court held that hiding material facts makes the contract void.

Page 17 of 61
Q4. “Indemnity is the controlling principle in insurance law, but all Insurance
Contract are not Perfect Contract of Indemnity.” Illustrate the statement with
giving reasons. [8] {3x}
Year: 2019/2020(5yrs)-2018/2020 (3yrs)
Indemnity means compensation for actual loss – The insured is restored to the
same financial position as before the loss. Indemnity is Explained under the
Section 124 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872.

Most insurance contracts follow the indemnity principle – The insured cannot
make a profit, only recover actual damages.
1. Why All Insurance Contracts Are Not Perfect Contracts of Indemnity?
General Insurance (Fire, Marine, Motor, Health) – Indemnity Contract
The insurer only pays for the actual loss, not more.
Example: If a car worth ₹5 lakhs is insured and gets stolen, the insurer only pays
₹5 lakhs, not more.
Life Insurance – Not a Contract of Indemnity
• Life insurance does not follow indemnity because life has no fixed
monetary value.
• A fixed sum (sum assured) is paid regardless of actual financial loss.
Example: If a person has a ₹50 lakh life insurance policy, their family receives
₹50 lakh upon death, even if they earned less.

Personal Accident Insurance – Not a Pure Indemnity Contract

✓ A heavy sum is paid based on injury severity, not the exact medical
expenses.
Example: If an insured person loses a leg, the policy pays a fixed amount, not
just hospital bills.

Page 18 of 61
Q5. “All Insurance Contract are the Contract of Indemnity except Life
Insurance.” Explain. [12]
Year: 2023/3yrs
Ans: Meaning of Contract of Indemnity:
• A contract of indemnity means that one party (insurer) promises to
compensate the other party (insured) for actual losses suffered due to a
specified event.
• The aim is to restore the insured to the same financial position before the
loss.
Insurance Contracts as Contracts of Indemnity: All types of insurance, except
life insurance, follow the principle of indemnity. This includes:
1. Fire Insurance – The insurer compensates only for the actual loss suffered
by the insured due to fire, subject to the policy limit.
2. Marine Insurance – The insured is compensated for the loss of ship or
cargo, ensuring no financial gain beyond actual damage.
3. Health Insurance – Medical expenses suffered by the insured are repaid
up to the policy amount, without providing any financial gain.
4. Motor Insurance – Covers actual loss or damage to the vehicle in case of
an accident, following the indemnity principle.
Exception: Life Insurance is NOT a Contract of Indemnity: Life insurance does
not follow the indemnity principle because:
1. Human Life Value is Indeterminate – Unlike property, a person’s life
cannot be financially valued in absolute terms.
2. Fixed Sum Assured – In life insurance, a predetermined amount is paid to
the nominee upon the insured’s death, regardless of financial loss.
3. No Restitution – The insurer does not restore the insured to their previous
position but provides a guaranteed benefit to beneficiaries.
4. Saving and Investment Part – Many life insurance policies such as funding
and whole life policies also act as savings or investment plans.

Page 19 of 61
Q6. State whether Insurance is a Contingent Contract or Indemnity Contract?
[8]
Year: 2017 (5yrs)
Ans:1. Insurance as a Contingent Contract
A contingent contract is a contract that depends on an uncertain future event.
• Insurance is a contingent contract because the insurer will pay the insured
only if a specific event (such as an accident, fire, death, or illness) happens.
• Until the event occurs, the insurer has no obligation to pay.
• Example: A life insurance policy pays money only when the insured person
dies. If the person survives the policy period, no claim arises.

2. General Insurance as a Contract of Indemnity

• General insurance (except life insurance) is a contract of indemnity
because the insurer compensates the actual loss suffered by the insured.
• It restore the financial position of the insured before the loss.
• Types of indemnity insurance: Fire insurance, marine insurance, health
insurance, and motor insurance.
• Example: If a car worth ₹5 lakhs is insured for ₹8 lakhs and gets stolen, the
insurer will only pay ₹5 lakhs, not more than the actual loss.

3. Life Insurance as a Contingent Contract

• Life insurance is a contingent contract because the insurer pays a fixed
amount when the uncertain event (death) happens.
• Unlike indemnity contracts, life insurance does not compensate for
financial loss but ensures financial support to the family.
• Example: If a person insures their life for ₹30 lakhs, the insurer must pay
₹30 lakhs to the nominee upon the insured’s death, regardless of actual
loss.

Page 20 of 61
Q7. Show how for Insurance is a wagering contract. [8]
Year: 2018 (3yrs)
Ans: A wagering contract is a bet or gamble where two parties agree that one
will pay money to the other based on the outcome of an uncertain event.
Agreements by way of wager are void under Section 30 of the Indian Contract
Act, 1872.
Insurance contracts are generally not considered wagering contracts due to the
presence of insurable interest.

1. Features of a Wagering Contract

• It is based on chance or luck.
• The parties have no actual financial interest in the event.
• One party gains profit, and the other suffers a loss depending on the
outcome.
• Example: A person bets ₹1,000 on a cricket match. If the team wins, they get
₹2,000; if they lose, they get nothing.

2. Why Insurance is NOT a Wagering Contract?

✓ Insurance is based on risk protection, not chance.
✓ The insured has an insurable interest in the insured object or life.
✓ Insurance compensates for actual financial loss (except life insurance).
✓ Premiums are paid regularly to cover the risk, not as a bet.
✓ Wagering contracts are illegal, but insurance is legal and regulated by law.

3. When Insurance May Resemble a Wagering Contract?

 Sometimes, insurance may look like a wager if misused, such as:
Taking insurance on someone else's life without a financial relationship.
 Over-insuring property for more than its value to make a profit.
 Taking multiple policies on the same risk without proper disclosure.
Example: If a person insures a stranger’s life and gets money upon their death,
it becomes a wager.

Page 21 of 61
Q8. Why are Insurance Contracts Called Contracts of Adhesion? [4]
Year: 2023 (3yrs)
Ans: A Contract of Adhesion is a contract where one party (insurer) sets all the
terms, and the other party (insured) must either accept or reject it without
negotiation.
Indian law doesn’t specifically mention contracts of adhesion, but insurance
contracts are considered such since insurers draft them, leaving the insured to
less scope of negotiation.
1. Features of a Contract of Adhesion in Insurance
✓ Pre-drafted Terms – The insurance company decides the terms and
conditions.
✓ No Negotiation – The insured cannot change the policy terms.
✓ Take-it-or-leave-it Basis – The insured must accept the policy as it is or reject
it.
✓ Favourable Interpretation – If any term is unclear, courts usually interpret it
in favor of the insured.
2. Example: A person buying health insurance must accept the policy terms as
written by the insurer. They cannot modify clauses like premium, coverage, or
exclusions.

