Reinforced Cement Concrete (RCC) arches are structural elements that use the combined action of In structural engineering,
ineering, shells and plates are thin structural
concrete and reinforcement steel to resist loads effectively. RCC arches are commonly used in elements designed to withstand forces through their specific
bridges, buildings, and other infrastructure projects due to their ability to span large areas and geometrical configurations. As per IS 456:2000 (Code of
support substantial loads. Based on IS 456:2000 and related codes like SP 16 (Design Aids for Practice for Reinforced Concrete) and SP 16 (Design Aids for
Reinforced Concrete), RCC arches can be categorized as follows: Reinforced Concrete to IS 456), the structural actions of shells
1. Fixed Arch and plates are distinct but related to their ability to resist loads
Definition: In this type of arch, both ends are fixed or restrained against rotation. efficiently. Below is an explanation of their structural behavior:
Behavior: Fixed supports resist horizontal thrust, vertical loads, and moments, reducing bending 1. Structural Action of Plates
stresses in the arch. A plate is a flat, thin structural element with thickness much
Applications: Bridges and structures requiring stability against heavy lateral forces. smaller than its other dimensions. It primarily resists loads by
Advantages: Minimal deflection and good load-carrying capacity. bending and in-plane forces.
Challenges: Requires strong foundations to resist moments and thrust. Key Characteristics:
2. Two-Hinged Arch Load Transfer: Plates transfer loads perpendicular to their
Definition: This arch has hinges at both supports, allowing rotation at the base but resisting surface (out-of-plane) through bending and shear stresses.
horizontal thrust. Deformation: Plates exhibit bending under transverse loads and
Behavior: More flexible than fixed arches but can still transmit horizontal thrust. in-plane stretching or compression under in-plane forces.
Applications: Medium-span bridges, roof trusses, and shelters. Stress Distribution:
Advantages: Easier to construct and provides good stability. Bending Moments: Lead to tensile and compressive stresses on
Challenges: Slightly more deflection compared to fixed arches. opposite faces.
3. Three-Hinged Arch Shear Stresses: Act parallel to the plate's surface due to
Definition: An additional hinge is provided at the crown (apex), making it statically determinate. transverse loads.
Behavior: The hinge at the crown reduces indeterminate stresses and simplifies analysis. Edge Support:
Applications: Temporary structures, lightweight bridges, and low-load spans. Plates require proper edge conditions (fixed, simply supported,
Advantages: Easy to analyze, flexible, and can tolerate foundation settlements. or free) to resist loads effectively.
Challenges: Lower stiffness and higher deflection under load. The support conditions significantly influence stress
4. Barrel Vault Arch distribution.
Definition: A continuous arch extending in one direction, forming a vault-like structure. Applications:
Behavior: Acts as a series of parallel arches, distributing loads evenly across the span. Floor slabs, roof slabs, bridge decks, and retaining walls.
Applications: Roofs of industrial sheds, auditoriums, and underground structures. 2. Structural Action of Shells
Advantages: Good load distribution and aesthetic appeal. A shell is a curved, thin structural element capable of resisting
Challenges: Complex formwork and higher construction costs. loads through its geometry, resulting in efficient load
5. Parabolic Arch distribution. Unlike plates, shells carry loads primarily through
Definition: The shape of the arch follows a parabolic curve, optimizing it for uniform load membrane forces (tension and compression).
distribution. Key Characteristics:
Behavior: The parabolic profile minimizes bending moments, as the shape closely aligns with the Load Transfer:
moment diagram under uniform loads. Shells resist loads through in-plane forces (axial tension and
Applications: Railway bridges and large-span structures. compression), minimizing bending stresses.
Advantages: Efficient load distribution and reduced material usage. Their curved geometry allows them to distribute loads
Challenges: Precise construction and design. efficiently over the entire surface.
6. Segmental Arch Stress Distribution:
Definition: A segment of a circular arc, less than a semicircle. Membrane stresses (tensile or compressive) dominate in thin
Behavior: This type reduces the rise of the arch, making it suitable for low-profile applications. shells under uniform loads.
Applications: Pedestrian bridges, low-height structures, and decorative features. In thicker shells or under concentrated loads, bending stresses
Advantages: Aesthetic and requires less clearance height. become significant.
