Air Quality Impact Assessment at Cairo Airport
Air Quality Impact Assessment at Cairo Airport
Appendix 2 Part 2
OPERATIONAL IMPACTS:
AIR QUALITY IMPACT ASSESSMENT
I. INTRODUCTION
Air Pollution Dispersion Modeling
Air Pollution Dispersion Modeling is the mathematical simulation of how air
pollutants disperse in the ambient atmosphere. The task is performed with computer
programs that solve the mathematical equations and algorithms which simulate the
pollutant dispersion. The dispersion models are used to predict the downwind
concentration of air pollutants emitted from sources such as industrial plants and
vehicular traffic. Such models are important to governmental agencies responsible for
protecting and managing the ambient air quality. The models are typically employed
to determine whether existing or proposed new industrial facilities are or will be in
compliance with the National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS).
There are no specific standards for air quality at roadside areas but there are Limit
Values for ambient air, which are given in the Executive Regulations of the
Environmental Law no. 4 of Egypt. These Air Quality Limit Values should be
achieved to avoid health risks due to higher concentrations of the first priority
pollutants. These pollutants and their Limit Values are presented in the following
table.
Table (1): Ambient Air Quality Limit values as given by Law no.4 for Egypt
(1994) compared to the World Health Organization (WHO) air quality guideline
values
Pollutant Averaging Maximum Limit Value
time
WHO Egypt
(SO2) 1 hour 500 (10 min) 350
24 hours 125 150
Year 50 60
(NO2) 1 hour 200 400
24 hours - 150
Year 40-50
(O3) 1 hour 150-200 200
8 hours 120 120
(CO) 1 hour 30 000 30 000
8 hours 10 000 10 000
(BS) 24 hours 50 * 150
Year - 60
(TSP) 24 hours - 230
Year - 90
(PM10) 24 hours 70 ** 150
Year 70
Lead (Pb) Year 0.5-1,0 1
* Together with SO2
** Norwegian Air Quality Limit value
II. OBJECTIVE
The objective of the air dispersion simulation modeling is to model the worst-case-
scenario based on the baseline scenario surveyed in order to test and introduce air
dispersion modeling as an effective tool in environmental planning and management
in the Cairo Airport region.
III. METHODOLOGY
The approach and methodology to the development of the simulation is as follows:
1. Selection of the modeling tools for the meteorology model and preparing the
downscaled model for one year.
2. Building an interface between the meteorology model and the dispersion
model.
3. Preparing the input data in the compatible format for input to the model.
4. Conducting several test runs for tuning the model.
5. Running the simulated scenarios.
The SCREEN3 Modeling software package is applied to our study to determine the
preliminary air quality impact results. It is then validated and verified using
AERMOD package to attain the final predicted air quality impacts of the study.
However, its main purpose is to account for the relative locations of the stack and the
building causing downwash, which is not accounted for in the original ISC or early
version of AERMOD.
The AERMOD modeling system has 3 components: AERMOD - the air dispersion
model; AERMET - the meteorological data preprocessor; and AERMAP - the terrain
data preprocessor.
Define Projection Import Base Map Set Control Options Define Sources
(Recommended) (Optional) (Recommended) (Required)
Process Buildings
Define Buildings Define Receptors Group Sources
(BPIP)
(Optional) (Required) (Optional)
(Optional)
Fig. 1: Data Input Flow for AERMOD. There are alternative methods for
entering data.
Air pollution at Cairo Airport comes from a wide variety of sources. The most
significant are:
In cities across the globe, the personal automobile is the single greatest polluter, as
emissions from a billion vehicles on the road add up to a planet-wide problem.
Driving a private car is a typical citizen's most harmful activity causing air pollution.
The negative health effects of automotive emissions are incurred when you sit in
traffic surrounded by cars with idling engines. Everyone in a traffic jam is getting
poisoned.
Hydrocarbons react in the presence of nitrogen oxides and sunlight to form ground-
level ozone, a major component of smog. Ozone irritates the eyes, damages the lungs,
and aggravates respiratory problems. A number of exhaust hydrocarbons are also
toxic, some with the potential to cause cancer.
Generally, hourly emissions from Nitrogen dioxide (NO2), Carbon Monoxide (CO),
and Hydrocarbons (HC) are considered the main emissions, and higher levels can
often be the result of increased airport vehicular traffic.
NCEP broadcasts global model outputs as girded data to be used for initial and
boundary conditions by World Area Forecast centers WAFS. The WAFS’s horizontal
resolution is 1.25o in latitude and longitude (at Equator) on 12 standard vertical
pressure levels. In addition, WAFS provide meteorological data files within the
AERMOD software package.