Page 22 of 61
Q9. What is Subrogation? [4/6]
Year: 2023 (5yrs)- 2021 (3yrs)
Ans: Definition of Subrogation
• Subrogation is a legal principle in insurance where
• the insurer gets the right to recover the loss amount from a third party
• The 3rd party is responsible for the damage after compensating the
insured.
The principle of subrogation is stated under Section 79 of the Marine Insurance
Act, 1963. It is not expressly mentioned in the Insurance Act, 1938
1. Key Features of Subrogation
✓ Applies only to indemnity insurance (fire, marine, motor, health).
✓ Insurer steps into the shoes of the insured to claim compensation from the
third party.
✓ Prevents the insured from making a profit from the insurance claim.
✓ Arises after the insurer has paid the claim to the insured.
2. Example: If a car owner’s vehicle is damaged due to another driver’s
negligence, and the insurance company pays for the repairs, the insurer can sue
the negligent driver to recover the amount.

Page 23 of 61
 DIFFERENCE:
1. Re-Insurance and Double Insurance [8] {3x}
Year: 2022 (5yrs)-2017/2021 (3yrs)
RE-INSURANCE BASIS DOUBLE INSURANCE
Section 101A Insurance Act, Section 34 Insurance Act, 1938
1938 insurance for insurance states that multiple policies
companies. Insurer transfers cover the same risk, it is Double
1. Meaning Insurance.
part of its risk to another
insurance company to reduce
financial risk.
Involves two insurers – the
Involves one insured and
original insurer and the 2. Parties Involved
multiple insurers.
reinsurer.
3. Privity of
Legal relation between the Legal relationship between
Contract (Direct
original insured person and the Insured person and insurance
parties
re-insured person. company.
involvement)
To reduce the burden on the To increase coverage or ensure
4. Purpose
original insurer. full compensation.
The original insurer must have
5. Insurable Interest The insured must have an
an insurable interest in the
insurable interest in the subject.
subject.

Claimed from only the original 6. Claim against Right to claim is subjected to the
insured person. whom? principle of contribution.

Governed by reinsurance Governed by the principle of

7. Regulation
agreements between insurers. contribution.

Re-insurer protects the Original Insured Company protects the

8. Protection
Insurer. insured person.

Page 24 of 61
BANKING LAW (10.3)
Module-6: NEGOTIABLE INSTRUMENT ACT, 1881

Q27. (a) What is a Promissory Note? (3X) (4/6) (2012/ 3Y 2010)

Ans.
▪ A Promissory Note is stated u/S.4 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881.
▪ It is a monetary instrument.
▪ Payer agrees to pay an amount of money to the payee.
▪ It is paid at a future date or on demand.
▪ It is an unconditional promise to pay.
▪ There are two parties in a Promissory Note:
• Maker/ Payer: The person who makes the promise to pay.
• Payee: The person to whom the payment is to be made.
▪ A Promissory Note must be written and signed by the Payer.
▪ It cannot be oral or implied.
▪ It can be transferred by agreement or delivery.
▪ Transferee has the same rights to payment as the original payee.

Q27. (b) What are the essential features of Promissory Note? (3X) (4/6) (2013/
3Y 2010)
Ans. Essential Features:
i) Unconditional Promise: A promissory note contains an unconditional
promise to pay a certain sum of money.
ii) Written Document: The promise must be in a clear written document.
iii) Parties Involved: There are two main parties involved in a promissory
note, Maker/ Payer, and Payee.
iv) Certain Amount: The amount of money to be paid must be certain and
clearly specified in the note.
v) Payable on Demand or at a Fixed Future Date: A promissory note can
either be payable on demand or at a fixed future date.
vi) Signature of the Maker: The maker must sign the promissory note to give
their intention to make a binding promise to pay.
vii)Transferability: A promissory note is transferable from one person to
another through agreement and delivery.

Page 25 of 61
 Q27. (c) How does it differ from a Bill of Exchange? (10) (2012)
Ans.
PROMISSORY NOTE BASIS BILL OF EXCHANGE
• It is a written, unconditional 1) Definition • A Bill of Exchange is a written,
promise. unconditional order.
• Made by the maker. • Drawer directs the drawee to
• A specific sum of money is pay a specific sum of money.
paid to the payee. • It is paid to the payee at a
• At a fixed future date or on fixed future date or on
demand. demand.
• Maker/ Payer: The person 2) Parties • Drawer: The person who
who promises to pay. creates the bill.
• Payee: The person to whom • Drawee: The person on
the payment is promised. whom the bill is drawn.
• Payee: The person who is to
receive the payment.
It is a promise to pay money. 3) Nature It is an order to pay money.
No acceptance is required. 4) Acceptance Acceptance is required from the
drawee.
A promissory note is 5) Transferability A bill of exchange is also
transferable. negotiable and transferable.
It must be supported by 6) Consideration The consideration is showed in
consideration. (the reason for the order to pay.
the promise to
pay)
The Maker/ Payer is directly 7) Liability The drawee is liable if they
liable to pay. accept the bill.
It is simple without any 8) Structure It is formal and complex, and
additional conditions. may include conditions.
Used for personal loans, credit 9) Usage Used in international business
arrangements, or small-scale transactions.
transactions.
It can be paid on demand or at a 10) Demand It can be payable:
fixed future time. vs. Time • On demand
• At a fixed time
• On presentation

Page 26 of 61
 • After a certain period
Q28. (a) Define Negotiable Instrument. (4) (3X) (2013/ 2023) What are the
special characteristics of Negotiable Instruments? (4) (2X) (2021/ 2023)
Ans. Under the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881,
▪ Negotiable Instrument is a document.
▪ It guarantees the payment of a fixed amount of money either on demand or
at a fixed future time.
▪ It is transferable.

Key Features:
i) Transferability: It can be transferred from one person to another.
ii) Rights to Payment: The holder of the instrument has the right to receive
payment.
iii) Types of Negotiable Instruments: Promissory Notes, Bills of Exchange, and
Cheques.
iv) Unconditional: The instrument must be free from any conditions.

Special characteristics of Negotiable Instruments:

a) Transferability: Negotiable instruments can be transferred from one person
to another.
b) Title Transfer: The transfer of a negotiable instrument gives the title of the
instrument to the transferee.
c) Right to Sue: The holder of a negotiable instrument has the right to sue on it.
d) Unconditional Promise or Order to Pay: A negotiable instrument contains an
unconditional promise or order to pay a fixed sum of money.
e) Presumptions: When a negotiable instrument is transferred, it is presumed
that it was done so for consideration.
f) Negotiability by Delivery or Agreement: A negotiable instrument can be
transferred either by agreement or by delivery.

Page 27 of 61
 Q28. (b) Discuss the various types of Negotiable Instruments under the
Negotiable Instrument Act. (6/12) (2X) (2013/2023) [OR] Define the term
“Cheque”. (4) (2022)
Ans. The Negotiable Instrument Act, 1881 specially gives 3 primary types of
negotiable instruments. These are as follows:

I. Promissory Note (S.4)

▪ A Promissory Note is a written, unconditional promise made by Maker/
Payer.
▪ It is made to pay a certain sum of money to the Payee either on demand
or at a specified future date.
▪ It is an unconditional promise to pay money.
▪ It can be transferred through agreement or delivery.
▪ No acceptance is required, as it is a direct promise to pay.

