UNSC 2023: Tackling Africa's Terrorism Crisis
UNSC 2023: Tackling Africa's Terrorism Crisis
Study Guide
Annual World Summit 2023
Agenda: Addressing the Insurgency and Terrorism Crisis
in Africa, focusing on Al-Shabaab and Boko Haram.
Table of Contents:
Dear Delegates, The Executive Board of UNSC welcomes you to the Annual World
Summit,[Link] Annual World Summit is an amazing platform where young
leaders get to express their ideas,make new friends and solve nerve racking situations
which have global implications. While this can be quite the daunting experience for
first timers we here at Jamnabai Narsee School ensure that there is maximum
participation and that everyone comes out of the conference having learnt
something. This is the perfect platform for amatuers as well as experienced debaters.
The United Nations Security Council (UNSC) is a vital organ of the United Nations,
responsible for maintaining international peace and security. Composed of 15
member states, including five permanent members with veto power, the UNSC plays
a crucial role in global affairs. The UNSC serves as a platform for diplomatic
negotiations, conflict resolution, and the promotion of international cooperation,
making it an essential body for addressing various global challenges.
The agenda for UNSC is one of great importance it being addressing the insurgency
and terrorism crisis in Africa focusing on Al-Shabaab and Boko Haram. While this
agenda gives the delegates a certain framework as to what research is needed to be
done, it also explores the key conundrum here, terrorism. This allows smaller nations
to pose their issues and finding a global consensus when it comes to finding a
solution. This issue is extremely volatile and requires the best of minds when it comes
to resolving it. Hence we aim to give equal opportunity to every delegate present and
hope for two days of heated debate.
Yours faithfully,
The UNSC Executive Board
1
Introduction
2
“Al-Shabab.” Council on Foreign Relations:
[Link]
“Examining Extremism: Harakat Al-Shabaab Al Mujahideen (Al-Shabaab).”
Examining Extremism: Harakat Al-Shabaab Al Mujahideen (Al-Shabaab) | Center for
Strategic and International Studies, 28 Oct. 2021,
Examining Extremism: Harakat Al-Shabaab al Mujahideen (Al-Shabaab) | Examining
Extremism | CSIS
Warner, Jason; Chapin. “Targeted Terror: The Suicide Bombers of Al-Shabaab.”
Homeland Security Digital Library, Combating Terrorism Center (U.S.), 1 Feb. 2018,
[Link] | Homeland Security Digital Library at NPS
In 2019, killing more than 90 civilians and injuring over 130 others, 4 and, more
recently, the attack on an African Union (AU) base in Somalia on Tuesday 5th August
2022, ensuing in a firefight that killed an estimated 30 soldiers. 5 In recent years, the
frequency of attacks by Al-Shabaab has seen a spike, drawing global attention and
becoming a cause for concern.
3
A key objective of Al-Shabaab is to increase its geographic reach. Since the group’s
formation, a constant struggle has ensued between the Somali government and Al-
Shabaab, with no entity gaining complete power. For example, in 2011 Al-Shabaab
occupied many parts of the Somali capital, Mogadishu, as well as important trading
centres such as the port city of Kismayo and Barawe. Soon after, the African Union
Mission to Somalia (AMISOM), a peacekeeping mission approved by the UN and
operated by the AU (African Union), successfully regained a majority of the territory
including both Mogadishu and the trading centres. However,even now, Al-Shabaab
controls a large portion of southern Somalia. Thus, clashes between AU organisations
working with the Somali military and Al-Shabaab have, unfortunately, continued into
the country’s present political environment, and the militant group remains a
constant threat to the security of the region.
This conflict between the government and Al-Shabaab is further exacerbated by
multiple power transitions occurring. First, the 2021 elections were delayed by more
than a year, due to an ‘electoral impasse” as the former president and the leaders of
the Federal Member States within Somalia were unable to come to an agreement on
the method of conducting elections. This resulted in a majority of power being with
AMISOM, which was subsequently reconfigured to the African Union Transition
Mission in Somalia (ATMIS) on 1st April 2022, after the elections were sure to be held
soon. The long-drawn-out elections were held on May 15th, 2022. Post
reconfiguration, the transition of power from ATMIS to the Somalian government led
by newly elected president H.E. Hassan Sheikh Mohamud (whose ideological stance
promotes peaceful dialogue and increased assistance from international partners) is
currently ongoing; this allows a window for the Al-Shabaab to take advantage of the
power vacuums created and extend their operations to gain territory and influence,
making it a matter of urgency.
4
the region, and the terror of Al-Shabaab have caused the internal displacement of 2.9
million 8 people in Somalia. Moreover, Al-Shabaab terrorizes civilians through
mutilation, sexual violence and the recruitment of children. These infringements of
the international humanitarian law are only worsened by the blockades to
humanitarian access for civilians; Al-Shabaab targets organisations working towards
the betterment of people, as it views them as fronts for Western intelligence services.
