Production Line Simulation Analysis
Production Line Simulation Analysis
net/publication/318689092
CITATIONS READS
13 993
3 authors, including:
All content following this page was uploaded by Mahmoud El-Sharief on 10 May 2023.
Abstract: Production lines modelling has many problems that are difficult to be solved using
analytical solutions, due to uncertainty and/or variability in variables and parameters. This paper
is targeting unreliable production lines with finite buffers for the objective of evaluating and
analysing the current situation and identifying bottlenecks. We use discrete event simulation to
model a real production line based on one-year historical data about the breakdowns of all the
production line’s machinery. This data is used to find appropriate probability distributions to
represent each machinery downtime and uptime. The simulation model is built using AnyLogic
software to abstract the actual production line, and the model is validated using the actual data
and information about the production line. Improvement scenarios are proposed to resolve the
observed bottlenecks, and therefore give managerial insights to increase the throughput according
to the increasing demand. Finally, production plans are set for different demands along the year.
Reference to this paper should be made as follows: Heshmat, M., El-Sharief, M.A. and
El-Sebaie, M.G. (2017) ‘Simulation modelling and analysis of a production line’,
Int. J. Simulation and Process Modelling, Vol. 12, Nos. 3/4, pp.369–376.
Figure 1 Schematic diagram of the cement production line (see online version for colours)
Figure 2 A flowchart represents the simulation methodology Table 1 A sample of the collected data for one of the two raw
(see online version for colours) mills
Downtime
Day Stoppage type Cause
(hours)
01 Energy saving1 4.75 Energy saving during peak
time
01 Electrical 0.75 Electric problem in the
problem clay reclaimer (The touch
screen was broken)
01 Electrical 0.5 Too long start of rheostat
problem of recycle
02 Electrical 1.83 Too long start on the
problem rheostat of mill fan
02 Production 0.5 Rope switch of main
problem feeding belt conveyor
02 Mechanical 0.75 Tighten bolts in the mill
problem shell
03 Electrical 3.167 Displacement of clay
problem reclaimer
03 Energy saving 4.25 Energy saving during peak
time
04 Electrical 2.25 Trip mill fan
problem
05 Lack of own 2.25 End limestone pile and
process changing to new pile
materials
08 Mechanical 8.5 Leakage of oil from outlet
problem low-pressure pump
09 Mechanical 2.5 Leakage of oil from outlet
problem low-pressure pump from its
oil seal
11 Energy saving 4.25 Saving power at peak time
18 Mechanical 7.167 Vulcanising clay belt
problem conveyor
18 Mechanical 3.83 Clay belt conveyor
problem
18 Energy saving 3.3 Energy saving during peak
time
19 Mechanical 2 Mechanical problem
problem in the chain of clay belt
conveyor
20 Production 1 Blockage in weigh feeder
problem
20 Mechanical 1 As a request of mechanical
problem team to check clay
reclaimer
26 Mechanical 0.67 High-temperature inlet
problem bearing
Note: 1At peak times, operations managers shut down
some equipment to save electrical energy.
Simulation modelling and analysis of a production line 373
Figure 4 A snapshot of the developed simulation model (see online version for colours)
70
60
produced per day. The average daily throughput of the 50
40
simulation model is 4,404.3 tonnes per day, whereas, the 30
20
average throughput of the real production line is about 10
0
4,750 tonnes per day without a significant difference
s
i ln
ler
er
ne
er
er
r
er
s
ill
ke
i ll
im
sh
sh
hi
K
m
oo
M
M
ac
ac
ru
ac
i
ru
la
la
C
aw
St
St
t
ec
C
M
C
ec
en
ne
R
y
R
ne
em
g
la
la
in
y
to
ne
C
to
C
la
C
ck
es
es
to
C
Pa
es
Li
Li
m
Li
because the kiln cannot accommodate all the arriving raw and the buffer size before the kiln will decrease as well. If
material due to its limited capacity. Another KPI, we run the any starvation occurs before the kiln area, then the crusher,
simulation model without considering breakdowns of the stacker, and reclaimer can be operated 24 hours other than
workstations to know the theoretical throughput of the 18 hours/day. In that case, simulation modelling can also be
production line, and therefore, the production line efficiency adopted to analyse that point.
can be estimated. The throughput without considering
breakdowns is 5,120 tonnes per day whereas; it is 4,404.3
tonnes per day in case of breakdown consideration. Hence, 5 Production planning for different demands
the production line efficiency is 0.86.