II. Bill of Exchange (S.5)

▪ A Bill of Exchange is a written, unconditional order.
▪ It is made by the Drawer to the Drawee.
▪ It is made to pay a certain amount of money to the payee at a fixed future
time or on demand.
▪ It is an unconditional order to pay money, not a promise.
▪ It Involves 3 parties:
(a) Drawer, who creates the bill.
(b) Drawee, the person to whom the order is directed.
(c) Payee, who gets the payment.
▪ It can be transferred to another person by agreement or delivery.

III. Cheque (S.6)

▪ A Cheque is a special form of Bill of Exchange drawn on a bank and payable
on demand.
▪ It is a written order by the drawer to the drawee to pay a fixed amount to
the payee or cheque bearer.
▪ Involves three parties:
(a) Drawer, the person writing the cheque.
(b) Drawee, the bank on which the cheque is drawn.
(c) Payee, the person to whom the cheque is issued.
▪ A cheque can be transferred by agreement or delivery.
▪ A cheque is only valid if it is signed by the drawer.

Page 28 of 61
Q29. (a) What do you mean by ‘Holder’ under the Negotiable Instrument Act,
1881? (4) (2X) (2013/3Y 2010)
Ans.
▪ Under the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, the term 'Holder' is defined in
S.8.
▪ A Holder is a person who is in possession of a negotiable instrument.
▪ It is payable either to bearer or to the person having rightful possession on
demand.
▪ The holder has the right to receive payment of the amount fixed in the
negotiable instrument.
▪ The holder can transfer the instrument to another person through agreement
or delivery.
▪ For e.g., If a cheque is drawn in favor of John, John is the holder of that
cheque, and he can either cash it or transfer it to another person.

Page 29 of 61
 Q29. (b) Distinguish between ‘holder’ and ‘holder in due course.’ (4/6) (2X)
(2013/3Y 2010)
Ans.
HOLDER BASIS HOLDER IN DUE COURSE
A person who has the 1) Definition A person who gets the
instrument and receives the instrument in good faith and
payment. without notice of defects.
May receive the instrument 2) Receive Must receive the instrument in
through transfer or any other good faith for value.
means.
Subject to previous claims or 3) Rights Makes the instrument free from
defenses from previous parties. defects in title and personal
defenses.
Do not have the right to sue 4) Right to sue Has complete right to sue
previous parties. previous parties.
Holder can become a holder 5) Maturity of the Holder in due course can only
before or after the maturity of Instrument become a Holder in due course
the Instrument. before the maturity of the
instrument.
May not be protected if there 6) Protection Enjoys greater protection even if
are defects in the instrument’s there are defects in the
title. instrument’s title, except for real
defenses.

Page 30 of 61
Q30. Discuss about the essential ingredients for enforcement of Section 138
(Dishonour of Cheques) of Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881. (8) (2021)
[OR]
State the provisions and procedure relating to dishonoured of cheque for
insufficiency of fund in the account with recent relevant judicial decisions. (12)
(2022)
Ans. Essential ingredients for S.138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 are:

1) Existence of a Cheque:
▪ A valid cheque must be drawn on a bank.
▪ It must be dishonoured for non-payment.
▪ The instrument must be in writing and signed by drawer.
▪ It must be payable on order.
2) Presentation of the Cheque for Payment:
▪ The cheque must be presented for payment within 3 months from the
issue date.
▪ If not presented, the dishonour provisions under S.138 cannot be
enforced.
3) Dishonour of the Cheque: The cheque must be dishonoured by the bank due
to Insufficient funds.
4) Receipt of a Notice of Dishonour:
▪ Payee must give a notice of dishonour to the drawer within 30 days of
receiving the memo from the bank.
▪ He can demand payment of the cheque amount.
▪ If no such notice is given, the drawer cannot be liable under S.138.
5) Failure to Make Payment Within 15 Days:
▪ Drawer must make the payment of the cheque amount within 15 days
from receiving notice.
▪ Failure to payment leads to legal proceedings u/S.138.
6) The Dishonour Must Be Willful: If the drawer intentionally issues an
insufficient funds cheque, they can be held liable u/S.138.
7) The Dishonour Must Be Within the Time Limit:
▪ The proceedings must be started within 1 month after 15-day notice
period.
▪ If not filed, the offense u/S.138 becomes time-barred.

Page 31 of 61
8) Criminal Liability of the Drawer: The drawer can be penalized with 2 yrs
imprisonment or fine for twice the cheque amount or both.

Case Laws:

a) M.S. Narayana Menon v. State of Kerala (2006): The Supreme Court stated
that:
▪ U/S.138, the holder in due course of a dishonoured cheque has the
right to start legal proceedings.
▪ If the drawer fails to pay the cheque amount after receiving a legal
notice, he is liable u/S.138.

b) K.K. Verma v. Union of India (2011): The Delhi High Court stated that only
because a cheque has been dishonoured does not automatically mean a
criminal offense u/S.138.

c) R. Vijayan v. Baby (2012): The Supreme Court of India stated that:

▪ Notice of dishonour must be given within 30 days after receiving the
dishonour memo.
▪ If not done, the right to file a complaint u/S.138 is lost.

Page 32 of 61
Q31. (a) Discuss that a holder in due course is a holder but a holder is not a
holder in due course. (8) (2023)
Ans. While every Holder in Due Course is a Holder, not every Holder qualifies as
a Holder in Due Course.

HOLDER:
• Holder is defined u/S.8 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881.
• A holder is a person who has the negotiable instrument.
• He can recover the amount due on it.
• The person must actually have the instrument.
• They must have the right to receive or recover the amount from the liable
parties.
• Title may be defective if the instrument was obtained fraudulently or
unlawfully.

HOLDER IN DUE COURSE:

• Holder in due course is defined u/S.9 of the Negotiable Instruments Act,
1881.
• He gets the instrument for consideration.
• He gets it before its maturity.
• He gets it in good faith and without knowledge of any defects.

A HOLDER IN DUE COURSE IS ALWAYS A HOLDER:

• Holder in due course has the instrument legally.
• He can enforce payment.
• They are necessarily a holder u/S.8.
• They enjoy additional privileges and protections, such as:
(a) They take the instrument free from all old defects in title.
(b) They have better rights than an ordinary holder.
(c) They can enforce payment even if the instrument was originally obtained
through fraud, coercion, or misrepresentation.

A HOLDER IS NOT NECESSARILY A HOLDER IN DUE COURSE:

• A person may be a holder but not a holder in due course if:
• They obtained the instrument without consideration.
• They received the instrument after maturity.
• They knew of defects in the title when acquiring it.