For example, during the food crisis in 2010, an estimated 3.64 million people required
food aid. However, Al-Shabaab enforced 11 conditions on aid organisations, including
a jiyaza (tax) of 20,000 dollars every six months, for them to operate in the country.
The violent extortions and attacks by the extremist group caused the World Food
Programme (WFP) and other organisations to suspend operations in southern
Somalia,rendering the Somali population vulnerable. Al-Shabaab’s actions are not
solely concentrated within Somalia, extending to Kenya, and some parts of Uganda.
For instance, in 2010, Al-Shabaab claimed responsibility for the 74 casualties that
occurred as a result of bomb blasts in Kampala, Uganda, as a result of Ugandan
support of AMISOM forces. As such, Al-Shabaab not only poses a risk to the Horn of
Africa region but could also compromise international security through its affiliation
with larger terrorist organisations like al-Qaeda in 2012.
Mohamed, Hamza. “What Is Delaying Somalia's Elections?” Elections News | Al
Jazeera, AlJazeera,10thFeb,2021.
[Link]
“Somalia: New President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud Promises Peace.” Return to
Frontpage, Frontline,18thMay,2022.
[Link]
mohamud-pr omises
“OperationalDataPortal.”Situation,CCCMSomaliaOverview
[Link]
COVID%2D19
&text=Given%20the%20conflict%2C%20insecurity%2C%20drought,urban%20are
as%2 0ac
Uganda: One Killed in Bomb Attack at Kampala Bar.” BBC News, BBC, 25 Oct. 2021.
[Link]
5
Furthermore, Somalia borders geostrategically important trading routes, such as the
Bab-el-Mandeb strait (a maritime choke point). If Al-Shabaab gains influence over
this strait, goods going to Europe and USA would have to travel around the African
subcontinent, thus disrupting global trade and having worldwide economic
implications.
The United Nations has taken several actions to mitigate this conflict, including the
creation of UNSOM, a peacekeeping force which supports AMISOM. It has also made
several attempts to cut off Al-Shabaab’s funding, including the imposition of
sanctions on Eritrea (which was allegedly funding Al-Shabaab). However, the
pervasive political instability due to the absence of a strong government has rendered
these actions largely ineffective. Thus, despite measures implemented by the UN and
its subsidiaries, Al-Shabaab maintains a formidable presence in Somalia, causing
death, destruction and instability in the region. Hence, in the face of the increasing
threat of Al-Shabaab, it is imperative for the global community to collaborate and
resolve the conflict in Somalia before further escalation.
KEY DEFINITIONS
6
Economic sanctions: As defined by the Council of Foreign Relations, economic
sanctions refer to actions taken by a country or organisation against the economy of
another country, such as travel bans, asset freezes, arms embargoes, and trade
restrictions, in order to alter the strategic decisions of state and nonstate actors that
threaten their interests or violate international norms of behaviour.
Improvised explosive devices: An improvised explosive device (IED) refers to a
homemade explosive weapon, made using any available equipment. It is frequently
used by insurgent groups and other non-state actors against a conventional military
force.
★ Sharia law: The fundamental basis of Islam, which dictates the duties and
necessary conduct of all followers. In addition to laying down the religious practices,
prayers and rituals, Sharia law also includes harsh penalties for crimes such as
adultery. Consequently, it can be misused to spread violence in the name of religion.
Maritime choke point: These are naturally narrow, strategically located trade routes
with high traffic.
Maritime choke point: These are naturally narrow, strategically located trade routes
with high traffic.
“Horn of Africa (Somalia,Ethiopia,Kenya).”
[Link]
Firestone, Reuven. “Jihadism' as a New Religious Movement.” The Cambridge
Companion to New Religious Movements, 29 May 2014
[Link] The
Nobel Peace Prize 1988.”
[Link]
“What Are Economic Sanctions?” Council on Foreign Relations, Council on Foreign
Relations.
[Link]
“Improvised Explosive Device.”
[Link]
“What Is Sharia Law? What Does It Mean for Women in Afghanistan?
”[Link]
7
BACKGROUND INFORMATION
Power vacuums:
In Somalia, both regional and national politics have contributed to the creation of
several power vacuums, leading to violent conflict and creating potential pathways for
the Al-Shabaab to gain more influence in the region.
8
weaker because of the number of changes that are expected to take place.
Furthermore, its power is transferred to the politically fragile Somali government.
Both aforementioned aspects create a significant power vacuum that Al-Shabaab can
exploit, which is a significant threat that delegates must consider.
9
Hassan, Abdiqani. “Somali Forces, Supposed to Unite against Islamists, Fight Each
Other .”[Link]
“America's Counterterrorism Wars.” New America,
[Link]/international-security/reports/americas-counterterrorism-
wars/the-war-i n-somalia/ .
