0% found this document useful (0 votes)
20 views7 pages

The Legendary Status of Dragons

This paper explores whether dragons deserve the title of 'legendary' monsters by examining their origins and representations in various cultures, particularly in ancient China and medieval Europe. While dragons are often depicted as villains in Western literature, they are revered as symbols of peace and unity in Eastern traditions. Ultimately, the research concludes that dragons are indeed worthy of being labeled as legendary creatures due to their complex portrayals in folklore and media.

Uploaded by

emarkow2
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
20 views7 pages

The Legendary Status of Dragons

This paper explores whether dragons deserve the title of 'legendary' monsters by examining their origins and representations in various cultures, particularly in ancient China and medieval Europe. While dragons are often depicted as villains in Western literature, they are revered as symbols of peace and unity in Eastern traditions. Ultimately, the research concludes that dragons are indeed worthy of being labeled as legendary creatures due to their complex portrayals in folklore and media.

Uploaded by

emarkow2
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

1

Are dragons worthy of the title “legendary” monster?

Ethan Markowicz

Dept. of English, The University of Tennesee, Knoxville

English 102: Inquiry Into Myths and Monsters

Dr. Sarah K. Cantrell

February 23, 2025


2

Abstract

This paper seeks to answer the following research question: Are dragons worthy of the

title “legendary” monsters? It does so by examining sources that investigate the origins of

dragons from various historical civilizations including ancient China, ancient Greece & Rome,

and Western Medieval Europe. Since their first appearances, dragons have been portrayed as

villains, heroes, metaphorical symbols, and even gods. Dragons have also taken diverse roles in

media and literature.

Keywords: Snake, Origin, Symbol


3

Introduction

​ When these mythical creatures originally appeared in the 9th century BCE, they were

nothing more than glorified snakes. As history went on, more and more depictions of dragons

became distorted. Stories of these menacing creatures were passed down from generation to

generation, and dragons slowly evolved into folklore. Although fire-breathing dragons have

become the stereotypical antagonists in medieval and fantasy novels, they weren’t always this

villainous.

​ Multi- Cultural Origins

When researching my monster, I found that Dragons have a significant cultural influence

in ancient Chinese mythology. A recent research article titled, “ Discovering the Long : Current

Theories and Trends in Research on the Chinese Dragon” explains how dragons were “a symbol

of peace and unity among various ethnic groups…”(Meccarelli, 2021). This article also goes into

detail about how the dragon was used as a unifying totem for many groups of people in ancient

China. The dragon totem symbolized a powerful unity between Chinese minority groups against

the Han Dynasty.

According to the aforementioned article above, there are many theories on the origins of

dragons in China. One of these theories contains the belief that dragons originated from snakes.

Some early thinkers compared dragons to pythons, crocodiles, and other aquatic snake-like

animals. I have also found dragons to be associated with water and weather in this article.

According to (Meccarelli, 2021), “the dragon took its form from large mythical reptiles and

several other living creatures (tigers, snakes, birds, and turtles) that were venerated in China and

related to water and the female element Yin” . Other hypotheses consider ancient Chinese

dragons to have been gods of weather and lived in the sky. This may have resulted from
4

spiral-shaped thunderclouds being mistaken for dragon-shaped figures. Overall, dragons

acquired an esteemed and respected reputation amongst ancient Chinese cultures for being

unifying symbols of peace. They were known for being good luck totems and being associated

with aquatic nature elements.

European & Medieval Dragons

While dragons were seen as positive symbols in ancient eastern civilizations such as

China, they were demonized by Middle European and Medieval civilizations. The stereotypical

medieval dragon is a large winged serpent-like creature. These monstrous beings had daunting

tails, sharp teeth, reptilian scales, and fire-breathing capabilities. Dragons have been spotted in

numerous mythological stories dating back to Homer's Illiad from the 9th century BC. Mentions

of dragon-like creatures and serpents have appeared in Greek mythology, Roman mythology,

Nordic mythology(Vikings), Judaic-Christian mythology, and many other cultures throughout

history. Dragons may have gotten their fire-breathing reputation shortly after they started to

become depicted with wings in the medieval era. An article titled “Snake to Monster: Conrad

Gessner's Schlangenbuch and the Evolution of the Dragon in the Literature of Natural History”

explains how “ The targeting of dragons by lightning may be a corruption of Zeus's targeting of

drakon-legged Titans with thunderbolts in Greek myth. By the eighth century Europeans were

calling meteors "dragons" (Brown 1980), and by the fourteenth century the Welsh used the same

word (draig) for dragons and for sheet-lightning (Lofmark 1995).”(Senter, P. et al.).

