Jute Fiber Composite Wear Analysis Report
Jute Fiber Composite Wear Analysis Report
I
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I would like to express our sincere thanks to Dr. Amar Patnaik sir, who has been
a source of guidance, supervisor and educator to us. He had taken many
lectures from that we had come to the platform to work on Summer Internship
Program project without any difficulty.
I would like to thank Prof. Udaykumar Yaragatti Director MNIT Jaipur who
has provided the abundant facilities for completing this summer internship
program.
I also acknowledge Prof. G. S. Dhangayach, HOD Mechanical, MNIT Jaipur.
I also thank Mr. Ankush Sharma (Junior Research Fellow), Mr. Vinayak
Rajashekhara Kiragi (Research Associate), Mr. Bhagiratha Sahu (Junior Research
Fellow) and the entire technical assistant who had provided valuable guide so
we can complete this internship easily.
Lastly, I would like to thank the almighty lord without whose mercy this
training could have been completed.
Abhishek Yadav
(14/591)
th
[Link] 7 semester
Aeronautical Engineering
University College of Engineering Kota
II
ABSTRACT
Abrasive wear is a major industrial problem. Therefore, a full understanding of
the effects of all system variables on the abrasive wear rates is necessary in
order to undertake appropriate steps in the design of the machinery and the
choice of materials to reduce/control wear. Need for the use of newer
materials to combat wear situations has resulted in the emergence of polymer-
based system. Polymers and their composites form a very important class of
Tribo-engineering materials and are mostly used in mechanical components
where wear performance in non-lubricated condition is a key parameter for the
material.
Advantages of these materials are light weight, excellent strength to weight
ratios, resistance to corrosion, non-toxicity, easy to fabricate, design flexibility,
self-lubricating properties, better coefficient of friction, and wear resistance.
Present research work is undertaken to study the mechanical and three body
abrasive wear behavior of jute fibre reinforced composite. Three different
forms of jute fibre reinforced composite consist of three types of filler content
that are considered for the present research work. Attempts have been made
to explore the possible use of jute fibers as reinforcement for polymer
composites.
The design of experiments approach using Taguchi methodology is employed
for the parametric analysis of abrasive wear process. Study reveals that abrasive
wear performance of jute fibre reinforced composite increases with increase in
filler content.
Keyword: Abrasive wear, Jute fibre reinforced composite, Taguchi methodology.
III
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. CERTIFICATE I
2 ACKNOWLEDEMENT II
3. ABSTRACT III
4. TABLE OF CONTENT IV
6. LIST OF TABLES IX
IV
CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION
Filler Material 2
MATERIALS
1.8 CONCLUSION 11
V
CHAPTER 2 LITERATURE REVIEW
2. INTRODUCTION 12
2.2 CONCLUSION 14
CHAPTER 3 METHODOLOGY
3. INTRODUCTION 15
3.2.1 Background 15
3.4 CONCLUSION 19
VI
CHAPTER 4 MATERIALS AND METHODS
INTRODUCTION
4. MATERIALS 20
FABRICATION OF COMPOSITE 21
INTRODUCTION 26
CONCLUSION 30
SCOPE FOR FUTURE RESEARCH 31
REFERENCES 32
VII
LIST OF FIGURES
VIII
LIST OF TABLE
IX
Computational and Experimental Analysis in Industrial Applications in Mech. Engg.
Chapter-1 Introduction
1. BACKGROUND OF THE STUDY
A Composite material (or composition material or a composite) is made by combining
two or more materials with different physical or chemical properties, when combined it
produces a material with different characteristics from the individual component
.Originating from early agricultural societies and being almost forgotten after centuries, a
true revival started of using lightweight composite structures for many technical solutions
during the second half of the 20th century. After being solely used for their
electromagnetic properties (insulators and radar-domes), using composites to improve the
structural performance of spacecraft and military aircraft became popular in the last two
decades of the previous century. First at any costs, with development of improved
materials with increasing costs, nowadays cost reduction during manufacturing and
operation are the main technology drivers. Latest development is the use of composites to
protect man against fire and impact (Figure 1.1 (a)) and a tendency to an environmental
friendly design, leading to the reintroduction of natural fibers in the composite technology,
see Figure 1.1 (b). Increasingly nowadays, the success of composites in applications, by
volume and by numbers, can be ranked by accessibility and reproducibility of the applied
manufacturing techniques.