“Surge in Militant Islamist Violence in the Sahel Dominates Africa's Fight against
Extremists.” Africa Center for Strategic Studies, 11 May 2022,
[Link]
sahel-dominate s-africa-fight-extremists/
“U.S. to Resume Small, Persistent Presence in Somalia.” U.S. Department of
Defense, [Link]
resume-small-per sistent-presence-in-somalia/
Humanitarian crisis:
Somalia is plagued by a plethora of humanitarian conflicts as a result of its fragile
political state, consistent attacks by the Al-Shabaab, and natural disasters like
drought. Recently, internal conflicts, the COVID-19 pandemic, and food shortages
with 2.2 million Somalis at the risk of starvation 24 have culminated in one of the
worst humanitarian crises the world has witnessed.
10
identified an 80% increase in sexual violence compared to 2019,with cases “involving
139 girls as victims of sexual and gender-based violence”. A suspension of these trials
means that these girls do not receive justice or peace. Thus, attempting a resolution of
these violations is integral to maintaining peace in the region. Moreover, Al-Shabaab
has also continuously engaged in the forced recruitment and abduction of
children according to the United Nations Country Task Force on Monitoring and
Reporting, “535 children were recruited between January and June 2020, some as
young as 13 years old.” These infringements by the Al-Shabaab violate all the ‘six grave
violations against children in times of war’ as identified and condemned by the UNSC:
killing and maiming of children, recruitment or use of children in armed forces and
armed groups, attacks on schools or hospitals, rape or other grave sexual violence,
abduction of children, and denial of humanitarian access for children. As can be seen,
the rise of Al-Shabaab’s power is paving the way for humanitarian conflict within the
nation, making it crucial to resolve this issue.
“Somalia: Call for Urgent Action Following 'Alarming' 80 per Cent Rise in Sexual
Violence [Link]
“Letter Dated 28 September 2020 from the Chair of the Security Council Committee
Pursuant to Resolution 751 (1992) Concerning Somalia Addressed to the President of
the Security Council.”
[Link]
“Six Grave Violations against Children in Times of War.” UNICEF, 28 June 2022,
[Link]/stories/children-under-attack-six-grave-violations-against-
children-times-war.
11
iMedecins San Frontieres, a non-governmental organisation that provides medical
assistance in conflict zones, decided to leave Somalia, where they had been treating
50,000 people a month for undernourishment, disease and injury. This decision was
finalised in response to the “violence against health workers,” as 16 members of the
international humanitarian group were abducted and killed. Violence and killings
such as these leave Somalia without crucial aid to support their citizens. Moreover,
despite the food insecurity faced by citizens in southern Somalia, several important
aid agencies have been banned by the Al-Shabaab, including the World Food
Programme, Mercy Corps, Med-Aid, Horn Relief, World Vision and ADRA. This ban,
enforced during the 2010 famine, is still in effect today, preventing the estimated
1.625 million Somalis who require emergency assistance and live in Al-Shabaab-
controlled territory from receiving aid. Additionally, threats have been issued to
NGOs advocating for social freedoms such as those promoting women’s rights
because such ideologies go against Al-Shabaab’s extremist outlook. In fact, between
1st January 2020 and 31st July 2020, the Panel of Experts on Somalia recorded 11
separate incidents wherein non-governmental organisations were targeted by the Al-
Shabaab, resulting in 8 deaths and 20 abductions of humanitarian workers.
Therefore, the inability to access humanitarian assistance due to Al-Shabaab’s
influence has led to further deterioration of humanitarian conditions for the people of
Somalia.
12
“Why MSF Decided to Leave Somalia: MSF.” Médecins Sans Frontières (MSF)
International [Link]/why-msf-decided-leave-somalia.
“Al-Shabaab's History with Humanitarian Assistance.”
[Link]
assistance
“World Report 2021: Rights Trends in Somalia.” Human Rights Watch, 13 Jan. 2021,
[Link]/world-report/2021/country-chapters/somalia.
Additionally, both the unstable political climate in Somalia and the threat of the Al-
Shabaab have led to over 2.6 million Somalis being internally displaced. The
aforementioned political turmoil caused by the extension of the presidential term led
to armed conflict between security forces supporting opposing political parties,
causing the displacement of around 60,000 to 100,000 people. Al-Shabaab has also
utilised threats, destruction of property, and confiscation of land to target civilians
who refused to comply with their ideology, causing extensive displacement especially
in the regions of Bay, Lower Shabelle and northern Somalia. For instance, in June
2020, an occupation of mosques and madrasas in the Markad, Sanaag region by the
Al-Shabaab caused the community to relocate 90 kilometres away in fear. An
increased intensity of both droughts and flooding has further caused the number of
displaced people to drastically increase, as reported by the UNHCR in 2021. It stated
that “Between January and June, 68,000 people were displaced by drought and
another 56,500 by floods.” Currently, there are around 2,000 Camps for IDPs in
Somalia, including those in Mogadishu and the Afgoi Corridor; however, most are
makeshift settlements with a lack of sanitation, clean food and water.