Page 33 of 61
 Q31. (b) What is the difference between a holder in due course and a holder
for value? (8) (2023)
Ans.
HOLDER IN DUE COURSE BASIS HOLDER FOR VALUE
A person who gets the 1) Definition • A person who holds the
negotiable instrument: negotiable instrument.
• In good faith • Has given something of value
• For value in exchange.
• Without notice of defects. • But may not have get it in
good faith or without notice
of defect.
Can freely transfer the 2) Transferability Cannot freely transfer the
Negotiable Instrument. Negotiable Instrument.
Must have the instrument in 3) Good Faith Good faith is not required.
good faith.
Must get the instrument 4) Notice of Defects May have notice of defects or
without notice of any defects. issues.
Highly protected under the law. 5) Legal Protection Less protected.
Can enforce the instrument 6) Ability to enforce Can enforce the instrument, but
against all previous parties. the Instrument may be subject to defenses.
A person who purchases a 7) Example A person who receives a cheque
cheque from a friend in good from a business in exchange for
faith without knowing the services, but the cheque was
cheque was dishonoured earlier. dishonoured.
M.S. Narayana Menon vs. State 8) Case Law S. R. S. Construction Co. vs.
of Kerala (2006) State of Tamil Nadu (2015)
SC stated that holder in due If a holder has received the
course can enforce the instrument with knowledge of
instrument free from previous defects, they cannot get
defects. protections of a holder in due
course.

Page 34 of 61
Q32. (a) What do you understand by presentment of a negotiable instrument?
(6) (3y/2011)
Ans.
▪ Presentment is defined in S.2(12) of the NI Act, 1881.
▪ It is the act of presenting a negotiable instrument for payment.
▪ It is usually done by the holder of the instrument at a fixed or expected place.

Types of Presentment:
a) Presentment for Payment: This occurs when the holder presents the
instrument to the person who has to pay on demand.
b) Presentment for Acceptance: This occurs when the holder presents a bill of
exchange to the acceptor for their acceptance.

Time and Manner of Presentment:

a) Timely Presentment:
▪ Presentment must be made within a reasonable time.
▪ If delayed, the holder may lose the right to take legal action against the
drawer or acceptor.
b) Place of Presentment:
▪ Presentment must be made at the stated place of payment.
▪ If no such place is given, the instrument should be presented at the
address of the maker, drawer, or acceptor.

Exceptions to Presentment: In some situations, presentment may be

surrendered by the holder.
a) If the drawer or acceptor surrenders presentment expressly.
b) In the case of overdue instruments, where further presentment may be
unnecessary.

Page 35 of 61
Q32. (b) Which are the instruments that should be presented for payment and
what circumstances render presentment for payment unnecessary?
(Exceptions) (10) (3y/2011)
Ans. According to the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, the following
instruments must be presented for payment:

a) Promissory Notes (S.18 of the NI Act, 1881):

▪ A promissory note is an instrument where the maker promises to pay a
fixed amount to a person on their order on demand or at a fixed future
date.
▪ A promissory note must be presented for payment when it is due.
▪ If the note is payable on demand, it must be presented for payment at a
reasonable time after it is issued.

b) Bills of Exchange (S.18 of the NI Act, 1881):

▪ A bill of exchange is a written order.
▪ Drawer gives it to the Drawee to pay a fixed amount to the Payee.
▪ It must be presented for payment on the due date of maturity.
▪ If accepted, the holder must present it to the acceptor for payment when
it matures.

c) Cheques (S.84 of the NI Act, 1881):

▪ A cheque is a type of bill of exchange, which is payable on demand.
▪ It is drawn on a bank.
▪ It must be presented for payment to the Drawee bank within a reasonable
time, i.e., within 6 months from the issue date.
▪ If failed the cheque may become expired and be dishonoured.

While presentment for payment is generally required, there are some exceptions
where presentment for payment is unnecessary:

a) Liability Released: If the maker, acceptor, or drawer has released the liability
on the negotiable instrument, presentment for payment is unnecessary.
b) Express Refusal: If the maker or drawer expressly refuse presentment,
presentment unnecessary.
c) Loss or destruction: If a negotiable instrument is lost or destroyed and the
holder is unable to present it, presentment for payment is unnecessary.
d) Late Instrument: Presentment for payment is unnecessary when the
instrument is late.

Page 36 of 61
e) Unavailable Party: Instruments that are payable on demand or have a fixed
maturity date, if the party is unavailable, presentment may be unnecessary.
f) Written Bill of Exchange: If a bill of exchange is accepted in writing by the
Drawee, presentment for payment is unnecessary.

Page 37 of 61
Q33. (a) Discuss the position of a minor and a person of unsound mind as a
party to Negotiable Instrument. (10) (3y/2010)
Ans. POSITION OF A MINOR AS A PARTY TO NEGOTIABLE INSTRUMENTS:
▪ A minor is a person who is not 18 years.
▪ As per Indian law, a minor is presumed to be incapable of doing a valid
contract.
▪ Any contract done by a minor is void ab initio.

a) Minor as a Drawer:
▪ A minor cannot be a drawer because a minor cannot legally do a contract.
▪ A minor cannot lawfully make a promise or order to pay.
▪ A minor’s signature on a negotiable instrument is invalid.
▪ The instrument cannot be enforced by or against a minor.

b) Minor as a Drawee:
▪ A minor cannot be a Drawee because they do not have the capacity to
accept a bill or cheque.
▪ A minor’s acceptance is invalid.

c) Minor as a Payee:
▪ A minor can be the payee, because payee does not require any contractual
capacity.
▪ The minor can get the due amount.
▪ Instrument remains voidable if the minor is the Drawer or Drawee.

Page 38 of 61
POSITION OF A PERSON OF UNSOUND MIND AS A PARTY TO NEGOTIABLE
INSTRUMENTS:
▪ An unsound mind person refers to a person who, due to mental illness or
incapacity, cannot understand the nature of their actions.
▪ The mental condition could be temporary or permanent.

a) Unsound Mind as a Drawer:

▪ An unsound mind person cannot be a drawer because they do not have
the mental capacity to understand the legal suggestions.
▪ Any such instrument executed by an unsound mind person is voidable.

b) Unsound Mind as a Drawee: An unsound mind person cannot be a drawee,

because they do not have the mental capacity to accept or pay a negotiable
instrument.

c) Unsound Mind as a Payee:

▪ An unsound mind person can be a payee of a negotiable instrument.
▪ Payee does not require any contractual capacity, so an unsound mind
person can legally receive the instrument.

Page 39 of 61
Q33. (b) What are the ways to discharge from liability on Notes, Bills, Cheques?
(6) (3y/2010)
Ans. Ways in which a party can be discharged from liability under the Negotiable
Instrument Act, 1881 are as follows:

1) Payment in Due Course (S.82):

▪ The primary way to discharge liability is by making payment in due course.
▪ Person pays the full amount left to the holder of the instrument under the
agreed terms.

