Types of Graphs for Data Representation
Types of Graphs for Data Representation
Show Me
the Data
Before You Start Goal
Students will use graphing techniques to visually represent
00:90
Time and Place data.
90 minutes, more if you explore
eBird data Learning Objectives
Indoors 1. Students will be able to correctly identify and describe four
kinds of graphs commonly used in science: pie charts, line
MATERIALS NEEDED graphs, scatter plots, and bar graphs.
Resource Pages 2. Students will be able to draw an appropriate example of a
• “Graphs of Bird Data” handout pie chart, line graph, scatter plot, and bar graph to repre-
• “Graphing My Data” article sent data.
• “The ‘I Wonder’ Kid” handout 3. Students will be able to explain how the four types of graphs
Journal Pages 7–11 are used to represent different kinds of information.
Other Curriculum Components
• None Lesson Outline
1. Introduce graphs.
You Provide
• Graph paper 2. Look at real world graph samples.
• Internet access 3. Discuss choosing the right kind of graph.
4. Generate class graphs.
Getting Ready 5. Become an eBird data sleuth (optional).
• Copy the Reference Guide
articles for each student. 6. Think on Your Own: complete another graph.
• Make a color transparency
or class handouts of “Graphs Conducting the Activity
of Bird Data,” or prepare to
project it for the class. 1. Introduce graphs.
Remind the students that in Investigation 2, they saw ex-
amples of bar graphs in “Amy’s Scientific Report,” and dif-
ferent kinds of graphs in the “Answering Your Scientific
Questions” article. Begin with a class discussion about how
and why people use graphs.
Ask questions such as
• Have you ever made a graph? Why do people make graphs?
• Can you name any types of graphs? (Make sure that bar, line,
and pie/circle graphs have been mentioned.)
• Why do you think that information is often presented in graphs
instead of just in lists or tables? (Graphs visually show relation-
ships between variables.)
17
BirdSleuth: Investigating Evidence Teacher’s Guide
Show Me the Data
2. Look at real world graph samples. REFERENCE PAGE 16
Display an overhead or give each student Graphs of Bird Data
the “Graphs of Bird Data” handout (REFER-
ENCE PAGE 16) that illustrates four kinds Pie Charts
of graphs you will focus on: pie, line, scat- Types of birds we counted this month
sented in each. 80
60
0
Minnesota New York Illinois Indiana
Average Count
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
1/1 2/1 3/1 4/1 5/1 6/1 7/1 8/1 9/1 10/1 11/1 12/1
Scatter Plots
Week Starting on
The effect of temperature on the number
of bird feeder visits in winter
20
15
Number of visits
10
0
0 10 20 30
Temperature (˚C)
16
BirdSleuth: Investigating Evidence Resource Materials Cornell Lab of Ornithology
18
BirdSleuth: Investigating Evidence Teacher’s Guide Cornell Lab of Ornithology
Show Me the Data
3. Discuss choosing the right kind of REFERENCE PAGE 17
graph.
Placeholder
Graphing Mytext
Data
Have students read “Graphing my Data”
(REFERENCE GUIDE PAGES 17–21). You’ve probably heard the phrase, “A picture is worth a thousand words.” A well-made
graph is worth a thousand words—it summarizes your data and might even make it easy to
Review the terms “Independent Vari- see any trends in your data! Graphing is all about showing people your data visually.
There are many kinds of graphs. Not every kind of graph will be best for your data. Deciding
able” and “Dependent Variable” if neces- on what kind of graph to draw, and how to draw it, can require thought—which makes
graphing a fun challenge! Here, you’ll learn about four kinds of graphs and when to use
sary. Discuss ways that different types of each kind.
songbirds
time.
other
showing trends in data. They show WHAT DO YOU THINK? What is the most common kind of bird the students
counted? What kind of bird was seen least often? Approximately what proportion
how much one variable is affected by of birds counted this month were water birds?
another.