Likewise, the severity of conflict in Somalia causes displaced citizens to seek refuge in
neighbouring countries on a daily basis, an estimated 1,500 people arrive at Kenya’s
Dadaab refugee camp, and 300 refugees arrive at Ethiopia’s Dolo Ado camp.
However, the freedom of movement of Somalis is hindered by armed militias like the
Al-Shabaab who set up roadblocks and taxation points at primary routes out of the
country such as Dhobley, a town near the Kenyan border. The primary intent of these
obstacles is to prevent Somalis from leaving Al-Shabaab territory and accessing
13
external aid because this reduces Al-Shabaab’s influence. Ameliorating this crisis
requires a focus on methods to reduce the number of internally displaced people
(IDPs), improving the conditions for the existing IDPs, and helping ensure safe
passage for refugees leaving the country.
“World Report 2022: Rights Trends in Somalia.” Human Rights Watch, 13 Jan. 2022,
[Link]/world-report/2022/country-chapters/somalia.
“Life Expectancy at Birth, Male (Years) - Somalia.”
[Link] “Al-
Shabaab's History with Humanitarian Assistance.” Critical Threats
,[Link]
assistance
14
Affiliation with Al-Qaeda:
Al-Qaeda is a militant extremist network, founded by Osama bin Laden with the
objective of ‘waging global jihad.’ On 1st February 2012, Al-Shabaab formally
announced its alignment with Al-Qaeda in an attempt to expand its network and
receive additional arms and funding, subsequently increasing the threat of Somalia
acting as a refuge for international terrorist organisations. An example of operations
extending far outside the Somali region was in December 2020, when a member of Al-
Shabaab was charged with the planning of an attack in the US similar to 9/11. In a
January 2022 interview, General Stephen Townsend, an AFRICOM commander, said
“Al-Shabaab remains Al Qaeda’s largest, wealthiest, and most kinetically active arm.”
As such, Al-Shabaab is not solely a threat to Somalia, but could have negative
ramifications globally. Furthermore, this affiliation allows larger organisations Al-
Qaeda to exert influence over trading routes around Somalia, such as the Gulf of Aden
and the Bab-el-Mandeb strait, which, as previously mentioned, is geostrategically
important for US and European trade. Considering that Europe is the largest export
market for over 80 countries and the US is the world’s largest importer and exporter
of goods, any disruption to trade by Al-Shabaab could be detrimental to the global
economy.
Terrorist financing:
A significant contributing factor to Al-Shabaab’s growth is the various channels of
funding it has. According to the UN, in 2019, “Al-Shabaab spent upward of $21 million
on fighters, weapons, and intelligence”. This large budget is a product of the Al-
15
Shabaab’s influence in southern Somalia where they control a large area spanning
several rural areas, borders of the capital and ports. They thus have control over
several routes of both internal and external trade. Consequently, their primary source
of funding is the taxation of the production and export of charcoal to the Arab states
of the Persian Gulf, especially the United Arab Emirates, Bahrain, Kuwait and Oman,
where it is used in shisha pipes. Additionally, the Al-Shabaab gains revenue through
charcoal trade, which is central to the Somali economy, by charging a jiyaza (tax) for
passing vehicles at taxation points. Despite several bans, reports by the UN indicate
that illicit charcoal trading continues, creating an important revenue stream for the
Al-Shabaab as they capitalise on taxing these exports. Former deputy Somalia
National Intelligence and Security Agency (NISA) chief Ismail Osman believes “the
group is now in a stronger financial position than ever before, allowing it to purchase
more bomb making materials and weapons.” This is a result of Al-Shabaab’s effective
utilisation of “taxation” to obtain funding; evidence for the same is in ‘Zakat’, an
annual religious tax. Moreover, findings of the UN Monitoring Group on Somalia
implicate several countries including Eritrea, Iran, Saudi Arabia, Syria, Qatar, and
Yemen, indicating that they provided assistance to the Al-Shabaab through funding
or provision of arms; however, none of these claims have sufficient proof. In this way,
an important aspect of resolving the Somali crisis is identifying and stopping their
source of income, without harming Somalia’s own economy or degrading aid
received.
16
Hassan, Mohamed Olad. “Al-Shabab Surge in Somalia's Suicide Attacks 'Change of
Tactics,
[Link]/a/al-shabab-surge-in-somalia-s-suicide-attacks-change-of-
tactics-expert s-say/[Link].
Al-Shabaab:
Ḥarakat Al-Shabāb al-Mujāhidīn, known as Al-Shabaab or ‘the youth’ in Somali, is a
religious extremist group based primarily in southern Somalia with its activities
extending to the Horn of Africa region. Founded in 2006, it has, since, exploited the
political instability in Somalia by conducting acts of terrorism through targeted
killings, suicide bombings, and the use of IEDs. After the demise of ex-leader emir
17
Ahmed Abdi Godane in a U.S. airstrike on 1st September 2014, the current leader of
Al-Shabaab is Ahmed Umar, who was listed as a Specially Designated Global Terrorist
in April 2015 by the U.S. State Department. Al-Shabaab reached its pinnacle in 2010,
where it controlled the Somali capital Mogadishu. Although it has since retreated
from major cities and the capital, Al-Shabaab remains extremely active, controlling
large rural areas and performing a myriad of attacks with high casualty rates.
