100% found this document useful (1 vote)
20 views4 pages

U.S. Society and Slavery in the 1840s

Paper

Uploaded by

bonet1022
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
100% found this document useful (1 vote)
20 views4 pages

U.S. Society and Slavery in the 1840s

Paper

Uploaded by

bonet1022
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

The 1840s

AHIS 308

Part I: Background
The U.S in the 1840s
• Overwhelmingly rural and agricultural
• Especially South
• But urbanizing (slowly)
• 6% urban (1810) to 20% (1860)
• About 4/5 could read and write
• Slaves only 1/10 literate
• Majority Protestant
• Anglo-Saxon superiority ideas
• White supremacy ideas
• Immigration (Catholic) just starting
• Second Great Awakening
• Reform!

• Tremendous technological change


• Cotton gin (“nadir of African American history”)
• “motor of a global economic machine” with “slavery as its fuel”
• Transformed value of land
• Steam engines
• Railroad expansion, esp in 1850s
• Steel plows
• Sectionalism, always present, started to magnify in 1840s
• Little sense of unity
• Sectionalism even broke apart religious sects and parties
• Overwhelming idea of the 1840s: that the U.S. had a “manifest destiny”
• idea based on Anglo-Saxon superiority over other “races”
The Constitution and Slavery
• Slavery completely legal
• Recognized 3 places
• 1. International slave trade couldn’t be touched until 1808
• 2. 3/5 compromise
• 3. Fugitive slaves had to be returned
• Framers expected slavery to die out slowly
• And believed that emancipation might lead to a race war.
• At the adoption of the Constitution there were 8 slave states and 5 free states
How the South benefited from Constitutional protection of slavery
• “domestic insurrections clause”
• Guaranteed federal assistance with slave rebellions
• Slave rebellions were major concern
• Increased South’s legislative power
• 3/5 clause added more representatives from slave states
• Increased electoral power
• Electoral college
• Increased ability to stop constitutional amendments
• Result: South controlled politics 1788-1860
• first 12 presidents were slaveholders except for those named Adams
Slavery: not an issue, 1787-1819
• Until Missouri applied for statehood in 1819 (as a slave state)
• Slave states = free states
• Balance important to Southerners so they can’t be outvoted in the U.S. Senate
• Some Northerners concerned about allowing slavery to spread
• Compromise needed
Missouri Compromise, 1820
• First of many
• Maine ready to break from Massachusetts
• The Compromise
• Maine admitted as free; Missouri admitted as slave to keep balance
• Slavery to be banned in any new states north of Arkansas Territory (36’30”)
• Settled issue (until new territory added)
• 1845 Texas
• 1848: Mexican Cession

How the North profited from slavery


• Cheap, plentiful cotton for mills/domestic and foreign
• South produced 2/3 world’s cotton
• 50% nation’s entire export value was cotton
• Production so high and costs so low because of the torture used
• Northerners owned all the shipping
• All the insurance
• All the banking
• Northern banks extended credit to slaveholders
• Using slaves as collateral
• Enormous profits from interest fees
• New York City so tied to South that it seriously considered seceding when the South left
(more on that later)
Early Black abolitionists (you’ve probably never heard of)
Northern opposition to slavery
• Abolitionism: rooted in religious belief
• opposed slavery as moral evil
• Anti-slavery: opposed slavery usually on free labor ideas
• American Anti-Slavery Society founded 1833
• Led by Wm Lloyd Garrison
• Undertook “the great postal campaign” 1835
Slavery as a “positive good”
• Congressman James Henry Hammond 1837 speech
• “I do firmly believe that domestic slavery, regulated as ours is, produces the highest
toned, the purest, best organization of society that has ever existed on the face of the
earth…If the abolitionist assault on Southern honor does not subside, we may have to
adopt an entire non-intercourse with the free States, and finally, we may have to
dissolve the Union.”
Two tracks
• Slavery as positive good
• Slavery as moral evil
• Most Americans paid little attention
Sectional differences growing
• Real or imagined?
• Major differences
• Labor systems
• Wage labor and agriculture in North
• Slave labor and “the chivalry” in the South
• Source of wealth
• Mixed economy in North
• Agriculture in South
• HONOR: a big difference
Abolition and Underground RR