The air quality assessment is based on data produced and collected from the already
installed air quality monitoring stations at Hall-4 and TB-2, in addition to the
emission and dispersion modeling (AerMod plus, Version 7.01). The objective of the
study was to collect the necessary input data, perform dispersion modeling and
present the future air quality data as a result of the proposed development for TB2
complex at Cairo Airport.
The already existing air quality monitoring stations of Hall-4 and TB-2 are classified
as the Hall-4 station represents the upwind station for the Cairo Airport region and
TB-2 Station represents the downwind station for the Cairo Airport region (Fig. 2).
Fig. 2: Location Map of the Air Quality Monitoring Stations at Cairo Airport.
The prevailing wind direction over the greater Cairo area is from the north. At the
Cairo International Airport area, north-north-westerly winds are dominant in the
summer months, while southerly and westerly winds also prevail in the winter
months, directing pollution from the airport away from the city (Figs. 3, 4, 5 & 6).
As demonstrated, the airport is upwind from the major air pollution sources in Cairo,
and the air quality in this area will thus be fairly clean compared to the high
concentrations of air pollutants in other parts of the city. Due to its geographic
location, the airport has a minimum significant impact on the surrounding residential
areas.
Fig. 5: A map showing the prevailing wind direction during summer season.
Scale
0 625 1250 1875 2500 m
Fig. 6: A map showing the prevailing wind direction during winter season.
The following climate summary data is obtained from the Egyptian Meteorological
Authority bulletin based on 30 years of observations at Cairo Airport station located
at the beginning of E3-1.
Temperature:
The warmest months of the year are June, July and August, which experience
a mean daily maximum temperature of 34.0°C, 35.5°C and 35.4°C
respectively and a mean daily minimum temperature of 20.5°C, 22.3°C and
22.6°C respectively. December, January and February are the coolest months
experiencing daily maximum temperature of 22.1°C, 20.2°C and 21.6°C
respectively and a mean daily minimum temperature of 10.8°C, 9.7°C and
9.8°C respectively.
Humidity:
Relative humidity peaks in November and decreases as the summer months
approach. The 12 p.m. relative humidity readings are lower than the 06 a.m.
readings throughout the year. The 9 a.m. relative humidity has an average
annual range of approximately 68% with a minimum of 59% in May and a
maximum of 80% in November. Similarly, a minimum 12 p.m. relative
Rainfall:
December and January are the wettest months of the year, receiving a mean
monthly rainfall of 6.0mm and 5.9mm respectively. Summer Months are dry
having zero rainfall amounts.
V. INPUT REQUIREMENTS
V-1. Emissions Data
Updating and modernizing of TB2 will increase the airport's capacity. Subsequent
growth in airport traffic will result in an increase in the airport's vehicular traffic, thus
affecting the performance of both the airport itself (in terms of available parking
spaces and entrance/exit gate capacities) and the main access roads.
As for the surrounding road infrastructure, the Consultants' analysis reveals that the
airport access routes will operate at lower levels of service after year 2020, due to the
combined effect of increased airport and background traffic. Given the considerable
future demographic and economical developments of the region (as estimated in the
Greater Cairo Transportation Master Plan prepared under the authority of the Ministry
of Transport) and the resulting increase in background traffic volumes (which account
for the majority of traffic on the access roads), the incremental increase traffic volume
on the main access roads as a result of the additional airport traffic would be
limited to a maximum of 7 percent of the total traffic flow.
All the collected data of NOx, CO and HC from the already existing air quality
monitoring stations of Hall-4 and TB-2 are QA/QC controlled, validated, verified
manually and compared with international values and are listed on the following table
(Figs. 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 & 12) because these pollution parameters represent the most
exhausted pollutants from increases in vehicular and aircraft activities.