Recently, the power of the Al-Shabaab has witnessed a substantial rise as a result of
the US withdrawal and tumultuous Somalian government transition. Overall, Al-
Shabaab has demonstrated that it will work towards obtaining its objective of an
Islamic state by any means, including terrorist activity, making it a threat which must
be resolved.
AMISOM (African Union Mission to Somalia) and (later) ATMIS (African Union
Transition Mission in Somalia):
AMISOM is a regional peacekeeping mission, which has received approval from the
18
UN and is operated primarily by the AU. It was initially established on 19th January
2007 with a six-month mandate to promote prolonged peace within Somalia, a
timespan which has then been extended through UNSC resolutions. The AMISOM
police has 1040 personnel across Somalia, mandated to “to train, mentor and advise
the Somali Police Force (SPF).” The military component of AMISOM assists in
stabilising the country to ensure safe conditions for humanitarian access by
combatting organisations like the Al-Shabaab. It consists of various troops from
Uganda, Burundi, Djibouti, Kenya, and Ethiopia distributed across “six sectors
covering south and central Somalia.” It is important to note that, with effect from 1st
April, 2022, AMISOM was officially reconfigured and replaced by ATMIS to facilitate
the transition of power to the newly elected government of Somalia and ensure the
power vacuums created will not be exploited by the Al-Shabaab by maintaining a
strong military presence in the region.
Ethiopia:
While large-scale violent action by the extremist group Al-Shabaab is not as prevalent
in Ethiopia as it is in Somalia and Kenya, the country remains in a precarious
position. Since it shares a large border with Somalia, Al-Shabaab remains a constant
threat, necessitating border vigilance by Ethiopian forces. The continued threat of Al-
Shabaab has facilitated collaboration between the Government of Ethiopia and its ally
the US, on counterterrorism measures, such as sharing information and access to
witnesses on cases related to Al-Shabaab, which have improved the efficiency of both
countries’ counterterrorism operations in Somalia. Furthermore, Ethiopia has
contributed approximately 4500 soldiers to ATMIS, and thus is at an increased risk of
retaliation by the Al-Shabaab; for instance, on 23rd April, 2022, the Ethiopia National
Intelligence and Security Service arrested 34 suspected members of Al-Shabaab, who
were "conspiring and preparing to conduct severe terror attacks in Ethiopia's capital
Addis Ababa.” This recent example highlights the importance of suppressing the
militant group to reduce the instability in the Horn of Africa region.
“In Pursuit of Peace; AMISOM Helps Somalia Make Steady Progress - Somalia.”
19
[Link]/report/somalia/pursuit-peace-amisom-helps-somalia-make-
steady-progres s.
“AMISOM Military Component.” AMISOM,
[Link]/mission-profile/military-component/.
“Ethiopia Foils Infiltration Attempt by Terror Group Al-Shabab.”
[Link]/english/africa/2021-07/30/c_1310095631.htm.
Kenya:
Kenya has always been deeply linked to the issue as it shares a border with southern
Somalia. In 2004, Somalia’s Transitional Federal Government (TFG) was formed in
exile in Nairobi, the capital of Kenya. Historically, Kenya has been a key country in
Somalia’s defence; its troops (Kenya Defence Forces) invaded southern Somalia in
‘Operation Linda Nchi’ in 2011, as a response to the cross-border raids carried out by
Al-Shabaab. Soon after, Kenya’s forces were integrated into AMISOM, and in October
2012, they played an integral role in ousting Al-Shabaab from their key stronghold of
the port city of Kismayo. Though the Al-Shabaab is mainly located in Somalia, many
of its activities, such as the aforementioned attack on Garissa university in 2015,
which killed 148 people, continue to extend to Kenya, as retaliation against their
support for the Somali government. In this way, maintaining national security within
Kenya requires the effective suppression of the Al-Shabaab, and, so, makes this
nation especially relevant to the agenda.
Somalia:
Since its formation in 1960, Somalia has been the subject of major political instability
and extremism. This facilitated the rise of Al-Shabaab, which is now the largest threat
in the region and conducts a plethora of activities including direct attacks on civilians,
extortions and blockades to humanitarian access. In the past, the Somalian
government and military have taken several actions to combat Al-Shabaab, such as
the 2014 Operation Indian Ocean, which was a joint endeavour supported by AMISOM
and the US forces. Despite these actions, the group continued to gain power and
maintain a prominent presence in the region due to the political instability of the
20
region. The current situation in Somalia is extremely fragile, as a direct result of the
aforementioned electoral impasse and subsequent ongoing transition of power from
ATMIS to the Somalian government. The increasing power of Al-Shabaab, especially
in Mogadishu, is evidenced by increasing the number of attacks; between January 1st
to 18th itself, four suicide bombings were conducted by the group. It is thus in
Somalia’s best interests to ensure the transition of power occurs smoothly while
combating Al-Shabaab’s increased attacks.