Dragons in Media & Literature

The portrayal of dragons in media and literature has changed over time. First, dragons are

portrayed as greedy and destructive in the novel, Beowulf. In the story, the dragon shows greed
5

by sleeping on a big mountain of treasure. After a small piece of his treasure is stolen, the dragon

wakes up enraged. The winged creature goes on a rampage and burns down several villages in

Beowulf's hometown. This rageful and destructive behavior is a good example of the stereotypes

given to dragons by medieval folklore.

Contrarily, dragons are shown in a more positive light in Dreamworks’ How To Train

Your Dragon. At the start of the film, “ Fire-spitting dragons attack the town as Viking warriors

mount counterattacks“(Wilhite, et al., 2010). The writers initially portray dragons as monstrous

beings in Nordic culture. At the movie's start, the Vikings and the dragons are enemies. After one

Viking named Hiccup befriends a dragon, he finds out that not all dragons are bad. Hiccup

continues to aid this injured dragon, eventually helping him to fly again. After the Hiccup and

the dragon go for a flight, they discover a common enemy of the dragons and the Vikings: A

villainous dragon queen. The village Vikings train the dragons to fight side by side, and the

dragons become heroes. This movie shows the common stereotype given to dragons in Norse

mythology and puts an exciting twist on the story. While the dragons are initially portrayed as

antagonists at the start of the film, the authors paint them in a different light by the end of the

novel.

Unlike the heroic dragons in How to Train Your Dragon, Smaug the dragon from The

Hobbit is painted in a more traditional light. Similar to the dragon in Beowulf, Smaug the dragon

guards a pile of gold and treasure. This metaphor for greed is commonly found in fantasy stories

involving dragons and heroes. In the novel, Smaug the dragon attacks the village and steals all of

their treasure. He takes it back to the mountain where he resides and proceeds to guard his

wealth. Unlike the dragon in Beowulf, Smaug the dragon is portrayed as cunning and devious.

This sets him apart from other stereotypical fantasy dragons as Smaugs motivation for rage and
6

destruction stems from intelligence rather than primal emotion. Although Smaug is portrayed as

evil, he initiates character development in Bilbo Baggins, the main protagonist of the story.

According to a 2018 peer-reviewed article, “The dragon frequently evokes admiration, respect,

and even sympathy. The relationship between the dragon and the hero itself is not always purely

adversarial – in many cases, it is the beast that triggers the positive transformation of the

hero”(Hyla, 2018). Although dragons mainly tend to contribute to the common theme of good

versus evil in fantasy literature, there is more to these monsters than meets the eye. Overall,

dragons continue to appear as powerful characters with very robust characteristics in media and

literature.

Conclusion

The Mighty Dragon has proved to be a tried and true staple in fantasy and folklore. For

something to be considered legendary, it must be remarkable, famous, and quite outstanding.

These beasts have been described as powerful, creatures capable of mass greed and destruction.

This is shown in the novels Beowulf and The Hobbit. That being said, dragons have also been

depicted as mighty spirit animals portraying ideas of peace, unity, and elemental divinity. The

eastern Asian origins of dragons show these creatures in a very honorable light. Furthermore,

Dreamworks How To Train Your Dragon shows how these creatures can use their awesome

powers for good. After much research, a conclusion has been made that dragons are worthy of

being labeled as legendary creatures.


7

References

Hyla, Anna. (2018). The image of dragon in literature. Pedagogical perspective on the basis of

John Ronald Reuel Tolkien’s Hobbit. Konteksty Pedagogiczne, 2(11), 207-218.

[Link]

Meccarelli, M. (2021). Discovering the long: Current theories and trends in research on the

Chinese dragon. Frontiers of History in China, 16(1), 123–142.

[Link]

Senter, P., Mattox, U., & Haddad, E.E. (2016). Snake to Monster: Conrad Gessner’s

Schlangenbuch and the Evolution of the Dragon in the Literature of Natural History.

Journal of Folklore Research 53(1), 67-124.

[Link]

Wilhite, C. J., Wilhite, C., & Williams, W. L. (2010). Dragon Training and Changing Culture: A

Review of DreamWorks' How to Train Your Dragon. The Behavior analyst, 33(2),

239–242. [Link]

Common questions

Powered by AI

Dragons are considered worthy of the title "legendary" due to their consistent portrayal across cultures as remarkable beings with extraordinary abilities and symbolic meanings. In Asian cultures, dragons are revered as symbols of unity and luck, intertwined with natural elements like water and weather . In European medieval mythologies, they are depicted as fearsome guards of treasure, epitomizing traits like greed and destruction . Over time, this multifaceted presence in mythology and literature, from heroic figures in "How to Train Your Dragon" to villains like Smaug in "The Hobbit," underscores their adaptability and deep-rooted cultural significance . These aspects together highlight their legendary status across historical representations.