2) Acceptance or Agreement of the Instrument (S.82):

▪ The liability of a party may also be discharged if the instrument is accepted
or agreed by the holder.
▪ If a bill of exchange or cheque is accepted by the drawee or agreed by the
payee, liability is discharged.

3) Cancellation of the Instrument (S.82): A cancellation of the negotiable

instrument will also discharge the liability of the person responsible for the
instrument.

4) By Release (S.78):
▪ The holder of the instrument can release the party from liability.
▪ It can be formal, through a written agreement or by a verbal agreement.

5) By Material Change (S.125):

▪ A party can be discharged from liability if the instrument has been
materially changed without their consent.
▪ If the instrument is changed in a way that is not agreed upon by the
parties, it becomes void.
▪ The person responsible for the changed instrument is discharged from
liability.

6) By Expiry of Time (S.84): The liability of the parties can be discharged if the
instrument is not presented for payment within the fixed time period.

Page 40 of 61
SHORT NOTES:
1) Promissory Note and Bill of Exchange (4) (2021):

PROMISSORY NOTES (S.18 of the NI Act, 1881):

▪ A promissory note is an instrument where the maker promises to pay a
specific amount to a person on their order on demand or at a fixed future
date.
▪ A promissory note must be presented for payment when it is due.
▪ If the note is payable on demand, it must be presented for payment at a
reasonable time after it is issued.

BILLS OF EXCHANGE (S.18 of the NI Act, 1881):

▪ A bill of exchange is a written order.
▪ Drawer gives it to the Drawee to pay a specified amount to the Payee on
their order at a certain time.
▪ It must be presented for payment on the due date of maturity.
▪ If accepted, the holder must present it to the acceptor for payment when
it matures.

2) Promissory Note (4) (2022)

A Promissory Note is defined under S.4 of the Negotiable Instruments Act,

1881.

Key features of a promissory note include:

1. Unconditional Promise: The note must have an unconditional promise to pay

the specified amount.
2. Parties: It must involve 2 parties—the Maker (who promises to pay) and the
Payee (to whom payment is made).
3. Written and Signed: The promise must be in writing and signed by the maker.
4. Specified Amount: The amount payable must be certain, and the payment
can be demanded either immediately or on a specific date.

Example: A person writing, "I promise to pay Rs. 10,000 to X on demand," makes
a valid promissory note.

Page 41 of 61
3) Bill of Exchange (4) (2022):
▪ A Bill of Exchange is defined under S.5 of the Negotiable Instruments Act,
1881.
▪ It is an instrument in writing that contains an unconditional order.
▪ It directs the Drawee to pay a certain sum of money to the order of a
specified Payee.
▪ Either on demand or at a fixed future time.

Key features of a bill of exchange include:

1) Unconditional Order: It must contain an unconditional order to pay.

2) Parties Involved: It involves 3 parties—the Drawer (who issues the bill), the
Drawee (who is ordered to pay), and the Payee (who receives the payment).
3) Written and Signed: It must be in writing and signed by the drawer.
4) Specified Amount: The amount payable must be certain.

Example: A merchant writes to a bank, "Pay Rs. 5,000 to John on his order." This
makes a valid bill of exchange.

Page 42 of 61
4) Cheque (8/4) (3X) (2012/2022/3y-2010):
▪ A Cheque is defined under S.6 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881.
▪ It is a bill of exchange drawn on a bank and payable on demand.
▪ It is an instrument used to make payments or transfer funds from one bank
account to another.

Key Features of a Cheque:

a) A cheque is a written order from a drawer to the drawee to pay a certain
amount to the payee.
b) It is payable immediately upon presentation at the bank.
c) It must be drawn on a bank account.
d) It must specify the amount to be paid, which must be in figures and words to
avoid ambiguity.
e) The drawer’s signature is important for the validity of cheque.
f) It serves as permission for the bank to make the payment.
g) Cheque is transferable.

Types of Cheques:
a) Bearer Cheque: A cheque payable to anyone who presents it to the bank.
b) Order Cheque: A cheque payable to a fixed person on their order.
c) Crossed Cheque: A cheque payable only through a bank and not at the
counter.
d) Post-Dated Cheque: A cheque written with a future date, which cannot be
cashed before that date.
e) Stale Cheque: A cheque presented after 3 to 6 months of issuance, which
may be dishonoured by the bank.

Page 43 of 61
5) Dishonour of Cheque (4) (2012):
▪ Dishonour is stated in S.138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881.
▪ It occurs when a bank refuses to make payment of the cheque due to
certain reasons.

Reasons for Dishonour:

a) Insufficient funds: When the drawer’s bank account has less balance to
cover the cheque amount.
b) Invalid Signature: If the drawer’s signature on the cheque does not
match the signature on record with the bank.
c) Closed Account: If the cheque is drawn on a closed or non-existent
account.
d) Post-dated or Stale Cheque: A cheque presented before or after the
fixed date.

Example: If a person issues a cheque with insufficient funds, and it gets

dishonoured, they may face legal action under S.138.

6) Cross Cheque (4) (3y/2011):

▪ A crossed cheque is a cheque that has two parallel lines drawn across its face.
▪ It states that the cheque must be deposited into a bank account and cannot
be cashed at the counter.
▪ The primary purpose of crossing a cheque is to add security.
▪ It ensures that the funds are deposited into the account of the payee.
▪ A crossed cheque can be transferred to another person.
▪ It can also be signed on the back by the payee to another person.

Types of Crossing:

a) General Crossing: The cheque is crossed with two parallel lines and may
include the words "and company" or "or company" between them.
b) Special Crossing: If the cheque is crossed with the name of a fixed bank
between the parallel lines, the payment is made only through that said bank.

Page 44 of 61
7) Exception to the duty to honour cheque (4) (3y/2010):
U/S.31 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, a bank has a duty to honour a
cheque. Some exceptions to this are as follows:

a) Insufficient Funds: If there is not enough fund in the drawer's account to

cover the cheque.

b) Cheque is Stale: If a cheque is presented after 6 months from the issue date.

c) Mismatch in Signature: If the signature on the cheque does not match the
signature on record with the bank.

d) Account Closed: If the drawer’s account is closed at the time of presentation.

e) Post-Dated Cheque: A post-dated cheque cannot be honoured before the

date mentioned on it.

f) Fraud or Forgery: If the cheque is found to be forged or taken by fraud.

Page 45 of 61
 GENDER JUSTICE AND FEMINIST JURISPRUDENCE (10.4)
Module 1: INTRODUCTION
Q1. What are the duties of State parties to eradicate the discrimination against
women under the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination
Against Women, 1979? (16) (2023)
Ans. The Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against
Women (CEDAW), 1979, needs State parties to take necessary measures to
eliminate discrimination against women. The key duties are:
1. Legal and Policy Measures 5. Health & Family Rights
• Adopt laws and policies to stop • Guarantee equal access to healthcare
discrimination against women. and family planning.
• Safeguard equality in courts, • Guarantee equality in marriage, divorce,
administration, and public life. child custody, and property rights.
2. Protection of Rights 6. Protection from Exploitation & Violence:
• Guarantee women's equal rights with men • Take steps to prevent trafficking and
in all fields. exploitation of women.
• Change or stop discriminatory laws, • Protect women from violence,
customs, and practices. harassment, and harmful practices.

