Cervical Cancer: HPV Impact and Guidelines
Cervical Cancer: HPV Impact and Guidelines
TUMOURS
Maria Rosaria Raspollini
47
Cervical cancer is the fourth most common cancer in of precancerous lesions remain essential to achieve
women globally, after breast, colorectal and lung cancers, elimination goals.
and it is one of the top three cancers in women younger Modelling exercises have indicated that high HPV
that 45 years in several countries. vaccination coverage of girls could have a substantial
The incidence rates vary in different coutries: cervical impact in reducing cervical cancer rates in most low- and
cancer is the fourth leading cause of cancer death of women middle-income countries over the course of this century,
in low- and middle-income countries. with a high uptake of screening necessary in countries with
Every year, there are over 600,000 new cervical cancer the highest burden.
cases worldwide. Over 91% of deaths from cervical cancer Primary and secondary preventions have significantly
occurs in low-and-middle-income countries. reduced incidence and mortality in high-income countries.
The incidence of cervical cancer in low-and-middle- At the current time, cervical cancers represent less that 4
income countries has tripled in the last decade. Due to cases for 100000 women in northern Europe and more
delay in detection, women often present themselves to the than 40 cases for 100000 women in eastern Africa. Low-
clinician at an advanced stage and higher mortality. and middle-income countries bear 85% of the disease
80–90% of cervical cancers are squamous cell burden and are expected to account for 11 million deaths
carcinomas (SCCs). from the disease over the next 10-20 years.
Cervical epithelial pathology is dominate by HPV The European Society of Gynaecological Oncology
infection and its neoplastic effects. HPV infection is (ESGO) jointly with the European Society for Radiotherapy
traditionally related to the development of cervical & Oncology (ESTRO) and the European Society of
carcinoma. High HPV vaccination coverage of girls could Pathology (ESP) published evidence-based guidelines in
have a great impact in reducing cervical cancer rates in low- order to improve the management of patients with cervical
and middle-income countries. In addition, the screening cancer within a multidisciplinary setting with the aim to
and the treating the preinvasive cancers might decrease the improve the quality of care for women with gynecological
invasive lesions. cancers across Europe. The guidelines has been first
The World Health Organization (WHO) launched published in 2018, and these have been updated in 2022 in
a Call to Action to eliminate cervical cancer through order to provide comprehensive guidelines on all relevant
immunization against the human papillomavirus, the issues of diagnosis and treatment in cervical cancer.
causative agent of virtually all cases of cervical cancer, The guidelines were developed using a process which
screening for human papillomavirus with a high- includes the creation of a multidisciplinary international
performance test, and treatment of cervical disease. Since development group, use of scientific evidence and
immunization coverage remains limited in low- and international expert consensus to support the guidelines,
middle-income countries and cannot fully protect women and use of an international external review process
already exposed to the virus, screening and treatment (physicians and patients).
469
470 Pathology of Cervical Malignant Tumors
Cervical carcinoma is related to HPV infection. possibly carcinogenic: 26, 53, 66, 67, 68, 70, 73, and 82.
Hovewer, it has become increasingly recognized that a Very rarely, low-risk HPV genotypes such as 6 and 11 have
significant proportion of cervical carcinomas, in particular been identified as the sole cause of cervical SCC.
adenocarcinomas, are not associated with HPV infection.
Pathogenesis
Moreover, as in the vulva, HPV-independent cervical
carcinomas are generally more aggressive than HPV- HPV-associated cervical SCC develops from a high-
associated carcinomas. The 2020 edition of the WHO grade squamous intraepithelial lesion (HSIL) as a result
classification of tumors differs from previous editions by of high expression levels of the viral oncogenes E6 and
dividing epithelial tumors and their precursors in HPV- E7 in dividing epithelial cells (a so-called transforming
associated or HPV-indipendent. infection). The progression of high-grade lesions to
Importantly, this change produces a classification that SCCs requires the accumulation of additional, not yet
will allow more accurate assessment of the role of HPV completely understood epigenetic and genetic alterations,
testing in cervical screening programmes, as well as the a process that may take 20–30 years. Hypermethylation
role of HPV vaccination. of CpG islands in promoter regions of tumour suppressor
Almost all cervical SCCs are HPV-associated, hovewer genes has been recognized as a molecular change from
HPV-independent SCC, although rare, has been described. HSIL towards cervical cancer. Several factors have been
For this reason, and in accordance to the classification associated with an increased risk of HPV persistence and
across lower genital tract, squamous lesions are subdivided progression, including immunosuppression (particularly
in 2020 WHO classification of Female Genital Tumors due to HIV), multiparity, smoking, and the use of oral
into HPV-associated and HPV-independent types. HPV- contraceptives.
