Natural History of Glaucoma Overview
Natural History of Glaucoma Overview
Purpose: To present an overview of the recent observations and research that shed light on the understanding
of open and closed angle glaucoma. Methods: Literature review. Results: Glaucoma is a major eye problem
afflicting millions of people worldwide. As the population increases, the number of people with glaucoma
also increases, with glaucoma becoming an increasing public health concern. This paper presents the
YQp/IlQrHD3i3D0OdRyi7TvSFl4Cf3VC4/OAVpDDa8KKGKV0Ymy+78= on 10/16/2024
natural history of open angle and angle closure glaucoma. We examine the glaucomatous progression in
terms of changes in optic disk morphology and visual fi elds as well as the risk factors for progression.
Conclusions: This present review highlights the magnitude of glaucoma globally and the need for a greater
understanding of this disease and its natural progression.
Key words: Angle closure glaucoma, natural history definition of glaucoma, open angle glaucoma
Open and closed angle glaucoma are leading causes of blindness. however, IOP is the only modifiable risk factor that can be used
With aging of the population, the number of people with glaucoma to prevent progressive optic neuropathy.
is expected to rise, posing a substantial public health challenge
worldwide. Understanding the natural history of glaucoma is Magnitude of Glaucoma Worldwide
essential to our clinical practices
Glaucoma is the leading cause of irreversible blindness
The manifestations of glaucoma range from mechanical worldwide, and the second most common cause of blindness
angle closure of outflow structures in patients with angle after cataracts. [1,2] It is responsible for 14% of blindness
closure glaucoma (ACG), who typically present with ocular worldwide.[3] It afflicts almost 70 million people, of whom 10%
pain and acute visual loss, to increased resistance of outflow are believed to be bilaterally blind.[2]
in patients with open angle glaucoma (OAG), who are often
asymptomatic. Although glaucoma embodies a diverse group Several population-based studies have contributed to our
of diseases, all these diseases share common characteristics, the understanding of the incidence and prevalence of OAG within
hallmarks of which include progressive irreversible damage defined populations in the United States and other countries.
to the optic nerve head and the retinal ganglion cells with In the Baltimore Eye Survey, the prevalence of OAG was
corresponding visual field loss. significantly higher in blacks (4.7%) than in whites (1.3%).[4]
The Los Angeles Latino Eye Study[5] found that Latinos in the
Primary OAG is defined as a chronic optic neuropathy United States have a prevalence of OAG of 4.7%. The prevalence
with characteristic changes in the optic disc and visual field. of OAG in Asians varies widely, perhaps in part because the
Risk factors for OAG include older age, black race, family term Asian encompasses broad racial and ethnic categories.
history (first-degree relative), thinner central corneal thickness, Rudnicka et al. documented OAG rates in Asia to range from
myopia and elevated intraocular ocular pressure (IOP). ACG 1 to 4%,[6] whereas Ramakrishnan et al. found the prevalence
is characterized by the opposition of the iris to the trabecular of OAG in India to be 1.7%.[7]
meshwork, resulting in blockage of the aqueous outflow. Risk
factors for developing angle closure include Asian race, female In Asian populations, ACG is the main cause of morbidity
gender and advanced age. Anatomic features predisposing to from glaucoma. ACG blinds 10-times more people than OAG
angle closure are hyperopia, anterior iris insertion and shallow does, and the worldwide incidence of ACG is growing.[8] While
anterior chamber. ACG represents only 10–15% of all glaucomas in the black and
white populations, it accounts for a significant percentage of
It is important to note that the definition of glaucoma has glaucomas that occur in Asian populations. The rate of ACG
evolved from a disease of eye pressure to a disease of optic among Chinese is three-times that of OAG.[1] Approximately
neuropathy. An elevated IOP in the affected eye is now seen 91% of bilateral blindness in China is due to ACG.[9] Vijaya
as a risk factor for glaucoma rather than its cause. Presently, et al. found that 2.75% of the population had angle closure and
0.88% had ACG.[10] The Andhra Pradesh Eye Disease Survey in
south India suggests that 0.7% of the population over 30 years
Doheny Eye Institute, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, of age has ACG.[11]
CA, USA
Glaucomatous Morphology of the Optic
Correspondence to: Dr Rohit Varma, Doheny Eye Institute, 1450 San
Pablo Street, Los Angeles, CA 90033, USA. E-mail: rvarma@[Link] Nerve
Manuscript received: 28.02.10; Revision accepted: 14.10.10 Glaucoma damages the ganglion cell and its respective axons,
S20 Indian Journal of Ophthalmology Vol. 59 Suppl. 1
which comprise the retinal nerve fiber layer (rNFL). This visual fields and/or localized visual field defects. In these
results in progressive and asymmetric changes in the optic earlier stages, peripheral changes in visual fields may be the
cup, with corresponding visual field loss. Typically, structural only detectable abnormality. Increasing scatter and fluctuation
changes occur before functional loss. Up to 40% of the retinal is often noted. Isolated defects tend to occur in the superior
nerve fibers may be destroyed before detectable changes in half of the visual field because of the susceptibility of the
visual field. The morphology of these rNFL defects follows the inferior poles of the optic nerve in early glaucomatous damage.