Filler Material
Marble is a metamorphic rock produced from limestone by pressure and heat in the earth’s
crust due to geological processes. It is widely used cement, construction and sculpture
industries. Marbles are, chemically, crystalline rocks constituting mainly calcite and
dolomite. In the last 2 decades, the marble industry has gained industrial importance.
Countries like USA, France, Belgium and other European countries have considerable
marble reserves. During marble processing, 30% of the stone goes to scrap because of
being smaller in size and/or being irregularly shaped. Millions of tons of marble powder
are processed every year during extraction, around the world. As a result, significant
environmental damage occurs from the large quantities of marble dust produced in these
industries. Marble dust may also lead to skin allergies. However, apart from these
disadvantages, marble powder is also among the most useful substances in the planet and
has found uses in several applications, in a number of different forms. It is mainly used as
a filler or additive in several industrial applications. Many researches previously
investigated marble waste as a potential constructional material. However, it can now also
be used to make a new class of polymer-MWP composites. Epoxy resins (ER) are very
useful substances as polymeric matrix system for developing such new composite
materials. With growing engineering applications, epoxy based composites have been a
subject of extensive research in the last few years.
In matrix-based structural composites, the matrix serves two paramount purposes viz.,
binding the reinforcement phases in place and deforming to distribute the stresses
among the constituent reinforcement materials under an applied force.
The demands on matrices are many. They may need to temperature variations, be
conductors or resistors of electricity, have moisture sensitivity etc. This may offer
weight advantages, ease of handling and other merits which may also become
applicable depending on the purpose for which matrices are chosen.
Solids that accommodate stress to incorporate other constituents provide strong bonds
for the reinforcing phase are potential matrix materials. A few inorganic materials,
polymers and metals have found applications as matrix materials in the designing of
structural composites, with commendable success. These materials remain elastic till
failure occurs and show decreased failure strain, when loaded in tension and
compression.
Composites cannot be made from constituents with divergent linear expansion
characteristics. The interface is the area of contact between the reinforcement and the
matrix materials. In some cases, the region is a distinct added phase. Whenever there
is interphase, there has to be two interphases between each side of the interphase and
its ad-joint constituent. Some composites provide interphases when surfaces dissimilar
constituents interact with each other. Choice of fabrication method depends on matrix
properties and the effect of matrix on properties of reinforcements. One of the prime
considerations in the selection and fabrication of composites is that the constituents
should be chemically inert non-reactive. Figure is classification of matrices.
Composition of the resin is enough to alter the conditions suitably for curing and
determine its other characteristics. They can be retained in a partially cured condition
too over prolonged periods of time, rendering Thermosets very flexible. Thus, they are
most suited as matrix bases for advanced conditions fiber reinforced composites.
Thermosets find wide ranging applications in the chopped fiber composites form
particularly when a premixed or molding compound with fibers of specific quality and
aspect ratio happens to be starting material as in epoxy, polymer and phenolic
polyamide resins.
Thermoplastics have one- or two-dimensional molecular structure and they tend to at
an elevated temperature and show exaggerated melting point. Another advantage is
that the process of softening at elevated temperatures can reversed to regain its
properties during cooling, facilitating applications of conventional compress
techniques to mould the compounds.
Resins reinforced with thermoplastics now comprised an emerging group of
composites. The theme of most experiments in this area to improve the base properties
of the resins and extract the greatest functional advantages from them in new avenues,
including attempts to replace metals in die-casting processes. In crystalline
thermoplastics, the reinforcement affects the morphology to a considerable extent,
prompting the reinforcement to empower nucleation. Whenever crystalline or
amorphous, these resins possess the facility to alter their creep over an extensive
range of temperature. But this range includes the point at which the usage of resins is
constrained, and the reinforcement in such systems can increase the failure load as
well as creep resistance. Figure 1.3 shows kinds of thermoplastics.
