0% found this document useful (0 votes)
55 views4 pages

Partition Function of Hydrogen Atom

The document outlines a problem set for a course on statistical mechanics, specifically focusing on canonical partition functions and related concepts. It includes various problems that require derivations and calculations related to entropy, average energy, partition functions, and heat capacities for different systems. The problems cover a range of topics including two-state systems, harmonic oscillators, and the behavior of gases under different conditions.

Uploaded by

archi Kumar
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
55 views4 pages

Partition Function of Hydrogen Atom

The document outlines a problem set for a course on statistical mechanics, specifically focusing on canonical partition functions and related concepts. It includes various problems that require derivations and calculations related to entropy, average energy, partition functions, and heat capacities for different systems. The problems cover a range of topics including two-state systems, harmonic oscillators, and the behavior of gases under different conditions.

Uploaded by

archi Kumar
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

Problem Set-3: Canonical Partition function

CHM322: Dr. Arnab Ghosh

February 28, 2025

P
1. Use the Gibbs expression for entropy S = −kB i Pi ln Pi to derive the
formula for the entropy of mixing.
P P
2. Maximize
P S = −kB i Pi ln Pi subject to the constraints that i Pi = 1
and i Pi Ei = U . Under this condition, show that the entropy can be
written as S/kB = ln Z + βU .
P
3. Maximize the Gibbs-Shannon
P P−kB i Pi ln Pi subject to the
entropy S =
constraints that i Pi = 1 and hf (x)i = i Pi f (xi ), and show that

e−βf (xi ) X d
Pi = ; Z(β) = e−βf (xi ) ; hf (x)i = − ln Z(β)
Z(β) i

4. Derive an expression for variance in energy for a two-state system under


canonical ensemble.

5. Find the average energy under canonical ensemble. for (a) An n-state
system with energy 0, ε, 2ε, ..., nε. and (b) A harmonic oscillator with
energy 0, ε, 2ε, ...
6. For a two-dimensional HO, n = nx + ny , where
   
1 1
E nx = n x + ~ωx ; Eny = ny + ~ωy
2 2

nx = 0, 1, 2, ... and ny = 0, 1, 2, .... What is the canonical partition func-


tion at a given temperature? Reduce it to the degenerate case ωx = ωy .
7. Show that at high temperature, such that kB T  ~ω, the partition func-
tion of the simple harmonic oscillator is approximately Z ≈ (β~ω)−1 .
Hence find U , Cv , F , and S at high temperature. Repeat the problem for
the high temperature limit of the rotational energy levels of the diatomic
molecule for which Z ≈ (β~2 /2I)−1 .

1
8. Consider a collection of N two level systems (TLS) in thermal equilibrium
at temperature T . Each system has only two states: a ground state of
energy 0 and an excited state of energy ε. Find each of the following
quantities and make a sketch of the temperature dependence. (a) The
probability that the above system will be found in the exited state. (b)
The entropy of the entire system.
9. Show that for N non-interacting spin-1/2 particles in a magnetic field B
the internal energy U is given by
 
µB B
U = −N µB B tanh
kB T

10. The internal levels of an isolated hydrogen atom are given by E = −RH /n2
where RH = 13.6 eV. The degeneracy of each level is given by 2n2 . Argue
that the expression of Z
∞  
X
2 RH
Z= 2n exp
n=1
n2 kB T

diverges for T 6= 0. Give argument that if the hydrogen atom is confined


in a box of finite size, which would cut off highly excited states n ≥ 3, Z
would not then diverge. Estimate mean energy of the H-atom under this
condition at 300 K.
11. ∗ The energy of classical rotor is given by
!
1 p2φ
E= p2θ +
2I sin2 θ

