● Introduction
Online learning has both positively and negatively affected the way students collaborate.
There is the consideration that students can work together and communicate via digital
means, no matter where they are, which is good for group work in less group work driven
environments. Tools that enable the students to collaborate in real time and asynchronously,
including discussion boards, video conferencing, and shared documents. However, not
connecting in person might slow the development of key collaborative skills such as group
dynamics, communication, and conflict resolution. Additionally, the digital divide or
technological barriers could hinder the effectiveness of virtual collaboration, as it could
complicate equitable student engagement with collaborative work.
● Problem description
The lack of in person interactions in an eclass makes it harder to build trust and to foster
collaboration. Participation in and access to technology are further unequal. Therefore,
students would not be able to build essential cooperation skills that they need to survive in
real world collaborative environments.
Background/context of the problem
The pandemic has quickly pushed students to online learning, which has hindered student
collaboration and teamwork. Once face-to-face interaction was lost, trust and the ability to
form effective teams were more difficult to build. Kalmar et al. (2022) noticed that the
absence of this increased the necessity to intentionally do social work, but the digital tools
most of the time hampered the communication—the teamwork and teamwork development
became more difficult to be performed and less effective with regard to developing skills for
'being part of a team'.
Causes of the Problem
Face to face interaction is one of the biggest challenges in online learning because it
blocks the formation of trust and strong personal relationships, the things that make
online working teamwork well. With no in person communication students may fall
into a place of disengagement and accountability (Herriott & McNulty, 2022). In
addition, technological barriers, including poor connectivity and painful usability of
the platform, could disrupt collaboration and create imbalance, for instance among
students with limited access to technology (Bui et al., 2021). In addition, student
engagement and motivation though vary, can impact their participation in online
settings. Oyarzun & Martin (2023) point to the fact that asynchronous learning and
the lack of physical presence means uneven contributions followed by dysfunctional
group dynamics.
Opportunities for Enhancing Teamwork Skills
Online education has its own challenges but, at the same time, is also
about massive possibilities to develop teamwork skills. The big advantage
of virtual environments is that they give you a lot of collaboration tools. This
allows us students to work in real time or individually at our own
convenience. Google Docs, Zoom, and Microsoft Teams are just a few of
the tools that help students collaborate on documents. In their review, Song
and Elftman (2024) point out how all of these can facilitate communication
and coordination. When students use these tools, they will be able to
improve their digital literacy and strengthen their capacity for working in a
‘virtual’ environment.
Flexibility in team composition and collaboration timelines is another benefit
of online learning. The students will form teams around their
complementary strengths. The ability to work asynchronously gives team
members an option to complete their work at their own pace. This flexibility
accommodates a variety of learning styles and time zones (Gaad, 2022),
and thereby it becomes conducive to being a more inclusive team working
environment. For students who struggle, working individually provides an
opportunity to fully participate in group activities.
In addition, the internationalisation of cooperation in online learning helps to
increase the range of viewpoints and cultures available to students.
Through virtual group projects and world-class classrooms, students work
together with people from other countries to strengthen cultural
understanding and communication skills (Alsayer, 2023). Undergoing this
practice of exposure to global perspectives is crucial for enabling a
pluralistic mind and developing students' intercultural competence. In our
interconnected world, this is an important skill.
Effective Strategies for Promoting Collaboration
To the fullest benefit of online collaboration some strategies can be applied to overcome
problems to promote teamwork. One approach, for example, is to use peer feedback
mechanisms. In particular, research supports the idea that peer feedback can spur more
accountability and enhance team work by allowing students to self and co reflect on their
own and their teammates' work (Kalmar et al., 2022). The more aware students are that their
work is being assessed by other students the more they are likely to pay attention; they will
also contribute more to the group goals.
Facilitation encourages your collaboration by guiding communication, resolving conflicts and
keeping everyone on an equal footing. Instructor check ins and feedback allow students to
stay on track and service any issues before they enter crisis (Hidayatullah & Setiawan,
2024). Encouraging an environment for collaborative learning allows the instructors to assist
the students in mastering the skills to perform well in multiple group areas, virtual and
physical working environments.
Another effective way to get online collaboration is with structured group activities. Students
know what they’re doing, what’s expected of them, and they have clear goals. A group work
framework provides the structure for understanding the responsibilities of group members
and for collaboration. To monitor the progress and make sure that deadlines are met, we can
use shared calendars, task management software or collaboration platform (Rosman, 2023).
Comparative Analysis of Online vs. Traditional Collaboration
There are so many ways to utilize the online aspect of working together, but at the
same time, there has to be some way to compensate for the weaknesses in order to
have a good team. One key strategy is incorporating peer feedback mechanisms.
With all the constant peer evluations, everyone is responsible and everyone knows
exactly how they're doing in the aspect of being a team [Link] feedback is
another strategy that promotes accountability and improves teamwork skills.
According to Oyarzun and Martin (2023), peer reviews allow students to assess each
other’s contributions and provide constructive feedback. However, this process may
introduce biases or conflict if not managed carefully.