A small quantum of shrinkage and the tendency of the shape to retain its original form
are also to be accounted for. However, reinforcements can change this condition too.
The advantage of thermoplastics systems over thermosets are that there are no
chemical reactions involved, which often result in the release of gases or heat.
Manufacturing is limited by the time required for heating, shaping and cooling the
structures. Thermoplastics resins are sold as moulding compounds. Fiber
reinforcement is apt for these resins. Since the fibers are randomly dispersed, the
reinforcement will be almost isotropic. However, when subjected to moulding
processes, they can be aligned directionally.
There are a few options to increase heat resistance in thermoplastics. Addition of
fillers raises the heat resistance. But all thermoplastic composites tend lose their
strength at elevated temperatures. However, their redeeming qualities like rigidity,
toughness and ability to repudiate creep, place thermoplastics in the important
composite materials bracket. They are used in automotive control panels, electronic
products encasement etc.
Newer developments augur the broadening of the scope of applications of
thermoplastics. Huge sheets of reinforced thermoplastics are now available and they
only require sampling and heating to be moulded into the required shapes. This has
facilitated easy fabrication of bulky components, doing away with the more
cumbersome moulding compounds.
Thermosets are the most popular of the fiber composite matrices without which,
research and development in structural engineering field could get truncated.
Aerospace components, automobile parts, defense systems etc., use a great deal of this
type of fiber composites. Epoxy matrix materials are used in printed circuit boards
and similar areas. Figure 1.4 shows some kinds of thermosets.
The developed composite shall be much stronger to hold a good product life for the slurry
abrasion condition; it shall be used in the areas where slurry abrasion takes place.
1.8 CONCLUSION
The biggest advantage of modern composite materials is that they are light as well as
strong. By choosing an appropriate combination of matrix and reinforcement material,
a new material can be made that exactly meets the requirements of a particular
application. Composites also provide design flexibility because many of them can be
moulded into complex shapes. Although the resulting product is more efficient, the
raw materials are often expensive. Slurry Abrasion Test Rig gives wear properties of
the specimen.
5. Patnaik et al. studied the slurry abrasive wear test on E-glass fiber reinforced
composite materials using marble dust and Tio2 as a filler and observed that by
incorporating of these particulate fillers into the glass-fiber reinforced vinyl
ester, synergistic effects, as expected were achieved in the form of modified
mechanical properties and improved slurry abrasion wear resistance.
1. Gopal et al. studied tensile and flexural properties of jute mat fiber with epoxy
composites and observed that the tensile test and flexural test were conducted
and the results are compared. The composite plate without powder is less
tensile and less flexural whereas proper mixing of coconut shell powder will
give good tensile strength and flexural strength and further the laminate
improve the tension and the delamination properties
2. Sodhi et al studied mechanical characterization of low cost natural hybrid
date/jute fibre reinforced epoxy composite and observed that the mechanical
properties such as tensile strength and flexural strength of epoxy resin
improves by a great extent due to the presence of reinforcement. On increasing
the weight fraction of reinforcement the mechanical properties of the FRP
composites increases.
3. Gopinath et al studied mechanical properties of jute fiber reinforced
composites with polyester and epoxy resin matrices and observed that the 5%
NaOH treated jute fiber reinforced composites seemed to show much better
results than the 10 % NaOH treated jute composites .Jute-epoxy exhibited
better tensile and flexural properties.
4. Girisha et al studied mechanical properties of jute and hemp fiber reinforced
epoxy and observed that the composites with polyester resin as matrix give
more tensile, flexural and impact strength than epoxy based hybrid composites.
Diagonal inclinations of the reinforcing fibres give poor mechanical properties
as observed in 30degee, 45 degree oriented composites.
5. Ranjt et al studied treated sunnhemp and treated jute fibre reinforced epoxy
composites and observed that the treated sunnhemp fibre reinforced
epoxy composite have more tensile, flexural and impact strength property as
compared to treated jute fibre reinforced epoxy composites.