Using classical statistical mechanics, calculate Cv of a heteronuclear di-


atomic molecule with moment of inertia I at temperature T .
12. In QM, energy of the rigid rotor is given by
~2
Ej = j(j + 1), j = 0, 1, 2, 3...
2I
where each j is (2j+1) fold degenerate. Find the expression of the partition
function and average energy of the system as a function temperature.
Derive an expression for the specific heat at high and low temperatures
and specify the range of temperatures where your expressions are valid.
13. Show that the single-partition function Z1 of a two-dimensional gas con-
fined in an area A is given by
A
Z1 =
λ2th

where λth = ~/ 2πmkB T

2
14. Show that S given by Sackur-Tetrode equation
 
5
S = N kB − ln(nλ3th )
2

is an extensive quantity. Use this to show that the entropy of a gas of


distinguishable particles is given by
 
3 2
S = N kB − ln(λth /V )
2

which is not extensive. [This non-extensivity of entropy is the orig-


inal version of Gibbs paradox]
15. An atom in a solid has two energy levels: a ground state of degeneracy g1
and an excited state of degeneracy g2 at an energy ∆ above the ground
state. Show that the partition function Zatom is

Zatom = g1 + g2 e−β∆

Show that the heat capacity of the atom is given by

g1 g2 ∆2 e−β∆
Cv =
kB T 2 (g1 + g2 e−β∆ )2

A mono-atomic gas of such atoms has a partition function given by Z =


Zatom ZN , where ZN is the partition function due to the translational
motion of the gas atoms and is given by ZN = (1/N !)[V /λ3th ]N . Show
that Cv of such gas is

g1 g2 ∆2 e−β∆
 
3
Cv = N kB T +
2 kB T 2 (g1 + g2 e−β∆ )2

16. The entropy of an ideal paramagnet in a magnetic field is given approxi-


mately by S = S0 −CU 2 , where C is a constant. (a) Using the fundamental
definition of temperature, determine the internal energy of the system U
and sketch a graph of U vs T for −∞ < T < +∞. Briefly explain the
physical significance of the negative temperature in the above plot.

17. Show that the single particle partition function Z1 of a gas of H-atoms is
approximately given by
V eβRH
Z1 =
λ3th
where RH = 13.6 eV and the contribution due to excited states are ne-
glected.
18. ∗ A certain magnetic system contains n independent molecules per unit
volume, each has four energy levels: 0, ∆ − gµB B, ∆, ∆ + gµB B (g is

3
constant). Write down canonical partition function, compute Helmholtz
free energy and finally magnetization M . Hence show that the magnetic
susceptibility χ is given by

µ0 M 2nµ0 (gµB )2
χ = lim =
B→0 B kB T (3 + e∆/kB T )

19. ∗ A material consists of n independent particles and is in a weak external


magnetic field B. Each particle can have a magnetic moment mµB along
the magnetic field, where m = J, J − 1, ..., −J + 1, −J, J being an integer
and µ is a constant. The system is at temperature T . (a) Find the
partition function. (b) Estimate the average magnetization of the material
at high temperature (kB T  µB B).
20. ∗ The energy of a paramagnet can be written as U = −m.B. Show that
if B is varied isothermally then T δS = −B.δm.

21. ∗ N weakly coupled particles obeying MB statistics may each exist in one
of the 3 non-degenerate energy levels of energies −E, 0, +E. The system
is in contact with a thermal reservoir at temperature T . (a) What is the
entropy of the system at T = 0K? (b) What is maximum possible entropy
of the system. (c) If C(T ) is the heat capacity of the system, evaluate the
R∞
value of the integral 0 C(T )
T dT ?

Common questions

Powered by AI

For T ≠ 0, the partition function Z of a hydrogen atom includes contributions from an infinite number of energy levels, with degeneracies growing as 2n². This leads to a divergence because the terms e^(−βE_n) do not decay quickly enough as n increases. Confinement introduces a high-energy cutoff by restricting the atom to finite spatial dimensions, reducing available states and thus truncating the series, preventing divergence. This cutoff effectively limits contributions to the partition function from very high energy levels, which would otherwise dominate in an unconfined system .

The Sackur-Tetrode equation for the entropy of a gas indicates an entropy expression, S = Nk_B (5/2 - ln(nλ³_th)), that is extensive, meaning it scales with the system size, N. However, for distinguishable particles, the derived entropy S = Nk_B (3/2 - ln(λ²_th/V)) is not extensive, as it does not scale linearly with volume. This discrepancy relates to Gibbs paradox, highlighting that the assumption of distinct particle labels leads to unphysical predictions. Recognizing this non-extensivity assisted in formulating the principle of indistinguishability in quantum mechanics, making correct statistical descriptions possible .