• What we thought we knew


• abolitionism and Underground RR mostly whites
• RR loosely organized and secretive
• Why did whites get the credit?
• records now reveal
• mostly blacks
• both legal (court cases, lobbying legislators) and underground (assisting fugitives on the
wary)
• well organized and in the North, often operated openly
What was the underground railroad?
• How did it start?
• In cities like New York and Philadelphia
• “vigilance committees”
• Free blacks and and some white abolitionists
• Set up to protect fugitives who were not safe because of the Fugitive Slave Act
• New York Vigilance Committee set up in 1835
• First decade: 2,000 assisted to permanent freedom
Black abolitionists
• The backbone of anti-slavery agitation
• Underground RR agents
Who escaped?
• Border state slaves more likely to attempt escape northward
• Deep south states slaves to cities like Mobile and New Orleans
• Or to Indian nations or Mexico
• How many? 10,000 perhaps
• Few records except in New York City
• Reasons for fleeing:
• Bad treatment
• Reunification with loved one
• Threat of being sold
• Promises of owner not kept
Mexican War, 1846-1848
• Clear that the U.S. would win
• Congressman David Wilmot (PA) concerned about spread of slavery into any new territory
gained
• Introduced Wilmot Proviso
• That no slavery would be allowed in lands ceded by Mexico
• Failed to pass but opened debate on slavery and its extension
• Mexico ceded all of the Southwest
• Big pic: U.S. invaded a weaker country to get its land
• New land for slavery
• Unintended consequence: new territory would lead to Civil War 15 years later
Political tensions arose
• North had been abandoning slavery and moving to free labor
• Population swelling by immigration after mid 1840s
• Northerners interested in westward expansion
• Southerners intent on expanding slavery into new territory
• Worried about expanding Northern population overpowering their interests
• Southerners grew defensive
• Westward movement from CA Gold Rush, 1849-1850s inflamed already increasing political
tension
• Which section’s labor system would prevail?

Common questions

Powered by AI

The concept of 'Manifest Destiny' propagated the belief that the United States was destined to expand across North America, which intensified sectional tensions by embedding ideas of Anglo-Saxon superiority and white supremacy . This ideology justified territorial expansion but also heightened disagreements between the North and South over whether new territories should permit slavery, further polarizing the nation and contributing to growing sectionalism .

Northern states benefited from the Southern slave economy through economic transactions and industries linked to slavery. Northern banks extended credit to slaveholders, using slaves as collateral, resulting in enormous profits from interest fees . Additionally, the North owned the shipping and insurance businesses essential for transporting cotton, which the South produced in abundance . This economic interdependence illustrates how deeply Northern prosperity was tied to Southern slavery .

Religious beliefs significantly influenced Northern abolitionist movements, with many abolitionists viewing slavery as a moral evil based on their religious convictions . The Second Great Awakening inspired many Americans to strive for social reforms, including abolitionism, viewing the fight against slavery as a divinely endorsed mission to purify society . This religiously driven moral imperative fueled the activities of organizations like the American Anti-Slavery Society, which pursued initiatives such as the great postal campaign to spread anti-slavery sentiment .

The introduction of the cotton gin had a profound impact on the Southern economy by significantly increasing cotton production, which became the main driver of the economy, often described as the 'motor of a global economic machine' with slavery as its 'fuel' . This technological advancement transformed the agricultural economy and expanded the demand for slave labor, marking a 'nadir' in African American history as it entrenched the institution of slavery further due to its economic profitability .

Sectional differences in labor systems had profound implications for the U.S. during the 1840s. In the North, a mixed economy combined agriculture with industrial wage labor, while the South remained agrarian with its economy based on slave labor . These differences not only defined regional identities but also exacerbated political tensions, as each region sought to expand its influence and systems into new territories. This rift became a central factor leading to the Civil War, as debates over which labor system should dominate inflamed sectional disputes and national politics .

Black abolitionists were crucial in the anti-slavery movement and the operation of the Underground Railroad. They formed the backbone of anti-slavery agitation, not just by assisting fugitives but also in legal and lobbying efforts . The Underground Railroad, although credited mainly to white abolitionists, was predominantly managed by Black individuals who organized and facilitated escapes, primarily through vigilance committees in cities like New York and Philadelphia . This reveals a misrepresented history where Black contributions were vital yet historically overshadowed .

Constitutional protections for slavery profoundly shaped U.S. political power dynamics by enhancing Southern legislative and electoral power. The 3/5 compromise increased Southern representation in the House of Representatives and the Electoral College . The Fugitive Slave Clause necessitated federal involvement in returning escaped slaves, while the domestic insurrections clause guaranteed federal assistance with revolts, ensuring political stability favored Southern interests . Consequently, these provisions allowed Southern states to maintain significant influence over national politics, controlling presidential outcomes and stymieing constitutional amendments against slavery .

The Missouri Compromise was significant in maintaining political balance by admitting Missouri as a slave state and Maine as a free state, thus preserving the Senate's equilibrium between free and slave states . It also established a geographical line at 36’30”, north of which slavery was to be prohibited in future states. This policy temporarily settled the sectional conflict over slavery but foreshadowed future tensions when new territories were added, highlighting the fragility of the Union .

The political consequences of the Mexican-American War were pivotal in escalating the debate over slavery's expansion. The acquisition of new territories from Mexico intensified tensions between the North and South, as Southerners sought to extend slavery into these areas while Northerners aimed to prevent its spread . The Wilmot Proviso, which proposed banning slavery in any new territory acquired, although it failed to pass, underscored the contentious national debate and contributed to the sectional divisions that eventually led to the Civil War .

In the 1840s, immigration began significantly shaping the United States' political and social landscape. Primarily Catholic immigrants started arriving, adding to the religious diversity and slowly altering the predominantly Protestant demographic . The influx also contributed to urbanization, changing societal structures and contributing to labor market transformations. Politically, immigration stoked nativist sentiments and influenced discussions on citizenship and the status of newly arrived populations, further amplifying cultural and regional tensions .

You might also like