100
Concentration (ug/m3)
80
60
40
20
0
8/1/08 0:00
8/7/08 0:00
8/13/08 0:00
8/19/08 0:00
8/25/08 0:00
8/31/08 0:00
9/6/08 0:00
9/12/08 0:00
9/18/08 0:00
9/24/08 0:00
9/30/08 0:00
10/6/08 0:00
10/12/08 0:00
10/18/08 0:00
10/24/08 0:00
10/30/08 0:00
11/5/08 0:00
11/11/08 0:00
11/17/08 0:00
11/23/08 0:00
11/29/08 0:00
12/5/08 0:00
12/11/08 0:00
12/17/08 0:00
12/23/08 0:00
12/29/08 0:00
Time
Time
Time
10/18/08 0:00 10/18/08 0:00
10/12/08 0:00 10/12/08 0:00
10/6/08 0:00 10/6/08 0:00
9/30/08 0:00 9/30/08 0:00
9/24/08 0:00 9/24/08 0:00
9/18/08 0:00 9/18/08 0:00
9/12/08 0:00 9/12/08 0:00
9/6/08 0:00 9/6/08 0:00
8/31/08 0:00 8/31/08 0:00
8/25/08 0:00 8/25/08 0:00
8/19/08 0:00 8/19/08 0:00
8/13/08 0:00 8/13/08 0:00
8/7/08 0:00 8/7/08 0:00
Consultant Office
260
240
220
200
180
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
Concentration (ug/m3) Concentration (ug/m3)
14
Monitoring Station of Hall-4 from 1 August 2008 to 31 December 2008.
12/29/08 0:00 Fig. 10: One-Hour Average Concentrations of NO2 Measured at Air Quality 12/29/08 0:00
12/23/08 0:00 12/23/08 0:00
12/17/08 0:00 12/17/08 0:00
12/11/08 0:00 12/11/08 0:00
12/5/08 0:00 12/5/08 0:00
11/29/08 0:00 11/29/08 0:00
11/23/08 0:00 11/23/08 0:00
11/17/08 0:00 11/17/08 0:00
11/11/08 0:00 11/11/08 0:00
Time
Time
10/18/08 0:00 10/18/08 0:00
10/12/08 0:00 10/12/08 0:00
10/6/08 0:00 10/6/08 0:00
9/30/08 0:00 9/30/08 0:00
9/24/08 0:00 9/24/08 0:00
9/18/08 0:00 9/18/08 0:00
9/12/08 0:00 9/12/08 0:00
9/6/08 0:00 9/6/08 0:00
8/31/08 0:00 8/31/08 0:00
8/25/08 0:00
8/25/08 0:00
8/19/08 0:00
8/19/08 0:00
8/13/08 0:00
8/13/08 0:00
8/7/08 0:00
Consultant Office
8/7/08 0:00
8/1/08 0:00
8/1/08 0:00
200
150
100
50
20
18
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
Concentration (ug/m3) Concentration (mg/m3)
Consultant Office
12.0
10.0
Concentration (mg/m3)
8.0
6.0
4.0
2.0
0.0
8/1/08 0:00
8/7/08 0:00
8/13/08 0:00
8/19/08 0:00
8/25/08 0:00
8/31/08 0:00
9/6/08 0:00
9/12/08 0:00
9/18/08 0:00
9/24/08 0:00
9/30/08 0:00
10/6/08 0:00
10/12/08 0:00
10/18/08 0:00
10/24/08 0:00
10/30/08 0:00
11/5/08 0:00
11/11/08 0:00
11/17/08 0:00
11/23/08 0:00
11/29/08 0:00
12/5/08 0:00
12/11/08 0:00
12/17/08 0:00
12/23/08 0:00
12/29/08 0:00
Time
The following contour maps reflect the current situation of distribution and levels of
the previously mentioned gaseous pollutants that can be affected by the increase of
traffic flow of vehicles and aircraft (NO2, CO and HC) (Figs. 13, 14 & 15).
Fig. 13: A contour map showing the levels of maximum one-hour average
Carbon Monoxide (CO) all over Cairo Airport Area.
Fig. 14: A contour map showing the levels of maximum one-hour average NO2
all over Cairo Airport Area.
Fig. 15: A contour map showing the levels of maximum one-hour average Total
Hydrocarbons (HC) all over Cairo Airport Area.
Updating and modernizing of TB2 will increase the airport's capacity. Subsequent
growth in airport traffic will result in an increase in the airport's vehicular traffic, thus
affecting the performance of both the airport itself (in terms of available parking
spaces and entrance/exit gate capacities) and the main access roads.
The Consultants' estimates of future parking demand and entry/exit vehicular facilities
fall broadly within the proposed capacity of the new project. Estimates of entry/exit
flows show that the new design of the car parks and entrance/exit gates will be
sufficient to accommodate the forecast future traffic by the year 2025.
Ring Road is an east-west main arterial road in the Greater Cairo Urban Area. It starts
from Corniche El Nile (from Giza Governorate), extends until the Abbasia area, and
ends at Cairo Airport. The total length of this road is approximately 23Km.