6. Gujjala et al studied jute fiber reinforced epoxy composites and compared
with the glass and neat epoxy composites and observed that the jute fibre
composite exibits brittle nature and lowest erosion rate as compared to other
composite,due to their chemical structure and bonding with epoxy which may
arrest the crack propagation and control deformation.
7. Satapathy et al studied processing and characterization of jute-epoxy
composites reinforced with SiC derived from rice husk and observed that
incorporation of filler modifies Tensile, Flexural, and Inter-laminar Shear
Strength of jute fibre.
8. Sanjay and Yogesha studied mechanical properties of jute/E-glass fibre
reinforced epoxy hybrid composites and observed that the incorporation of
glass fiber in jute fiber composites enhances the mechanical properties and it
leads to the increase of the utilization of natural fibers in various applications.
9. Gon et al studied how to substitute wood by jute composites and observed that
the usage of natural fibre based products in post-disaster management of
rehabilitation & rebuilding would become cost competitive compared to other
building materials.
10. Singh studied jute/glass epoxy based hybrid composites and tells the reader
about the use of all the composite materials that are very essential like natural
fibre, hybrid fibre and synthetic fibre materials.
2.2 CONCLUSION
In the recent years there is a vast growth in natural fibre based polymer composites
due to its various attractive features likes biodegradability, no abrasiveness, flexibility,
availability, low cost, light weight etc. Different researchers have performed various
experiments to enhance the mechanical properties of natural fibre based polymer
composites.
Chapter-3 Methodology
3. INTRODUCTION
This chapter details out the research methodology for the present study. It explains the
research objectives and a suitable methodology to achieve those objectives.
3.2.1Background
The Englishman, Sir [Link], first proposed the technique of laying out the
conditions of experiments involving multiple factors. The method is popularly known
as the factorial design of experiments. A full factorial design will identify all possible
combinations for a given set of factors. Since most industrial experiments
Usually involve a significant number of factors, a full factorial design results in a large
number of experiments. To reduce the number of experiments to a practical level, only
a small set from all the possibilities is selected. The method of selecting a limited
number of experiments, which produces the most information, is known as a partial
fraction experiment. Although this method is well known, there are no general
guidelines for its application or the analysis of the results obtained by performing the
experiments. Taguchi constructed a special set of general design guidelines for
factorial experiments that cover many applications.
The procedure for Taguchi analysis was shown in figure 3.1
Set performance
Characteristics (Dome Height,
Thinning Factor)
Parameters
Choose array
Confirmation experiment to
check whether there is
No
improvement
Yes
END
Levels
Process parameters
Level 1 Level 2 Level 3
LOAD – A 2 3 4
Orthogonal arrays are special standard experimental design that requires only a small
number of experimental trials to find the main factors effects on output. Before
selecting an orthogonal array, the minimum number of experiments to be conducted is
to be fixed based on the formula below
N Taguchi = 1+ NV (L – 1)
NV = Number of parameters
L = Number of levels
In this work
NV = 3 and L = 3, Hence
N Taguchi = 1+ 4 (3-1) = 9
Hence at least 9 experiments are to be conducted. Based on this orthogonal array
(OA) is to be selected which has at least 9 rows i.e., 9 experimental runs.
The following standard orthogonal arrays are commonly used to design experiments:
2-Level Arrays: L4, L8, L12, L16, L32
3-Level Arrays: L9, L18, L27
4-Level Arrays: L16, L32
In this work L9 is sufficient. It would require a total of 27 experiments to optimize the
parameters. Taguchi experimental design of experiments suggests L9 orthogonal
array, where 9 experiments are sufficient to optimize the parameters. Based on main
factor, the variables are assigned at columns, as stipulated by orthogonal array. Once
the orthogonal array is selected, the experiments are selected as per the level
combinations. It is important that all experiments are conducted.
Experiment Variables
No.
