Counter Statement for Trademark Opposition
Counter Statement for Trademark Opposition
INDEX
Delhi Filed By
29.01.2025
-~~
SUNIT~HN, Adv
ANITTA & ADONA LLP, LAW FIRM,
45-A, SUNLIGHT COLONY-2,
ASHRAM, NEW DELHI-110014
Mob: 9891779857 I Email ID: office@[Link]
I
TM-0 (COUNTER STATEMENT)
THE TRADE MARK ACT, 1999
(COUNTER STATEMENT UNDER SECTION 21(2) OF THE ACli
AND RULE 44 OF THE TRADE MARK RULES, 2017)
TO,
TRADE MARKS REGISTRAR
INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY
BUILDING, G.S.T. ROAD, GUINDY
CfiE~AJ-600032
Respected Sir,
Sir,
1. Prior Use and Ownership: That the Applicant has been the first
adopter and continuous user of the trademarks "TRIPIFY" and
"TRIPIFYME" in India since 2014, well before the Opponent's
alleged use or interest in similar marks. The trademarks have been
used in commerce, specifically in connection with taxi service$,
transp~~ation, and travel services, establishing goodwill and bran~
recogmtwn. [_1
2. Domain Name and Online Presence: The Applicant acquiretl
domain names [Link] and [Link] in 2014, which havle
been actively used for conducting business. This demonstratd\s
significant prior use and public recognition of the trademarks.
3. Common Law Rights: By virtue of long-standing and extensive
use, the trademarks "TRIPIFY" and "TRIPIFYME" are exclusive!~
associated with the Applicant, as recognized under common law
principles. The Opponent's application for "TRIPIFY" in 2016 an~
subsequent actions constitute passing off, unfair competition, and al1
attempt to unlawfully benefit from the Applicant's establishetl
goodwill. I
4. Rebuttal to Grounds of Opposition: Without prejudice to thr
above, we refute the grounds of opposition as follows:
a) No Likelihood of Confusion: The Applicant's trademar c
"TRIPIFYME" is distinctive and uniquely associated with itk
services. Any claims of consumer confusion are baseless, as th~
Applicant's trademarks have been in use since 2014, with nf
evidence of actual confusion provided by the Opponent. I,
b) Fraud or Misrepresentation: The Opponent's allegations or
fraudulent or bad-faith application by the Applicant are witho~t
merit. The Applicant's trademark application is a legitimat~
effort to protect its rights established through prior use. \
c) Unfounded Claims of Ownership: The Opponent has failed t~
provide substantive evidence supporting its claims of ownershiiP
or prior use of the trademarks "TRIPIFY" or "TRIPIFYME." Th~
Opponent's application for "TRIPIFY" in 2016 postdates th~
Applicant's extensive use of the marks and therefore cannot
override the Applicant's rights under the priority of us~
doctrine. I
d) Statutory Protection: The Applicant's pending trademarK.
application seeks protection under the Trade Marks Act, 1999~
which recognizes prior use as a valid basis for ownership. Th~
Opponent's claims conflict with the principles laid down iri
Sections 18 and 34 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999, which grant
priority rights to the first user of a trademark. We further reserv1
our rights to take appropriate legal action against the OpponenT
for infringement, passing off, and damage to the Applicant's
goodwill and reputation.
5. Relief Sought: Based on the above, we respectfully request t~e
Registrar to: I
a. Reject the Opposition (1361232) filed by the Oppone1,
Mr. Krishan Kumar Khanna.
b. Allow the Applicant's trademark application No. 6384071 :6 r
"TRIPIFYME" to proceed to registration.
c. Pass such order or orders in the interest of justice, which th ·s
Hon'ble Authority deems fit.
Delhi Filed B
29.01.2025
SUNIT~~Adf
ANITTA & ADONA LLP, LAW FIRM,
45-A, SUNLIGHT COLONY-~,
ASHRAM, NEW DELHI-llOOHt
Mob: 9891779857 I Email ID: office@anittaadona.cod1
VERIFICATION
I, SARATH KRISHNAN, the Applicant verifies at New Delhi on this 29 J
l
of January, 2025 that the statement made in Paragraph 1 to 4 of the counte[
statement are true to the knowledge and belief of the applicant, anf
contents made in Paragraph No.5 is humble prayer to the Hon'bl .
Registrar.
Enclosures:
1. Legal notice issued by the Counsel for opponent to the
Applicant dated 19.10.2024.