3. Participation in Political & Public Life: 7. Rural & Weak Women

• Check women have equal rights in voting,
• Give special protections for rural and
government positions, and decision-
weak women.
making.
• Provide access to resources, loan,
• Promote women's participation in
housing, and employment.
international representation.
4. Equal Education & Employment: 8. Awareness & Training
• Give equal access to education at all levels.
• Promote education to eliminate gender
• Provide equal job opportunities, fair discrimination.
wages, and protection from discrimination
• Train government officials, employers,
at work.
and the public on gender equality.

Page 46 of 61
 Module 2: CONSTITUTION OF INDIA AND THE POSITION OF WOMEN
Q2. Discuss the relevant provision of constitution relating to gender equality
and empowerment of woman in India. (16) (2X) (2016/ 2022)
Ans. The Indian Constitution provides several provisions to verify gender
equality and women's empowerment.

1. Fundamental Rights (Part III)

• Article 14 – Guarantees equality before the law and equal protection of laws for men
and women.
• Article 15(1) – Stops discrimination on the basis of sex, caste, religion, or place of birth.
• Article 15(3)
– Allows the government to make special provisions for women and children to promote
equality.
- Based on this, laws like the Dowry Prohibition Act, 1961, Protection of Women from
Domestic Violence Act, 2005, and Maternity Benefit Act, 1961 were made.
• Article 16 – Give equal opportunities in public employment for men and women.
• Article 23 – Stops human trafficking and forced labor, which protects women from
exploitation.
• Article 24 – Stops child labor, and prevents early exploitation of girls.

2. Directive Principles of State Policy (DPSP) (Part IV)

• Article 39(a) – Gives equal right to livelihood for both men and women.
• Article 39(d) – Guarantees equal pay for equal work for both genders.
• Article 42 – Provides for maternity relief and proper working conditions for women.
• Article 46 – Promotes education and economic interests of weaker sections, including
women.
3. Fundamental Duties (Part IV-A) 4. Reservation for Women
• Article 51A(e) – Requires citizens to stop • Article 243D & 243T – Reserves one-
disrespectful Actions against women's third seats for women in Panchayati Raj
dignity. Institutions and Urban Local Bodies.
• 103rd Constitutional Amendment –
Provides for reservation of economically
weaker sections (EWS), including
women.

Page 47 of 61
Q3. What is the status of women representing the local bodies like Panchayats
or Municipalities under the Constitution of India? (16) (2023)
Ans. The Indian Constitution gives reservation for women in Panchayats (rural
local bodies) and Municipalities (urban local bodies) to make sure they actively
participate in Governance.

1. Reservation in Panchayats (Rural Local Bodies) {Article 243D (73rd

Amendment Act, 1992)}
 Reserves one-third (33%) of total seats for women in Gram Panchayats,
Block Samitis, and Zila Parishads.
 One-third of Chairperson posts (Pradhan/Sarpanch) are also reserved for
women.
 Includes Scheduled Castes (SC) and Scheduled Tribes (ST) women in the
reservation.
2. Reservation in Municipalities (Urban Local Bodies) {Article 243T (74th
Amendment Act, 1992)}
 Reserves one-third (33%) of total seats in Municipalities (Nagar
Panchayat, Municipal Council, and Municipal Corporation) for women.
 One-third reservation applies to Chairperson posts as well.
 SC/ST women also benefit from this reservation.
3. Women’s Political Empowerment
 Ensures direct elections for women in local governance.
 Increases women’s role in decision-making and policy application.
 Leads to better focus on women's issues like education, health, and
safety.
4. Increased Reservation in Some States: Some states like Bihar, Rajasthan,
Madhya Pradesh, and Kerala have increased women’s reservation to 50% in
local bodies.
5. Effect on Governance
 More women in leadership roles at the grassroots level.
 Improves focus on social welfare, sanitation, and economic development.
 Empowers women by giving them political and financial power.
 This reservation system makes sure greater political representation and
empowerment of women in local governance across India.

Page 48 of 61
Module 3: CRIMINAL LAW AND WOMEN
Q4. (a) Define Cruelty. (4/6) (2X) (2016/2022)
Ans.
 It is a criminal offense u/S.498A of the Indian Penal Code (IPC), 1860.
 These are acts of physical or mental abuse done by a husband or his relatives
on a woman.
 It causes harm to her health, life, or well-being.
 The law deals with the issues of dowry-related violence and the abuse of
women in marital relationships.
a) Physical or Mental Harm: The offense involves either physical harm (like
assault, beating) or mental harm (like harassment, threats).
b) Abuse by Husband or Relatives: Cruelty related to dowry demands must be
committed by the husband or her in-laws.
c) Intention or Knowledge: The cruelty must be committed with the intention
of causing harm or knowledge that it is likely to cause harm to the woman’s
health, safety, or well-being.
d) Punishment: U/S.498A, IPC, 1860 the punishment for cruelty can be
imprisonment for a term of up to 3 years and a fine.

Page 49 of 61
Q4. (b) Discuss the legal provisions relating to cruelty by husband or his
relatives for dowry. (8) (2016)
Ans. The Criminal Law in India provides legal protection to women against
cruelty by their husband or in-laws for dowry demands. The main provisions are:

1. Section 498A IPC – Cruelty by Husband or His Relatives: This section punishes
a husband or his relatives if they subject a woman to cruelty which includes:
 Physical or mental harm that risk the wife’s life, health, or safety.
 Harassment for dowry demands, including threats and emotional abuse.
 Punishment under Section 498A: Imprisonment up to 3 years and Fine may
also be charged. It is a cognizable, non-bailable, and non-compoundable
offence.
2. Section 304B IPC – Dowry Death
 Applies when a woman dies under unnatural circumstances within 7 years
of marriage.
 Dowry-related harassment before death is a key factor.
 Punishment: Minimum imprisonment of 7 years, which may extend to life
imprisonment.
3. Section 306 IPC – Abetment of Suicide
 If cruelty for dowry leads a woman to commit suicide, the husband or in-
laws can be punished.
 Punishment: Imprisonment up to 10 years, along with a fine.
4. Burden of Proof (Presumption under Law): If a woman dies due to cruelty or
harassment, the court presumes the husband or in-laws are responsible under
Section 113A and 113B of the Indian Evidence Act.
5. Protection for Victims: Affected women can file a police complaint or take
help under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005.

Page 50 of 61
Q5. (a) Define “Domestic Violence”. (4) (2022)
Ans. The Indian Penal Code (IPC) does not directly define "Domestic Violence,"
but it is covered under Section 498A IPC and the Protection of Women from
Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (PWDVA).

