Dimensional Analysis and Measurement Problems
Dimensional Analysis and Measurement Problems
[M ][LT 2 ]
[LT 1 ] = [ LT 1
]
[ML1 T 1 ][L]
L.H.S. = R.H.S. i.e., the above formula is Correct.
Problem 35. A dimensionally consistent relation for the volume V of a liquid of coefficient of viscosity
flowing per second through a tube of radius r and length l and having a pressure difference
p across its end, is
pr 4 l 8 pl p
(a) V (b) V (c) V (d) V
8l 8 pr 4
r 4
8lr 4
Volume
Solution : (a) Given V = Rate of flow = [L3 T 1 ] , P = Pressure = [ ML1 T 2 ] , r = Radius = [L]
sec
= Coefficient of viscosity = [ML1 T 1 ] , l = Length = [L]
By substituting the dimension of each quantity we can check the accuracy of the formula
P r 4
V
8l
[ML1T 2 ] [L4 ]
[L3 T 1 ] 1 1
= [L3 T 1 ]
[ML T ] [L]
L.H.S. = R.H.S. i.e., the above formula is Correct.
1
Problem 36. With the usual notations, the following equation S t u a(2t 1) is
2
(a) Only numerically correct (b) Only dimensionally
correct
(c) Both numerically and dimensionally correct (d) Neither numerically
nor dimensionally correct
Solution : (c) Given S t = distance travelled by the body in tth sec.= [LT 1 ] , a = Acceleration = [LT 2 ] ,
Since the dimension of each terms are equal therefore this equation is dimensionally
correct. And after deriving this equation from Kinematics we can also proof that this
equation is correct numerically also.
Problem 37. If velocity v, acceleration A and force F are chosen as fundamental quantities, then the
dimensional formula of angular momentum in terms of v, A and F would be
= [ML2 T 1 ]
L.H.S. = R.H.S. i.e., the above formula is Correct.
Problem 38. The largest mass (m) that can be moved by a flowing river depends on velocity (v), density
( ) of river water and acceleration due to gravity (g). The correct relation is
2v 4 v 6 v 4 v 6
(a) m 2
(b) m 2
(c) m 3
(d) m
g g g g3
Solution : (d) Given, m = mass = [M], v = velocity = [LT 1 ] , = density = [ML 3 ] , g = acceleration due to
gravity = [LT–2]
By substituting, the dimension of each quantity we can check the accuracy of the formula
v6
mK
g3
[ML3 ][ LT 1 ]6
[M ]
[LT 2 ] 3
= [M]
L.H.S. = R.H.S. i.e., the above formula is Correct.
(5) As a research tool to derive new relations : If one knows the dependency of a physical
quantity on other quantities and if the dependency is of the product type, then using the method
of dimensional analysis, relation between the quantities can be derived.
Example : (i) Time period of a simple pendulum.
Let time period of a simple pendulum is a function of mass of the bob (m), effective length
(l), acceleration due to gravity (g) then assuming the function to be product of power function
of m, l and g
l
So the required physical relation becomes T K
g
l
The value of dimensionless constant is found (2 ) through experiments so T 2
g
Units, Dimensions and Measurement 71
(ii) Stoke’s law : When a small sphere moves at low speed through a fluid, the viscous
force F, opposing the motion, is found experimentally to depend on the radius r, the velocity of
the sphere v and the viscosity of the fluid.
So F = f (, r, v)
If the function is product of power functions of , r and v, F K x r y v z ; where K is
dimensionless constant.
or [MLT 2 ] [M x L x y z T x z ]
Equating the exponents of similar quantities x = 1; – x + y + z = 1 and – x – z = – 2
Solving these for x, y and z, we get x = y = z = 1
So eqn (i) becomes F = Krv
On experimental grounds, K = 6; so F = 6rv
This is the famous Stoke’s law.
r 3
So the time period can be given as, T K S 1 / 2 r 3 / 2 1 / 2 K .
S
72 Units, Dimensions and Measurement
Problem 41. If P represents radiation pressure, C represents speed of light and Q represents radiation
energy striking a unit area per second, then non-zero integers x, y and z such that P x Q y C z
is dimensionless, are
[AFMC 1991; CBSE 1992; CPMT 1981, 92; MP PMT 1992]
Solution : (b) [P x Q y C z ] M 0 L0 T 0
By substituting the dimension of each quantity in the given expression
[ML 1 T 2 ] x [MT 3 ] y [LT 1 ] z [M x y L x z T 2 x 3 y z ] M 0 L0 T 0
by equating the power of M, L and T in both sides: x y 0 , x z 0 and 2 x 3y z 0
by solving we get x 1, y 1, z 1 .