A B C D
1 1 1 1 1
2 1 2 2 2
3 1 3 3 3
4 2 1 2 3
5 2 2 3 1
6 2 3 1 2
7 3 1 3 2
8 3 2 1 3
9 3 3 2 1
Variables
1 2 140 800 0
2 2 180 1000 10
3 2 220 1200 20
4 3 140 1000 20
5 3 180 1200 0
6 3 220 800 10
7 4 140 1200 10
8 4 180 800 20
9 4 220 1000 0
3.4 CONCLUSION
The need of optimization is to obtain the best result. By altering the input parameters, the
optimization process seeks for improved output so that the performance of a system can be
enhanced. Taguchi‘s method is considered as global optimization method.
4.1 MATERIALS
The following materials were used in the preparation of jute-epoxy-marble powder
composite:
4.1.1 Jute Fibre: Jute fibre has some unique physical properties like high tenacity,
bulkiness, sound & heat insulation property, low thermal conductivity, antistatic
property etc. Due to these qualities, jute fibre is more suited for the manufacture of
technical textiles in certain specific areas. Moreover, the image of jute as a hard and
unattractive fibre does not affect its usage in technical textiles. Jute is 100% bio-
degradable and thus environment- friendly. It is available in India at competitive
prices. Now it is not just a major textile fibre, but also a raw material for non- textile
products, which helps to protect environment, which is an integral part of any
development planning.
Jute fibers are always known as strong, coarse, environment friendly, and organic. The
use of jute was primarily confined to marginal and small manufacturers and growers,
but now it is used as important raw materials for several industries. It is unfortunate
that jute still lags behind other fibers like silk, wool, and cotton. However at present
time, jute is termed as a favorite fabric for packaging materials and furnishings and as
golden fibers for national and international fashion world. Jute fibers are used for
making mats, gunny cloth, cordage, hangings, paper, and decorative articles. Prevalent
uses of jute in handicraft stuff, in order to give an aesthetic appeal, have made it
popular across the globe.
4.1.2 Epoxy (L12) (Bis-phenol A): A translucent dense fluid with high viscosity served
as the matrix in the composite. It is a thermosetting resin with high molecular weight.
Currently, there are a wide variety of matrix resins available for use in reinforced
polymeric composite materials. The most commonly used thermosetting resins are epoxy,
unsaturated polyester, and vinyl ester. These resins can satisfy a variety of
4.1.3 Hardener (K6): Epoxy curing agent K-6 is a low viscosity room temperature
curing liquid hardener. Being rather reactive it gives a short pot life and rapid cure at
normal ambient temperatures. It has a shelf life of least two years if stored in its
original container away from humidity and heat. The supplier fixes the mixing ratio of
mixing of epoxy and hardener as 10:1.
4.1.4 White marble dust: A white fine powder with density more than that of the
epoxy matrix and served as the particulate reinforcement (filler material). Marble
powder is produced from the marble processing plants during the cutting, shaping and
polishing. During this process, about 20-25% of the process marble is turn into the
powder form. It is mixed with the epoxy in the weight percentage proportion.
Step 1: First of all, a release gel is sprayed on the release sheet to avoid the sticking of
polymer to the surface. Thin release sheets are used at the top and bottom of the mold
plate to get good surface finish of the product.
Step 2: Reinforcement in the form of woven mats are cut as per the mold size and
placed at the surface of mold after perspex (release) sheet.
Step 3: Then thermosetting polymer (epoxy resin) in liquid form is mixed thoroughly
in suitable proportion with a prescribed hardener (curing agent) and poured onto the
surface of mat already placed in the mold.
Step 4: The polymer is uniformly spread with the help of brush. Second layer of mat is
then placed on the polymer surface and a roller is moved with a mild pressure on the mat-
polymer layer to remove any air trapped as well as the excess polymer present.
Step 5: The process is repeated for each layer of polymer and mat, till the required
layers are stacked. After placing the release sheet, release gel is sprayed on the inner
surface of the top mold plate which is then kept on the stacked layers and the pressure
(weight) is applied. After curing at room temperature, mold is opened and the
developed composite part is taken out and further processed.
(a) (b)
Figure 4.1: a) Schematic diagram of hand lay-up process. b) Orientation of fiber layers
Hand lay-up method finds application in many areas like aircraft components,
automotive parts, boat hulls, diase board, deck etc.