1. Meaning of Domestic Violence: Any act of physical, emotional, sexual, or

economic abuse by a husband or his relatives against a woman in a domestic
relationship.
2. Key Provisions Related to Domestic Violence
 Section 498A IPC – Punishes cruelty by husband or in-laws, including physical
and mental harassment.
 PWDVA, 2005 – Provides legal protection, including residence rights,
monetary relief, and protection orders.
3. Punishment under Section 498A IPC
 Imprisonment up to 3 years.
 Fine may also be charged.

Page 51 of 61
Q5. (b) State the duties and functions of the Protection Officers under the
Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005. (6) (2022)
Ans. The Protection Officer (PO) plays an important role in applying the
Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (PWDVA). The duties
and functions of a Protection Officer are:

1. Assisting the Aggrieved Woman

 Helps the woman in filing a complaint and getting protection under the
Act.
 Provides information about legal rights and remedies available.
2. Filing a Domestic Incident Report (DIR)
 Prepares and submits a Domestic Incident Report (DIR) to the Magistrate.
 Checks that all details of violence and abuse are recorded.
3. Assisting the Court and Police
 Helps in serving notices to the respondent (accused person).
 Helps in the execution of protection orders and other court orders.
4. Ensuring Safe Shelter and Medical Aid
 Arranges for the immediate shelter of the victim if required.
 Helps in providing medical examination and treatment.
5. Helping in Legal Proceedings
 Assists the woman in filing cases under IPC (like Section 498A) and other
legal provisions.
 Agrees to follow with Monetary Relief, Custody, and Residence Orders
issued by the court.
6. Reporting to the Magistrate: Submits regular reports on the case status to
the Magistrate.

Page 52 of 61
Q6. (a) Define Family Court. (6) (2016)
Ans.
 Family Courts are special courts established under the Family Courts Act,
1984 to handle family-related disputes.
 Though mainly dealing with civil matters (like divorce, child custody, and
maintenance), they also handle criminal matters related to family law under
the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC).
 Family Courts aim to provide speedy, sensitive, and effective justice in
family disputes, including certain criminal matters related to women and
children.

KEY CRIMINAL LAW PROVISIONS IN FAMILY COURTS

1. S.125 CrPC – Deals with maintenance for wife, child, and parents.
2. Domestic Violence Act, 2005 – Family Courts enforce protection orders,
residence orders, and monetary relief.
3. S.498A IPC – Cases of cruelty by husband or in-laws may be referred to
Family Courts for settlement.

Page 53 of 61
Q6. (b) Discuss the powers of State Government in appointing Judges, Social
Welfare Agencies, Counsellors, and another employees of Family Court. (10)
(2016)
Ans. The State Government has powers under the Family Courts Act, 1984
regarding the appointment of Judges, Social Welfare Agencies, Counsellors,
and other employees in Family Courts.
1. Appointment of Judges:
 Under S.4 of the Family Courts Act, 1984, the State Government, consults
with the High Court, and appoints Family Court Judges.
 The appointed judge must be:
 A District Judge or qualified to be a District Judge.
 A person with experience in family law and social issues.
2. Appointment of Social Welfare Agencies and Counsellors:
 Under S.6, the State Government may appoint:
 Counsellors to help in conciliation and dispute resolution.
 Social welfare agencies to provide support and rehabilitation
services.
3. Appointment of Other Employees:
 Under S.8, the State Government appoints:
 Administrative staff such as clerks, officers, and support staff.
 Employees to assist in court proceedings and case management.
4. Consultation with the High Court:
 All appointments of Judges and legal officers must be approved by the High
Court.
 Checks that qualified and experienced personnel handle family matters.
5. Establishment of Family Courts: Under S.3, the State Government has the
power to set up Family Courts in cities with a population of over 1 million.

Page 54 of 61
 Q7. State the judicial approach towards Marital Rape in different countries.
(16) (2022)
Ans.
• Marital rape means sexual intercourse without consent by a husband with
his wife.
• The legal status of marital rape is different in different countries.
They are as follows:
COUNTRIES WHERE MARITAL RAPE IS AN COUNTRIES WHERE MARITAL RAPE IS NOT
OFFENCE AN OFFENCE
(a) United States: All 50 states have (a) India
criminalized marital rape. The Supreme Court • Exception 2 to Section 375 of IPC states
has upheld that marital status does not protect that forced intercourse by a husband
from rape charges. with his wife (if she is above 18) is not
rape.
• Marital rape is not criminalized, but its
legality is debatable.
• Several High Court judgments and
petitions in the Supreme Court are
challenging this provision.
(b) United Kingdom: Marital rape was (b) Pakistan: Marital rape is not a criminal
criminalized in 1991 through the landmark case offense unless the wife is below 16 years.
R v R (1991), where the court ruled that a wife
is not the property of her husband.
(c) Canada: Criminalized in 1983 by removing (c) Saudi Arabia & UAE: Based on Sharia law,
the marital exception from rape laws. Marital where a wife is expected to obey her
rape is treated as sexual assault, with severe husband. Marital rape is not recognized as a
punishments. crime.

COUNTRIES WHERE MARITAL RAPE IS PARTIALLY AN OFFENCE

These countries recognize marital rape only in certain conditions, such as judicial separation
or extreme violence:
(a) China: Recognized only in cases of extreme abuse or where the couple is living separately.
(b) South Africa: Criminalized marital rape under the Sexual Offences Act, 2007, but
application is weak.

Page 55 of 61
 Module 4: SPECIAL WOMEN WELFARE LAWS
Q8. (a) Discuss the legal provisions relating to indecent representation of
women in India. (8) (2022)
Ans. The Indian legal system has different laws to stop the indecent
representation of women in advertisements, publications, and other media.
The key legal provisions are:
1. Indecent Representation of Women (Prohibition) Act, 1986
This Act specifically stops the indecent representation of women in any form.
Key Provisions:
• Section 3: Stops the publication, printing, or distribution of any material that
contains an indecent representation of women.
• Section 4: Stops the Showing of advertisements containing indecent representation
of women.
• Punishment:
✓ First offense: Imprisonment up to 2 years and fine up to ₹2,000.
✓ Subsequent offense: Imprisonment up to 5 years and fine up to ₹10,000 to ₹1
lakh.
2. Indian Penal Code (IPC), 1860
• Section 292: Punishes the sale, distribution, or public display of indecent books,
pamphlets, drawings, or any other material.
• In Ranjit D. Udeshi v. State of Maharashtra (1965), the Supreme Court upheld the
restrictions on indecent content under Section 292 IPC. Courts have emphasized that
women’s dignity and modesty must be protected in all forms of media.
• Section 293: Stricter punishment for selling or distributing indecent material to
minors.
• Section 294: Criminalizes indecent acts and songs in public places.

