0% found this document useful (0 votes)
18 views6 pages

Corporate Governance and Fraud Prevention Analysis

This chapter outlines the research methodology for studying the effect of corporate governance on fraud detection and prevention in Nigerian banks. It details the ex-post facto research design, the population of 14 quoted deposit money banks, and the purposive sampling technique used to select 10 banks for analysis. The study employs secondary data from annual financial reports and utilizes panel regression analysis to examine the relationship between corporate governance variables and fraud control.

Uploaded by

mrkeem4real
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
18 views6 pages

Corporate Governance and Fraud Prevention Analysis

This chapter outlines the research methodology for studying the effect of corporate governance on fraud detection and prevention in Nigerian banks. It details the ex-post facto research design, the population of 14 quoted deposit money banks, and the purposive sampling technique used to select 10 banks for analysis. The study employs secondary data from annual financial reports and utilizes panel regression analysis to examine the relationship between corporate governance variables and fraud control.

Uploaded by

mrkeem4real
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

CHAPTER THREE

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

3.1 Introduction

In determining the effect of corporate governance on fraud detection and prevention, the study

ought to have a research methodology which layout the procedure through which the research

was conducted. Five sections are incorporated in this chapter that includes the research design,

the population, the procedure of collecting data, the diagnostics tests to validate the data and

lastly the technique of analyzing the data.

3.2 Research Design

This study will adopt ex- post facto research method and positivist research philosophy for the

purpose of addressing the research problem. An ex- post facto research design is commonly used

in studies that investigate possible cause-and-effect relationships by observing a condition and

searching back in time for plausible causal factors. Positivist research is applied when research

tests a theory rather than develop a new one. In the case of this study, the research investigated

the effect of corporate governance on fraud detection and prevention after the event under

investigation has taken place.

3.2 Population, Sample and Sampling Technique

The population for this study consists of fourteen (14) quoted deposit money banks in Nigeria as

at 31st December 2022. This includes: Access Bank Plc; Eco Bank Plc; FCMB Bank Plc; Fidelity

Bank Plc; First Bank Plc; Guaranty Trust Bank Plc Jaiz Bank; Stanbic IBTC Plc; Sterling Bank

1
Plc; Union Bank Plc; United Bank of Africa Plc; Wema Bank Plc; Zenith International Plc;

Unity Bank Plc

Table 3.1 Population of the Study

S/N NAMES OF QUOTED AGRICULTURAL COMPANIES IN NIGERIA

1 Access Bank

2 Eco Bank

3 Stanbic IBTC

4 Sterling Bank

5 Union Bank

6 First Bank

7 Wema Bank

8 Zenith Bank

9 GT Bank

10 FCMB

Source: Nigerian Exchange Group, December, 2022

The table 3.1 above shows the ten (10) quoted deposit money banks quoted on the NGX, serve as

the population of this study.

Purposive sampling technique was adopted to select commercial banks with up to date and

complete annual reports and accounts for the study period (2018-2022). The sample size of this

study, therefore, consist of ten (10) quoted commercial banks hat were continuously listed and

actively trading on the floor of the Nigerian Stock Exchange (NSE) during the period 1st January

2018 to 31 December 2022 and whose financial statements are available and have been

consistently submitted to NSE for the period under study. They are: Access Bank Plc; Eco Bank

2
Plc; FCMB Bank Plc; Fidelity Bank Plc; First Bank Plc; Guaranty Trust Bank Plc; Stanbic IBTC

Plc; Sterling Bank Plc; Union Bank Plc; United Bank of Africa Plc; Wema Bank Plc; Zenith

International Plc; Unity Bank Plc.

3.3 Methods of Data Collection

This study used secondary source of data for the study. The secondary source was extracted from

the annual financial reports of the quoted commercial banks in Nigeria for the period of five

years (2018-2022). The use of secondary data in this study is justified based on the fact that the

study is built on the quantitative research methodology, and hence requires quantitative data.

3.4 Model Specification

The econometric model used in this study forms the equation given as:

ROA = β0 + β1OWNC + β2BDSZt + β3ACI + Є

Where:

ROA = Return on Assets

OWNC = Ownership Concentration

BDSZ = Board Size

ACI = Audit Committee Size

The modification of the adapted model is stated thus:

AIBίt = β0 + β1OWNCίt + β2BDSZίt + β3ACSZίt + Єίt β0 = Constant (intercept)

β1, β2, β3 = Coefficient of the independent variable

3
Є = Error Term of bank ί in period t

AIBίt = Artificial Intelligence Biometrics of bank ί in period t

OWNCίt = Ownership Concentration of bank ί in period t

BDSZίt = Board Size of bank ί in period t

ACSZίt = Audit Committee Size of bank ί in period t

Measurement of Variables

Table 3.2 Variable Description

Variable Proxies Acronym Measurement

Independent Variable (Corporate Governance)

Ownership OWNC the percentage (%) of shares owned

Concentration by the largest shareholder.

Board Size BDSZ Total Number of Directors on the

Board

Audit Committee Size ACSZ Measured as the total number of audit

committee members

Dependent Variable (Fraud Control)

Artificial Intelligence AIB 0 and 1 Dichotomy: is coded if the

Biometrics Bank employed Artificial Intelligence

Biometrics, otherwise we assign 0

Sources: Researcher’s Compilation

3.5 Justification of Methods

4
Since this study used time series and cross-sectional data, which is quantitative in nature, hence,

analysing the data with the use of panel regression analysis is the best method because the panel

regression properties are known as the best linear unbiased and efficient estimator. Ordinary least

square estimators are best liner unbiased estimators because they have smallest variance and

mean square error estimation. The objective of regression technique is to minimize the error term

with the view of finding the model or regression equation that explain the data.

