Source Final
Source Final
®
ArcGIS Anchors Grid
Modernization
Copyright © 2019 Esri
All rights reserved.
Printed in the United States of America.
The information contained in this document is the exclusive property of Esri. This work is protected under United States copyright law and
other international copyright treaties and conventions. No part of this work may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means,
electronic or mechanical, including photocopying and recording, or by any information storage or retrieval system, except as expressly
permitted in writing by Esri. All requests should be sent to Attention: Contracts and Legal Services Manager, Esri, 380 New York Street,
Redlands, CA 92373-8100 USA.
Esri, the Esri globe logo, The Science of Where, ArcGIS, Insights, [Link], and @[Link] are trademarks, service marks, or registered
marks of Esri in the United States, the European Community, or certain other jurisdictions. Other companies and products or services
mentioned herein may be trademarks, service marks, or registered marks of their respective mark owners.
ArcGIS Anchors Grid Modernization
Table of Contents
Spatial Analysis............................................................................... 9
Spatial Analysis Creates Better Insight....................................................10
Imagery Enhances Decision-Making .......................................................10
ArcGIS Utilizes Spatial Analysis.............................................................11
Summary.......................................................................................... 17
June 2019 4
ArcGIS Supports Grid Modernization
Where are outages occurring? Where are obsolete assets? Where are the distributed
energy resources (DERs)? Where are customers using retailers? Where is the grid
subject to cyber-attack? Where is the grid vulnerable? Where are customers
behaving differently?
Geographic information system (GIS) technology has been used in utilities for
decades. However, it has largely been relegated to back-office mapping groups. That
is changing.
ArcGIS is a location intelligence platform. It needs to be a critical element of grid
modernization. Why? Location plays such a dominant role in both the problems and
the solutions facing utilities today.
One strategy to help utilities meet these challenges is to fully leverage ArcGIS in
three ways:
■ Migrate to a real-world model of the
assets in the GIS. Include all parts
of the grid as completely as
possible.
■ Implement a full system of
engagement in which the GIS is
exposed to all stakeholders, inside
and outside the company. Likewise,
use the GIS to consume data from
a variety of internal and external
sources.
■ Fully leverage ArcGIS software's
analytical capabilities. Employ a
system of insight.
ArcGIS is a complete GIS. It is a system
of record, engagement, and insight. It
models the grid to improve risk
assessment. It consumes real-time data
from sensors and social media. That
heightens awareness of threats. It uncovers patterns. This makes for better
investment, security, and operational decisions. It provides immediate situational
awareness. It helps utilities understand customers.
Grid Short-term power failures inconvenience people. Longer-term failures shut down
Modernization businesses, causing revenue loss. Extended outages create havoc and chaos. This
chaos often results in loss of life—sometimes in substantial numbers.
Jobs are lost. People are permanently displaced.
EIA says power failures increased 54 percent between 2013 and 2016. The grid was
based on the weather patterns that existed decades ago. During Superstorm Sandy,
storm water inundated electrical equipment. No one had anticipated this.
For most of its history, power flowed from large, central generating plants. The
balance of supply and consumption was well understood. Not so with solar and wind
power sources. They vary with the weather. As renewable energy produces a
substantial and growing part of the power supply mix, the control of the grid becomes
far more complex.
In many states, utilities no longer own their power plants, nor do they have a direct
relationship to end-use customers. This puts additional pressure on earnings.
Distributed energy resources siphon revenues.
Utilities are under constant threat of cyber and physical attacks, sometimes in
combination.
Because of these issues, the US Department of Energy (DOE) created the Grid
Modernization Initiative (GMI) just a few years ago.
What Is Grid Modernization?
DOE recognized that
▪ There are too many outages.
▪ The grid is old.
▪ Renewable energy is projected to grow 31 percent from its current level by 2050.
▪ Deregulated markets will increase.
▪ Cyber and physical attacks will continue to be a threat.
▪ Customers expect electricity pricing to be competitive and affordable.
In its GMI 2018 report, DOE stated the following:
"Our extensive, reliable power grid has fueled the nation's growth since the early
1900s. However, the grid we have today does not have the attributes necessary to
meet the demands of the 21st century and beyond."