Major construction has been done on a new road connecting TB1, TB2, and TB3 to
the circular road of Cairo, which we believe will have a great effect on the road
network around Cairo airport as shown in the following figure.
• Two peaks are observed on El Nasr Road: a morning peak (during hour
10:00), and an afternoon peak (during hour 17:00).
Public Transport
Public transport to and from Cairo Airport includes unscheduled taxis, limousines,
minibuses, and various scheduled bus, some are owned by private operators, and the
others by public agencies. A summary of these public transport services is presented
in the following Table. A central bus station exists next to TB1 Car Park, while part of
TB2 Car Park is reserved for public transport and taxi vehicles.
So, the expected number of passengers that will enter the Cairo Airport Area is 11,000
passenger/day. This total number of passengers will be distributed for the public
transportation vehicles (Shuttle buses) and private cars. For the worst case scenario, it
is assumed the total increase in traffic flow is 5000vehicle/day and 36 aircraft daily.
The previous assumptions are verified by the daily present traffic flow for the Cairo
Airport area as 18,000. The current total capacity of all terminals is 15 million
passengers per year. If the capacity is increased to 19 million passengers per year, the
expected increase of daily traffic flow for the Cairo airport area is 4800 vehicles/day.
Therefore, the expected and predicted NO2 concentration estimates resulting from
emissions of road traffic and aircraft operations due to increasing and enlarging the
capacity of traffic movements as a result of the additional airport traffic would be
limited to a maximum of 7 percent of the total traffic flow from vehicles and aircrafts.
The concentrations in the maximum impact area resulting from all sources linked to
the future development and modernization of TB2 Cairo Airport scenario are
estimated to be approximately 88-90µg/m3 as a one-hour average. The highest
concentrations will occur along the road system and close to the terminal buildings.
At the end of the runways the average concentrations of NO2 may reach 33-35µg/m3
but these concentrations will diminish quickly with distance, i.e. at only a few
hundred meters away from the runways and from the terminal building.
The international standards, as well as the AQL values given in Law No. 4, are 400
µg/m3 as a one-hour average. None of these AQL values will be exceeded due to
emissions from airport activities alone, especially at a distance of about 3 km from the
airport facilities (runways and terminal).
Scale
0 800 1600 2400 3200 m
(a)
(b)
Fig. 16: (a) Predicted Maximum One-hour Average NO2 Concentration
Distributions Estimated in the Airport as a Result of Emissions from
Airport Activities – Aircraft and Vehicles (µg/m3) and (b) Utilized grid
interval for contouring.
At peak hour, based at the time when international flight activity is at its highest and
the road traffic is peaking, CO concentrations inside the loading zone as well as
between the terminal buildings and the aircraft taxiing areas, will reach levels close to
or above international limit values of 30 mg/m3.
None of these AQL values will be exceeded due to emissions from airport activities
alone and it should be noted that at a distance of about 3 km from the airport facilities
(runways and terminal) the CO concentrations would be less than 2.7 mg/m3 during
the concentration peak hour.
Scale
0 800 1600 2400 3200 m
(a)
(b)
Fig. 17: (a) Predicted Maximum One-hour Average CO Concentration
Distributions Estimated in the Airport as a Result of Emissions from Airport
Activities – Aircraft and Vehicles (mg/m3) and (b) Utilized grid interval for
contouring.
The highest HC concentrations as a seasonal average are found near parking area and
at idling mode. The maximum one-hour average concentration levels are
approximately 180 µg/m3, which are due to cars in the parking area and at idling
mode, with some contribution from aircraft likely. The highest short-term
concentration of HC is estimated at about 4mg/m^3 near the terminal area.
Scale
0 800 1600 2400 3200 m
(a)
(b)
Fig. 18: (a) Predicted Maximum One-hour Average HC Concentration
Distributions Estimated in the Airport as a Result of Emissions from Airport
Activities – Aircraft and Vehicles (µg/m3) and (b) Utilized grid interval for
contouring.
The results indicated that the contribution from Cairo Airport on local and regional air
quality is very small and insignificant.
However, cumulative impacts from the contributions from other sources in the north-
eastern Cairo area may lead to impacts that will affect the population's exposure and
well being, giving rise to undesirable effects. There is no simple mitigation for these
types of impacts. The best form of mitigation from the point of view of Cairo Airport
would be to offer alternative forms of transportation to and from the airport to reduce
the dependency on private car usage, and enforce short term parking time zones
outside the terminal buildings to reduce idling time to a minimum.