2. Reply notice issued by the counsel for the Applicant
dated 07.11.2024.
3. Power of attorney dated 20.11.2024
Saviour l!.f!J· ·{
ADVOCATES I
PALLAV ARORA
ADVOCATE, DELHI HIGH COUirr
Date- 19/10/, 24
To.
TRIPIFYME TRAVEL
Address:
2nd Floor, Valamkottil TO\vers.
6/858-M, Vidya Nagar Colony,
Thrikkakara, Kalamassery,
Kochi , Kerala-682021
Contact: 90721 21217
Dear Sir/Madam,
Under the i~structions fr~m and _on behalf of my client TRIPIFY PRIVATE LIMIT1 ID, I
serve you with the followmg notice;
I
TRIPIFY PRIVATE LIMITED via its directors Mr. Nitin Khanna and Shikha SJthi
having its, registered office at 8/33 B, Block 8, Kirti Nagar Industrial Area, Kirti NJ~ar,
!
SAVIOUR LEGAL
Address: 403, New Delhi House, Barakhamba Road, New Delhi 110001 I
New Delhi. DeihL 110015 (hereinafter referred to as "we'' or 11 our Company"), hereby
this formal notice regarding the unauthorized use of our registered trademark 11 TRIPli ."
lt bas come to ~ur ~tte~tion. that your comp~ny [Link]~es under the na~ne "TRIPIFT E
TRAVEL," \Vluch Is rdenttcal and confusmgly snmlar to our regrstered [Link]
"TRl~IFY" We wish to bring to your immediate attention that we are the reg1slled
propnetors of the trademark "TRJPIFY," duly registered under Class 39 ofthe Trade~ rks
Act, 1999. As the registered proprietors of the "TRlPIFY" trademark, we must asse hat
~he .use of "TRlPIFY" as a prefix in your company's name also constitut~s a df ect
mfnngement of ou.r [Link] .rights. This si1~ilarity not only in~rin~es on ~ur mtellel ual
property but also nsks mrsleadmg and confusmg consumers, which IS a senous cancer .
~s the reg~stere~ proprietm:, we posse~s e~c~usiv~ rights to use t~e trademark "TRlPifr"
m connectron \\'Ith the sen1 lces for which It 1s registered. These nghts are protected urljer
Sections 28 and 29 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999. Section 28 grants us the exclusive rt·ht
I
!
Saviour £.'!!} (
ADVOCATES
PALLAV ARORA
ADVOCATE, DELHI HIGH COURT
[Link].D-6283/2017
to use our tmdemarL while Section 29 pro hi bits any use of a mark that is identi+ f or
deceptively similar to our registered trademmk i r such use is likely to cause confusmi or
deception.
The unauthorized use of the name "TRIPIFYME TRAVEL" has resulted in substa 1 tial
- I'
harm to our business . We have observed a significant decline in traffic to our websitJe{iand
social media platforms, as potential customers are being misled, and redirected tal our
business due to the similarity in names. This unauthorized usage IS not only affect1d our
online presence but also leading to a loss of genuine clients and potential r~venue, Fr~er
your company's adoption of the name "TRIPIFYME TRAVEL" 1s done w1thout o~tr mg
proper registration or authorization for the trademark, further compoundmg the
among consumers.
In addition to the above, please be informed that TRIPIFY PRIVATE LIMIT~ID has
multiple pending trademark applications in various classes, which are currentl: l ~nder
examination and are expected to be granted in due course. Once granted, these trad~rarks
will further expand our exclusive rights and protection across additional classes, thbreby
broadening the scope of our intellectual property portfolio, Should the infringing acl~ities
continue, we will seek to enforce our rights not only under the existing registration i~iClass
SAVIOUR LEGAL
Address: 403, New Delhi House, Barakhamba Road, New Delhi 110001
A-199, Third Floor, Gujranwala Town Part-1, Delhi 110009 I
Tel: +91-11-45534440 j Mobile: +91-96505-10445 I Email: [Link]@hotmaii. hom
I
[,
Saviour £.'f!), f
PALLAV ARORA ADVOCATES
AuvoC/\TE, DI·:LJJI Hic;II C:ouir i·
_ENIW~,_L._]'JO. I~:-_62[33/29 '17
3 9 bur n /so u ndcr I/Jc J<u·r /J cum ing regis! ru 1inns in nl /Jcr dn~sc:. :,:lS-:lJ ~~r;t~~: ;,;;(J~Jing
i•:lri ngc•_:' en: wi./1 1111 nre.r 11 dd i I iumrl perwlr ios. 11 11</ legn I eon seq uenuus nssocintcd wit~ jhcsc
new IY gr ""' cd I r.r d em 111 ks, Iurr her cxucerbu ling th c Jegn I repereuss rons Ior your corm ~any.
