0% found this document useful (0 votes)
59 views5 pages

Investment Strategy Reflection in STAX Game

Uploaded by

ANGEL
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
59 views5 pages

Investment Strategy Reflection in STAX Game

Uploaded by

ANGEL
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

Alcordo, Dixiebelle

Ayuban, Kirby
Borja, Angelo Julian
Lumayno, Angel Wayne
BSMA 2A

Reflection Questions:

[Link] a screenshot of your portfolio at the end of the game and paste it in the box below.
[Link] approximate percentage did you have in each asset class? Complete the table below
using the Investment Portfolio pie chart. Estimate the percentage for each of the asset
classes using the pie chart as a reference.

Type of Savings Certificate Index Fund Individual Governmen Communit Gold


Asset Account of Deposit Stocks t Bonds y Crops

Dollar $0 $0 $245,757.3 $132,330.8 $0 $0 $0


Amount 5 8

Percentage 0% 0% 65% 35% 0% 0% 0%

[Link] at the table above, did you finish the game with a diversified portfolio? Explain.

No, because we were taking the risk in investing huge amounts of money in individual stocks and index
fund, mostly of our money went to index fund.

[Link] your investment strategy as you played the game.


a. What was your plan when you first started playing and how did it change during the
course of the game?

Our plan was to invest heavily in the index fund because it has a high return rate, and to invest in individual
stocks when their graph shows a decline, selling them immediately if we make a profit. Our strategy involved
putting a lump sum of money into the index fund, allowing it to grow, and occasionally withdrawing some to
invest in individual stocks. We had a golden rule for individual stocks: we only bought when their graph was in
the red but projected to turn green, and we sold immediately if we gained a profit.

[Link] you didn't have a strategy, why not?


N/A

5. Describe the various emotions you felt as you played the game. How did your emotions
impact your decision-making while playing the game? Provide specific examples.

The Buildyourstax game was challenging at first, but we managed to overcome the difficulties. It turned out to be
really enjoyable and provided a wealth of new experiences. It was also quite informative since you need to figure
out the right moments to take certain actions and successfully completing tasks felt incredibly satisfying. Especially
the Index Fund, we had to rely on it for profit and on the individual stocks, we didn't invest in the Gold as we know
it would lower our profit more.

6. What strategy did the computer follow? Why do you think that strategy was so successful
in beating so many of the students in your class?

The Computer is leaning towards the Index Fund, since the game stresses learning about sustainable investing
methods, it is likely that the computer prioritizes safer, lower-risk options to provide stable returns, which is why it
favors the Index Fund over picking individual equities.

[Link] friend brags, "It was easy to try to beat the computer in the STAX game. I made
$100,000 more with my strategy of actively trading those individual stocks. Why would you want to just buy
an index fund? It's so much fun to try to beat the market!" How would you respond?

Honestly, that’s awesome you made that much, but active trading sounds super stressful to me. I get the thrill of it,
but I’d rather take a more chill approach with an index fund. It’s less time-consuming and I don’t have to worry
about the ups and downs as much. Sure, you might beat the market sometimes, but over the long haul, index funds
usually perform well, and I’d rather have steady growth than gamble on short-term wins. Plus, I’ve got other things
I’d rather focus on than obsessing over stock prices all day!

8. If you had the opportunity to play STAX a second time, what would be your strategy?

We would use our strategy again but change it a little bit when it comes to year 15, in year 15 we would want to
invest in the certificate of deposits and government bonds more because that year mostly of the stocks would go
down.
9. What do you think would be the consequences of having less money saved for retirement?
How would that impact your life?

Finding appropriate employment can be difficult for older persons, particularly in physically demanding areas or
industries that favor younger workers. Lack of resources may force some people to live with family members or
depend on them for financial support, which compromises their independence and sense of dignity. If your
retirement savings are lower, you may have to make difficult choices about where to live, what to buy, and if you
can afford medical care.

10. Bonus Question: You had seven different investment options in the game. The most
diversified portfolio would include all of these various options. On average, should this
diversified portfolio have the highest return? Why or why not?