associated and HPV-independent SCCs cannot be reliably More than 70% of HPV-associated SCCs exhibit
distinguished by the morphological criteria alone; p16 genomic alterations in either one or both of the PI3K/
immunostaining or HPV testing is required, nevertheless, MAPK and TGF-β signalling pathways. ERBB3 (HER3),
a morphological diagnosis without differentiating the two CASP8, HLA-A, SHKBP1, and TGFBR2 have been reported
categories is acceptable where the tecniques to make this as significantly mutated genes. Almost all HPV-associated
distinction are not available. Although the percentage SCCs show strong and diffuse p16 overexpression in both
of HPV-independent SCCs in the cervix is very low, it is the nuclei and the cytoplasm.
reccomended to distinguish HPV-associated and HPV-
Pathology
independent SCC on the pathology report, even there
is currently no difference in treatment between HPV- SCCs are characterized by infiltrating, angulated,
associated and HPV-independent tumors. irregularly sized and shaped nests, anastomosing cords,
Although the majority of endocervical adenocarcino- and solid sheets separated by desmoplastic or inflammatory
mas are associated with HPV infection, a significant mi- stroma. Nuclear pleomorphism and an increased mitotic
nority are no-correlated. The 2020 WHO classification count are seen. Grading systems, based on either nuclear
recognizes this by separating HPV-associated and HPV- pleomorphism or differentiation, have not shown any
independent adenocarcinomas, dividing the latter into consistent correlation with behaviour.
specific gastric, clear cell, mesonephric and endometrioid Several histological patterns have been described.
types. Adenocarcinoma in situ has similarly been divided • Non-keratinizing SCCs are composed of polygonal
into HPV-associated and HPV-independent groups. squamous cells growing in nest or sheets. Intercellular
bridges or individual cell keratinization can be seen,
Squamous Cell Carcinoma, HPV- but keratin pearls are not present.
Associated, of the Uterine Cervix • Keratinizing SCCs are characterized by the presence of
The large majority of cervical SCCs, more than 90–95%, keratin pearls. Tumor cells show a mature appearance,
are HPV-associated. with polygonal cytoplasm and intercellular bridges.
High-risk HPV genotypes cause the vast majority • Basaloid SCCs show nests of immature, basal-type
(> 90–95%) of SCCs. Twelve HPV types are classified by squamous cells with scant cytoplasm, resembling the
WHO as oncogenic: 16, 18, 31, 33, 35, 39, 45, 51, 52, 56, 58, cells commonly seen in HSIL (Figure 1A and 1B). Some
and 59, but two types (16 and 18) are responsible for 70% individual keratinization can be present, but keratin
of all SCCs. Another eight HPV types have been rarely but pearls are rarely seen. (Basaloid and non-keratinizing
consistently identified as single HPV infections in about patterns are the most frequently identified patterns in
3% of cervical carcinomas and are classified as probably/ HPV-associated SCC)
Pathology of Cervical Malignant Tumors 471
Figure 1. HPV-associted SCC of the uterine cervix. Basal-type squamous cells (A) which are positive for High Grade HPV DNA (B).
• HSIL-like growth pattern (uncommon cases) criteria can reliably differentiate HPV-associated and HPV-
• Warty (condylomatous) SCC shows an exophytic independent SCCs. p16 immunohistochemistry showing
surface and koilocyte-like changes. a negative result is an acceptable surrogate biomarker,
• Papillary SCC shows exophytic growth of fibrovascular although occasional HPV-associated carcinomas show loss
cores lined by a multilayered atypical epithelium with of p16 within the invasive component.
squamous differentiation.
• Transitional-like appearance SCC: carcinoma with
Adenocarcinoma, HPV-Associated, of
exophytic growth pattern. The occasional reported
the Uterine Cervix
cases of SCC associated with low-risk HPV types show
Epidemiology
this morphology.