normal structural pattern of the rNFL in the retina. Normally, Although central vision is preserved during the early course
rNFL has a striated appearance, radiating from the optic disk, of glaucoma, defects can involve the fixation point. Isolated
Downloaded from [Link] by BhDMf5ePHKav1zEoum1tQfN4a+kJLhEZgbsIHo4XMi0hCywCX1AWn
and is thickest in the superior and inferior poles, compared paracentral defects can appear as the initial glaucoma defect
with the nasal and the temporal poles. Glaucomatous rNFL in 41% of the patients.[16]
changes can present as focal wedge-shaped defects of varying
Progression in visual fields can occur in a variety of ways.
width radiating from the optic nerve head or as diffuse loss
YQp/IlQrHD3i3D0OdRyi7TvSFl4Cf3VC4/OAVpDDa8KKGKV0Ymy+78= on 10/16/2024
associated with the conversion to OAG included advanced a more aggressive disease, with a mean progression rate
age, elevated IOP, central corneal thickness thinner than the corresponding to full-field blindness within 10 years. In
study mean, increased cup-to-disc ratio and increased pattern addition, glaucoma patients with higher IOP are more likely
standard deviation on the visual field.[21,22] to progress rapidly than those with IOP <21. NTG patients
progressed more slowly and had a lower risk of rapid evolution
Data from individuals in the Early Manifest Glaucoma Trial
to blindness. Therefore, the immediacy and aggressiveness of
(EMGT) randomized to the no-treatment group shed light on
therapy for these patients may be less than that for patients with
the natural course of newly detected OAG and can be used to
HTG and PXEG. That being said, high intragroup variability
Downloaded from [Link] by BhDMf5ePHKav1zEoum1tQfN4a+kJLhEZgbsIHo4XMi0hCywCX1AWn
the untreated patients showed definite visual field progression, studies that studied large groups of people with glaucoma
with an overall median time to progression of 42.8 months. without treatment. These two studies have provided important
The study also revealed a very large variation in time to data on the natural course of OAG and on its risk factors for
progression among the subjects. Some progress rapidly, with progression. Patients need to be monitored carefully after
a deterioration in the MD index of greater than 10 dB per year; being diagnosed with glaucoma to determine the rapidity of
others did not progress at all, even after lengthy follow-up. Of glaucoma progression. Individualized treatment plans must be
those individuals in the high-tension glaucoma (HTG) group tailored to patients and to their rate of progression.
(with elevated IOP ≥21 mm Hg), 74% had progressed, with
a median time to progression of 44.8 months, while 56% of Natural History of Angle Closure Glaucoma
those individuals with NTG progressed, with a median time to Although OAG is more common worldwide, ACG causes more
progression of 61.1 months. Of the pseudoexfoliation patients serious loss of vision than OAG.[9] ACGs are characterized
(PXEG), 93% progressed, with a median time to progression by apposition of the peripheral iris against the trabecular
of 19.5 months. Thus, the visual field loss progressed for meshwork, resulting in obstruction of the aqueous outflow.
most of these patients; the majority progressed slowly, but a The main mechanisms of closure are pupillary block, plateau
minority progressed rapidly. Specifically, in the PXEG group, iris, lens-related and retrolenticular causes. The most common
the MD on automated visual field testing was −3.13 dB/year.
cause is pupillary block.