• Bar graphs are used to compare two
or more categories of things.
• Line, bar, and scatter plot graphs all
have a dependent variable that is BirdSleuth: Investigating Evidence Resource Materials
17
Scatter Plot
Bar Graph
7
BirdSleuth: Investigating Evidence Investigator’s Journal
19
Cornell Lab of Ornithology BirdSleuth: Investigating Evidence Teacher’s Guide
Show Me the Data
ten responses as part of your assesment. JOURNAL PAGE 8
Name: Date:
ples below). Students should record a sample Question you are trying to answer
graph of each of the four kinds on JOURNAL Title for your graph
Labels for x and y axes (line, bar, and scatterplots)
PAGES 8–10. Scale measurements for x and y axes (line and bar graphs, scatterplots)
Key or legend
20
BirdSleuth: Investigating Evidence Teacher’s Guide Cornell Lab of Ornithology
Show Me the Data
6. Create a key to identify the sections of JOURNAL PAGE 9
the pie chart. Name: Date:
Placeholder
Show Me thetext
Data
Line Graph 2. Line Graph
• Examples to graph: a student’s growth Question to graph
40 5 42
30
6 45
20
7 48
10
8 50
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 0 10 8 52
Age (in years)
10 54
Figure 2: Sample of line graph Table 2: Table of student’s growth
21
Cornell Lab of Ornithology BirdSleuth: Investigating Evidence Teacher’s Guide
Show Me the Data
title should go at the top and describe
the relationship between the variables
represented.
Scatter Plots
Scatter plots are best for showing whether
two variables are correlated.
• Examples to graph: the number of hours
that students spent studying for an exam
versus the grade received (see Figure 3).
• Steps for making a line graph:
1. Collect the data and organize them
in a table with column and row head-
ings (see Table 3).
2. Draw the outline of a graph (a right
angle) on the board to represent the
graph axes.
3. Label the x and y axes of the graph.
Lay out the scales for each axis.
4. Transfer the data to the graph by add-
ing data points.
5. You may choose to draw a best-fit line
through the points if they seem to be
correlated. (This has not been done
in the sample, but it appears there is
a positive correlation between time Hours spent
Student Test score
spent studying and test score.) studying
1 3 80
2 5 90
3 2 75
4 6 80
5 7 84
6 1 55
Effect of Study Time on Test Scores
7 2 64
100
8 0.5 48
90
0 9 1 42
70
10 7 100
Test Score
60
50 11 1.5 81
40
0 12 2.5 82
0
10
13 3.5 82
0 14 4 91
0 2 4 6 8
Hours Spent Studying 15 1.5 61
Figure 3: Sample scatter plot Table 3: Table of study time and associated test score
22
BirdSleuth: Investigating Evidence Teacher’s Guide Cornell Lab of Ornithology
Show Me the Data
6. Decide on a title for the graph. The JOURNAL PAGE 10
title should go at the top and de- Name: Date:
Bar Graph
• Examples to graph: which movies the
students have recently watched, what
pets they own, or which ice cream flavors
are their favorites.
• Steps for making a bar graph:
1. Collect the data and organize them in
a table with column and row head-
ings (see table 4).
2. Draw a right angle on the board to
represent the axes of the graph.
3. Label the x and y axes for the graph.
Lay out the scales for the y-axis and
the categories for the x-axis.
4. Transfer data to the graph by draw-
10
Cornell Lab of Ornithology BirdSleuth: Investigating Evidence Investigator’s Journal
8
6 Dog 6
5 Cat 7
2
Fish 8
0
Dog Cat Fish Rodents Others Rodents 5
Kind of Pet
Others 3
Figure 4: Sample bar graph Table 4: Pets owned by students
23
Cornell Lab of Ornithology BirdSleuth: Investigating Evidence Teacher’s Guide
Show Me the Data
ing bars on the graph.
