0% found this document useful (0 votes)
29 views3 pages

Canonical & Grand Canonical Ensembles Analysis

This document is a problem set for CHM322 by Dr. Arnab Ghosh, dated March 7, 2025, focusing on canonical and grand canonical ensembles in statistical mechanics. It includes various problems related to partition functions, chemical potentials, equilibrium constants, and thermodynamic properties of gases and photons. The problems require calculations and derivations related to statistical mechanics concepts and their applications.

Uploaded by

archi Kumar
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
29 views3 pages

Canonical & Grand Canonical Ensembles Analysis

This document is a problem set for CHM322 by Dr. Arnab Ghosh, dated March 7, 2025, focusing on canonical and grand canonical ensembles in statistical mechanics. It includes various problems related to partition functions, chemical potentials, equilibrium constants, and thermodynamic properties of gases and photons. The problems require calculations and derivations related to statistical mechanics concepts and their applications.

Uploaded by

archi Kumar
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

Problem Set-4: Canonical and Grand Canonical

Ensembles and Related Applications


CHM322: Dr. Arnab Ghosh

March 7, 2025

1. If the partition function ZN of a gas of N indistinguishable particles is


given by ZN = Z1N /N !, where Z1 is the single particle partition function,
show that the chemical potential is given by µ = −kB T ln ZN1 .
2. The fugacity z is defined as z = eβµ . Using µ = kB T ln(nλ3th ), show that
z = nλ3th for an ideal gas. Comment on the limits z  1 and z  1.
3. Consider the ionization of atomic H, governed by chemical reaction H
p+ + e− . Explain why µH = µp + µe . Use the partition function for H-
βRH
atom Z1 = V eλ3 and µ = −kB T ln ZN1 , show that, one can recover Saha
th
equation
ne np (2πme kB T )3/2 −βRH
= e
nH h3
where, nx = Nx /V is the number density of species x.
4. Show that the equilibrium constant Kc for the gas-phase dissociation of
a diatomic molecule A2 2A, at temperature T much higher than the
molecule’s θrot = h2 /8π 2 IkB but much lower than its θvib = hν/kB and
too low for significant electronic excitation of either the molecule or ion,
is p
g2 mkB T /π −D/kB T
Kc = A e
gA2 2hR2
where D is the energy of dissociation of the molecule from its ground
vibrational state, m is the mass of the atom, R is the equilibrium inter-
nuclear distance, gA and gA2 are the degeneracies of the ground electronic
states of the atom and the molecule.

5. Calculate the equilibrium constant Kp for the dissociation of I2 2I at


800K. The ground state of the iodine atom is 2 P3/2 , hence 4-fold degener-
ate, while that of the molecule is 1Σ+
g , hence non-degenerate. The excited
electronic states of I and I2 may be neglected at 800K. For the molecule,

1
θrot = 0.054K, θvib = 308K, and the dissociation energy from the ground
vibrational state is D = 1.5417eV.
6. Calculate the molar entropy of CH4 at 25◦ C and 1 atm, as an ideal gas
and compare with the experimentally determined ∆Sexpt ≈ 44.5 cal/(mol
K). [ θrot = 7.54K and θvib = 1870K for CH4 and symmetry number is
σ = 12]
7. The equilibrium internuclear distance of N2 is 1.094Å and the vibrational
frequency of N2 is 7.07 × 1013 s−1 . The ground electronic state of N2 is
non-degenerate. Calculate the molar entropy of N2 as a hypothetical ideal
gas at 1 atm and 25◦ C. [Expt. 191.5 J/(mol K)].
8. ∗ A solution of NaCl dissolved in water, which is 0.9% by weight NaCl,
is isotonic with blood. Show that the osmotic pressure of blood is nearly
eight times atmospheric pressure.
P
9. Maximize the entropy S = −kB i Pi ln Pi , where Pi is the probability
P of
the
P i-th level beingPoccupied, subject to the constraints that i P i = 1,
i Pi Ei = U , and i Pi Ni = N , to derive the grand canonical ensemble.

10. Show that the volume of a hypersphere in d-dimension with radius ‘k’ is
given by
π d/2
Vd = Ak d where, A=
Γ(d/2 + 1)
11. Show that in d-dimension, DOS of particles with spin degeneracy g in a
volume V is given by
gV π d/2 d
g(k)dk = Bk d−1 dk, where, B=
Γ(d/2 + 1)(2π)d

12. Consider a general dispersion relation of the form:  = apα , where a and
α are constants. Using the previous question, so that DOS as a function
is energy is given by
Bd/α−1 d
g()d =
αhd ad/α
gV π d/2 d
where B = Γ(d/2+1)(2π)d
.
∗ Hence show that single particle canonical partition function
V
Z1 =
Λdth
where d-dimensional Λth is given by
 1/α  1/d
h a Γ(d/2 + 1)
Λth = √
π kB T Γ(d/α + 1)
Show that above results for 3d matches with standard result for (i) non-
relativistic case when s = 2 (iii) relativistic case with s = 1.