The perimetric MD for the NTG group and the HTG group
was −0.36 dB/year and −1.31 dB/year, respectively.[25] Large ACG may be divided into acute, subacute and chronic ACG.
variations existed between the rates of progression in visual Although they represent different clinical manifestations, they
field for HTG, NTG and PXEG as well as among subjects within can occur at different times in the same person. In acute ACG,
each group. closure of the angle occurs suddenly, resulting in rapid rise in
IOP. The affected person may present with dramatic symptoms
This variability in clinical course was also found by the
of severe ocular pain, nausea, vomiting, headache and blurred
Collaborative Normal Tension Glaucoma Study (CNTGS).
vision. Subacute or intermittent ACG occurs when episodes of
Similar to the EMGT, the CNTGS documented the natural
pupillary block resolve spontaneously and can recur repeatedly
course of untreated NTG.[26] The study specifically focused on
over time. Chronic ACG develops when the angle narrows
patients with glaucomatous optic nerve damage and visual
slowly and results in scarring between the peripheral iris and
field loss accompanied by IOP in the normal range. While some
the trabecular meshwork.
believe that NTG represents a distinct variety of glaucoma from
primary OAG, the two most likely represent a continuum of The natural history of ACG has been subdivided into three
glaucomas. After 5–7 years of follow-up, progression of the stages: (1) an anatomically narrow angle without elevated IOP,
visual field defect was noted in 60% of those individuals with abnormal visual fields or peripheral anterior synechia (primary
untreated glaucoma with optic nerve damage, visual loss and angle closure suspect [PAC]), (2) development of peripheral
IOP under 21 mmHg. Treatment targeting IOP lowering of anterior synechia or a closed angle with elevated IOP, labeled
>30% decreased the progression rate to 20%.[26] Most cases PAC and (3) development of an anatomical angle closure with
progressed slowly, requiring several years to demonstrate glaucomatous optic nerve and visual field changes, termed
progression; in other cases, deterioration manifested within 1 primary angle closure glaucoma (PACG).[27]
year. The mean estimated slope of the MD index deterioration
Although the prevalence and pattern of disease varies across
for all untreated subjects was −0.41 dB/year. However, the MD
different parts of the world, the majority of those with ACG
index ranged from −0.2 dB/year to −2 dB or more/year. This 10-
will be Asian due to their anatomical predisposition. Data
fold range reflects the broad range in the rates of deterioration.
on the natural history of ACG are limited. Large population-
Because the course of glaucomatous progression is highly based data on the disease progression are nonexistent. In one
variable, identifying factors that predict progression can help small study, 22% of the normal patients with narrow angles
guide clinical practice and patient treatment and monitoring. developed synechial angle closure (64%) or appositional
In the EMGT, faster and greater progression was noted in angle closure (36%) over a period of 5 years.[28] Of 28 subjects
older patients (≥68 years of age) when compared with younger who were identified as having PAC, eight progressed to
patients. Frequent disc hemorrhages predict faster progression, PACG within 5 years. Only one of the nine participants who
as did bilateral disease and greater visual field loss at initial underwent laser peripheral iridotomy (LPI) progressed
diagnosis, as measured by perimetric MD. PXEG glaucoma, compared with seven of 19 subjects who refused the laser
when compared with NTG and HTG, was also noted to be iridotomy.[28] Publications on response to treatment provide
S22 Indian Journal of Ophthalmology Vol. 59 Suppl. 1
important insight into the natural history of angle closure. 9. Foster PJ, Johnson GJ. Glaucoma in China: how big is the problem?
The first-line treatment of LPI relieves the relative pupillary Br J Ophthalmol 2001;85:1277-82.
block element. The response to LPI and the long-term course 10. Vijaya L, George R, Arvind H, Baskaran M, Ve Ramesh S, Raju P,
of PACG appears to vary by race. Studies found that LPI in et al. Prevalence of primary angle closure disease in an urban south
Caucasian subjects with ACG were more likely to effectively Indian population and comparision with a rural population. The
Chennai Glaucoma Study. Ophthalmology 2008;115:655-60.
prevent the subsequent need for surgical intervention than
LPI in Asian subjects. Intraocular pressure was controlled 11. Dandona L, Dandona R, Mandal P, Srinivas M, John RK, McCarty
with LPI alone in 65–76% of eyes, with only 0–13% of the CA, et al. Angle closure glaucoma in an urban population
Downloaded from [Link] by BhDMf5ePHKav1zEoum1tQfN4a+kJLhEZgbsIHo4XMi0hCywCX1AWn
of iridectomy for primary acute angle-closure glaucoma. Am J appearing in the Glaucoma Supplement are sponsored articles.
Ophthalmol 1978;86:506-9.