Problem 42. The volume V of water passing through a point of a uniform tube during t seconds is related
to the cross-sectional area A of the tube and velocity u of water by the relation V A u t ,
which one of the following will be true
(a) (b) (c) (d)
Solution : (b) Writing dimensions of both sides [L3 ] [L2 ] [LT 1 ] [ T ] [L3 T 0 ] [L2 T ]
By comparing powers of both sides 2 3 and 0
1
Which give and (3 ) i.e. .
2
Problem 43. If velocity (V), force (F) and energy (E) are taken as fundamental units, then dimensional
formula for mass will be
(a) V 2 F0 E (b) V 0 FE2 (c) VF2 E0 (d) V 2 F0 E
Solution : (d) Let M V a Fb Ec
Putting dimensions of each quantities in both side [M ] [LT 1 ]a [MLT 2 ]b [ML2 T 2 ]c
Equating powers of dimensions. We have b c 1, a b 2c 0 and a 2b 2c 0
Solving these equations, a 2, b = 0 and c = 1
So M [V 2 F 0 E]
[L] .[ L3 ][L x ]
[ L]
[ L]
[L] [L3 x ] ; 3 x 1 or x 2
A 2
s u t (1 / 2) a t 2 or y a sin t
cannot be derived by using this theory (try if you can). However, the dimensional
correctness of these can be checked.
(4) The method of dimensions cannot be applied to derive formula if in mechanics a
physical quantity depends on more than 3 physical quantities as then there will be less number
(= 3) of equations than the unknowns (>3). However still we can check correctness of the given
equation dimensionally. For example T 2 1 mgl can not be derived by theory of dimensions
but its dimensional correctness can be checked.
(5) Even if a physical quantity depends on 3 physical quantities, out of which two have
same dimensions, the formula cannot be derived by theory of dimensions, e.g., formula for the
frequency of a tuning fork f (d / L2 ) v cannot be derived by theory of dimensions but can be
checked.
1.13 Significant Figures.
Significant figures in the measured value of a physical quantity tell the number of digits in
which we have confidence. Larger the number of significant figures obtained in a measurement,
greater is the accuracy of the measurement. The reverse is also true.
The following rules are observed in counting the number of significant figures in a given
measured quantity.
(1) All non-zero digits are significant.
Example : 42.3 has three significant figures.
243.4 has four significant figures.
74 Units, Dimensions and Measurement
0.90
(iii) 0.2112676
4.26
Answer = 0.21
1.16 Order of Magnitude.
In scientific notation the numbers are expressed as, Number M 10 x . Where M is a
number lies between 1 and 10 and x is integer. Order of magnitude of quantity is the power of
10 required to represent the quantity. For determining this power, the value of the quantity has
to be rounded off. While rounding off, we ignore the last digit which is less than 5. If the last
digit is 5 or more than five, the preceding digit is increased by one. For example,
(2) Mass of electron 9.1 10 31 kg 10 30 kg (as 9.1 > 5).
In significant figures volume of cube will be 373 .7 m 3 because its side has four significant
figures.
Problem 46. The number of significant figures in 0.007 m 2 is
(a) 1 (b) 2 (c) 3 (d) 4
Solution : (a)
Problem 47. The length, breadth and thickness of a block are measured as 125.5 cm, 5.0 cm and 0.32 cm
respectively. Which one of the following measurements is most accurate
(a) Length (b) Breadth (c) Thickness (d) Height
Solution : (a) Relative error in measurement of length is minimum, so this measurement is most
accurate.
Problem 48. The mass of a box is 2.3 kg. Two marbles of masses 2.15 g and 12.39 g are added to it. The
total mass of the box to the correct number of significant figures is
(a) 2.340 kg (b) 2.3145 kg. (c) 2.3 kg (d) 2.31 kg
Solution : (c) Total mass 2.3 0.00215 0.01239 2.31 kg
Problem 50. Each side of a cube is measured to be 5.402 cm. The total surface area and the volume of
the cube in appropriate significant figures are :
(a) 175.1 cm 2 , 157 cm 2 (b) 175.1 cm 2 , 157.6 cm 3
(c) 175 cm 2 , 157 cm 2 (d) 175.08 cm 2 , 157.639 cm 3
Solution : (b) Total surface area = 6 (5.402)2 175 .09 cm 2 175 .1 cm 2 (Upto correct number of significant
figure)
Total volume (5.402)3 175 .64 cm 3 175.6 cm 3 (Upto correct number of significant figure).
Problem 51. Taking into account the significant figures, what is the value of 9.99 m + 0.0099 m
(a) 10.00 m (b) 10 m (c) 9.9999 m (d) 10.0 m
Solution : (a) 9.99 m 0.0099 m 9.999 m 10 .00 m (In proper significant figures).
Problem 52. The value of the multiplication 3.124 4.576 correct to three significant figures is
(a) 14.295 (b) 14.3 (c) 14.295424 (d) 14.305
Solution : (b) 3 .124 4 .576 14 .295 =14.3 (Correct to three significant figures).
an am an
The absolute errors may be positive in certain cases and negative in certain other cases.