2
13. Show that the number of states in a gas with energies below Emax is
Z Emax 3/2

V
2mEmax
g(k)dk =
0 6π 2 ~2
p
For Emax = 32 kB T , show that this number is 6/π(V /λ3th ), where λth =
√ h is the thermal de-Broglie wavelength.
2πmk TB

14. Ignoring the zero point energy, show that the partition function Z for a
gas of photons in volume V is given by
Z ∞
V
ln Z = − 2 3 ω 2 ln(1 − eβ~ω )dω
π c 0

Hence, by integrating by parts, yields

V π 2 (kB T )3
ln Z =
45~3 c3
and other thermodynamic quantities:

4σV T 4 16σV T 3 4σV T 4 4σT 4


F =− ; S= ; U= ; p=
3c 3c c 3c
and various thermodynamic relations : pV = U/3 and S = 4U/3T . Fi-
nally, show that Cp for photon gas is infinite. What is the significance of
this result?
15. ∗ Show that the total number N of photons in blackbody radiation con-
tained in a volume V is
Z ∞  3
g(ω)dω 2ζ(3) kB T
N= = V
0 e~ω/kB T − 1 π2 ~c

Hence show that the average energy per photon

U π4
= kB T = 2.701kB T
N 30ζ(3)

and the average entropy per photon is

S 2π 4
= kB = 3.602kB
N 45ζ(3)

Compare the results with that for an ideal gas. What is physical signifi-
cance for the difference?

Common questions

Powered by AI

Maximizing the entropy function S = −k_B Σ P_i ln P_i, subject to the constraints Σ P_i = 1, Σ P_i E_i = U, and Σ P_i N_i = N, leads to the derivation of the grand canonical ensemble. This results in using Lagrange multipliers to introduce chemical potential μ and temperature T to handle the constraints, leading to probabilities described by P_i ∝ exp[−(E_i − μN_i)/k_BT], which defines the grand canonical distribution suitable for open systems exchanging particles and energy with their environment .

The degeneracy of states g(k)dk for particles with spin degeneracy g in a d-dimensional volume V is derived as g(k)dk = B * k^(d-1)dk, where B = gVπ^(d/2) / [Γ(d/2 + 1)(2π)^d]. The derivation involves integrating over momentum space considering the isotropic momentum distribution and uses statistical mechanical principles to accommodate quantum states in a dense spectrum .

The volume V_d of a hypersphere in d-dimensions with radius k is given by V_d = A * k^d, where A = π^(d/2) / Γ(d/2 + 1). This expression relies on integrating over a d-dimensional volume using polar coordinates and the Gamma function, which generalizes factorials to non-integer values. This formula is important in statistical mechanics where systems can be analyzed in high-dimensional phase spaces .

The thermal de-Broglie wavelength λ_th = h / √(2πmk_BT) connects the quantum scale to macroscopic variables, indicating the particle's wave nature relevance. It emerges in calculating properties like partition functions and density of states, where energies below Emax yield a distributed number of states as shown by ∫_0^Emax g(k)dk = V6π^2(2mEmax/ħ^2)^{3/2}, simplifying to √6/π(V/λ^3_th) for Emax = 3/2k_BT, indicating if quantum effects dominate over classical behavior by comparing λ_th against interparticle separation .

The partition function Z for a gas of photons is ln Z = -Vπ^2c^3 ∫_0^∞ ω^2 ln(1 - e^(-βħω))dω, reducing via integration by parts to ln Z = Vπ^2(k_BT)^3 / 45ħ^3c^3. This illustrates unique thermodynamic properties like a lack of particle conservation and implications for thermodynamic stability, leading to derived expressions for energy U = 4σVT^4/c, and entropy S = 16σVT^3/3c, distinct from typical ideal gases due to free oscillation and radiative characteristics .

Cp, the heat capacity at constant pressure, is infinite for a photon gas because the energy of a photon gas is proportional to T^4, and its volume also changes with temperature in a way that requires infinite energy to change temperature infinitesimally. The significance is that the photon gas does not obey classical thermodynamics laws due to its unique property that the number of particles is not conserved, indicating it behaves differently than gases where particle numbers are conserved, reflecting the nature of electromagnetic radiation .

The Saha equation relates the ionization states of an atomic gas in thermal equilibrium. It derives from the equality of the chemical potentials of reactants and products, specifically for the process H ⇌ p^+ + e^-. By using the partition function and chemical potential expressions, the equation is formulated as n_en_p/n_H = (2πm_ek_BT)^{3/2}/h^3 * e^{-βRH}, where n_x denotes the number densities of species x. The equation incorporates both statistical mechanics and quantum chemistry to predict the degree of ionization based on temperature and density .

In the context of an ideal gas, the fugacity z is defined as z = nλ^3_th, where n is the number density and λ_th is the thermal de-Broglie wavelength. When z ≪ 1, the system behaves as a dilute gas, and interactions between particles can be neglected, meaning it approaches the ideal gas behavior more closely. Conversely, when z ≫ 1, the system transitions into a regime where quantum statistics are significant, indicating a dense system close to or entering degeneracy, such as a Fermi gas or Bose-Einstein condensation .

The dispersion relation ε = ap^α, where a and α are constants, affects the density of states (DOS) by dictating how energy levels are distributed. By transforming momentum space to energy space via this relation, DOS as a function g(ε)dε is computed as Bε^(d/α - 1)dε/αh^d a^(d/α), indicating how energy accumulates in d-dimensional systems differently from conventional quadratic dispersion (α=2). It clarifies energy-space characteristics and influences thermodynamic properties such as heat capacity and particle number in various domains of quantum and classical gases .

Comparing the entropy (S/N = 3.602k_B) and energy (U/N = 2.701k_BT) per photon with those of an ideal gas reveals essential differences in behavior due to the quantum nature and indistinguishability of photons, as well as the lack of conservation of photon number. An ideal gas consists of material particles with conserved number and energy proportionality, while for photons, the number fluctuates, leading to uniquely different thermodynamic properties. This highlights differences in thermal capacity and energy distribution characteristics fundamental in radiation versus typical gas systems .

You might also like