So far the executive board could put production planning
scenarios to face the fluctuating demand. This section is
4.1 Observed bottlenecks dedicated to using simulation to set the production line to
We use the definition of a bottleneck from Yu and Matta accommodate different demands along the year. The large
(2016) which states that “a machine becomes the bottleneck space in the actual production line is exploited to determine
if the sensitivity of the system throughput to its throughput any needed inventory. Let the expected demand is as listed
in isolation is higher than all other machines in the system”. in Table 5, and these targeted demands require increasing
It is clear from the simulation outputs and this rule that there the capacity of some workstations. Several simulation
is a bottleneck in the clinker production area. That is experiments are conducted to reach to the production line
because of the highest utilisation of the kiln (95%) and also capacity modifications.
the largest queue before the kiln. This big queue makes
Table 5 Demands and corresponding modifications in the
blockages before the kiln and therefore raises the average
production line
utilisation of the kiln. In addition, the operations managers
have informed us that they have to shut down the raw mills Demand (tonne/day) Modifications
for hours due to the high silo level. This feedback increases 500 No
the confidence in our simulation model results. On the other
600 Increasing the kiln capacity by 20%
hand, quite low utilisation in the succeeding stages, namely
and operating the crusher, stacker, and
the cement mills and the packaging machines. We have reclaimer for 20 hours instead of 18
been also informed by the operations engineers that hours per day
sometimes there is starvation in the cement mills which 700 Increasing the kiln capacity by 30 %
enforce them to shut down one of them temporarily. This and operating the crusher, stacker, and
bottleneck also has an effect on the preceding buffer size reclaimer for 24 hours instead of 18
and makes blocking at all the preceding stages. This hours per day
problem enforces the operations managers to operate the 300 Working all the line for 18 hours
workstations before the raw mills only two shifts (18 hours) instead of 24 hours per day
instead of three shifts (24 hours). This action is considered
an indirect economic loss in these workstations due to the
idleness rather than adding value. Simulation modelling and 6 Conclusions
analysis of a production line.
The objective of this study was achieved by using discrete
event simulation to capture, analyse, and measure some
4.2 Bottleneck resolving
KPIs for a cement production line. The production line was
To resolve the observed bottleneck in the kiln area, a thoroughly analysed and found to have bottlenecks that
proposal is made to increase the kiln capacity by 10%. Then were causing congestion in the kiln area. Simulation was
the model is run with the new proposal and thus the used to analyse this bottleneck and resolve it. The
bottleneck is resolved, hence the total production line production line throughput could be increased by 8% if the
throughput increases by 8%. This improvement could be kiln capacity is increased by 10%. In addition, the
implemented in the actual production line because there is a simulation model can be used to check production scenarios
sufficient space after the kiln area apart from the clinker according to demand. The feedback obtained from the
stocks. Another alternative, the kiln could be replaced by production line operations managers supports the credibility
another larger one which has a larger diameter with the of the simulation model.
same length. The cost of the new extension or even the new An important extension to this work, an economic study
kiln could be compensated after a certain time especially the will be studied to find the cost of commissioning an
demand for the product has been increasing. Adding a new extension to the kiln area. This cost will be compared to the
extension of the kiln or replacing it will decrease the profit coming from increasing the throughput. That feasible
idleness of the succeeding states, and thus the throughput, study is considered a crucial step towards the
implementation phase.
376 M. Heshmat et al.
References Hsieh, L.Y., Huang, E., Chen, C-H., Zhang, S. and Chang, K-H.
(2016) ‘Application of multi-fidelity simulation modelling to
Abidi, M., Lyonnet, B., Chevaillier, P. and Toscano, R. (2015) integrated circuit packaging’, International Journal of
‘Contribution of virtual reality for lines production’s Simulation and Process Modelling, Vol. 11, Nos. 3/4,
simulation in a lean manufacturing environment’, pp.259–269.
