HUL 211: Introduction to Economics
IIT Delhi
Practice Problems 2
January 21, 2025
Definition: An allocation x = {x1 , x2 , x3 , ....., xn } is Pareto efficient if and
only if there exists no x′ such that
ui (x′ ) ≥ ui (x), ∀i.
holds and with strict inequality for some i.
An allocation x′ is Pareto inefficient if there exists at least one allocation x
dominating it.
• Situation 1 is called Pareto superior to situation 2 (a Pareto improvement
over situation 2) if no individual is worse off in the first than in the second
while at least one individual is strictly better off.
• Situations are called Pareto efficient, Pareto optimal or just efficient if
Pareto improvements are not possible.
Typical trade-offs: a policy may increase national output but also increase in-
equality, it may increase employment but also increase inflation, it may benefit
one group but make another group worse off...
1. If the set of feasible allocations is convex, then, to any Pareto optimal
allocation corresponds one set of weights, such that that particular alloca-
tion is the one maximizing the households weighted sum. True or False?
Argue why? What if the set of feasible allocations is concave?
2. Consider the production of wine and cheese in France and Spain. This
table gives the number of necessary hours to produce each (labor is the
only input):
(a) For each good, which country has an absolute advantage? For each
good, which country has a comparative advantage?
1
Figure 1: Table
(b) Is it in Spain’s interest to develop trade relationships with France?
Is it in France’s interest to trade with Spain? Is France more com-
petitive at producing both goods?
(c) Suppose that France and Spain are under autarky (no trade). Draw
the production possibility frontier for each country for the number of
goods they can produce in one day (24 hours, one worker).
(d) France and Spain decide to trade and suppose they agree to trade
one bottle of wine for k kilos of cheese. What values of k would make
both France and Spain strictly better off under trade? Draw the new
consumption set for each country under trade. How has it changed
and why?
3. Consider the two Ricardian economies whose endowments and technolo-
gies are those described below. Each has a fixed endowment of labor – its
only factor of production – and can produce two goods, X and Y , using
the indicated constant amounts of labor per unit of output:
Figure 2: Table
(a) Draw the production possibility frontiers for each of these countries.
(b) Which country has an absolute advantage in good X? Which in good
Y ? Which has a comparative advantage in good X? Which in good
Y?
(c) Discuss the possibilities of trade. Draw the new consumption set for
each country under trade.
4. Observe the picture below. Discuss the notions of pareto efficiency and
economic efficiency.
2
Figure 3: Efficiency