ln snndm cases. courts huvc consistently awarded substantial damages and issued orJcrs
Cor the destruction of infringing products. For instance:
Reckitt Benckiser (India) Ltd. v. Jyoti Laboratories (201 8): The Delhi High 'ourt
awarded damages of INR 2 cro r e to RcckiU Benckiser for the infringemen f its
trademark "I-Iarpic" by Jyoti Laboratories' product. "Harpect.." The court emphasiz: .d the
significant financial impact of [Link] infringement and ordered the destruction f the
infringing products.
The Gillette Company v. N. V. International (2014): In this case, the Delhi High Court
imposed a monetary penalty of!NR 20 lakhs on N. V. International for the sale of+ , ducts
infringing on Gillette ' s trademark . The court's decision also included an injunctio~ [nd an
order for the destruction of the infringing products.
1
In the case MIS. DLx:cy Textiles Pvt. Ltd. v. MIS. G. J(. Associates (2023):, the Dell' High
Court awarded damages of INR 10 lakhs to Dixcy Textiles Pvt. Ltd. for infringJ ent of
its trademark . The defendant was found to be selling products that were deceptivelt imilar
to the plaintiffs registered trademarks. The court also issued a permanent
against the defendant and ordered the destruction of all infringing goods. l
i~ nction
That is, we hereby demand that you immediately cease and desist from using I f name
"TRIPIFYME TRAVEL" or any other mark that is identical or confusingly si' rpilar to
I
SAVIOUR LEGAL
Address: 403, New Delhi House, Barakhamba Road, New Delhi 110001
A-199, Third Floor, Gujranwala Town Part-1, Delhi 110009
Tel: +91-11-45534440 I Mobile: +91-96505-10445 I Email: [Link]@hotma,[Link]
I .: ,.
Savjour .f.l!ja(
·
PALLAV A RORA
AD\ 'OC:\TE, DELHI HIGH COURT
E\ROLL. INj·0.· D- 678~/?0
'--'- ~) ~ ·1 -I
, ADVOCATES
''TRJ PIFY." \\' e a !so req uirc ~h~r~,:llr r~rur:~-~~~HI des\ roy aII rna teri aIs. i~c!t:dir~g b~t not
limited 10 p~[Link].. adn~ rusemems. and digital content bear.m~. th~ mfnngmg Trk.
F. unhernwr~.:'. you must discontinue all services offered under the I~[Link] mark and~~ ase
any ongoing marketing or pron~otional activities related to it. Add~twnally. we requesf ~at
you prO\ 'Jde a \\Tltten undertakmg \Ylthm seven (7) da:y·s ofrecel\'lng th1s notice, affi mg
I
thm you \\·ill nOl use or distribute any goods or services under a mark similar to "TRJPI IFY"
in the future.
Please be adYised that failure to comply with these demands within fifteen (15) days
the date of this notice \\'ill compel us to pursue legal remedies to protect our trade
rights. That is , we will seek an injunction from a competent court to prevent further us of
the infringing mark, file a suit for damages to recover losses incurred due td the
infringement and pursue any other legal actions available under applicable [Link] to
safeguard our brand.
Please direct all responses and correspondence regarding this matter to:
TRlPIFY PRIVATE LIIVIITE D
Address:
8/338, Block 8,
Kirti Nagar Industrial Area, Kirti Nagar,
Ne\\. Delhi, Delhi, 110015
Email: support·1&tripify .com
Phone: 080-6968-6968
SAVIOUR LEGAL
Address: 403, New Delhi House, Barakhamba Road, New Delhi 110001
A-199, Third Floor, Gujranwala Town Part-1, Delhi 110009 I
II
I
.