• Lymphoepithelioma-like SCC is a rare pattern showing In non-screened populations, adenocarcinoma represents
a dense stromal inflammatory infiltrate. EBV is not 5% of all cervical carcinomas. However, the relative
involved in these tumors in the cervix. prevalence of adenocarcinoma has increased to 10–
25% of all cervical carcinomas in developed countries,
predominantly as a result of the impact of cytology-based
Squamous Cell Carcinoma, HPV-
screening on detecting and treating squamous precancers.
Independent, of the Uterine Cervix Primary HPV-based screening improves prevention of
About 5–7% of all SCCs of the uterine cervix are negative adenocarcinoma over cytology, presumably through better
for HPV, even when very sensitive techniques for HPV detection and treatment of HPV-associated glandular
detection are used. Usually, these tumors occur in older precursors.
patients, in the seventh decade of life. Etiology is unknown The mean patient age at presentation is 40–42
and few data are known about the molecular abnormalities years, significantly younger than for HPV-independent
in HPV-independent SCCs. These carcinomas show a adenocarcinomas.
higher rate of abnormal p53 immunostaining suggestive of These tumors are caused by infection with HR-
mutation. Mutations in KRAS, ARID1A, and PTEN have HPV. The most common HPV types are 18, 16, and 45,
been described. accounting for about 95% of cases. Coinfection with
multiple HPV types, as seen in HPV-associated SCC,
Pathology
occurs in about 10% of cases.
HPV-independent SCCs are frequently of keratinizing type
(Figure 2) or basaloid type. However, the other histological Pathogenesis
patterns of SCC can be described. Hovewer, this diagnosis Adenocarcinomas are associated with HPV clades A9
needs the demonstation of absence of HPV, demonstrated (typically HPV16) and A7 (typically HPV18). The HPV
using highly sensitive molecular techniques for the viral oncoproteins E6 and E7 inactivate p53 and RB1,
detection of HPV DNA or mRNA. No morphological respectively; this inactivation is associated with integration
472 Pathology of Cervical Malignant Tumors
causes circumferential induration, imparting a barrel shape Stella reaction or trophoblastic disease may mimic clear
to the cervix. cell adenocarcinoma.
The key feature is glandular cells with abundant This neoplasm is not associated with HPV. Case reports
clear or pale eosinophilic cytoplasm and distinct cell of clear cell carcinomas thought by the authors to be of
borders. Apical mitoses and apoptosis are present but endocervical origin describe rare POLE mutation with DES
inconspicuous. Cytoplasm contains neutral mucins, exposure and Lynch syndrome.
which stain pale pinkish-red on Alcian blue/PAS special
staining (in contrast to the dark purple of acid mucins of Adenocarcinoma, HPV-independent,
normal endocervix). Morphology ranges from extremely Mesonephric Type, of the Uterine Cervix
well differentiated adenocarcinoma (previously termed
Adenocarcinoma, HPV-independent, mesonephric type,
minimal deviation adenocarcinoma), with deep haphazard
is a malignant neoplasm with mesonephric (Wolffian)
claw-like gland distribution and limited desmoplasia, to
differentiation.
poorly differentiated glands, clusters, and single cells.
Mesonephric carcinomas are typically associated
Poorly differentiated glands are lined by cells with variable
with mesonephric remnants along the course of the
nuclear changes, including large vesicular nuclei with
embryological mesonephric duct located deep in the
visible nucleoli. Lymphovascular invasion is present in
cervical wall (lateral side).
about the 50% of cases.
It is an uncommon tumor, it represents less than 1% of
Molecular Pathology cervical carcinomas. It occurs in the fifth decade. There is
no association with HPV
These tumors are negative for HPV infection. STK11
These neoplasms are thought to arise from vestiges of
mutations are frequent. Some cases are related with Peutz–
the embryological male reproductive system (Wolffian/
Jeghers syndrome. TP53 is frequently altered. ERBB2
mesonephric duct). Most harbour KRAS mutations and
(HER2) and MDM2 gene amplification is detected in some
gain in chromosome 1q (with a subset showing concurrent
tumors.