3.5 Sources of Data Collection

The study will employ secondary sources for the purpose of data collection. The data will be

collected from the annual reports of the sampled companies for a period of five (5) years (2018

to 2022). These firms are public limited companies listed on the Nigerian Stock Exchange. By

virtue of being public limited companies and as a requirement of being listed, annual financial

report has to be made available to the Nigerian Exchange Group. Annual financial statements are

a preferred choice for the purpose of data collection based on the type of data to be collected,

availability of data to be collected, ease of access ability and ease of results comparability.

3.6 Data Analysis Techniques

This study used panel regression analysis to describe relevant aspects of corporate governance

and provide detailed information about each relevant variable. Correlation models, specifically

multiple regression analysis, panel regression analysis was applied to measure the degree of

association between different variables under consideration, while regression analysis was used

to examine the relationship of independent variables with dependent variable and to know the

effect of selected independent variables on fraud control.

5
This study adopted multiple regression equation model to investigate the hypothesized

relationship between the independent variables (board size, audit committee independence &

ownership concentration) and dependent variable (Fraud Control) in this study.

3.7 Diagnostic Checks

To determine the viability of the study model, several diagnostic tests will be tested, which will

include normality test, test for Multicollinearity, test for homogeneity of variances and the

autocorrelation test. Normality tests the presumption that the residual of the response variable

has a normal distribution around the mean. The test for normality was done by the Shapiro-wilk

test or Kolmogorov-Smirnov test. In the case where one of the variables was not normally

distributed it was transformed and standardized using the logarithmic transformation method.

Autocorrelation measures how similar a certain time series is in comparison to a lagged value of

the same time series in between successive intervals of time. This was measured by the Durbin-

Watson statistic and incase the assumption was violated the study employed robust standard

errors in the model (Khan, 2008).

Multicollinearity occurs when an exact or near exact relation that is linear is observed between

two or several predictor variables. Variance Inflation Factors (VIF) and the levels of tolerance

were used. Any multicolinear variable should be dropped from the study and a new measure

selected and substituted with the variable which exhibits co- linearity. Heteroskedasticity tests if

the variance of the errors from a regression is reliant on the independent variables. The study

assessed for heteroskedasticity using the Levene test and incase, the data fails the assumption of

homogeneity of variances the study used robust standard errors in the model (Burns & Burns,

2008).

Common questions

Powered by AI

An ex-post facto research design is suitable for this study because it investigates possible cause-and-effect relationships by observing an event and searching back in time to identify plausible causal factors. This is relevant in studying corporate governance and fraud detection since the events and data to be analyzed have already occurred, allowing the researcher to analyze the impact of governance practices on fraud prevention retrospectively .

Ownership concentration refers to the percentage of shares owned by the largest shareholder. A high concentration could lead to more effective monitoring and control over management, reducing fraud opportunities. Conversely, it might also result in minority shareholders' interests being overlooked, potentially creating an environment where fraudulent activities are designed to benefit the controlling shareholders at the expense of others .

The study employs a purposive sampling technique to select quoted commercial banks that have up-to-date and complete annual reports for the period 2018-2022. This technique ensures that only relevant and information-rich cases are included, possibly improving the accuracy and relevance of findings regarding corporate governance in Nigerian banks. However, it may also introduce selection bias, as the sample may not be fully representative of all banks .

The hypothesis likely posited by this study could be that larger board sizes are associated with more effective fraud control in Nigerian banks due to enhanced oversight capabilities and diverse decision-making perspectives that can help detect and prevent fraudulent activities. The study's use of variables like board size in its regression models implies such a relationship is under investigation .

Artificial Intelligence Biometrics (AIB) is used as a dependent variable coded as a dichotomy (0 or 1), indicating whether a bank employs AI for fraud detection. This approach measures the practical application of technology within banks, which is considered a proxy for their efforts in fraud control. By analyzing AIB alongside other corporate governance variables, the study attempts to identify significant relationships and impacts on fraud prevention .

Panel regression analysis is used to understand the impact of corporate governance variables, such as board size, audit committee independence, and ownership concentration, on fraud control in banks. This technique allows for examining cross-sectional and time-series data, accounting for variables' variation over time and across different banks, thus providing robust insights into the relationships between corporate governance practices and fraud control mechanisms .

Diagnostic checks such as testing for multicollinearity ensure that independent variables in the regression model are not highly correlated, which could distort the analysis' accuracy and inflate the variance of the coefficient estimates. Heteroskedasticity checks ensure that the variance of residuals is consistent across observations; failing this assumption could lead to inefficient estimators and unreliable hypothesis tests. These checks are critical for maintaining the integrity and validity of the regression analysis .

Multiple regression equations enable the study to quantify and test the relationships between several independent variables (e.g., board size, audit committee independence, ownership concentration) and a dependent variable (fraud control). This helps isolate and measure each governance factor's effect while controlling for the influence of other variables, facilitating a more comprehensive understanding of how they collectively impact fraud control measures .

Using secondary data from annual financial reports may limit the research due to potential inaccuracies or inconsistencies in reporting, lack of detailed qualitative insights that primary research might provide, and limited scope in data reflecting only what is disclosed in reports. Additionally, financial reports may not directly capture all aspects of fraud detection and prevention efforts or outcomes .

The choice of public limited companies listed on the Nigerian Stock Exchange is crucial because these entities are required to publicly disclose their annual financial reports, providing reliable secondary data for the research. This transparency ensures consistent availability of comparable data, which is essential for assessing corporate governance's impact on fraud detection and constructing meaningful, generalized findings .

You might also like