33. Playfair TJ, Watson PG. Management of acute primary angle-
closure glaucoma: A long-term follow-up of the results of Source of Support: Nil, Conflict of Interest: None declared.
peripheral iridectomy used as an initial procedure. Br J Ophthalmol
In early glaucomatous damage, isolated defects often occur in the superior half of the visual field due to the susceptibility of the inferior poles of the optic nerve. Isolated paracentral defects can be the initial glaucoma defect in 41% of patients. As glaucoma advances, initial defects may deepen, extend, and coalesce into nasal steps, arcuate scotomas, or complete altitudinal defects. New defects may also appear. In advanced stages, double arcuate scotomas can form superiorly and inferiorly, leading to the creation of central and temporal islands. Eventually, these islands may disappear, ultimately leading to complete visual loss .
The rate of visual field progression in open-angle glaucoma (OAG) varies slightly by ethnicity, with European-derived, Hispanic, African-derived, and Chinese patients experiencing mean visual field changes of −1.12, −1.26, −1.33, and −1.56 dB/year, respectively. However, these differences are not statistically significant. Factors influencing these variations are not entirely clear from the data provided, but treatment status and baseline risk factors could potentially have an impact .
Pseudoexfoliation is associated with more aggressive glaucoma progression, with 93% of affected patients showing progression and a median time to progression of 19.5 months. Consequently, treating pseudoexfoliation glaucoma requires an especially vigilant approach due to its rapid progression, often necessitating more aggressive and immediate therapeutic strategies to manage intraocular pressure and monitor for visual field changes, compared to other forms of glaucoma .
Baseline factors influencing the conversion from ocular hypertension to open-angle glaucoma include advanced age, elevated IOP, central corneal thickness thinner than the study mean, increased cup-to-disc ratio, and increased pattern standard deviation on the visual field. Preventive measures include regular monitoring of these baseline factors and implementing early treatment strategies aimed at reducing IOP, as reducing IOP is shown to have a protective effect, significantly lowering the conversion rates .
In normal-tension glaucoma (NTG), reduction of intraocular pressure (IOP) by more than 30% is associated with decreased progression of visual field defects, reducing the progression rate to 20% from 60% in untreated individuals. This suggests that even in NTG, where IOP is within a normal range, lowering IOP can have significant beneficial effects on disease progression. Therefore, even though NTG might seem less urgent for treatment than high-tension glaucoma, IOP reduction remains a valuable target in managing NTG .
The Early Manifest Glaucoma Trial (EMGT) reveals that untreated patients with open-angle glaucoma often progress with visual field defects; 68% showed progression after six years. The trial also highlights that lowering intraocular pressure (IOP) by an average of 25% significantly reduces the rate of progression. These findings underscore the importance of early IOP-lowering interventions in slowing disease progression and preserving visual function in patients with open-angle glaucoma .
Early detection and treatment of glaucoma are crucial in preventing significant visual field loss because glaucoma often remains asymptomatic until substantial and irreversible damage has occurred. The lack of early symptoms is a primary challenge, delaying diagnosis until advanced stages. Challenges include identifying at-risk populations, as well as implementing widespread screening and monitoring programs to detect disease early. Enhancing public awareness about the disease's subtle onset and promoting regular eye check-ups are essential strategies to combat these challenges .
Frequent disc hemorrhages are associated with faster progression of glaucoma. In clinical practice, the presence of disc hemorrhages should be seen as a prognostic indicator that suggests a heightened risk of rapid disease progression. This underscores the need for closer monitoring and potentially more aggressive treatment in patients who exhibit these hemorrhages to mitigate further damage .
Chronic angle-closure glaucoma develops when the angle narrows gradually and results in scarring between the peripheral iris and the trabecular meshwork, often without dramatic symptoms. In contrast, acute angle-closure glaucoma occurs suddenly, leading to a rapid rise in intraocular pressure, and is characterized by severe symptoms such as ocular pain, nausea, and blurred vision. Common mechanisms of angle closure include pupillary block, plateau iris, lens-related and retrolenticular causes, with pupillary block being the most common .
The high variability in the progression of open-angle glaucoma (OAG), with differences in rates of visual field deterioration among individuals, suggests that clinical management and monitoring need to be highly individualized. Frequent monitoring to assess the rate of progression and tailored treatment strategies based on individual risk factors such as age, baseline visual field status, and optic nerve damage are crucial. Particularly aggressive forms, like pseudoexfoliation glaucoma, require more immediate and rigorous intervention .