The DOE further stated what a modern grid must have:
▪ Greater resilience to hazards of all types
▪ Improved reliability for everyday operations
▪ Enhanced security from an increasing and evolving number of threats
▪ Additional affordability to maintain our economic prosperity
▪ Superior flexibility to respond to the variability and uncertainty of conditions at
one or more time scales, including a range of energy futures
▪ Increased sustainability through energy-efficient and renewable resources
Location Is a Common Theme
The traits of a modern grid, as noted above, all have one attribute in common—
location. That suggests that GIS and specifically ArcGIS underpin nearly every grid
modernization measure.
ArcGIS models the grid to improve risk assessment. It reveals where it is best to
invest in resiliency. It consumes real-time data from sensors and social media to
heighten awareness of threats. It uncovers patterns for better investment, security,
and operational decisions. It provides immediate situational awareness. It helps
utilities understand customer behavior. It delivers productivity tools to keep costs
down.
Grid Grid modernization relies heavily on a thorough understanding of the physical
Modernization aspects of the grid. Utilities need to understand the behavior and the vulnerabilities
Anchored by of the grid. ArcGIS provides the means to model the grid in detail. The DOE stated
ArcGIS that the grid must be made resilient, reliable, secure, affordable, flexible, and
sustainable. ArcGIS is the technology to help utilities do that. ArcGIS does this in
three unique ways:
■ Unifies IT and OT into a single coherent framework
■ Leverages spatial analysis
■ Delivers operational awareness
June 2019 6
ArcGIS Supports Grid Modernization
IT and OT Utilities struggle with siloed systems. For example, supervisory control and data
Unified into a acquisition (SCADA) systems only manage real-time information from utility
Single, Coherent monitoring devices and control devices. Those devices include substation
Framework breakers, relays, instruments, and meters.
They do not measure other devices, such as sound, temperature, or wind sensors.
SCADA systems do not consume social media services. Also, SCADA is only
marginally geography based. SCADA abstracts the transmission network to a
schematic representation. It has no knowledge of terrain, earthquake zones, or flood
zones.
Enterprise asset management (EAM)
systems handle the asset life cycle. They
cannot manage assets' spatial relationship
to each other or to other, nonutility assets.
Advanced metering infrastructure (AMI)
processes customer consumption. It only
understands customer addresses. It has no
knowledge of the relationship of meters to
the grid. Nor does it know the location of the
communication infrastructure that underpins
the system.
An Advanced Distribution Management
System (ADMS) is geography based. It only
manages the operational model of the
distribution system. It does not have direct
data about the transmission system. Nor
does it manage the structural elements of
the distribution network. It cannot do spatial
analysis.
Utilities perform simulation studies of the electric network. These include load flow,
short-circuit analysis, state estimation, insulation coordination, and stability analysis.
Like SCADA, these systems are schematic based. In most cases, the modeled
devices do not have location information. ArcGIS can consume the results of the
system analysis and combine that data with other system data and services. ArcGIS
brings system analysis to life.
Customer information system (CIS) or customer relationship management (CRM)
technologies have a plethora of information about the customers. This includes their
addresses and consumption patterns. These technologies lack the connection of the
customers to the electrical network. Also lacking is the ability to look at aggregate
customer behavior.
A simple example illustrates how ArcGIS can bring together data from completely
different IT and operational technology (OT) systems.
This example shows how ArcGIS accesses real-time voltage data from a cable
company, then displays that data with electric distribution data from a power
company. ArcGIS could even access voltage complaint data from the company’s
CRM. The external sensors are fiber-to-coax nodes. The dashboard of figure 2
shows the real-time voltage measurements of an electric distribution network. The
electric network data is managed by ArcGIS.
This illustrates how ArcGIS can consume real-time Internet of Things (IoT) data in an
app. It also illustrates the ability to provide spatial analysis and coordination of the
sensors to the electric distribution network. It shows these attributes:
■ IoT integration—Two distinct sets of data: one being real-time information (from
the sensor network) and one being a system of record from ArcGIS. As noted,
other datasets can be added from other IT systems such as a CRM, AMI or other
services (weather, traffic), or internal OT systems such as an outage
management system.