(2) Mean absolute error : It is the arithmetic mean of the magnitudes of absolute errors in
all the measurements of the quantity. It is represented by a. Thus
| a1 | | a 2 | ..... | an |
a
n
Hence the final result of measurement may be written as a am a
This implies that any measurement of the quantity is likely to lie between (am a) and
(am a).
(3) Relative error or Fractional error : The relative error or fractional error of
measurement is defined as the ratio of mean absolute error to the mean value of the quantity
measured. Thus
mean absolute error a
Relative error or Fractional error
mean value am
Note : The quantity which have maximum power must be measured carefully because it's
contribution to error is maximum.
(a) ( b1 c1 d1 e1 )% (b) ( b1 c1 d1 e1 )%
(c) ( b1 c1 d1 e1 )% (d) ( b1 c1 d1 e1 )%
Solution : (d) a b c /d e
a b c d e
100 . 100 . 100 . 100 . 100
a max b c d e
Problem 56. The pressure on a square plate is measured by measuring the force on the plate and the
length of the sides of the plate. If the maximum error in the measurement of force and
length are respectively 4% and 2%, The maximum error in the measurement of pressure is
(a) 1% (b) 2% (c) 6% (d) 8%
F F
Solution : (d) P , so maximum error in pressure (P )
A l2
P F l
100 100 2 100 = 4% + 2 × 2% = 8%
P max F l
Problem 57. The relative density of material of a body is found by weighing it first in air and then in
water. If the weight in air is (5.00 0.05 ) Newton and weight in water is (4.00 0.05)
Newton. Then the relative density along with the maximum permissible percentage error is
(a) 5.0 11% (b) 5.0 1% (c) 5.0 6% (d) 1.25 5%
Solution : (a) Weight in air (5.00 0.05 ) N
5.00 0.05 0 .1
Now relative density with max permissible error 100 5.0 (1 10)%
1.00 5.00 1.00
5 .0 11 %
V
Problem 58. The resistance R = where V= 100 5 volts and i = 10 0.2 amperes. What is the total
i
error in R
5
(a) 5% (b) 7% (c) 5.2% (d) %
2
V R V I 5 0.2
Solution : (b) R 100 100 100 100 100 (5 2)% = 7%
I R max V I 100 10
Problem 59. The period of oscillation of a simple pendulum in the experiment is recorded as 2.63 s, 2.56
s, 2.42 s, 2.71 s and 2.80 s respectively. The average absolute error is
(a) 0.1 s (b) 0.11 s (c) 0.01 s (d) 1.0 s
2.63 2.56 2.42 2.71 2.80
Solution : (b) Average value 2.62 sec
5
Now | T1 | 2.63 2.62 0.01
Problem 60. The length of a cylinder is measured with a meter rod having least count 0.1 cm. Its
diameter is measured with venier calipers having least count 0.01 cm. Given that length is
5.0 cm. and radius is 2.0 cm. The percentage error in the calculated value of the volume
will be
(a) 1% (b) 2% (c) 3% (d) 4%
0 .01 0 .1
2 100 100 (1 2)% = 3 %
2 . 0 5 . 0
Problem 61. In an experiment, the following observation's were recorded : L = 2.820 m, M = 3.00 kg, l =
4 Mg
0.087 cm, Diameter D = 0.041 cm Taking g = 9.81 m / s 2 using the formula , Y= , the
D 2 l
maximum permissible error in Y is
(a) 7.96% (b) 4.56% (c) 6.50% (d) 8.42%
4 MgL Y M g L 2D l
Solution : (c) Y so maximum permissible error in Y = 100 100
D l2
Y M g L D l
1 1 1 1 1
2 100
300 9.81 9820 41 87
0 .065 100 6 .5 %
Problem 62. According to Joule's law of heating, heat produced H I 2 Rt, where I is current, R is
resistance and t is time. If the errors in the measurement of I, R and t are 3%, 4% and 6%
respectively then error in the measurement of H is
(a) 17% (b) 16% (c) 19% (d) 25%
Solution : (b) H I 2 R t
H 2I R t
100 100 (2 3 4 6)% 16 %
H I R t
Problem 63. If there is a positive error of 50% in the measurement of velocity of a body, then the error
in the measurement of kinetic energy is
(a) 25% (b) 50% (c) 100% (d) 125%
82 Units, Dimensions and Measurement
1
Solution : (c) Kinetic energy E mv 2
2
E m 2v
100 100
E m v
v
Here m 0 and 100 50 %
v
E
100 2 50 100 %
E
1
A3B 2
Problem 64. A physical quantity P is given by P= 3
. The quantity which brings in the maximum
C 4 D 2
percentage error in P is
(a) A (b) B (c) C (d) D
Solution : (c) Quantity C has maximum power. So it brings maximum error in P.