5. Decide on a title for the graph. The title Teacher Background
should go at the top and describe what ADVANCED INQUIRY OPTIONS
the graph is about. (Taken from Most Wanted Birds:
“Become an eBird Data Sleuth”)
5. Become an eBird Data Sleuth (option-
Open Inquiry
al). Give a copy of the “Questions to Investigate”
We encourage you to complete or begin BIRD- handout (Resource Materials) to each student. Ask
SLEUTH: MOST WANTED BIRDS LESSON each pair of students to explore the question that
interests them the most. You may wish to have
6, “Become an eBird Data Sleuth”
students present what they have found either to
with your students if you have not the whole class, to another group, or in a written
already done so. If you began the report.
lesson, but did not complete either of
the “Advanced Inquiry Options” (page 32 Independent Inquiry
Have each student or pair of students develop
of that unit), consider doing that part at this
a question that they think can be answered using
time (see TEACHER BACKGROUND box the eBird database, then research the answers.
this page, “Advanced Inquiry Options,” for You might specify that they examine either your
information.) classroom’s BirdSleuth eBird data (if you have col-
(BirdSleuth: Most Wanted Birds may be or- lected enough), or all eBird data. Ask students to
dered on the BirdSleuth web site. note any interesting findings as well as the answer
to their question as they work. Students should
Project “The ‘I Wonder’ Kid” overhead (RE- share their findings with another group, with the
SOURCE PAGE 22—note that the students entire class, or in a written report.
were previously introduced to this figure
in the “Kinds of Questions” article on RE-
SOURCE PAGE 4.) Emphasize the “Explore RESOURCE PAGE 22
and Analyze Data” jumping in point on the The “I Wonder” Kid
diagram. To answer these kinds of questions,
students will need to look at data that have
already been collected. The Cornell Lab of
Ornithology’s citizen science databases are a EXPERIMENTAL DESCRIPTIVE
STUDY STUDY
perfect resource. For example, eBird is full of co
nd
I wonder…?
cond
data about the kinds and numbers of birds uct uc
t
ANSWER
sio
YOUR
lu
QUESTION
ily generates graphs of that data. Consider
nc
co
aw
REPORT
en
FINDINGS
th
this resource.
d,
a
re
BirdSleuth modules: BirdSleuth Most Wanted Where will you jump into the process?
Depending on your question, you can enter the process of science at different stages. Look at the
Birds and BirdSleuth: Exploring Bird Behav- dotted arrows to see where this student scientist could jump into the scientific process. Some conduct
their investigations through experimental or descriptive studies, some start by exploring and
“Become an eBird Data Sleuth,” particu- BirdSleuth: Investigating Evidence Resource Materials
24
BirdSleuth: Investigating Evidence Teacher’s Guide Cornell Lab of Ornithology
Show Me the Data
larly the “Advanced Inquiry Options” JOURNAL PAGE 11
(page 32 of that module, see Teacher Name: Date:
• BirdSleuth: Exploring Bird Behavior “Ex- Create a graph and exchange it with another person or group.
the students. Cornell Lab of Ornithology BirdSleuth: Investigating Evidence Investigator’s Journal
25
Cornell Lab of Ornithology BirdSleuth: Investigating Evidence Teacher’s Guide
Show Me the Data
Notes Page
26
BirdSleuth: Investigating Evidence Teacher’s Guide Cornell Lab of Ornithology
Name: Date:
Types of Graphs
After a class discussion about graphs, fill in the reasons for using each type of graph.