International Journal of Computer Theory and Engineering,
Huang, P.B., Chen, J.C., Yu, C.W. and Chen, C.C. (2016)
Vol. 8, pp.182–189.
‘Integration of simulation and neural network in forecasting
AnyLogic (2016) ‘Multi-method simulation software’ [online] the throughput for TFT-LCD colour filter fabs’, International
[Link] (accessed 12 December 2016). Journal of Computer Integrated Manufacturing, Vol. 29, No.
Aqlan, F., Lam, S.S. and Ramakrishnan, S. (2014) ‘An integrated 3, pp.298–308.
simulation-optimization study for consolidating production Jeon, S.M. and Kim, G. (2016) ‘A survey of simulation modeling
lines in a configure-to-order production environment’, techniques in production planning and control (PPC)’,
International Journal of Production Economics, Vol. 148, Production Planning & Control, Vol. 27, No. 5, pp.360–377.
pp.51–61.
Kayar, M. and Akalin, M. (2016) ‘Comparing heuristic and
Atieh, A.M., Kaylani, H., Almuhtady, A. and Al-Tamimi, O. simulation methods applied to the apparel assembly line
(2015) ‘A value stream mapping and simulation hybrid balancing problem’, Fibres and Textiles in Eastern Europe,
approach: application to glass industry’, The International Vol. 24, No. 2, pp.131–137.
Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, Vol. 84,
Omar, M.A., Qilun, Z., Lujia, F., Ali, A.A., Lahjouji, D. and
Nos. 5–8, pp.1573–1586.
Khraisheh, M. (2016) ‘A hybrid simulation approach for
Fanti, M.P., Rotunno, G., Stecco, G., Ukovich, W. and Mininel, S. predicting energy flows in production lines’, International
(2015) ‘An integrated system for production scheduling in Journal of Sustainable Engineering, Vol. 9, No. 1, pp.25–34.
steelmaking and casting plants’, IEEE Transactions on
Papadopoulos, C.T., O’Kelly, M.E.J., Vidalis, M.J., S. (2009)
Automation Science and Engineering, Vol. 13, No. 2,
Analysis and Design of Discrete Part Production Lines,
pp.1112–1128.
Springer, New York.
Galankashi, M.R., Fallahiarezoudar, E., Moazzami, A., Yusof,
Pawlewski, P. and Kluska, K. (2014) ‘Using DES/ABS approach
N.M. and Helmi, S.A. (2016) ‘Performance evaluation of a
to model and simulate bus assembling process’, Highlights of
petrol station queuing system: a simulation-based design of
Practical Applications of Scalable Multi-Agent Systems. The
experiments study’, Advances in Engineering Software, Vol.
PAAMS Collection: International Workshops of PAAMS
92, pp.15–26.
2016, Sevilla, Spain, 1–3 June 2016, Springer, Vol. 616,
Guner, H.U., Chinnam, R.B. and Murat, A. (2016) ‘Simulation pp.110–132.
platform for anticipative plant-level maintenance decision
Pekel, E. and Kara, S.S. (2016) ‘Simulation-based fleet scheduling
support system’, International Journal of Production
in the Metrobus’, International Journal of Simulation and
Research, Vol. 54, No. 6, pp.1785–1803.
Process Modelling, Vol. 11, Nos. 3/4, pp.326–336.
Hajihosseini, F.H. and Hajihosseini, H. (2009) ‘Importance of
Sajadi, S.M. and Rad, M.F. (2016) ‘Optimal production rate in
simulation in manufacturing’, World Academy of Science,
production planning problem with simulation optimisation
Engineering and Technology Vol. 51, pp.285–288.
approach by simulated annealing’, Int. J. Industrial and
Heshmat, M., El-Sharief, M.A. and El-Sebaie, M.G. (2013) Systems Engineering, Vol. 22, No. 3, pp.262–280.
‘Simulation modeling of production lines: a case study of
Yu, C. and Matta, A. (2016) ‘A statistical framework of data-
cement production line’, Journal of Engineering Sciences,
driven bottleneck identification in manufacturing systems’,
Vol. 41, No. 3, pp.1045–1053.
International Journal of Production Research, Vol. 7543,
No. 21, pp.1–16.