Composites of different compositions is with three different filler content (marble dust)
(0wt%, 10wt% and 20wt %). Figure 4.2 (a) shows bidirectional jute fibre. Similarly,
Figure 4.2 (b) shows jute fibre reinforced epoxy composite. The detailed composition and
designation of the composites are presented in Table 4.1 Finally the specimens of suitable
dimension are cut with the help of hack saw for characterization and testing.
(a) (b)
Figure 4.2: (a) Bi-directional jute fiber, (b) Jute fibre reinforced epoxy composite
Composites Composition
(a) (b)
Figure 4.3: a) Slurry abrasion tester, (b) Interior view of slurry abrasion tester
Abrasive Slurry Mixture of 212 micron dry sand (2.5 Kg) and water ( 1 litre)
5. INTRODUCTION
This chapter presents the mechanical and three-body slurry abrasive wear behavior of
the jute fiber reinforced epoxy composites. The effect of filler content on composites
is also discussed. The effects normal load, RPM, and number of revolution on the
three-body slurry abrasive wear response of the composites are also presented.
Table 5.2 shows the initial and final mass of the specimen.
Initial Mass Final Mass Initial Mass Final Mass Initial Mass Final Mass
(gm.) (gm.) (gm.) (gm.) (gm.) (gm.)
90 89.185 80 79.304 90 89.774
Table 5.3: Height of wear and mass loss in the specimen according to the experiment
Performed
Exp. C1 C2 C3 C4 C5 C6 C7 C8
No. Load RPM Revolution Filler Height of Mass SNRA1 SNRA2
Content wear loss(g/kg)
1 2 140 800 0 1.02 9.05 -19.1330 -
0.17200
2 2 180 1000 10 1.42 8.70 -18.7904 -
3.04577
3 2 220 1200 20 1.47 2.51 -7.9935 -
3.34635
4 3 140 1000 20 1.44 4.01 -12.0629 -
3.16725
5 3 180 1200 0 1.22 10.83 -20.6926 -
1.72720
6 3 220 800 10 1.25 3.47 -10.8066 -
1.93820
7 4 140 1200 10 1.57 5.76 -15.2084 -
3.91799
8 4 180 800 20 1.41 7.12 -17.0496 -
2.98438
9 4 220 1000 0 1.33 3.82 -11.6413 -
2.47703
5.4 DISCUSSION
5.4. Three-body slurry abrasive test
The relation between percentage of filler content and height of wear and mass loss can be
seen from the following graph:
Figure 5.3: Relation between filler content, height of wear and mass loss
Conclusion
The study on the three-body abrasive wear and mechanical behavior of jute fiber
reinforced polymer composites led to the following conclusions:
Fabrication ofbi-directional jute fibre reinforced epoxy composite has completed
successfully.
The study on mechanical properties of jute fiber reinforced epoxy composite
revealed that these properties is affected by filler content, applied load, RPM and
number of revolution.
Three-body abrasive wear study depicted that with increase in filler content the rate
of mass loss increases but height of wear first increase from 0% filler content to
10% filler content and after that it decreases.
Abrasive wear characteristics of the composites using Taguchi methodology was
been analyzed. The optimal parameter setting had obtained for jute fiber reinforced
epoxy composites. From Taguchi design of experiment method the S/N curve
depicted that which combination of parameter is best for less wear rate and less
mass loss.
References
[1] “Composite Material.” [Online]. Available:
[Link] [Accessed: 21-Jun-2017].
[4] A. Kumar, “Study of Slurry Abrasion Behaviour of mild steel and weld
deposited alloy steel,” vol. 2, no. 11, pp. 339–344, 2016.
[9] G. Raghavendra, S. Ojha, S. Acharya, and S. Pal, “Jute fiber reinforced epoxy
composites and comparison with the glass and neat epoxy composites,” J.
Compos. Mater., vol. 48, no. 20, pp. 2537–2547, 2014.
[20] D. Gon, K. Das, P. Paul, and S. Maity, “Jute Composites as Wood Substitute,”
vol. 1, no. 6, pp. 84–93, 2012.
[21] R. P. Singh, “Study of jute/glass epoxy based hybrid composites,” vol. 4, no. 3,