Case Analysis Grading Rubric (100 Points)
CRITERIA Outstanding Above Average Satisfactory Insufficient
Analysis Throughout the Throughout most Throughout much Throughout little
whole work of the work of the work to none of the
35 pts
work
29-35 pts 22-28 pts 15-21 pts
• the analysis examines, summarizes, and
0-7 pts
integrates issue(s) to reveal insight
• evidence is well organized with smooth
transitions
Support Throughout the Throughout most Throughout a Throughout little
whole work of the work much of the work to none of the
35 pts
work
29-35 pts 22-28 pts 15-21 pts
• claims are supported with detailed and
0-7 pts
persuasive examples
• the analysis incorporates required and
additional resources, when necessary
Conclusions Throughout the Throughout most Throughout a Throughout little
whole work, of the work, much of the work, to none of the
20 pts
conclusions conclusions conclusions work, conclusions
• logically extrapolate inquiry findings
17-20 pts 13-16 pts 9-12 pts 0-3 pts
• demonstrate relevant and wide-ranging
research that supports analytical
reasoning in response to case study
questions
CRITERIA Outstanding Above Average Satisfactory Insufficient
Grammar, Mechanics, and Style Throughout the Throughout most Throughout a Throughout little
whole work, of the work, text much of the work, to none of the
10 pts
text text work, text
7-8 pts
• demonstrates good writing skill, following
9-10 pts 5-6 pts 0-2 pts
correct APA style
• is free of major errors in grammar,
spelling, syntax, and citation (where
applicable)
• is clear and concise
• demonstrates strong word choice and
sentence variety