'
f
I •
iI
I·
ADVOCATES
PALLAV ARORA
ADVOCATE, DELHI HIGH COUHT
ENROLL~ ~~Q_-~2§}/?01.7 ----~ . ----
mTilliJr!!ll
(;tnf.'.-JIIIH:Ill of fudfu
.I c-<ucm f(l'il1 <f~rr{l
i Trn<lc Mal'l<.< Rcglstr·y
~rtrR ftwl'i ,Jrfllr~m<Jr, 1'J99
I:r...,~~~:~
. . ~ (: f1> Cnr
.~~~"1'
. !.~ . •\1 im:-f..l ~~:;. [Link] ~:...-m (: ~r.
.. . . . .. . . _. .
;>Jif
.
n rl~
. ~ ..
n
.. .
tr<7( t1
II
• ~\.'11 ~-.:tllhal ~·JU.:·
I l'--t !!k I ." .' ~1~~-
....:n ;;r H • l ''-.!ll'JL:".-...:..: :~·to;1•·.
'"" b:."\:" ' " C"': J.t,,\. !1 111 or.·
R KR B H A A KU !v'Af>. K K/,,,NA , C-1J,, SF BLOCK c. KRT.I Nt. ~R. DELH•I1 DO 15. SERV CE P RO V OE R S. cs;, >g:e Fl.m)
Ilk.! ~ ~·· ·.,; / ~~ ~
I
I
r;mf2~'lt~
a-atm t:ruo ~r<r!l
Trade Mari< s R &iJis lry [Link] Reg strar ofTrademcrks
•f'l~('lolr l"' l~.A .t'1 .o:/111 I I " of( .. f~'!' I t/'1 ,., ; ., ..c I( •• oi .(} o u .. ~ ._ r•r 11\1 'f·l6 '" rt .£.l « ~I ~ .f. :#lPiof ol( Jl1 "' /l..o'Jot tl (Ioiii :tl ..... , 1
e< ,.
1
,....,...,,,,rnr :~'i'"· ~ ~r.·.. niJ,. ~" ol '4/(J.. : :f'l..r,<; ?.Uf 1wr. t.\ tl..-..::. h-•f'*' ,..~d IO~Y\ ~• n rlll19ftj)'/.1'li:lrd•.ldl p;.( c.J r;/10)"'f'41'1.
:::o: : " ' II/1T/ rr~ T if>r. t1 J:; ;: · . ~.r> U !~l;f./ t ;.,~; ~ , /"'11/f k-: .-:; 1'1"11 r~::~riJ r
To.,,.-,-,. ~ ·.;..,l..r i,. •...,J IU "rtl fl ,,. . J', ;-'V"~_.J ,J; ~ ·, !:..t ~.U•l'lll'o\1 ~J"'iji;IU'! I:IC> o.o-.d
~ rn M••rr •rrr • Hmr-t 11 "'r: ll""' f::!".l .,_,, ' ' 111 1' ~!'I IITI .-: ~~ ni'J'f ~om' Jl rrr HTT1 1'1 n!l'!TII' $ ll'l'f rt:1 "'lin., II r.:t ,-r T!r."""• 4',.,.., rrtz:.,-l!m loJ'.-. 01111111 'Cir!JY.
P"<l"l of2
Annexure-1
SAVIOUR LEGAL
Address: 403, New Delhi House, Barakhamba Road, New Delhi 110001
A-199, Third Floor, Gujranwala Town Part-1, Delhi 110009
Tel: +91-11-45534440 I Mobile: +91-96505-10445 I Email: [Link]@hotmail !com
J~aviour £e
1\llVOCJ\TJ.:S
r
PALLAV Ano nA
1\ I) V0 C: 1\'l' 1·:, I) l ·:I. Ill Ill l; II Ctllll {'J'
l~NIWI.I .. Nu. D ·- (l;~ u:l;::.o 1'7
/0
Wl' 11'\ISI thnt :"'tlll \\'ill :tdd !'l' S:i this 11\lll!l'l' pi'UillpiJy lliHil'(HljK'I'Ilit' f't!IJy IU J'CSUJVc iilis j ' Sll~
<llllk tthly. Wl' l(lok 1\llwmd Ill )'lllll' l'lllllplinllL'l' lliHiil ~;willrc~;()ltJiion o!'llti~; lllfllll'l' .
p/
~~0': .