Type of
When to Use This Graph
Graph
Pie Chart
Line Graph
Scatter Plot
Bar Graph
7
BirdSleuth: Investigating Evidence Investigator’s Journal
Name: Date:
Follow along with your class to complete an example of a pie chart, line graph, scatter
plot, and bar graph. For each graph remember to include:
1. Pie Chart
Question to graph
8
Cornell Lab of Ornithology BirdSleuth: Investigating Evidence Investigator’s Journal
Name: Date:
Placeholder
Show Me thetext
Data
2. Line Graph
Question to graph
3. Scatter Plot
Question to graph
9
Cornell Lab of Ornithology BirdSleuth: Investigating Evidence Investigator’s Journal
Name: Date:
10
Cornell Lab of Ornithology BirdSleuth: Investigating Evidence Investigator’s Journal
Name: Date:
11
Cornell Lab of Ornithology BirdSleuth: Investigating Evidence Investigator’s Journal
Graphs of Bird Data
Pie Charts
Types of birds we counted this month
songbirds
water birds
shorebirds
birds of prey
other
Bar Graphs
Percentage of feeders visited by
Northern Cardinals in four states
120
80
60
40
Line Graphs 20
0
Group sizes of American Crows in New York state Minnesota New York Illinois Indiana
22 State
20
18
16
14
Average Count
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
1/1 2/1 3/1 4/1 5/1 6/1 7/1 8/1 9/1 10/1 11/1 12/1
Scatter Plots
Week Starting on
The effect of temperature on the number
of bird feeder visits in winter
20
15
Number of visits
10
0
0 10 20 30
Temperature (˚C)
16
BirdSleuth: Investigating Evidence Resource Materials Cornell Lab of Ornithology
Placeholder
Graphing Mytext
Data
You’ve probably heard the phrase, “A picture is worth a thousand words.” A well-made
graph is worth a thousand words—it summarizes your data and might even make it easy to
see any trends in your data! Graphing is all about showing people your data visually.
There are many kinds of graphs. Not every kind of graph will be best for your data. Deciding
on what kind of graph to draw, and how to draw it, can require thought—which makes
graphing a fun challenge! Here, you’ll learn about four kinds of graphs and when to use
each kind.
Pie Charts
• When you can convert data to show percentages, you can use a pie chart.
• Remember that the pieces of a pie together make 100%.
songbirds
water birds
shorebirds
birds of prey
other
Figure 1
WHAT DO YOU THINK? What is the most common kind of bird the students
counted? What kind of bird was seen least often? Approximately what proportion
of birds counted this month were water birds?
17
BirdSleuth: Investigating Evidence Resource Materials
Placeholder
Graphing Mytext
Data
Bar Graphs
• Use a bar graph when there is no connection from one data point to another
(this is called categorical data). For example, a bar graph can be used to present
data from different sites.
In the example in Figure 2, students wanted to know whether Northern Cardinals are seen
at feeders more often in states where the cardinal is the state bird. They hypothesized that
Northern Cardinals would be seen more in states like Illinois and Indiana, where the cardinal
is the state bird, than in states that chose another bird as the state bird, like Minnesota and
New York.
100
80
60
40
20
0
Minnesota New York Illinois Indiana
State
WHAT DO YOU THINK? Was the girls’ hypothesis right? Were Northern
Cardinals reported more often in states that have Northern Cardinal as the
state bird?
18
BirdSleuth: Investigating Evidence Resource Materials Cornell Lab of Ornithology
Placeholder
Graphing Mytext
Data
Line Graphs
• Line graphs are an excellent way to map Dependent and Independent Variables
that are both quantitative (measured with numbers). Unlike a bar graph, the
data are not grouped in categories.
• Line graphs are most useful for showing whether something changes over
time.
• Draw a line through the data points when you have plotted them.
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
1/1 2/1 3/1 4/1 5/1 6/1 7/1 8/1 9/1 10/1 11/1 12/1
Week Starting on
Figure 3: Group sizes of American Crows. From [Link]
WHAT DO YOU THINK? Does the group size of American Crows seem to
change during the year in New York state?
19
Cornell Lab of Ornithology BirdSleuth: Investigating Evidence Resource Materials
Placeholder
Graphing Mytext
Data
Scatter Plots
• Scatter plots show at a glance whether a relationship exists between the
Dependent and Independent Variables.
• Scatter plots are like line graphs in that the Dependent and Independent
Variables are both quantitative, but you don’t draw a line through the data
points.
