0% found this document useful (0 votes)
5 views5 pages

Band 9 Essay Analysis for S12 Homework

The document analyzes two high-scoring essays on phone usage in the UK and fish cultivation rates, highlighting their structure, vocabulary, grammar, and cohesion. Essay 1 discusses the trends in phone usage from 1995 to 2002, noting a decline in local fixed line calls and a rise in mobile phone usage. Essay 2 compares the cultivation rates of Arctic char, salmon, and rainbow trout over ten years, showing a significant increase in salmon production while Arctic char's dominance diminished.
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
5 views5 pages

Band 9 Essay Analysis for S12 Homework

The document analyzes two high-scoring essays on phone usage in the UK and fish cultivation rates, highlighting their structure, vocabulary, grammar, and cohesion. Essay 1 discusses the trends in phone usage from 1995 to 2002, noting a decline in local fixed line calls and a rise in mobile phone usage. Essay 2 compares the cultivation rates of Arctic char, salmon, and rainbow trout over ten years, showing a significant increase in salmon production while Arctic char's dominance diminished.
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

Writing S12 | Homework

(This homework has FIVE pages)

The following essays are band 9 (yes they are solid 9). Let’s analyze them through five
activities to gain more insights about Task 1

Activity 1: Read

Essay 1

The bar chart gives details of phone usage in the UK from 1995 to 2002 on three types of phone
line.

Overall, total phone use increased and the majority of calls were made using a fixed line.
However, towards the end of the period, local fixed line calls declined as mobile phone use
increased significantly.

During the first four years, all categories increased steadily, although usage was dominated by
local fixed line calls. The data for these calls was consistently almost double that of national and
international calls, with the former rising from over 70 billion to a peak of 90 billion minutes,
while the latter rose from approximately 37 billion to 48 billion. These figures contrast starkly
with the data for mobile phone calls in the same period, which began at approximately two
billion minutes and saw only gradual increases, climbing to ten billion minutes in 1998.

The picture was very different from 1999 to 2002, when, despite retaining the top position, local
fixed line calls dropped back to their initial level and ended the period only 10 billion higher
than
fixed line national and international calls, which increased consistently throughout. Notably, the
drop in local calls corresponded with dramatic increases in mobile phone use, which, by 2002,
had reached almost 45 billion minutes, considerably reducing the gap between all three
categories.

Essay 2

The table compares the cultivation rates of three species of fish in one region over a ten-year
period.

Overall, while Arctic char dominated initially, salmon was cultivated in far greater numbers
towards the end of the period, and rainbow trout has consistently been produced the least.

In 2008, 3124 million tones of Arctic char were produced in this region. As this figure was more
than ten times greater than the next highest, farmed salmon at 292 million tonnes, this species
clearly dominated at that time. However, Arctic char fell slightly in 2010 and rose only gradually
from 2012 onwards, while salmon rose exponentially in almost every two-year period. In fact, in
2014, salmon overtook Arctic char, and reached a striking 13448 million in 2018, considerably
more than any other species.

In contrast, rainbow trout was continually cultivated in relatively small amounts, beginning at
only six million tones in 2008. Although it did increase steadily, reaching a peak of 2138 million
tonnes in 2016, this level was short-lived, and by 2018 it had fallen to 295, which was almost
the same as salmon's starting point ten years earlier.

Activity 2: Task Response and Coherence focus analysis


Which information is selected for Overview, Body 1, and Body 2 in each essay? (Note briefly)

Essay 1
Overview
Body 1
Body 2

Essay 2
Overview
Body 1
Body 2

Activity 3: Lexical Resource focus analysis


Spot Topic vocabulary and Descriptive vocabulary in each essay

Essay 1
Topic vocabulary: Descriptive vocabulary
Minutes of telephone call (increase, decrease, stable, fluctuate,…)

Essay 2
Topic vocabulary: Descriptive vocabulary
Types of fish farmed (increase, decrease, stable, fluctuate,…)

Activity 4: Grammar focus analysis


Code sentence types for each essay as Red for simple, Green for compound and Purple for
Complex sentences

Essay 1:

The bar chart gives details of phone usage in the UK from 1995 to 2002 on three types of phone
line.

Overall, total phone use increased and the majority of calls were made using a fixed line.
However, towards the end of the period, local fixed line calls declined as mobile phone use
increased significantly.
During the first four years, all categories increased steadily, although usage was dominated by
local fixed line calls. The data for these calls was consistently almost double that of national and
international calls, with the former rising from over 70 billion to a peak of 90 billion minutes,
while the latter rose from approximately 37 billion to 48 billion. These figures contrast starkly
with the data for mobile phone calls in the same period, which began at approximately two
billion minutes and saw only gradual increases, climbing to ten billion minutes in 1998.

The picture was very different from 1999 to 2002, when, despite retaining the top position, local
fixed line calls dropped back to their initial level and ended the period only 10 billion higher
than
fixed line national and international calls, which increased consistently throughout. Notably, the
drop in local calls corresponded with dramatic increases in mobile phone use, which, by 2002,
had reached almost 45 billion minutes, considerably reducing the gap between all three
categories.

Essay 2:

The table compares the cultivation rates of three species of fish in one region over a ten-year
period.

Overall, while Arctic char dominated initially, salmon was cultivated in far greater numbers
towards the end of the period, and rainbow trout has consistently been produced the least.