//
./
Signature
Pallav Aroru
Advocate
DELHI HlGI-1 COURT
D/6283/20 17
SAVIOUR LEGAL
Address : 403, New Delhi House, Barakhumba Road, New Delhi 110001
J'
A-199, Third Floor, Gujranwala Town Part-1, Delhi 110009
Tel: +91-11-4-5534440 I M obil e: +91-96505-104451 Email: [Link]@[Link]
I
'
II
Saviour l!.f!J' f
ADVOCATES
PALLAV ARORA
ADVOCATE, DELHI HIGH COURT
ENROLL. No. 0-6283/2017
Paga of2
SAVIOUR LEGAL
Address: 403, Nevv Delhi House, Barakhamba Road, New Delhi 110001
A-199, Third Floor, Gujranwala Town Part-1, Delhi 110009
Tel: +91-11-45534440 I Mobile: +91-96505-10445 I Email: [Link]@[Link]
I
To;
Pallav Aror~ Advocate
Savior 1egal, 403-New .Defhi House,
ANN s-;{ LJ gE - 2-
Barakhamba Road, New aelhi-1100:01
·
to your Cease-and-Desist Notice dated 19· [Link]· 20Z4, ·YY-Jc-LL'""-'-"
lO.T~e ev1deace clearly shows that y~ur d~ent. 's_~ . : · fnngemen..t [Link] -o:1m·
1
1
chent's trademarks has been ongomg smce 2016-, and g1ven :tnJ-
deliberate and wilful nature of this infringement, it is apparent tha ,. I
. c·1·1ent h as -k.n:OWID&Y
y:our . ""l an d mtentn:ma
. . 11y [Link]. u:amage·
...1
to o 1
1
of T1 ademarks" ._I I
the future.
.l:.
12. This notice must be cmnplied ·with within .seven· (1) days from th:e I
:o
date_o~rec-eipt ?fthls lett_~r. Failure .c omply witl:l thi~ d~and '!il1
result m our chent pursumg all available legal :[Link];- induuing
but not limited to: . . I
a. FiLing a suit for infringement {)f trad'e mark under 'Sections 21 ··
and 134 of the Trade Marks Act~, l-999;
b. S:~~king lnju~cttve reJiefto prevent further 1mriflgement;· ..
c. Fllmg a clann for [Link] and accounts fqr .a ny prafits i
wwngfull:y earned by -your client .as a .[Link] .of their fufrirrgin~ I
1
[Link]; jl
d. Any other remedies available under civil and crnninal law fa]·
the deliberate violation of intellectual property rightii~ 1
13. We urge your' client to take this matter s-erioMsly and avoid .an
further escaJati'OB by immedlat€1y c0mply.in_g with the demands se
[Link] in this notice-. .
Yo [Link] sincerely r
Sun1f£
Advo·cate
t I
.. ~...
27AA
1J N NtfKV /08:- 3
FORMTM-48
[Section 145, Rule 21]
~
~ I, SARATH KRISHNAN, S/o RADHAKRISHNAN NAIR, CHAITHANY j
[Link] P 0, AYIROOR, PATHANAMTHITTA, KERALA-689614 do ~!
auth~rize M/s ANITTA & ADONA LLP, Law Firm, address at 45-A,
Col<fly-2, Ashram, New Delhi-110014, its Partners being Mrs. Sunitha John
Mr. Jojo Jose advocates ·or any other Associates authorized by 11/s ANI~fTA
. AD.;NA LLP to act jointly and severally as om attorneys, agent for filing
prosycuting all my trademarks applications, iricluding prosecuting and u...._,,.....,"' ...H'
oppJsitions, if any, changes of name or address and for doing of all the
necersary and incidental to the application, registration and enforcement ofthe
marks, appointment of representatives as may be necessary OF expedient for
pur~se of doing all the above ac~s, and to pay all necessary fees and costs in
or as may be required to be made by me from time to time.
V/e hereby revoke all previous authorizaticns, if any, and confirm the
alr~ady taken by the agents/representat~ves above named in respect of the
proceedings.
All communications relating to this application may be sent to the foil
address in India:-
Dated: (Name) ·
To,
The Registrar of Trade Marks
The Office of the Trade Marks Registry at New Delhi
!
27AA 033319
FORMTM-48
[Section 145, Rule 21]
. .... )... t
'"·• uiJf
2
\X/ e hereby revoke all previous authorizatiens, if any, and confirm the action
already taken by the agents/representatives above named in respect of the above
proceedings.
All communications relating to this application may be sent to the following
address in India:-
Dated: (Name) ·
~
(signature)
To,
The Registrar of Trade Marks
The Office of the Trade Marks Registry at New Delhi