And the other is the teacher's part, that is a big portion in facilitating teamwork is also
crucial. The role of instructors in facilitating teamwork is also crucial. Herriott and
McNulty (2022) emphasize that instructors can play an active role in fostering
collaborative learning by setting clear expectations, moderating discussions, and
providing timely feedback. However, they face challenges in offering individualized
support, especially in large courses.
Structured group activities are another important strategy. Clearly stated rules and
set assignments help the students stay focused, and be sure of what they are
suppose to do and what they are working for. When there are set assignments with
due dates and a definite flow of work, there is structure, and structure allows for
productivity. But structured asignments can stifle the creativity and flexibility of the
student so there must be some sort of balance (Song Elftman, 2024).
Recommendations for Improving Online Collaboration
In the online world, teachers and students alike must adjust to different
methods and means of working together. It is imperative that teachers give
explicit directions, establish expectations, and utilize cooperative
technology like shared documents and and communication platforms is
essential. Continual checking and feedback will also help keep the students
on the right path and interested. But this active process takes so much
time, especially in big classes (Lu Smiles, 2022).
Students must learn to take the initiative and communicate openly, and
provide peer feedback in order to work as a successful team. Active
participation and responsibility for one's contributions help build stronger
collaboration skills. On the other hand, some students might find it difficult
to take on the added responsibility and self-management that online
learning entails (Thi, Bui Phu Hung, Huong, 2023). Teachers can do their
part by providing direction and a helping to establish a helpful online
community. By combining clear expectations, digital tools, and active
participation, both educators and students can improve online collaboration
outcomes.
The transition from traditional face-to-face collaboration to online teamwork has introduced
both challenges and opportunities for students and educators. While online collaboration
offers flexibility and accessibility, it lacks the immediacy and richness of in-person
interactions, which can hinder the development of trust and effective communication. Hybrid
models, combining the benefits of both online and traditional collaboration, offer a potential
solution, though they may not always be practical. Collecting and analyzing student
testimonials can further inform strategies for improving online collaboration, ensuring that it
meets the needs of all participants. Ultimately, by understanding the experiential differences
between online and traditional collaboration, educators can design more effective learning
environments that foster teamwork and enhance student success.
References
Alsayer, A. A. (2023). Learners’ Experiences in an Online Learning Environment: An
Analysis of the Impact of International Collaboration. SAGE Open, 13(4).
[Link]
Bui, T. X. T., Ha, Y. N., Nguyen, T. B. U., Nguyen, V. U. T., & Ngo, T. C. T. (2021).
A Study on Collaborative Online Learning among EFL Students in Van Lang
University (VLU). AsiaCALL Online Journal, 12(3), 9–21.
[Link]
Chen, M.-J., She, H.-C., & Tsai, P.-Y. (2024). The effects of online simulation-based
collaborative problem-solving on students’ problem-solving, communication and
collaboration attitudes. Education and Information Technologies, 29.
[Link]
Gaad, A. L. (2022, December 4). The Effects of Online Collaborative Learning
(OCL) on Student Achievement and Engagement. The International Academic Forum
(IAFOR). [Link]
article-2/
Herriott, H. L., & McNulty, M. A. (2022). Virtual learning impacts communication
and teamwork. The Clinical Teacher, 19(5). [Link]
Hidayatullah, & Setiawan, B. (2024). Empowering students’ collaborative skills
sustainability by utilizing problem-based learning as an instructional strategy in online
learning. Cogent Education, 11(1). [Link]
Kalmar, E., Aarts, T., Bosman, E., Ford, C., de Kluijver, L., Beets, J., Veldkamp, L.,
Timmers, P., Besseling, D., Koopman, J., Fan, C., Berrevoets, E., Trotsenburg, M.,
Maton, L., van Remundt, J., Sari, E., Omar, L.-W., Beinema, E., Winkel, R., & van
der Sanden, M. (2022). The COVID-19 paradox of online collaborative education:
when you cannot physically meet, you need more social interactions. Heliyon, 8(1),
e08823. [Link]
Oyarzun, B., & Martin, F. (2023). A Systematic Review of Research on Online
Learner Collaboration from 2012–21: Collaboration Technologies, Design,
Facilitation, and Outcomes. Online Learning, 27(1).
[Link]
Rosman, S. (2023, July 17). Strategies for Online Education: Collaborative Work &
Discussions. SpatialChat Center. [Link]
for-fostering-collaboration-work-and-discussions/
S. Lu, H., & Smiles, R. (2022). The Role of Collaborative Learning in the Online
Education. International Journal of Economics, Business and Management Research,
06(06), 125–137. [Link]
Song, X., & Elftman, M. (2024). Beyond Collaborative Learning: a Comparison of
Small Groups in Face-to-Face and Online Settings. Medical Science Educator, 34.
[Link]
Thi, C., Bui Phu Hung, & Huong, T. (2023). Impacts of online collaborative learning
on students’ intercultural communication apprehension and intercultural
communicative competence. Education and Information Technologies, 29.
[Link]