loss of 1p). Two thirds have mutations in chromatin
remodelling genes (ARID1A/B or SMARCA4) and one
Adenocarcinoma, HPV-independent, third in BCOR/BCORL1. A minority have mutations in
Clear Cell Type, of the Uterine Cervix TP53 or CTNNB1. They have a low mutation burden and
Clear cell carcinoma is a malignant glandular neoplasm absence of microsatellite instability.
composed of uniform, clear or eosinophilic, flat or cuboidal
cells arranged in one or more patterns: tubulocystic, Pathology
papillary, solid. The tumor epicentre is usually within the cervical wall,
These tumors are rare, they represent the 3–4% of where mesonephric remnants reside, with extension
cervical adenocarcinomas. They arise in two distinct to overlying cervical mucosa. Full-thickness invasion,
settings: as sporadic tumors (median patient age: 51 years, circumferential involvement, ulceration, and extension
in the endocervix) and in association with in utero DES into the lower uterine segment are not uncommon.
exposure (mean patient age: 19 years, in the ectocervix). Some tumors can form an exophytic or polypoid mass.
Tumors are firm, white or grey, and they can be diffusely
Pathology haemorrhagic.
Grossly, tumors can present as endophytic with diffuse The classic pattern is tubular, with back-to-back
enlargement of the cervix, exophytic with a protruding tubules lined by cuboidal cells with lumina filled
mass, or without a clinically evident mass. with dense eosinophilic secretions (PAS-positive
The tumor cells are organized in a tubulocystic, and mucicarmine-positive). Additional patterns are
papillary, and/or solid pattern, lined by cells with clear the ductal (pseudoendometrioid) pattern, which is
(intracytoplasmic glycogen), eosinophilic, granular characterized by angulated glands lined by columnar
cytoplasm, sometimes hobnailed, with minimal cells, papillary, retiform, sex cord–like, hobnail,
stratification. Cytoplasmic boundaries are prominent. The glomeruloid, spindled, and solid patterns. Nuclei are
nuclei may show hyperchromasia, enlarged nucleoli, or uniform, with coarse or vesicular chromatin or grooves
pseudonuclear inclusions. Tubules or cysts lined by a single and inconspicuous nucleoli. Mitotic activity is variable.
layer of flattened epithelial cells may appear deceptively Sarcomatous differentiation, including chondrosarcoma,
benign. The mitotic count is usually low, and stromal rhabdomyosarcoma, and osteosarcoma, allows the
hyalinization is common. Endocervical glands with Arias- diagnosis of mesonephric carcinosarcoma.
474 Pathology of Cervical Malignant Tumors
The carcinomatous component can be represented by a cytoplasm. A stromal reaction is absent. Adenoid basal
subtype such as squamous cell carcinoma, adenocarcinoma, carcinoma is often associated with a high-grade squamous
adenoid basal carcinoma, mesonephric carcinoma, or intraepithelial lesion or with an invasive carcinoma of
neuroendocrine carcinoma). The mesenchymal component another type, most commonly squamous cell carcinoma.
is often homologous (fibrosarcoma, endometrioid Adenoid basal carcinoma associated with another invasive
stromal sarcoma) but can occasionally show heterologous carcinoma type should be reported as a mixed carcinoma,
differentiation (rhabdomyosarcoma, osteosarcoma). with a description of the constituent histotypes and their
The prognosis is poor, with a 2-year overall survival proportions.
rate of 60%. Tumor stage is the single most important Adenoid basal carcinoma has no known metastatic
prognostic indicator.
potential when occurring in pure from. The outcome of
mixed carcinomas with an adenoid basal tumor component
Adenosquamous and Mucoepidermoid depends on the prognostic features of the other component.
Carcinomas of the Cervix
It represent the 5-6% of all cervical cancers. Carcinoma of the Uterine Cervix,
These tumors are associated with high-risk HPV, most Unclassifiable
commonly types 16 and 18.
Carcinoma of the uterine cervix, unclassifiable, is a
In situ hybridization or PCR can be used to detect HPV.
cervical malignant epithelial tumor that cannot be further
Compared with squamous carcinoma, adenosquamous
subclassified; diagnosis requires the exclusion of potential
carcinoma exhibits lower ARID1A expression, whereas
histological mimics, including primary and metastatic
expression of EGFR (HER1) and PDGFRA is common in
the absence of activating mutations. tumors.