■ Analysis—ArcGIS can perform spatial analysis not just on data from the GIS but
from all data it consumes, regardless of the source. This is critical. Once a
service is consumed by the ArcGIS platform, that data appears as if it was
maintained and managed by ArcGIS.
■ Awareness—This dashboard can be delivered to anyone in the organization.
Decision-makers in different locations can see what's going on, all at the same
time.
ArcGIS will not replace any IT or OT system. What it will do is bring together OT and
IT systems. It reveals the relationship of one data source to another. ArcGIS can
consume services from outside the utility, such as imagery; weather, lightning,
demographic, crime, and fire reports; and other IoT services into a single
environment.
ArcGIS can bring together data from SCADA (for transmission), ADMS (for
distribution), and customer information (from CRM and AMI). It can add data from
EAM for work locations. It can take all this data and help users visualize and analyze
it—all by location. It truly unifies IT and OT.
June 2019 8
ArcGIS Supports Grid Modernization
Spatial Analysis Once data is collected from a variety of sources, ArcGIS adds significant value
using spatial analytics. Those sources come from real-time sensors and control
systems such as SCADA and ADMS.
Other sources include spatial information from the web through services. This
information also comes from IT systems as noted above. GIS visualizes that data.
However, it does even more. It uncovers patterns and trends that simple visualization
cannot.
June 2019 10
ArcGIS Supports Grid Modernization
potential fire hazard. ArcGIS can then determine how close critical electric facilities
are to the hazardous trees.
ArcGIS Utilizes Spatial Analysis
Spatial analysis is used by ArcGIS with the following capabilities:
■ Assesses risk—Network risk that is risk of a network failure equals vulnerability
plus consequences. Spatial analysis considers both. ArcGIS consumes data from
many sources. This includes load flow, short-circuit, and stability studies. It uses
statistics, science, and big data analytics to focus where vulnerability exists.
ArcGIS then examines where that vulnerability will have the greatest negative
impact on the network and the community it serves.
■ Processes imagery—ArcGIS processes images to provide insight into the
surrounding environment. Using spectral analysis, it can uncover issues hidden
from the naked eye.
■ Provides machine learning and big data analytics—In combination with imagery
and video, ArcGIS can uncover imminent failures. Using machine learning,
utilities can scan millions of devices in seconds to locate dangers lurking in their
network.
Key Attributes of Resiliency and reliability require a thorough knowledge of the behavior of the grid.
a Modern Grid A secure grid requires a deep understanding of the threats, both physical and
cyber. Utilities will adopt technology for improved productivity. Customers demand
affordability and flexibility. Society has embraced sustainability.
June 2019 12
ArcGIS Supports Grid Modernization
June 2019 14
ArcGIS Supports Grid Modernization
becoming smarter. They can communicate the grid's health. The bad news is that
these very same devices become targets for cyber-attack. No single system is as
effective as ArcGIS to assess the relationship of these devices to other aspects of the
grid. ArcGIS knows where every sensor is located and what it should be seeing.
Figure 10 illustrates a simple task-based app. After a storm, utilities must perform a
comprehensive damage assessment. The assessors might be office workers
dispatched for that task only. They can be equipped with tablets with simple forms to
complete that would illustrate the location and extent of the damage. Figure10 is a
simple configuration of Esri's Operations Dashboard for ArcGIS, which collects the
data from damage assessors in real time. It's simple, affordable, and flexible.
Sustainability
ArcGIS supports renewable resources. It is used for land management, solar
radiation density, wind density, and geothermal analysis. It is critical that utilities
carefully model the location and attribution of all distributed energy resources. In the
very near future, utilities and other entities will model DER financial transactions
using technologies such as blockchain. ArcGIS is the software to help in the records
management, visualization and analysis of this new utility business model.
ArcGIS has served as the foundation for planning, building, and operating renewable
resources. Figure 12 shows the solar radiation densities in a proposed development.
June 2019 16
ArcGIS Supports Grid Modernization