For N non-interacting spin-1/2 particles in a magnetic field, the divergence of the partition function implies an unrealistic prediction of infinite thermodynamic quantities at low temperatures. This divergence arises due to the assumption of infinite potential energy states contributing to the sum in quantum systems. Confinement to physical or realistic bounds, like finite particle numbers or discrete energy level limits, prevents this divergence, ensuring that calculations of internal energy, U = −NµBB tanh(µBB/k_BT), and related properties such as magnetization remain finite and measurable. This constraint is pivotal for accurately modeling real-world magnetic systems using statistical mechanics .

The derivation starts by maximizing the Gibbs-Shannon entropy under given constraints for the system's probability distributions and average energy. Using the method of Lagrange multipliers, one introduces multipliers for these constraints and differentiates to find the stationary points. This yields probability distributions Pi = e^(-βEi)/Z, where Z is the partition function. The entropy expression S/k_B = ln Z + βU comes from substituting these probability distributions back into the Gibbs-Shannon formula, reflecting the dual dependence of entropy on the partition function and internal energy .

The partition function for a two-level atom, Z_atom = g1 + g2e^(-βΔ), depends on the degeneracies of its energy states. With non-zero degeneracies (g1 for the ground state, g2 for the excited state), the number of effective ways to occupy each energy level increases, thus impacting the partition function's value and thermodynamic properties. The heat capacity contribution, Cv = g1g2Δ²e^(-βΔ) / (k_BT²(g1 + g2e^(-βΔ))²), reflects how these degeneracies influence energy distribution and fluctuations. Greater degeneracy typically lowers energy quantization effects, leading to smoother transitions in thermodynamic quantities .

The moment of inertia I is crucial in determining the rotational energy levels, E_j = ħ²/(2I) j(j + 1), for a diatomic molecule. It affects the spacing of these energy levels, which determines at what temperatures transitions between them significantly affect the partition function. Small moments of inertia lead to closely spaced levels, affecting specific heat at low temperatures as the population of excited states becomes thermally accessible. At high temperatures, the specific heat approaches a classical limit, but at low temperatures, the quantum mechanical spacing significantly alters the temperature dependence of Cv .

Negative temperatures occur in systems with bounded energy states, such as ideal paramagnets in strong magnetic fields, where entropy can decrease as energy increases. Here, unlike typical systems where adding energy increases disorder, increasing energy aligns more spins, hence decreasing entropy. This gives rise to a negative derivative in entropy with respect to energy, effectively defining negative temperature. Physically, a negative temperature system is 'hotter' than any positive temperature system because it will give up energy if brought into contact with a positive temperature system, causing unique thermodynamic behaviors such as absorbing energy rather than dissipating it upon contact with higher positive temperature systems .

The Gibbs expression for entropy, S = −kB Σi Pi ln Pi, is foundational in statistical mechanics as it provides a way to quantitatively describe entropy in terms of probability distributions. To derive the entropy of mixing, one applies this expression to a system of two or more different ideal gases. The process involves calculating the change in entropy when these gases, initially separated, are mixed. It shows that entropy increases due to the increase in possible microstates when the system is mixed, quantitatively described by the change in the sum of compositions times the natural logarithm of their compositions .

At high temperatures, where k_BT ≫ ħω, the energy spacing between quantum states becomes negligible compared to thermal energy, leading to a behavior similar to a classical system. In this regime, the partition function for a harmonic oscillator can be approximated as Z ≈ (βħω)^(-1), indicating a simplification due to reduced quantum effects. The specific heat, Cv = k_B, reaches the classical limit, indicating equal partition of energy across degrees of freedom. This demonstrates how quantum systems revert to classical statistical mechanics at sufficiently high temperatures .

The partition function encapsulates all the statistical properties of a system by summing over contributions from all possible energy states. In a magnetic material at high temperatures, the thermal energy k_BT easily overcomes small energy differences caused by external magnetic fields, simplifying the partition function. The system then follows classical statistical distributions, and the average magnetization can be predicted from thermal averages, where magnetization, M = mB/k_BT, becomes proportional to the applied field, reflecting the alignment tendency of magnetic moments that is described by the partition function .

You might also like