“Timeline: Al Shabab (2004–2020).”
[Link]/timeline/al-shabab.
Background Report Al-Shabaab Attack on Garissa.
[Link]/pubs/STARTBackgroundReport_alShabaabGarissaU_April2015.
pdf.
“Somali Capital Gunfire amid Election Protests.”
[Link]/news/world-africa-56123481.
“Africa File: Al-Shabaab Surges Bombings amid Somali Political Crisis.”
[Link]
bombings-amid-s omali-political-crisis
21
includes supporting and advising both the African Union Mission in Somalia
(AMISOM) and the FGS on counterterrorism and humanitarian operations, making it
a significant organisation in combating the threat posed by Al-Shabaab.
TIMELINE OF EVENTS
22
➡️
the port city of Kismayo and Barawe. 1st August 2010 AMISOM and Transitional
FGS forces regain control of the major urban centres including Mogashidu from Al-
➡️
Shabaab 11th July 2010 Multiple suicide bombings occurred in Kampala, Uganda,
with 74 casualties and 85 injured. This was Al-Shabaab’s first full-fledged foreign
terrorist attack, as a retaliation against the Ugandan troops in Somalia as a part of
➡️
AMISOM. 5th December 2011 Sanctions were imposed on Eritrea to prevent it
➡️
providing support to Al-Shabaab by the UNSC. 1st February 2012 Al-Shabaab's
alignment with al-Qaeda formally announced, raising global concerns for
➡️
international security. 1st September 2014 15th January 2016 6th November 2020
Leader of Al-Shabaab, known as the ‘emir,’ Ahmed Abdi Godane was killed in an
AFRICOM airstrike performed in cooperation with Somali forces. Al-Shabaab
launches an attack against the Somali National Army (SNA) camp which is in close
proximity to the Kenya Defence Forces (KDF) camp. Al-Shabaab fighters detonate a
car bomb that kills an officer of the U.S. Central Intelligence Agency and four Somali
➡️
intelligence officers in Gendershe in retaliation to American involvement. 27th
May 2020 AMISOM and regional security forces launch an operation in Dinsor town
combatting Al-Shabaab and killing 5 extremists. The day of Biden's inauguration;
National Security Adviser Jake Sullivan issues a mandate that would limit
➡️
counterterrorism drone strikes outside of Afghanistan and Syria. 20th January 2021
To hinder the election process, an Al-Shabaab suicide bomber used an IED on a bus
➡️
full of delegates travelling to the president’s office, killing 6 people. 3rd May 2022
An estimated 450 Al-Shabaab militants ambushed the ATMIS base in El Baraf, killing
30 soldiers. The camp was eventually overrun by these militants.
23
RELEVANT UN TREATIES AND EVENTS
24
PREVIOUS ATTEMPTS TO SOLVE THIS ISSUE
In addition to the UN events mentioned above, several efforts to curb the threat of Al-
Shabaab in Somalia have been undertaken by both international organisations and
the FGS. However, none of them have been completely effective in diminishing the
threat of Al-Shabaab. Thus, its lethal insurgency continues. In order to successfully
comprehend future steps that need to be taken, it is essential to analyse previous
attempts made to resolve the issue.
A number of peaceful measures have been attempted by the Somali government to
resolve conflict with the al-Shabab throughout the years. The first notable one was
when President Sheikh Sharif Ahmed organised a meeting in 2009 with Al-Shabaab
leaders to discuss ways to end the conflict. These talks failed as no compromise was
found suitable to both parties. Considering these futile attempts, in 2012, President
Hassan Sheikh Mohammed took a different approach: targeting individual Al-
Shabaab commanders for defection or arrest. This strategy was partially successful,
with Somali forces causing high-ranking Al-Shabaab officials, Mohamed Said Atom
and Zakariya Ahmed Hersi, to defect. Unfortunately, the measures were extremely
small-scale, and did not have a very significant effect on Al-Shabaab’s strength. More
recently, it has been reported that Fahad Yasin, former NISA chief, attempted to
explore opportunities for dialogue with Al-Shabaab in 2020 and 2021, but was
unsuccessful.