In 2008, 3124 million tones of Arctic char were produced in this region. As this figure was more
than ten times greater than the next highest, farmed salmon at 292 million tonnes, this species
clearly dominated at that time. However, Arctic char fell slightly in 2010 and rose only gradually
from 2012 onwards, while salmon rose exponentially in almost every two-year period. In fact, in
2014, salmon overtook Arctic char, and reached a striking 13448 million in 2018, considerably
more than any other species.

In contrast, rainbow trout was continually cultivated in relatively small amounts, beginning at
only six million tones in 2008. Although it did increase steadily, reaching a peak of 2138 million
tonnes in 2016, this level was short-lived, and by 2018 it had fallen to 295, which was almost
the same as salmon's starting point ten years earlier.

Activity 5: Cohesion focus analysis


Bold Cohesive devices, in terms of Reference and Conjunction, in each essay

Essay 1:

The bar chart gives details of phone usage in the UK from 1995 to 2002 on three types of phone
line.
Overall, total phone use increased and the majority of calls were made using a fixed line.
However, towards the end of the period, local fixed line calls declined as mobile phone use
increased significantly.

During the first four years, all categories increased steadily, although usage was dominated by
local fixed line calls. The data for these calls was consistently almost double that of national and
international calls, with the former rising from over 70 billion to a peak of 90 billion minutes,
while the latter rose from approximately 37 billion to 48 billion. These figures contrast starkly
with the data for mobile phone calls in the same period, which began at approximately two
billion minutes and saw only gradual increases, climbing to ten billion minutes in 1998.

The picture was very different from 1999 to 2002, when, despite retaining the top position, local
fixed line calls dropped back to their initial level and ended the period only 10 billion higher
than
fixed line national and international calls, which increased consistently throughout. Notably, the
drop in local calls corresponded with dramatic increases in mobile phone use, which, by 2002,
had reached almost 45 billion minutes, considerably reducing the gap between all three
categories.

Essay 2:

The table compares the cultivation rates of three species of fish in one region over a ten-year
period.

Overall, while Arctic char dominated initially, salmon was cultivated in far greater numbers
towards the end of the period, and rainbow trout has consistently been produced the least.

In 2008, 3124 million tones of Arctic char were produced in this region. As this figure was more
than ten times greater than the next highest, farmed salmon at 292 million tonnes, this species
clearly dominated at that time. However, Arctic char fell slightly in 2010 and rose only gradually
from 2012 onwards, while salmon rose exponentially in almost every two-year period. In fact, in
2014, salmon overtook Arctic char, and reached a striking 13448 million in 2018, considerably
more than any other species.

In contrast, rainbow trout was continually cultivated in relatively small amounts, beginning at
only six million tones in 2008. Although it did increase steadily, reaching a peak of 2138 million
tonnes in 2016, this level was short-lived, and by 2018 it had fallen to 295, which was almost
the same as salmon's starting point ten years earlier.

Common questions

Powered by AI

Rainbow trout cultivation consistently remained the lowest. It started at six million tonnes in 2008, peaked at 2138 million tonnes in 2016, but then fell to 295 by 2018. In contrast, salmon production began low but rose exponentially, greatly surpassing trout by reaching 13,448 million tonnes in 2018 .

Essay 1 uses topic vocabulary such as "minutes of telephone call" to depict phone usage trends, with descriptive terms like "increase," "decline," and "dominate" to articulate changes. Essay 2 employs "types of fish farmed" with similar descriptive vocabulary, such as "rose exponentially" and "dropped," to convey cultivation trends .

The document emphasizes the use of cohesive devices like conjunctions and reference terms to maintain flow and clarity. For instance, in essay 1, terms like "however," "despite," and "notably" are key for transitioning between contrasting ideas and reinforcing connections between points .

The essays employ strategies such as initial overview statements to summarize trends, followed by detailed breakdowns using chronological order and quantitative comparisons. For instance, contrasts in peak values and growth rates are utilized to effectively illustrate differences in each category’s performance over the period .

Increasing salmon cultivation, reaching 13,448 million tonnes by 2018, suggests rising demand and increased market value, while the decline in Arctic char and fluctuating rainbow trout numbers indicate shifting consumer preferences and possibly lower market prices for these species due to less demand and competition .

Essay 1 structures the task response with an overview that summarizes increasing total phone use, dominated by fixed lines. Body 1 details initial usage, describing steady increases with double the local fixed line calls compared to national/international calls. Body 2 contrasts this with a decline in local calls after 1999, paired with a significant rise in mobile phone usage .

The shift in phone line usage marks a pivotal transition in communication technology, reflecting growing reliance on mobile phones. By 2002, the dramatic increase in mobile usage relative to steady or declining fixed line calls symbolizes a broader technological shift towards mobile connectivity, which likely influenced telecom policy and investment .

Initially, Arctic char was cultivated the most, but its production declined slightly after 2010 and rose gradually from 2012. In contrast, salmon production increased exponentially, overtaking Arctic char by 2014 and reaching 13,448 million tonnes by 2018. Rainbow trout was always produced the least, and despite a peak in 2016, its levels dropped to 295 by 2018 .

Compound and complex sentences in essay 1 enhance coherence by linking ideas and contrasting trends effectively. For example, compound sentences relay sequential growth in usage, while complex sentences provide detailed contrasts between different phone line uses over time periods, enhancing readability and understanding .

During the first four years from 1995 to 1998, the usage of all phone types increased steadily, with local fixed line calls dominating. However, from 1999 to 2002, local fixed line calls declined to their initial levels, while mobile phone usage increased dramatically, reaching nearly 45 billion minutes by 2002 .

You might also like