Challenges: Higher horizontal thrust compared to a full semicircular arch. Geometry:
7. Flat Arch Curvature enhances structural stiffness and reduces material
Definition: Appears almost flat, with a slight rise to distribute loads. usage.
Behavior: Acts mainly in compression and requires strong abutments to resist horizontal forces. Types of Shells:
Applications: Entrance gates, lintels, and architectural features. 1. Cylindrical Shells: Resist loads through axial compression and
Advantages: Simple construction and visually appealing. hoop tension (e.g., pipes, aqueducts).
Challenges: Limited load-carrying capacity and high thrust. 2. Spherical Shells: Efficient in resisting uniform loads (e.g.,
Design Considerations (As per IS 456 and SP 16): water tanks, domes).
1. Load Analysis: 3. Hyperbolic Paraboloid Shells: Provide high strength-to-
Dead loads, live loads, and environmental factors (wind, seismic loads) must be considered. weight ratios and are used in aesthetic architectural designs.
2. Thrust and Reactions: Applications:
The horizontal thrust and its impact on abutments should be evaluated. Domes, water tanks, roofs of large-span structures (stadiums,
3. Reinforcement: auditoriums), and cooling towers.
Proper placement of steel bars to resist tensile forces, especially at the intrados and extrados. Comparison of Plates and Shells
4. Crack Control:
Ensure crack widths are within permissible limits as per IS 456.
5. Durability:
Consider exposure conditions and use suitable concrete grades and cover thickness.
RCC arches are versatile and efficient structural elements that can be designed for diverse
applications, provided proper analysis and construction techniques are employed.
15. What are the environmental and social impacts of street? Environmental and Social
Impact: Walkability: Well-designed streets encourage walking, contributing to public
health, reducing traffic congestion, and lowering carbon emissions. Social
Interaction: Streets that are designed to be attractive and accessible foster community
interaction and social cohesion. Sustainability: Incorporating green infrastructure,
promoting non-motorized transportation, and managing storm water are ways that
streets contribute to urban sustainability. 16. What are challenges in designing streets?
Balancing Uses: Ensuring that streets serve multiple purposes— transportation,
commerce, social interaction—without prioritizing one at the expense of others.
Traffic Management: Designing streets that effectively manage traffic flow while
ensuring safety for all users. Accessibility: Making streets accessible to everyone,
including people with disabilities, requires careful consideration of design features
such as curb cuts, tactile paving, and ramps. Climate Adaptation: Streets need to be
designed to cope with climate- related challenges such as flooding, extreme heat, and
changing weather patterns. 17. What are the key aspects of expressive quality in built
forms? Form and Shape: Geometry: The shape of a building can convey different
meanings. For instance, angular forms may evoke strength and stability, while curved
forms can suggest fluidity and movement. Complexity vs. Simplicity: Simple forms
may communicate clarity and purity, whereas complex forms can express dynamism
and richness. Symbolism: Certain shapes have symbolic meanings (e.g., a dome might
symbolize unity and eternity, a spire might represent aspiration Scale and Proportion:
Human Scale: Buildings designed with human scale in mind create a sense of comfort
and accessibility, while monumental scale can evoke awe and grandeur. Proportion:
Harmonious proportions can create a sense of balance and order, while exaggerated
proportions Material and Texture: Material Choices: The choice of materials (e.g.,
wood, stone, glass, steel) significantly impacts the expressive quality of a building.
Natural materials might evoke warmth and tradition, while modern materials like glass
and steel can express innovation and transparency. Texture: The texture of surfaces
contributes to the tactile experience of a building. Rough textures might evoke a sense
of ruggedness or age, while smooth textures can suggest sleekness and modernity.
Color: Emotional Impact: Color has a profound effect on the mood and atmosphere
of a space. Warm colors (reds, yellows) can create a sense of warmth and energy, while
cool colors (blues, greens) can evoke calmness and tranquility. Symbolism and
Identity: Colors can also carry cultural and symbolic meanings (e.g., white for purity,
red for power) and are often used to reinforce the identity or purpose of a building.
Light and Shadow: Illumination: The way light interacts with a building’s surfaces can
dramatically alter its appearance and mood. Natural light can enhance the sense of
openness and connection to the environment, while artificial lighting can be used to
highlight specific features or create different atmospheres. Shadow Play: Shadows
cast by architectural elements can add depth, drama, and a sense of time to a building,
emphasizing its form and texture.