Dragons in literature are frequently used as metaphors for various themes, prominently representing greed, as seen in both "Beowulf" and "The Hobbit," where dragons guard immense treasures, embodying avarice and the destructive nature of unbridled wealth . Moreover, they symbolize the dichotomy of power and fear, acting as challenges that protagonists must overcome, which is metaphorically reflective of internal conflicts and the journey towards self-discovery . Additionally, dragons can represent cultural and societal antagonisms requiring understanding and reconciliation, as portrayed in "How to Train Your Dragon," where initial perceptions are challenged to foster unity . These metaphorical uses convey stories beyond the literal, offering readers insights into complex human emotions and societal issues.

In ancient China, dragons were seen as symbols of peace and unity, often associated with water and weather, and venerated as unifying totems across various ethnic groups . Meanwhile, in medieval Europe, dragons were demonized, portrayed as large, dangerous, fire-breathing serpentine creatures that symbolized destruction and greed . This contrast highlights a stark difference in cultural perspectives: one of reverence and unity, and the other of fear and antagonism.

In both "Beowulf" and "The Hobbit," dragons embody the perils of excessive wealth and unchecked power. They are portrayed as hoarders of treasure, reflecting historical anxieties about greed and the corrupting influence of wealth . In "Beowulf," the dragon's obsession with gold and subsequent rampage upon a theft represents the destructive cycle of material greed . Similarly, Smaug in "The Hobbit" is not just physically powerful due to his size and fire-breathing but intellectually cunning, showcasing the corruptive potential of amassed wealth and wisdom when not tempered by morality . These portrayals critique historical and, implicitly, contemporary power dynamics, emphasizing themes of greed and moral downfall associated with the pursuit of power.

The portrayal of dragons in literature has evolved from greedy, destructive creatures to more complex characters with multidimensional roles. In classic literature like Beowulf, dragons are depicted as hoarding creatures synonymous with greed . In contrast, Smaug from The Hobbit, while still showcasing traits of old myths, is portrayed as cunning and intelligent . Modern adaptations, such as "How to Train Your Dragon," depict dragons as misunderstood creatures that can form symbiotic relationships with humans and even act as heroes . This evolution reflects changing societal values and a deeper exploration of characters beyond mere villainy.

Greek mythology tends to depict dragons as formidable serpentine beings often linked with divine struggles, such as the drakon-legged Titans targeted by Zeus's thunderbolts. This underscores their role as formidable adversaries to gods and heroes alike . In contrast, middle European mythology, particularly during the medieval period, portrays them as large, fire-breathing creatures, symbolizing chaos and destruction, infamous for hoarding treasures and plaguing villages . The European depiction often emphasizes their antagonistic nature and the moral struggles they present, whereas Greek mythology highlights their association with mythological epic conflicts.

Several speculative theories exist regarding the origins of dragons in ancient mythology. In ancient China, one theory suggests that they may have originated from snakes and other aquatic creatures like crocodiles, integrating characteristics of revered animals such as tigers and turtles to symbolize elemental influences and weather . Another theory posits that spiral-shaped thunderclouds might have been mistaken for dragon-shaped figures, associating dragons with the skies and storms . In European mythology, the evolution from simple serpentine figures to drakon-like beings involved a blend with meteor phenomena, as ancient Europeans named meteors "dragons," linking them to celestial occurrences . These speculations illustrate attempts to explain natural phenomena through mythological symbolism, providing cultural insights into how ancient peoples perceived the world around them.

Dragons often serve as pivotal catalysts in the transformation of characters within fantasy literature. For instance, in "The Hobbit," Smaug’s presence and actions compel Bilbo Baggins to grow into his heroic role, encouraging personal growth and bravery . Similarly, a 2018 peer-reviewed article notes that dragons evoke admiration and respect, occasionally serving as transformative agents for heroes, driving them towards positive change . These interactions symbolize the hero's internal and external battles, ultimately aiding their character development and moral evolution.

In Chinese mythology, dragons are imbued with multiple symbolic meanings, representing peace, unity, and good fortune. They are often associated with the natural elements of water and weather, embodying divinity related to these forces . Furthermore, dragons act as unifying symbols among various ethnic groups, serving as potent totems that fostered solidarity against historical adversaries such as the Han Dynasty . Thus, they hold a prestigious place within Chinese cultural and mythological narratives, symbolizing prosperity and harmony.

The depiction of dragons in "How to Train Your Dragon" reflects contemporary societal values such as understanding, acceptance, and collaboration across perceived boundaries. Initially portrayed as antagonists mirroring traditional Nordic perceptions, dragons in the film undergo a transition to allies, illustrating a journey from misunderstanding to mutual cooperation . This shift mirrors modern narratives focused on reconciling differences, promoting empathy, and building partnerships beyond initial prejudices. It signifies a move towards inclusive storytelling that values diverse perspectives and cooperation for common goals.

You might also like