0% found this document useful (0 votes)
11 views2 pages

Types of Gifted and Talented Students

Uploaded by

Craig Sheehan
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
11 views2 pages

Types of Gifted and Talented Students

Uploaded by

Craig Sheehan
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

Craig Sheehan

Gifted Vs Talented

The first thing I have to address before talking about this topic is what are the differences

between gifted and talented students. Well gifted students have the potential to be great at

something if they work at it, while talented students naturally have a skill that is above average.

Personally I believe that in the music world this situation plays out itself. Typically what will end

up happening in high school programs is the division of the music program into different levels

of ensembles. Naturally this ends up separating many of the talented and gifted students who

work who work hard from the average students, or gifted students who have not reached their

potential yet. In a middle level ensemble with gifted and talented students the best way to

accommodate both of their musical needs is to simply pick music that is in the middle of the

difficulty repertoire for your ensemble. This allows for the gifted and talented students in your

program are challenged. The talented students will be challenged because they will want to be

the “hero”. You basically will end up having to challenge them to blend with the rest of the

ensemble, while the gifted students will either be self motivated, or you will have to motivate

them. There are a couple ways to motivate gifted students. One way is simply having playing

tests, this mainly plays on the fact that no one wants to be embarrassed in front of their peers,

so they will end up practicing even if it is for 10 minutes, it will eventually build up to longer

periods of time once they see that the practice pays off. Another way to do this by placing some

kind of incentive, and if the students work hard and fulfil it they get the award. In the music field

it can be difficult to explain to students why music is worth it. Many of them may perceive music

as a privilege, and not as a basic necessity of a healthy human being. The best way to get

students to realize music is important is simply by pointing out the fact that when they do
something really well that something has shifted in the classroom. A sense of accomplishment

spreads around the classroom and that really helps with student self-worth. The best way to

encourage a high level of student and teacher relationships is simply by the teacher putting in

the effort to get to know every single student. This will show the students that the teacher does

care, and it will encourage the students to begin to form positive relationships with said teacher.

Personally I believe that gifted students are overrepresented in high school dropout rates mainly

due to the fact that teachers do not believe that they will achieve greatness. The teacher has to

encourage the student constantly to work hard, and eventually the student will. When that does

not happen the student will tend to dropout. It is never the students fault. Most of the time

negligent teachers are to blame.

Common questions

Powered by AI

Gifted students tend to drop out at higher rates because teachers often do not believe in their potential greatness and fail to encourage them consistently. This lack of belief and support can lead to disengagement. Conversely, when the teacher commits to motivating and supporting the student, the risk of dropout is reduced. Therefore, teacher negligence, rather than student aptitude, is largely to blame for higher dropout rates among gifted students .

Accomplishment in music classes can greatly enhance a student's overall academic experience by boosting self-esteem, fostering resilience, and encouraging the pursuit of excellence in other areas. This emotional positivity can translate into greater academic engagement and personal development, cultivating a sense of self-worth and reinforcing the skills of discipline and perseverance, which are valuable across educational domains .

Blending gifted and talented students in a music program can create a dynamic learning environment that encourages individual growth and collaborative learning. Talented students may strive to meet ensemble standards, fostering team unity, while gifted students can be inspired to unlock their potential through peer interactions. As these students work together, the ensemble benefits from diverse skill sets and perspectives, potentially leading to a higher overall standard of musical performance .

The document suggests selecting music that is of moderate difficulty to provide an appropriate challenge for both gifted and talented students in a middle-level ensemble. This strategy ensures that talented students are urged to blend and gifted students are encouraged to practice and develop. Such repertoire can cater to the diverse needs within the group, allowing all students to grow musically .

A strong teacher-student relationship can significantly enhance the effectiveness of music education by fostering a supportive learning environment where students feel respected and motivated. Teachers who make an effort to know their students demonstrate care, which can encourage students to engage more deeply with the material, leading to improved educational outcomes and potentially greater musical accomplishments .

Music can contribute to student self-worth by providing a sense of accomplishment when performed well, which positively shifts classroom dynamics and reinforces each student's value. Teachers can leverage this by recognizing and celebrating these achievements, thereby enhancing student motivation and engagement in music. This sense of achievement can be amplified by the teacher's conscious effort to establish personal connections with students, showing that they are cared for and valued .

Teachers play a crucial role in preventing the dropout of gifted students by providing encouragement, support, and motivation. If a teacher fails to consistently motivate and recognize a gifted student's potential, it can lead to disengagement and feelings of inadequacy, increasing the risk of dropout. Teacher negligence often results in a lack of belief in the student’s abilities, reinforcing a negative cycle that can result in the student leaving school .

Educators can motivate gifted students by implementing playing tests, which leverages peer pressure to inspire practice and improvement. Additionally, offering incentives for hard work can also inspire these students to put forth extra effort. These methods can gradually encourage gifted students to practice more, thereby helping them reach their potential .

Viewing music as a privilege rather than a necessity could lead students to undervalue music education, potentially reducing their engagement and effort in the subject. This perception might result in lower prioritization of music in academic settings. To counter this, teachers should emphasize the intrinsic value and emotional benefits of music, encouraging students to appreciate its importance for healthy human development and academic achievement .

Gifted students have the potential to excel if they work hard, while talented students naturally possess skills above average. In a music program, these differences manifest in how students are challenged and motivated. Talented students, motivated by the chance to be the 'hero', may find difficulty in blending with the ensemble, while gifted students may require motivation through playing tests and incentives to unlock their potential. Musical selections need to straddle the middle of the difficulty spectrum to adequately challenge both groups .

You might also like