3. The Information Technology (IT) Act, 2000 4. The Cinematograph Act, 1952 Empowers
• Section 67: Punishes publishing or the Central Board of Film Certification
transmitting indecent material (CBFC) to regulate indecent content in films
electronically, including on websites and before public release.
social media.
5. The Press Council Act, 1978: The Press
• Punishment: Imprisonment up to 3 years
Council of India (PCI) has the power to act
and fine up to ₹5 lakh.
against newspapers and magazines
publishing indecent content about women.

Page 56 of 61
Q8. (b) Discuss the legal provisions relating to Causing of miscarriage of injuries
to unborn children under Indian Penal Code, 1860. (8) (2X) (2016/2022)
Ans.
• The Indian Penal Code (IPC), 1860 criminalizes the causing of miscarriage
and harm to unborn children under Sections 312 to 316.
• However, medical termination of pregnancy is allowed under the Medical
Termination of Pregnancy (MTP) Act, 1971, in certain conditions.
• These provisions aim to protect pregnant women and unborn children from
intentional or negligent harm.
1. Section 312 – Causing Miscarriage
 Punishes voluntarily causing miscarriage to a woman.
 Exception: If miscarriage is caused in good faith to save the woman’s life, it is
not an offense.
 Punishment:
 If it is before foetus movement: Up to 3 years of imprisonment, or fine,
or both.
 If it is after foetus movement: Up to 7 years of imprisonment, and fine.
2. Section 313 – Causing Miscarriage Without Woman’s Consent
 If miscarriage is caused without the woman’s consent, the punishment is
up to life imprisonment or up to 10 years and fine.
 This section applies regardless of the pregnancy stage.
3. Section 314 – Death Caused by Act Done with Intent to Cause Miscarriage
 If a person causes miscarriage leading to the woman’s death, the
punishment is:
 If done with the woman’s consent: Up to 10 years imprisonment and
fine.
 If done without consent: Punishable under Section 302 (murder) or
Section 304 (culpable homicide).
4. Section 315 – Act Done to Prevent Child from Being Born Alive
 Criminalizes intentional acts that prevent a child from being born alive or
cause death after birth.
 Exception: If done in good faith to save the mother’s life.
 Punishment: Up to 10 years imprisonment or fine, or both.

5. Section 316 – Causing Death of Unborn Child by Act Amounting to Culpable

Homicide

Page 57 of 61
 If an act leads to the death of an unborn child (capable of being born alive),
it is punishable as culpable homicide.
 Punishment: Up to 10 years imprisonment and fine.

Page 58 of 61
 Q9. (a) State the definition of ‘brothel’ under the Immoral Traffic (Prevention)
Act, 1956. (2) (2022)
Ans. As per S.2(a) of the Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act, 1956, a "brothel"
includes:
• Any house, room, conveyance, or place used for the purpose of sexual
exploitation or abuse for the gain of another person.
• It includes places where two or more persons are involved in prostitution.
Thus, a brothel is not limited to a building but can be any place used for
commercial sexual exploitation.

Q9. (b) What are the punishments for keeping a brothel or allowing premises
to be used as a brothel? (8) (2022)
Ans. Under the Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act, 1956 (ITPA), keeping or
allowing premises to be used as a brothel is a punishable offense.
Running a brothel or allowing premises to be used for prostitution is a serious
offense under the ITPA, 1956.
Strict penalties, imprisonment, and fines apply to offenders, ensuring such
activities are prevented.
The relevant provisions are:
1. Section 3 – Punishment for Keeping a Brothel or Allowing Premises to be Used as a
Brothel
• First conviction: Imprisonment for 1 to 3 years and a fine of up to ₹10,000.
• Subsequent conviction: Imprisonment for 2 to 5 years and a fine of up to ₹2,00,000.

2. Section 7 – Allowing a Public Place to be Used for Prostitution: If a public place is used
for prostitution with the knowledge of the owner or occupier, the punishment is:
• First conviction: Imprisonment up to 3 months or fine up to ₹200.
• Subsequent conviction: Imprisonment up to 6 months or fine up to ₹500.

3. Section 18 – Closing of Brothel and Eviction of Offenders: A Magistrate can order to close
a brothel and evict the offenders from the premises.

Page 59 of 61
Q9. (c) State your view about whether the prostitution is illegal in India. (6)
(2022)
Ans. Prostitution itself is not completely illegal in India, but many activities
related to it are criminalized under the Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act, 1956
(ITPA).
Prostitution as a private profession is not illegal, but organized activities like
brothels, hiring, requesting, and trafficking is punishable under Indian law.
Legal Aspects:
1) Engaging in Prostitution Privately – Not Illegal if done voluntarily and
without request in public places.
2) Running a Brothel (Section 3 ITPA) – Illegal and punishable with
imprisonment.
3) Living on the Earnings of Prostitution (Section 4 ITPA) – Illegal, applies to
prostitution controller or others financially dependent on sex work.
4) Requesting Clients in Public (Section 8 ITPA) – Illegal, stops openly
requesting customers.
5) Prostitution Near Public Places (Section 7 ITPA) – Illegal, banned within 200
meters of public places like schools, hospitals, etc.

Page 60 of 61
Q10. "Selling and buying minor for purpose of prostitution is an offence under
the Indian Constitution." Discuss with relevant case laws. (16) (2023)
Ans. The sale and purchase of minors for the purpose of prostitution is a
violation of human rights. The Indian Constitution stops such practices by
relevant statutes like:
a) The Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act, 1956 (ITPA)
b) The Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 (POCSO Act)
c) The Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015 (JJ Act)
d) Indian Penal Code (IPC)

Some Case laws related to selling and buying minor for purpose of prostitution:
1) Gaurav Jain vs. Union of India (1997):
▪ This landmark case addressed the issue of human trafficking, especially
the trafficking of women and children for sexual exploitation.
▪ The Supreme Court stated the need for a complete law to prevent the
trafficking of women and children for prostitution.
▪ The court stated the importance of protecting the dignity of women and
children.
▪ It gave better enforcement of laws to stop trafficking.

2) Laxmi vs. Union of India (2014):

▪ The Supreme Court of India held that prostitution is not illegal.
▪ Activities like trafficking, buying minors for prostitution, and exploitation
of women for commercial purposes are stopped.
▪ The court stated the importance of giving support to victims.

3) Budhadev Karmaskar vs. State of West Bengal (2011):

▪ The Supreme Court dealt with the condition of sex workers and their
rights.
▪ The case focused on the rights of adult sex workers.
▪ The judgment stated that children are unsafe to trafficking for
prostitution.
▪ Exploitation is a severe violation of their fundamental rights.
▪ It is the state’s responsibility to protect unsafe children from exploitation.

4) Rupan Deol Bajaj v. KPS Gill (1995):

▪ This case focused on sexual harassment.
▪ It supports the constitutional commitment to gender justice.
▪ It states the need for gender-sensitive legal frameworks that protect
women from exploitation and harassment.

Page 61 of 61