Not necessarily, a diversified portfolio includes a variety of assets to spread out risk, meaning that if one asset
performs poorly, others might perform well and offset the loss. This lowers the portfolio's overall risk. However,
diversification is more about balancing risk and return, not maximizing returns. While it reduces the chance of large
losses, it also means you may miss out on higher returns from more aggressive, high-risk investments.

Common questions

Powered by AI

Actively engaging in stock trading during simulations like BuildYourStax affects players' perceptions by providing an experiential understanding of market fluctuations and investment risk. The thrill associated with potential gains from active trading, juxtaposed with stress over monitoring market changes, teaches players about volatility and the time commitment necessary for short-term gains. This experience can lead to a preference for stable investments in future real-life scenarios, as the stress and complexity of active trading highlight the unpredictability and risks involved .

If players were to participate in the BuildYourStax game again, they would consider adjusting their strategy around year 15 by investing more in certificates of deposits and government bonds. This change is based on the anticipated downward trend of most stocks during that year, aiming to mitigate investment losses by choosing safer, lower-risk options at a critical time period .

A lack of retirement savings can severely impact an individual's financial independence and decision-making in later life. It may lead to difficulties in securing appropriate employment, particularly in industries favoring younger workers or demanding physical labor. Financial constraints could force individuals to rely on family support, compromising their independence and dignity. With limited savings, retirees may face tough choices about living arrangements, purchases, and healthcare affordability, potentially affecting their lifestyle and wellbeing significantly .

During the BuildYourStax game, players experienced a mix of challenges and enjoyment, leading to a heightened awareness of timing in financial decisions. Emotions such as satisfaction from completing tasks and anxiety over potential losses influenced decision-making. For example, while relying on index funds provided a sense of security, players restrained from investing in gold due to concerns about negatively impacting profits. Emotions played a role in risk tolerance, affecting strategies and urgency in decision-making .

Players might prefer investing in index funds over actively trading individual stocks due to the stability and lower time commitment that index funds offer. Active trading, while potentially more profitable, is stressful and requires constant monitoring of stock prices, which is time-consuming. Index funds provide a long-term steady growth, reducing the emotional and time investment associated with active trading. Many players value these traits despite the allure of occasionally beating the market through active trading .

Game-based learning in investment simulations like BuildYourStax plays a significant role in enhancing financial literacy by providing a practical, engaging environment to understand investment concepts. It allows participants to experiment with strategies, witness the consequences of financial decisions, and develop critical thinking about market behaviors and risk management. The experiential learning approach aids in grasping complex financial principles more effectively than theoretical study alone, making it a valuable tool for educating individuals about investment responsibilities and long-term financial planning .

A diversified investment portfolio spreads risk by incorporating a variety of assets, so if one asset class underperforms, others may perform better to offset potential losses. This approach reduces overall risk but may also moderate potential high returns that could be achieved with a more concentrated, high-risk approach. Diversifying balances risk with return but doesn't guarantee the highest returns, as aggressive investments might offer higher gains albeit with higher risks. This principle was discussed in the context of the BuildYourStax game, where players suggested that diversification involved managing risk rather than maximizing returns .

The primary investment strategy adopted in the BuildYourStax game involved heavily investing in the index fund due to its high return rate, while selectively investing in individual stocks when they showed a declining trend expected to improve. This strategy reflected risk management principles by focusing on index funds, which are considered low-risk options providing stable returns, as compared to the more volatile individual stocks. The players aimed to minimize risk by making data-driven decisions, buying stocks when indicators suggested growth potential, and immediately selling them for profit when feasible .

A player might argue against diversifying with all available investment options even with potential risk mitigation because full diversification might dilute the potential returns from high-performing assets. While diversification minimizes risk by spreading it across various asset classes, it might also limit gains that concentrated investments in high-risk, high-return assets could offer. If a player has a higher risk tolerance or insight into certain market trends, they may argue that selective concentration could optimize their returns, even if it involves greater short-term risk .

The BuildYourStax game emphasizes the value of sustainable investing methods by encouraging reliance on index funds and other low-risk financial instruments, illustrating the benefits of stable, long-term investment strategies over speculative, high-risk approaches. This emphasis influences player strategies by directing them towards safer investment choices that offer steady returns. This approach was reflected in both player and computer strategies, favoring index funds over picking individual equities, thus highlighting the game's educational role in teaching sustainable investing practices .

You might also like