The international community, recognising the urgency of reducing Al-Shabaab’s
power, has also attempted several measures in collaboration with the FGS. As
previously mentioned, the United States has played a large role in attempting to
suppress Al-Shabaab, through drone-strikes and military support. An estimated 269
total counterterrorism strikes have been performed by the United States, with
support of Somalia, which have been highly effective against Al-Shabaab, causing
1900 deaths. Furthermore, the United States of America has partnered with the FGS
to improve the quality of the Somali Police Force, thereby enabling Somalia to
strengthen itself against Al-Shabaab. Furthermore, several organisations supported
25
by the UN and other nations have attempted to work towards resolving the Somali
crisis, through methods such as stabilising Somalia’s political structure, providing
assistance through troops, and funding. Examples of this include organisations like
the UNSOM, AFRICOM, AMISOM and ATMIS, operations and aims of which have
been previously detailed, as well as Kenya and Ethiopia, which provide assistance by
sending troops. However, even with these organisations and countries lending
assistance, the threat of Al-Shabaab remains due to the fragile political structure of
Somalia and potential power vacuums. To subdue Al-Shabaab and maintain
international stability, increased collaboration and cooperation is required.
“Considering Political Engagement with Al-Shabaab in Somalia.”
[Link]/africa/horn-africa/somalia/309-considering-political-
engagement-Al-Shabaab-somalia.
“America's Counterterrorism Wars.”
[Link]/international-security/reports/americas-counterterrorism-
wars/the-war-in-somalia/.
POSSIBLE SOLUTIONS
The question of Somalia, especially with respect to Al-Shabaab and its violent
activities, is one that has not been addressed effectively by the international
community. This, therefore, necessitates collaboration between countries to devise
solutions that address the political, humanitarian and economic intricacies of this
agenda.
Firstly, increasing the efficacy of current peacekeeping missions, keeping in mind the
reduction in US forces, is imperative. This can be done through methods such as
improving training of both the SPF and the Somali Armed Forces, with a special
emphasis on counterterrorism strikes. Furthermore, promoting effective
collaboration between different organisations present, such as NISA and ATMIS, for
the collection and evaluation of data, such as locations of Al-Shabaab bases and
predicted further activities, could improve their efficiency.
Secondly, an important aspect of the issue to consider is limiting the funding of Al-
26
Shabaab. This can be done by promoting the cooperation of intelligence agencies
across all nations, especially Kenya, Ethiopia, and Uganda, so that any sources of
funding may be identified. Furthermore, it is important to increase the efficiency of
the charcoal ban to limit the funding of Al-Shabaab through the monitoring and
imposition of fines for illegal charcoal trade, by organisations within Somalia such as
AMISOM. If any other country, entity or group is identified to be funding Al-Shabaab,
economic sanctions could be imposed under the jurisdiction of the UN, similar to the
ones on Eritrea. Additionally, UNSOM should evaluate structures that currently fund
government effort in Somalia to detect any loopholes. This will assist in identifying
and blocking sources of funding of the Al-Shabaab.
Thirdly, it is vital to prevent the exploitation of power vacuums by Al-Shabaab and
increase the efficiency of the political transition. This can be done through
strengthening the political structure and FGS and through regular reports on the
situation by ATMIS. Furthermore, ATMIS could encourage the Somali government to
adopt legislative reforms to reduce the prevalence of sexual and gender-based
violence and abuse, for example criminalising child marriage and sex-trafficking.
Lastly, providing refugees and IDPs with basic human rights through the
construction of shelters in regions of Somalia with large numbers of IDPs is
imperative. Such relocation efforts must be taken where it is safe to do so, with the
assistance of UNHRC. Additionally, working in collaboration with the SOCHUM to
provide vocational training and education for IDPs and refugees to successfully
integrate them within their relocated community could augment the humanitarian
situation in Somalia. Overall, solutions should address the various facets to the issue
of Al-Shabaab in Somalia, take into account the urgency and depth of this problem,
and work towards maintaining peace and stability in all affected regions.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
The Africa Center for Strategic Studies January 24, 2022. “Surge in Militant Islamist
Violence in the Sahel Dominates Africa's Fight against Extremists.” Africa Center for
Strategic Studies, 11 May 2022,
[Link]
sahel-dominates-africa-fight-extremists/.
27
“Africa File: Al-Shabaab Surges Bombings amid Somali Political Crisis.” Critical
Threats, [Link]
surges-bombings-amid-somali-political-crisis
Al Jazeera. “Somalia's Allies Fear Instability as Political Crisis Deepens.” News | Al
Jazeera, Al Jazeera, 28 Dec. 2021,
[Link]/news/2021/12/28/somalias-allies-fear-instability-as-political-
crisis-deepens.
Al Jazeera. “Somalia's Shabab Bans UN Food Aid.” News | Al Jazeera, Al Jazeera, 28
Feb. 2010, [Link]/news/2010/2/28/somalias-shabab-bans-un-food-aid.
“Al-Shabaab's History with Humanitarian Assistance.” Critical Threats
[Link]
assistance
“Al-Qaeda.” Counter Extremism Project
[Link]/threat/al-qaeda.
. “Al-Shabaab Terrorist Network: The Nature of This Enemy.” United States Africa
Command,
[Link]/pressrelease/33101/Al-Shabaab-terrorist-network-the-nature-of-
th.