• You may wish to draw a “line of best fit” between or near the points to show
any correlation or relationship.
Examples
Imagine you wanted to determine whether the availability of food affects the weight of
nestlings. You might imagine that the more insects a mother Eastern Bluebird brings to the
nest in an hour, the heavier her fledglings will be when they leave the nest. The graph in
Figure 4 shows a positive correlation; as one variable goes up, the other does too.
31.5
Weight of fledgling
31
30.5
(in grams)
30
29.5
29
28.5
28
27.5
0 5 10 15 20
Average number of insects provided per hour
WHAT DO YOU THINK? What is the range of weights of these Eastern Bluebird
fledglings? In this sample, about how much does an average flegling weigh?
20
BirdSleuth: Investigating Evidence Resource Materials Cornell Lab of Ornithology
Placeholder
Graphing Mytext
Data
Some researchers have found that when it is snowier or colder, birds visit feeders more
(perhaps because they burn more energy staying warm, or perhaps when it is colder there
is less food available besides seed at feeders, or both). If you graphed this relationship, you
would find a negative correlation; as one variable goes up, the other goes down. See
Figure 5.
15
Number of visits
10
0
0 10 20 30
Temperature (˚C)
Conclusion
After you summarize your data in graphs, you might notice a trend in the data, or you might
find no trend at all. Either will help you draw conclusions about the evidence of data in your
experiment or observational study, and show others what you found, too!
21
Cornell Lab of Ornithology BirdSleuth: Investigating Evidence Resource Materials
The “I Wonder” Kid
EXPERIMENTAL DESCRIPTIVE
STUDY STUDY
I wonder…?
co
cond nd
uct uc
t
explore
DATA
and analyze
t
ou
ab
ns
ANSWER sio
YOUR
lu
QUESTION
nc
co
aw
dr
REPORT
n
he
FINDINGS
,t
ad
re
MORE REFERENCE
QUESTIONS MATERIALS
Figure 1
22
BirdSleuth: Investigating Evidence Resource Materials
The Climate Challenge
This g ame is bas ed on a tr ad it ional bo ard g ame mo del, except it us es
three s epar at e bo ards to help t each part icip ants about t he effects t hat
climate chang e may have on birds. T he game r eq uir es p layers to ass ume
the r ole o f a bird , and then fig ure out how climat e chang e is affecting
their lives in their Food , Habit at, and Migr at ion.
Materials:
• A pr int ed cop y (pr efer ably laminat ed) o f the g ame bo ards (t hree
sheets fo llow these instruct ions).
• So me sort of bird fig ures or to y bir ds that p articip ants can us e to
mo ve across the g ame bo ards- plush birds will work , or even
plain game p ieces if yo u do n’t have any bird -r elat ed fig ures .
• A few s ets of dice ( you may want to enclos e t hes e s ep arat ely in a
small, clear plastic box so that they d on’t get lost ; yo u will only
need one at a t ime).
• A r eward or pr ize o f so me sort for playing.
Optional Materials:
• Poster or chart to k eep track o f how many birds ar e successful in
all t hree ar eas.
Putting It Together:
Att ach the bo ards to a t able with tap e so that they ar e fix ed in one spot .
It do esn’t matt er what ord er yo u put t he game bo ards in!!
Put g ame pieces /bird fig ures in the fr ont ( befor e the bo ards) and then
the p oster wit h r esults so mewhere at the end .
4 5 6
Habitat
1 2 3
Warmer weather There have been no
led to a drought, effects from climate The level of the
which dried up the change here. Your sea is rising, and
wetland where you habitat remains the the salt marsh
normally go to same and you will where you live is
breed. You will not have lots of food slowly flooding.
be able to raise any for your healthy Your habitat is
chicks this year. chicks this year. changing, but you
adapt and raise
healthy baby birds
this year.
4 5 6
Migration
1 2 3
4 5 6