“Al-Shabab.” Council on Foreign Relations, Council on Foreign Relations,
[Link]/backgrounder/al-shabab.
“America's Counterterrorism Wars.” New America,
[Link]/international-security/reports/americas-counterterrorism-
wars/the-war-in-somalia/
. “AMISOM Military Component.” AMISOM,
[Link]/mission-profile/military-component/
Background Report Al-Shabaab Attack on Garissa.
[Link]/pubs/STARTBackgroundReport_alShabaabGarissaU_April2015.
pdf.
“Conflict with Al-Shabab in Somalia | Global Conflict Tracker.” Council on Foreign
Relations, Council on Foreign Relations,
[Link]/global-conflict-tracker/conflict/al-shabab-somalia.
28
“Considering Political Engagement with Al-Shabaab in Somalia.” Crisis Group, 21
June 2022,
[Link]/africa/horn-africa/somalia/309-considering-political-
engagement-Al-Shabaab-somalia.
“Ethiopia Arrests Al-Shabaab Militants Smuggling Weapons from Somalia.” Garowe
Online, [Link]
“Ethiopia Foils Infiltration Attempt by Terror Group Al-Shabab.” Xinhua,
[Link]/english/africa/2021-07/30/c_1310095631.htm.
“Examining Extremism: Harakat Al-Shabaab Al Mujahideen (Al-Shabaab).”
Examining Extremism: Harakat Al-Shabaab Al Mujahideen (Al-Shabaab) | Center for
Strategic and International Studies, 28 Oct. 2021,
[Link]/blogs/examining-extremism/examining-extremism-harakat-Al-
Shabaab-al-mujahideen-Al-Shabaab .
29
Matt Bryden, Theodore Murphy. “Somalia's Election Impasse: A Crisis of State
Building.” ECFR, 16 Feb. 2021,
[Link]/article/somalias-election-impasse-a-crisis-of-state-building/
Mohamed, Hamza. “What Is Delaying Somalia's Elections?” Elections News | Al
Jazeera, Al Jazeera, 10 Feb. 2021,
[Link]/news/2021/2/10/what-is-delaying-somalias-election.
Network, MI News. “What Are Maritime Chokepoints?” Marine Insight, 26 Oct. 2021,
[Link]/marine-navigation/what-are-maritime-chokepoints/.
“Six Grave Violations against Children in Times of War.” UNICEF, 28 June 2022,
[Link]/stories/children-under-attack-six-grave-violations-against-
children-times-war.
“Somali Capital Gunfire amid Election Protests.” BBC News, BBC, 19 Feb. 2021,
[Link]/news/world-africa-56123481.
“Timeline: Al Shabab (2004–2020).” Council on Foreign Relations, Council on Foreign
Relations, [Link]/timeline/al-shabab
“Trump Orders Pentagon to Withdraw Most Forces from Somalia.” Air Force
Magazine, 7 Dec. 2020,
[Link]/trump-orders-pentagon-to-withdraw-most-forces-from-
somalia/
“U.S. Relations with Somalia - United States Department of State.” U.S. Department
of State, U.S. Department of State, 18 Mar. 2022,
[Link]/u-s-relations-with-somalia/.
“U.S. to Resume Small, Persistent Presence in Somalia.” U.S. Department of
Defense, [Link]
resume-small-per sistent-presence-in-somalia/
“Uganda: One Killed in Bomb Attack at Kampala Bar.” BBC News, BBC, 25 Oct. 2021,
[Link]/news/world-africa-59028210.
“Unanimously Adopting Resolution 2628 (2022), Security Council Endorses Decision
to Reconfigure Existing Entity into African Union Transition Mission in Somalia | UN
Press.” United Nations, United Nations,
[Link]/press/en/2022/[Link].
30
United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees. “Displaced Somalis and Refugees
Struggle to Recover as Climate Change Brings New Threats.” UNHCR,
[Link]
recover-climate -change-brings-new-threats
United States Africa Command,
[Link]/.
“The US Military Is Ramping up Its Secret Air War in Somalia, with a Deadly Impact
for Civilians on the Ground.” Amnesty International, 14 June 2021
[Link]
civilian-deaths-mount-from-us-air-strikes/ .
Warner, Jason; Chapin. “Targeted Terror: The Suicide Bombers of Al-Shabaab.”
Homeland Security Digital Library, Combating Terrorism Center (U.S.), 1 Feb. 2018,
[Link]/?abstract&did=821292.
“What Are Economic Sanctions?” Council on Foreign Relations, Council on Foreign
Relations,
[Link]/backgrounder/what-are-economic-sanctions.
“World Report 2021: Rights Trends in Somalia.” Human Rights Watch, 13 Jan. 2021,
[Link]/world-report/2021/country-chapters/somalia.
“World Report 2022: Rights Trends in Somalia.” Human Rights Watch, 13 Jan. 2022
[Link]
31